- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ravi Kumar Bajpai v. Renu Awasthi Bajpai
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, Ravi Kumar Bajpai (husband) and his father-in-law, filed a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure challenging the institution of a private complaint (M.J.C. No.59/2010) by the respondent under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 ("Domestic Violence Act"). The marriage between petitioner no.1 and the respondent was solemnized on 22.2.2008. The respondent alleged dowry demand, cruelty, and harassment after marriage, leading to the filing of a complaint under Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act on 14.9.2009 before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Hoshangabad. Notices were issued to the petitioners, who filed preliminary objections that were rejected, and subsequently filed a reply denying the allegations. The case was at the stage of recording evidence when the petitioners sought quashment of the complaint via this petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Magistrate erred in taking cognizance of the complaint and summoning the petitioners without considering the report of the Protection Officer, as mandated by the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act.
- Whether the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act is mandatory in requiring the Magistrate to consider the Protection Officer's report before issuing summons or merely before passing any final order on the application.
- The scope and interpretation of the Magistrate’s powers under Sections 12, 23, and 28(2) of the Domestic Violence Act concerning taking cognizance and summoning parties without the Protection Officer’s report.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners contended that the respondent instituted a false and frivolous case.
- Reliance was placed on the judgment of this Court in Shri Rama Singh vs. Smt. Maya Singh (2012(4) MPHT 169), which held that the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act is mandatory.
- They argued that the Magistrate’s taking cognizance and summoning without considering the Protection Officer’s report violated this mandatory proviso, thus the proceedings should be quashed.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent's counsel relied on Section 23 of the Domestic Violence Act, emphasizing the Magistrate’s power to grant interim and ex parte orders.
- It was argued that the proviso’s requirement to consider the Protection Officer’s report applies only before passing any order on the application, not before taking cognizance or issuing summons.
- Reference was made to the judgment in Ajay Kant Sharma and others vs. Smt. Alka Sharma (2008 Cri.L.J 264), supporting that the Magistrate need not consider the report before issuance of notice.
- Section 28(2) was cited to show that the Court may lay down its own procedure, which does not preclude the Magistrate from taking cognizance based on prima facie material without the report.
- The respondent contended that the Magistrate’s order taking cognizance was lawful and the petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. should be dismissed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shri Rama Singh vs. Smt. Maya Singh (2012(4) MPHT 169) | Proviso to Section 12 of Domestic Violence Act is mandatory before taking cognizance and summoning. | Petitioners relied on this judgment to argue mandatory consideration of Protection Officer’s report before summons; Court discussed its scope and held it was per incuriam. |
| Ajay Kant Sharma and others vs. Smt. Alka Sharma (2008 Cri.L.J 264) | Magistrate must consider Protection Officer's report before passing final order, not before issuing notice or taking cognizance. | Cited by respondent to support that summons can be issued without the report; Court relied on this interpretation. |
| Tehmina Qureshi vs. Shazia Qureshi (2010(1) MPHT 133) | Context of joining family members as parties under Domestic Violence Act. | Referenced in relation to the scope of proceedings and parties; Court considered it alongside other precedents. |
| Sou. Sandhya Manoj Wankhade vs. Manoj Bhimrao Wankhade and others (2011 Cri.L.J. 1687) | Supreme Court judgment clarifying the correct proposition of law under Domestic Violence Act. | Court held prior Madhya Pradesh High Court judgments (Ajay Kant Sharma and Tehmina Qureshi) as per incuriam in light of this Supreme Court ruling. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act, which mandates that before passing any order on an application, the Magistrate must consider any report received from the Protection Officer or service provider. The Court clarified that this obligation applies to the passing of a final order, not to the preliminary stage of taking cognizance or issuing summons.
Relying on the judgment in Ajay Kant Sharma, the Court noted that it is not obligatory for the Magistrate to call for or consider the Protection Officer's report prior to issuing notices to the parties. The phrase "before passing any order" was interpreted to mean final orders, not the initial procedural steps.
The Court further reviewed the judgment in Shri Rama Singh, which had held the proviso mandatory at an earlier stage, but found that in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Sou. Sandhya Manoj Wankhade, the earlier Madhya Pradesh High Court judgments including Ajay Kant Sharma and Tehmina Qureshi were per incuriam (i.e., decided without proper consideration of binding authority).
Therefore, the Court held that the Magistrate acted within legal bounds in taking cognizance and summoning the petitioners without the Protection Officer’s report. The Court emphasized the discretionary power of the Magistrate under Sections 23 and 28(2) of the Domestic Violence Act to lay down procedure and pass interim or ex parte orders.
Holding and Implications
The petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashment of the complaint is dismissed.
The direct effect of this decision is that the proceedings initiated under the Domestic Violence Act before the Judicial Magistrate are upheld and continue. The Court’s ruling clarifies that the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act requires consideration of the Protection Officer’s report only before passing a final order and does not mandate such consideration before taking cognizance or issuing summons. No new precedent altering the substantive law was set; rather, the Court reaffirmed existing interpretations consistent with Supreme Court authority.
MCRC-14047-2013
(RAVI KUMAR BAJPAI Vs SMT. RENU AWASTHI BAJPAI)
16-09-2015
Invoking the jurisdiction under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure challenging the illegal and
arbitrary action of the respondent of instituting a false
and frivolous case M.J.C. No.59/2010 filed before Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Hoshangabad under the Protection
of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (in short be
called as 'Domestic Violence Act'), petitioners have filed
this petition seeking quashment of the same.
2. Petitioner no.1 is the husband and petitioner no.2 is the
father-in-law of the complainant/respondent. It is said that
the marriage of the petitioner no.1 and respondent was
solemnized on 22.2.2008 at Hoshangabad. After
marriage, as alleged respondent was subjected to
demand of dowry, cruelty and harassment, however, a
complaint under Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act
was filed on 14.9.2009 in the Court of Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Hoshangabad whereupon notices were issued
to the petitioners. On receiving the notice, a preliminary
objection was filed by the petitioners which was rejected,
thereafter reply has also been filed denying the
allegations made in the complaint, and now, the case is at
the stage of recording the evidence. In the meantime,
present petition has been filed seeking quashment of the
private complaint.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners has put forth
solitary contention seeking quashment of the private
complaint, placing reliance on the judgment of this Court
in the case of Shri Rama Singh vs. Smt. Maya Singh
and others reported in 2012(4) MPHT 169 and submits
that taking cognizance by the Magistrate and to call upon
the petitioners without asking and taking into
consideration the report of the Protection Officer is in
violation of the proviso to Section 12 of the Domestic
Violence Act. It is contended that the proviso to Section
12 is mandatory as held in the said judgment therefore,
without having a report of the Protection Officer, passing
an order by the Magistrate to summon the petitioners is
not in conformity to law, therefore, the proceedings may
be quashed.
4. Learned counsel representing respondent referring to
Section 23 submits that the Magistrate under the
Domestic Violence Act conferred with the power to grant
interim and ex parte order. However, the connotation
âbefore passing any order on such application the
magistrate shall consider domestic incidence report
received by himâ would not include an order of taking
cognizance or summoning the petitioners and infact the
report may be considered at the time of passing the final
order. In support of his contention, reliance has been
placed on a judgment of this Court in the case of Ajay
Kant Sharma and others Versus Smt.Alka Sharma
reported in 2008 Cri.L.J 264. It is also urged that as per
Section 28(2), the Court may lay down its own procedure
for disposal of the application under Section 12 or under
sub-section (2) of Section 23, therefore, it do not preclude
the magistrate in exercising the power to take cognizance
on having prima facie satisfied on the basis of material
brought before him to summon the respondent, without
the report of the Protection Officer or Service Provider. In
such circumstances, the order passed by the Magistrate
taking cognizance is in accordance with law and this
petition seeking quashment in exercise of the powers
under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. may be dismissed.
5. After hearing learned counsel appearing on behalf of
both the parties, on the point in issue as advanced, this
Court has earlier considered the scope of Section 12 of
Domestic Violence Act and its proviso. Firstly in the case
of Ajay Kant Sharma (supra), learned Single Judge in
Para-3 after referring Section 12 has observed as under :-
âOn perusal of the aforementioned proviso
appended to the provision, it appears that
before passing any order on the application, it
is obligatory on a Magistrate to take into
consideration any report received by him
from the Protection Officer or the service
provider. Neither it is obligatory for a
Magistrate to call such report nor it is
necessary that before issuance of notice to
the petitioners it was obligatory for a
Magistrate to consider the report. The words
before passing any order provide that any
final order on the application and not merely
issuance of notice to the respondent/the
petitioners herein. The words any report also
mention that a report, if any, received by a
Magistrate shall be considered. Thus, at this
stage if the report has not been called or has
not been considered, it cannot be a ground
for quashing the proceeding.â
Secondly, in the case of Shri Rama Singh (supra)
wherein this Court has considered the judgments of Ajay
Kant (supra) and also Tehmina Qureshi vs. Shazia
Qureshi reported in 2010(1) MPHT 133. In the context
of joining other family members as a party in complaint,
the Court observed that in the wake of pronouncement of
the Supreme Court judgment in the case of Sou.
Sandhya Manoj Wankhade vs. Manoj Bhimrao
Wankhade and others reported in 2011 Cri.L.J. 1687
the view taken by this Court in the case of Ajay Kant
Sharma (supra) and Tehmina Qureshi (supra) do not
describe the correct proposition of law, however, in this
respect, for all practical purposes those two judgments
are held as per incuriam. In the judgment of Shri Rama
Singh (supra), the judgment of Ajay Kant Sharma
(supra) has also been considered in the context of proviso
to Section 12(1) of Domestic Violence Act. On the said
Alert