Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ammu Ammal v. Venkitadri Iyer

Kerala High Court
Jun 6, 1980
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

In execution proceedings, the judgment-debtor claimed protection under Ordinance 9 of 1977. The decree-holder responded by serving interrogatories on the judgment-debtor. The execution court overruled the judgment-debtor's objection that interrogatories could not be served in execution proceedings and directed the judgment-debtor to answer them. The judgment-debtor challenged this direction through a revision petition. The core issue for consideration was whether interrogatories could be served and answered in execution proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether interrogatories can be served on a party in execution proceedings.
  2. Whether the court has jurisdiction to direct the opposite party to answer interrogatories in execution proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Judgment-Debtor's Arguments

  • Reliance was placed on Rule I of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which pertains to discovery by interrogatories only in suits and not in execution proceedings.
  • It was contended that Section 141 of the Code and the provisions of Order XI do not apply to execution proceedings.
  • The argument was made that discovery and inspection cannot be ordered in execution proceedings except under the provisions of Order XI, which apply only to suits.

Decree-Holder's Position (as reflected by the court)

  • The execution court held that the suit does not terminate with the decree but only after execution proceedings are complete, suggesting interrogatories may be relevant in execution.
  • The court relied on the broad jurisdiction under Section 30 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to make necessary or reasonable orders related to interrogatories at any time, including execution proceedings.
  • It was emphasized that interrogatories serve as a tool to facilitate proof, obtain admissions, and shorten litigation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri M.L Sethi v. Shri R.P Kapur ((1972) 2 SCC 427 : AIR 1972 SC 2379) Recognition of broad jurisdiction of courts under Section 30 of the CPC to order discovery and interrogatories in any matter. Supported the view that courts can order interrogatories even in execution proceedings, not limited to suits.
D. Bhushayya v. K. Ramakrishnayya (AIR 1962 SC 1886) Section 141 of the CPC and applicability to execution proceedings. Referenced by petitioner but court distinguished this precedent as the decision was based on Section 30, not Section 141 or Order XI.
Alagesundaram Pillai v. Pichuvier (AIR 1929 Madras 757) Applicability of Section 141 of the CPC to execution proceedings. Referenced by petitioner; court noted this precedent but did not rely on it for its decision.
Ram Sewak v. H.K Kidwai (AIR 1964 SC 1249) Power of tribunals and courts to direct discovery and inspection under CPC when trying a suit. Used to emphasize that Section 30 confers power to order discovery and inspection "at any time," including execution proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the applicability of Rule I of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, which explicitly refers to suits and not execution proceedings. However, it did not rely solely on this provision. Instead, it focused on Section 30 of the Code, which grants courts wide jurisdiction to make necessary or reasonable orders relating to delivery and answering of interrogatories at any time, including execution proceedings. The court noted that this section follows the English procedure allowing discovery in any cause or matter and that interrogatories are a useful tool to obtain admissions and shorten litigation. The court rejected the argument that interrogatories cannot be served or answered in execution proceedings and held that the execution court has jurisdiction to direct the answering of interrogatories. The court also clarified that its decision was not based on Section 141 or Order XI but on the broader powers under Section 30. It further declined to rehear the revision petition after considering the arguments and relevant precedents.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The court held that interrogatories can be served and answered in execution proceedings under the jurisdiction conferred by Section 30 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. This decision affirms the execution court's power to regulate discovery processes to facilitate the execution of decrees. No costs were awarded. The ruling clarifies that the provisions of Order XI, which apply strictly to suits, do not limit the court's broader powers under Section 30 in execution matters. The decision does not establish new precedent beyond this clarification but confirms the existing scope of judicial powers in execution proceedings.

Show all summary ...

1. In proceedings in execution the judgment-debtor claimed protection of the provisions of Ordinance 9 of 1977. Thereupon the decree-holder served certain interrogatories on the judgment-debtor. Overruling the objection of the judgment-debtor that no interrogatory could be served in execution proceedings on the opposite party, that court directed the judgment-debtor to answer the interrogatories. The judgment-debtor has come up in revision. The only point that arises for consideration is as to whether interrogatory could be served in execution proceedings and whether the opposite party on whom interrogatories are served could be directed to answer the same.

2. Reliance was placed on behalf of the judgment-debtor, revision petitioner, on Rule I of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 relating to discovery by interrogatories where reference only to suit and not to execution proceedings is made.

3. Before the lower court also the same contention was raised. That court took the view that the suit does not terminate by judgment and decree and it terminates only when the fruits of the decree are realised and the execution proceedings have come to an end. This may be one approach, but I do not propose to rest my decision on that.

4. S. 30 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 confers jurisdiction on the court to make such orders as may be necessary or reasonable in all matters relating to (among others) the delivery and answering of interrogatories at any time either of its own motion or on the application of any party. This power is wide enough to make the court competent to direct any party to answer interrogatories at any time before the suit is decreed, and after the suit is decreed in execution proceedings. The section aforesaid appears to follow the Engligh procedure which enables the court to order discovery in any ‘cause’ or ‘matter’ in the Supreme Court to which the rules of the Suprme Court apply. This aspect has been adverted to by our Supreme Court in Shri M.L Sethi v. Shri R.P Kapur ((1972) 2 SCC 427 : AIR. 1972 SC. 2379). It should in this connection be noticed that interrogatories are usually served on the opposite party to facilitate the proof of his own case and “administering of interrogatories is to be encouraged as it is a means of getting admissions and tends to shorten litigation”. See Mulla's commentaries on the Code of Civil Procedure. Thirteenth Edition, Vol. I at page 829.

5. At any rate I am not prepared to say that the execution court has no jurisdiction to direct the opposite party on whom the interrogatories have been served to answer the same. This jurisdiction is vested in a court under S. 30 of the Code as already pointed out, be it that court is trying a suit or executing a decree.

6. In view of what is stated above there is no merit in this civil revision petition. The same is dismissed. There will be no order as regards costs.

Dismissed.

CMP. No. 8776 of 1980 in CRP. 302/1978-A

7. I disposed of CRP. No. 302 of 1978 dismissing the same. The revision petition was against an order passed by the execution court allowing the decree-holders application to serve certain interrogatories on thejudgment-debtor. It was pointed out by the decision in the aforesaid revision petition that under S. 30 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 the court has jurisdiction to make such orders as may be necessary or reasonable in all matters relating to (among others) the delivery and answering of interrogatories at any time, either on its own motion or on the application of any party. It was further pointed out that the execution court has therefore power and jurisdiction to pass orders as regards answering of interrogatories, though Order XI of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 as such may not be attracted to proceedings in execution, in so far as that order confers power as regards discovery and inspection “in any suit”.

8. The decision aforesaid was on merits and not one for default of the learned counsel for the petitioner. However, the learned counsel was not heard in the matter and he has come up with this C.M.P pointing out that he was not heard and that he may be heard. The learned counsel for the petitioner relying on two decisions, one of the Supreme Court, D. Bhushayya v. K. Ramakrishnayya (AIR. 1962 SC. 1886) and the other of the Madras High Court, Alagesundaram Pillai v. Pichuvier (AIR. 1929 Madras 757) submits that S. 141 of the Code is not attracted to execution proceedings and that therefore the provisions in Order XI of the Code are not attracted to the execution proceedings. The decision in the revision proceeds not on the basis of S. 141 or of the provisions in Order XI of the Code, but on S. 30.

9. The argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that but for the provisions in Order XI of the Code discovery and inspection cannot be ordered and that the provisions in Order XI apply only to suits. I am afraid that the submission aforesaid is not right. In Ram Sewak v. H.K Kidwai (AIR. 1964 SC. 1249) the Supreme Court says that the “Tribunal has undoubtedly the power to direct discovery and inspection of documents with which the civil court is invested under the Code of Civil Procedure when trying a suit”. This power is conferred by S. 30 of the Code, which enables the Court to pass the orders made mention of in that section “at any time”.

10. In view of what is stated above I see no reason to rehear the revision petition. Dismissed.

11. Dismissed.