- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sambasiva Aiyar And Another v. Ganapathy Aiyar And Another
1. I cannot agree with the Subordinate Judge that the effect of allowing the amendment would have been to settle the affairs of two mills instead of one and that the amendment prayed for was substantially such as to extend the scope of the suit.
2. Paragraph 17(e) of the plaint contained a prayer for taking the accounts of the Nammeli Mill as well as the accounts of the Mannargudi Mill and the taking of accounts is a form of relief.
3. Therefore the words in para. 16 of the plaint saying that no relief was prayed, for in respect of the Nammeli Mill were clearly erroneous and contradictory to what appeared later. Probably the explanation for this statement lies in the fact that as stated elsewhere in the paint, the Nammeli business had ended in a loss up to the date when the plaintiffs parted with their rights in it to defendant 2. They were however liable for the debts of this business and they claimed a right to outstandings prior to 25th November; and it was right and proper in a partnership suit that a Court should take into account all the transactions between the partners with a view to avoid multiplication of proceedings and to finally determine all the matters regarding which the partners were at issue.
4. It is also just that all such amendments should be made as may be necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties: Savugan Chetty v. Krishna Aiyangar(1).
5. Recently however this Court has decided not to interfere under Section 115 of the CPC, in revision with orders however incorrect, refusing to allow amendment of plaints: Penumarthi Vasantarayadu v. Reddi Subbamma(2), and although the learned Judge who admitted this petition permitted the party to add Section 15 of the Charter Act, under which this Court has exercised powers in respect of interlocutory orders passed by Subordinate Courts in many instances, the principle on which interference has been justified in such cases has always been that there has been an improper exercise of jurisdiction by the Subordinate Court or an improper refusal to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it: sea Somasundaram Chettiar v. Manick Vasaka Desika Gnana Sammanda Pandara Sannadi(3) Mankolam Vasudevan Nambudri v. Manakolam Sankaran Nambudri(4), Sree Krishna Dass v. Chandook Ghand(5) and Kamal Kutty v. Udayavarma Raja Valiah Rajah of Ghirakal(6). In my opinion no question of jurisdiction arises in this case and the aggrieved party has another remedy by way of appeal against the final decree that may be passed in the suit. I must therefore decline to interfere and I dismiss the petition but under the circumstances without costs.
S.N/R.K
6. Petition dismissed.
Alert