- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Krishna Pillai v. State Of Kerala
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from an order refusing to restore a Land Acquisition Reference dismissed for default. The appellant, a landowner, filed an application under Section 20 of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act seeking a reference to the civil court for determination of land value following an award by the Land Acquisition Officer. The reference court issued notice, and the appellant appeared and filed a written statement claiming enhancement of land value. A commission inspected the land and submitted a report. However, on 3-10-1983, the Sub Judge dismissed the reference for default due to the appellant's absence. Subsequently, on 26-10-1983, an application to restore the reference was filed but dismissed by the impugned order. The present appeal challenges that dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Sub Court has jurisdiction to dismiss a reference made under Section 21 of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act for default.
Arguments of the Parties
Government Pleader's Arguments
- The provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) apply to proceedings before the court under the Act, except where inconsistent with the Act.
- Since CPC provisions apply, dismissal for default by the court is permissible.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chimanlal v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona ((1988) 3 SCC 751 : AIR 1988 S.C 1652) | The award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer is an offer; the court must determine the market value afresh and cannot dismiss the reference for default. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that dismissal for default is inconsistent with the Act, as the court must answer the reference regardless of the presence or absence of the interested party. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the provisions of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act, particularly Sections 21, 22, 25, and 28. It noted that the Act requires the civil court to determine the objection and pass a written award specifying the compensation. The court observed that dismissal of the reference for default results in no award being passed, leaving the reference unanswered, which is inconsistent with the statutory scheme.
While Section 59 of the Act incorporates the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) provisions, this incorporation is only to the extent they are not inconsistent with the Act. The court concluded that dismissal for default is inconsistent with the Act's mandate. Even if the person interested does not adduce evidence, the court must pass an award based on available materials, either confirming or enhancing the compensation.
The court further relied on the Supreme Court decision in Chimanlal v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, which clarified that the Land Acquisition Officer's award is merely an offer, and the court must independently determine market value. The absence of the interested party does not deprive the court of jurisdiction to pass the award. Hence, dismissal for default equates to refusal to answer the reference, which the Act does not permit.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed and the impugned order refusing restoration of the reference is set aside.
The application for restoration of the reference is allowed, thereby reinstating the proceedings before the civil court. This decision ensures that references under Section 21 of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act cannot be dismissed for default, mandating the court to determine compensation regardless of the parties' attendance. No new precedent beyond the direct effect on these parties is set by this ruling.
1. This appeal is against an order refusing to restore a Land Acquisition Reference which was dismissed for default. Pursuant to an Award passed by a Land Acquisition Officer for the land acquired for public purpose, the appellant who is the land owner filed an application under Sec. 20 of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act (for short ‘the Act’) requiring the said officer to refer the matter to the civil court for determination of the land value. The sub court to which the reference was made issued notice to the appellant. He appeared and filed a written statement in which he set out his claim for enhancing land value. A commission was issued at the instance of the appellant and the Commissioner filed a report after inspecting the land which was acquired. On 3-10-1983 learned Sub Judge dismissed the reference for default, as the appellant was absent on that day. Subsequently on 26-10-1983 the present application was filed for restoration of the reference. That was dismissed by the impugned order.
2. The only question to be considered in this appeal is whether the sub court has jurisdiction to dismiss for default a reference made under Sec. 21 of the Act.
3. Learned Government Pleader contended that inasmuch as the provisions or the Code of Civil Procedure (for short ‘the Code’) are made applicable to the proceedings before the court a dismissal for default is permissible. No doubt, Sec. 59 of the Act says “save in so far as they may be inconsistent with anything contained in this Act, the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 shall apply to all proceedings before the court under this Act”. It is clear that the provisions of the Code can be applied only when there is no provision in the Act which is inconsistent therewith.
4. A reference is made to the civil court “for the determination of the court” of the question which either relates to the measurement of the land or the amount of compensation or the person to whom it is payable or the apportionment of the compensation and the person interested. In making the reference, the Land Acquisition Officer shall state in writing for the information of the Court those matters specified in sec. 21 of the Act. On such reference being made the court shall issue notice to be served on the person who applied for reference and also on other persons interested in the objection. Sec. 22 says that the notice shall specify the day on which “the court will proceed to determine the objection”. Sec. 25 says that in determining the amount of compensation to be awarded for the land, the court shall take into consideration the matters enumerated thereunder. Sec. 28(1) says that every award shall be in writing signed by the Judge and shall specify the amount awarded under clause first of sub-section (1) of section 25 and also the amounts, if any, respectively awarded under each of the other clauses of the same sub-section, together with the grounds of awarding each of the said amounts.
5. The provisions referred to above show that the court thas to pass an award when there is a reference under Sec. 21 of the Act. If a court dismisses the reference for default, there will be no award and the reference will remain unanswered. Such a situation is not consistent with the provisions of the Act. It may be, when the person interested does not adduce evidence the court may pass the award on the basis of the materials available on record. Even if no evidence is adduced, court has to pass an order either maintaining the amount specified in the award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer, or enhancing it on account of some valid reasons.
6. In Chimanlal v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona, ((1988) 3 SCC 751 : AIR 1988 S.C 1652), the Supreme Court pointed out that the award passed by a Land Acquisition officer is to be treated by the court only as an offer made by the officer to the land owner and it is for the court to determine the market value of the property afresh on the basis of the materials produced. Absence of the person interested in the land will not divest the court of its jurisdiction to pass the award envisaged in Sec. 28 of the Act. If the court dismisses a reference for default, it tantamount to refusal to answer the reference which is not warranted by the provisions of the Act. So the position is this: When there is a reference to the civil court, such reference has to be answered irrespective of the presence or absence of the person interested.
7. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the impugned order is set aside. The application for restoration of the reference will stand allowed.
Alert