- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Thankamma v. Unniamma Antharjanam
Opinion Summary — Revision Petition on Court Fee Valuation (Kerala)
Factual and Procedural Background
This document summarizes a revision petition directed against an order of the learned Subordinate Judge, Kottayam, on Issue No. 1 relating to the correctness of the court fee paid by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs filed a suit for partition and separate possession claiming to be co-owners (entitled to 2/5 shares) of properties alleged to be the self-acquisitions of the deceased Damodaran Nambiathiri. The plaintiffs averred that they are children of the deceased by his first (Nair) wife, that the 1st defendant is the second (Nambiathiri) wife and that defendants 2 and 3 are her children. The plaintiffs pleaded that since the death of Damodaran Nambiathiri (9 December 1961) the 1st defendant has been appropriating income from the properties and has not been paying the plaintiffs' share (allegedly fixed at Rs. 150).
At the request of the 1st defendant, Issue No. 1 (whether proper court fee was paid) was tried as a preliminary issue. The learned Subordinate Judge held that the plaintiffs should have paid court fee calculated on the market value of their shares under Section 37(1) of the Kerala Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act, 1959, rather than on the basis invoked by the plaintiffs under Section 37(2). The plaintiffs filed the present revision petition challenging that finding.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the learned Subordinate Judge was correct in holding that the plaintiffs were required to pay court fee on the market value of their shares under Section 37(1) of the Kerala Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act, 1959, rather than on the basis adopted by the plaintiffs under Section 37(2).
- Whether the averments in the plaint (specifically the allegation that the 1st defendant has been appropriating income) amount to an averment of exclusion from possession such that Section 37(1) would apply.
- Whether, for the purpose of determining the correct court fee, the court should confine itself to a prima facie reading of the averments in the plaint rather than considering denials or controversies raised in the written statement.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' (Plaintiffs') Arguments
- Learned counsel for the petitioners (Mr. V. G. Sankaranarayana Pillai) attacked the subordinate judge's finding that court fee should be computed under Section 37(1), contending that the plaint, when read prima facie, shows the plaintiffs claim joint possession as co-owners and only pleads non-receipt of income, not exclusion from possession.
- It was argued that the judge erred in treating the allegation of appropriation of income as amounting to exclusion from possession.
Respondents' Arguments
- Objection was raised on behalf of the defendants that the suit was not properly valued and that because the plaint contains averments that the plaintiffs were being excluded from possession, the proper provision to apply was Section 37(1) (court fee on market value of shares).
- The learned Government Pleader and Mr. G. R. Menon (counsel for the defendants-respondents) supported the Subordinate Judge's order that court fee should be paid under Section 37(1).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Abdul Lateef v. Musthaf Ali, 1959 KLT 412 (Division Bench: Raman Nayar & Velu Pillai, JJ.) | Interpreting sub-section (1) of Section 37 of the Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act: subsection (1) applies only where the case pleaded is one of exclusion from possession; mere appropriation of profits or exclusive use/occupation by one co-sharer does not amount to exclusion of other co-sharers. | The court relied on this authority to conclude that the Subordinate Judge erred in treating the plaint's allegation of appropriation of income as an averment of exclusion from possession; therefore the direction to compute court fee under Section 37(1) was incorrect and had to be set aside. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by first restating the general principle that for the purpose of computing court fee the averments in the plaint must be accepted prima facie; denials or controversies in the written statement do not affect that determination. The truth of the plaint's allegations does not get decided at the court-fee stage.
The court then analysed the particular averments of the plaint: the suit sought partition and separate possession of 2/5 shares, asserted the properties to be self-acquisitions of the deceased, and pleaded that the plaintiffs and defendants claimed possession as co-owners since 9 December 1961. The only allegation suggestive of exclusion was that the 1st defendant had been appropriating the entire income and had not paid the plaintiffs' share (para. 5).
The Subordinate Judge had given two reasons for applying Section 37(1): (i) that joint possession as a family would be prima facie difficult because the plaintiffs were children by a Nair wife while the 1st defendant was of another (Nambiathiri) wife; and (ii) that the plaintiffs' averment of appropriation of income constituted an admission of exclusion from possession. The revisional court rejected both contentions.
On the first point, the revisional court held that the judge overlooked the central allegation that the properties were self-acquisitions of the deceased; if that allegation is established, children (even by a Nair wife) can be co-owners, and possession by the 1st defendant and her children could be possession as co-owners on behalf of the plaintiffs. The question whether that allegation is true is for trial, not for the court-fee determination.
On the second point, the court distinguished exclusion from possession from mere deprivation of income. It emphasised that appropriation of profits or exclusive receipt of income by one co-sharer is legally different from being excluded from possession. The court relied on the Division Bench decision in Abdul Lateef v. Musthaf Ali (1959 KLT 412) to underscore that Section 37(1) applies only where exclusion from possession is pleaded. Because the plaint does not plead exclusion of possession (only non-payment of income), the Subordinate Judge's conclusion that the plaintiffs had pleaded exclusion was erroneous.
Consequently, the revisional court concluded that the Subordinate Judge's direction to treat the case as one of exclusion and to require court fee under Section 37(1) was wrong.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The order under attack is set aside and the revision petition is allowed.
Implications and direct effects:
- The court held that the court fee already paid by the plaintiffs is sufficient; the plaintiffs need not re-value the suit or pay court fee under Section 37(1) on the market value of their shares.
- The suit will proceed in accordance with law on the basis of the plaint as it stands (i.e., the court-fee determination remains as per the plaintiffs' contention under Section 37(2)).
- Parties will bear their own costs.
The opinion applied existing precedent (Abdul Lateef v. Musthaf Ali) in resolving the legal question; it did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond that application.
1. In this revision petition mr. V. G. Sankaranarayana pillai, Learned counsel for the petitioner, Attacks the finding of the learned subordinate judge of kottayam on issue no. 1 regarding the correctness of the court fee paid by the plaintiffs.
2. Issue 1 related to the question as to whether the plaintiffs have paid proper court fee. At the request of the 1st defendant, This issue was tried as a preliminary issue, And ultimately the learned subordinate judge by his order, Which is under attack, Has held that the plaintiffs should have paid the court fee upon the market value of their shares as contemplated in s. 37 (1) of the kerala court fees and suits valuation act, 1959. The correctness of this view expressed by the learned judge is challenged in this revision on behalf of the plaintiff - petitioners.
3. There can be no controversy that for purposes of court fee the averments in the plaint will have to be prima facie accepted. A denial or other controversy raised in the written statement by the defendants has absolutely no bearing on the question of considering the court fee that is payable on the plaint; and for that purpose the court will have exclusively to confine its attention to the averments made in the plaint itself. The truth or otherwise of the allegations in the plaint will not arise at the time of deciding the question of the correct court fee to be paid.
4. In this case it will be seen that the suit itself was for partition and separate possession of the plaintiffs' shares, Claiming to be co - tenants along with the defendants. The plaintiffs claim to be the children by the 1st wife - a nair woman - of deceased damodaran nambiathiri. According to the plaintiffs, The properties, Which are subject of partition, Are the self - acquisitions of deceased damodaran nambiathiri. The 1st defendant is said to be the second wife of deceased damodaran nambiathiri, A nambiathiri woman, And defendants 2 and 3 are said to be her children. The 4th defendant has been impleaded as the widow of one vasudevan nambiathiri of the said illom and according to the plaintiffs the 4th defendant will be entitled to her maintenance claim recognised on the b schedule properties. The said damodaran nambiathiri died on 9th december 1961 intestate, And the plaintiffs aver that inasmuch as the properties, Which are the subject of the litigation, Are the self - acquired properties of the deceased, They are entitled to 2 out of 5 shares and that they are in legal possession of the properties jointly along with the other co - owners. The plaintiffs have also stated, No doubt, That ever since the death of damodaran nambiathiri, Viz., 9th december 1961 the 1st defendant has been appropriating the income accruing from the properties and that she has not been paying the plaintiffs' share, Which is fixed at rs. 150. The plaintiffs have also referred to certain other matters in the plaint. In particular it will be seen in para. 4 of the plaint, They refer to their being entitled in law to 2/5 shares in the properties of the deceased, Owned by themselves along with the other co - owners. So far as i could see, The averments in para. 5 of the plaint are that the 1st defendant, Ever since the death of damodaran nambiathiri, Is taking the income from the properties and appropriating it to herself and not paying their share. Ultimately they also recognise the right of the 4th defendant to have her maintenance right declared in respect of the b schedule properties, And subject to that right, They ask for relief by way of partition and separate possession of 2/5 shares, And also pray for directing the 1st defendant to pay their share out of the income that she has collected ever since the death of damodaran nambiathiri. On this basis, The plaintiffs have ultimately valued the reliefs claimed in the plaint, Under s. 37 (2) of the court fees and suits valuation act, 1959.
5. As i mentioned earlier, Objection appears to have been taken on behalf of the defendants that the suit has not been properly valued and that inasmuch as there are averments in the plaint that the plaintiffs have been excluded from possession of the properties, The proper provision of the statute, Under which they should have paid court fee, Is on the market value of their shares of the properties under s. 37 (1) of the act. The question is whether this contention of the defendants is correct or not. The learned subordinate judge has no doubt ultimately accepted the contentions raised on behalf of the defendants and, As i have already stated, Has held that court fee will have to be paid on the market value of the plaintiffs' shares under s. 37 (1) of the act.
6. So far as i could see, Two reasons have been given by the learned judge for coming to this conclusion, Namely (i) that the plaintiffs being the children by a nair wife of the deceased damodaran nambiathiri, Joint possession as a family becomes prima facie difficult, If not altogether impossible, Especially when the plaintiffs' status as children of the deceased nambiathiri is denied. The second reason given by the learned subordinate judge is that the plaintiffs themselves have averred that the 1st defendant has been appropriating to herself the income accruing from the properties, Without paying their share from the date of death of damodaran nambiathiri, I. E., 9th december 1961. This circumstance, According to the learned judge, Will clearly show that even according to the plaintiffs, They have been excluded from the possession of properties and therefore payment of court fee under s. 37[2] of the act is not justified; and in consequence he has called upon the plaintiffs to pay court fee under s. 37[1]. This order of the learned judge is very strenuously attacked by mr. Sankaranarayana pillai, Learned counsel for the plaintiff - petitioners.
7. No doubt, The learned government pleader appearing for the state, To whom notice has been issued, As well as mr. G. R. Menon, Learned counsel for the defendants - respondents, Have attempted to sustain the order of the learned judge. I am not inclined to accept the reasons given by the learned judge for coming to the conclusion that averments in the plaint will give an indication that even according to the plaintiffs they have been excluded from possession of the properties. But on the other hand, A reading of the plaint will clearly go to show that after the death of damodaran nambiathiri, The plaintiffs and the defendants claim to be in law, In possession as co - owners and they are in such possession from 9th december 1961, And that in law the plaintiffs are entitled to 2/5 shares out of the properties owned jointly by the plaintiffs and the other defendants. The only averment in the plaint which will show that they have not been getting the income due to them from the properties is contained in para. 5, Wherein they have no doubt stated that the 1st defendant is realising the entire income from the properties ever since the death of damodaran nambiathiri from 9th december 1961 and that the 1st defendant has not been paying the plaintiffs' share which is fixed at rs. 150.
8. The learned subordinate judge seems to have been obsessed with the idea that because the plaintiffs are the children by the nair wife of deceased damodaran nambiathiri, There cannot be a joint possession as such by the plaintiffs and the defendants. Evidently the learned judge forgot that the whole plaint is based on the allegation that the properties, In respect of which the plaintiffs are seeking a partition and possession of their 2/5 shares, Are the self - acquired properties of deceased damodaran nambiathiri. As to whether that allegation is true or not, Or as to whether the plaintiffs will be able to make out that case, Is a matter which will arise for consideration in the suit. If the plaintiffs are the children of deceased damodaran nambiathiri and the properties are self - acquired properties of the deceased, Then there can be no controversy, That notwithstanding the fact that they may be the children by the nair wife of deceased damodaran nambiathiri, The possession by the 1st defendant and her children, Who are no doubt the caste wife and children of deceased damodaran nambiathiri, Will certainly amount to possession as co - owners in law for and on behalf of the plaintiffs also. That aspect unfortunately has been missed by the learned judge.
9. Then the question is whether the view of the learned judge that because the plaintiffs themselves have stated that they have not been getting the income from the properties from 9th december 1961 and that the 1st defendant has been appropriating the income, It will amount to an averment that the plaintiffs have been excluded from possession. Exclusion from enjoyment of receipt of income is totally different from exclusion from possession. This aspect again has been very seriously missed by the learned judge in the order under attack. The learned judge has proceeded on the basis that the mere circumstance that the plaintiffs have averred that they are not being given their legitimate share of the income from the properties by the 1st defendant, Will also amount to a plea of exclusion of possession from the properties. Authority for the position that this view is wrong, If it is necessary, Is to be found in the division bench decision of this court by raman nayar and velu pillai, Jj., Reported in abdul lateef v. Musthaf ali 1959 klt. 412. In that decision the learned judges have considered the scope of sub - section (1) of s. 37 of the court fees and suits valuation act, And held that the provision in sub - section (1) of s. 37 can apply, Only, If the case pleaded is one of exclusion of the plaintiff from possession. The learned judges have also held that mere appropriation of the profits of the property or even exclusive use or possession of the property by one co - sharer, Does not amount in law to 'exclusion' of other co - sharers from possession, And such exclusion will have to be established by the averments in the plaint and other evidence in the case. Therefore, Going by the averments in the plaint, In my view, The direction given by the learned judge that the plaintiffs should be understood to proceed on the basis that they are excluded from possession and therefore court fee should be paid under s. 37 (1), Is absolutely erroneous and that order has to be set aside.
if that order is set aside, It follows that the court fee already paid by the plaintiffs is sufficient and the suit will proceed in accordance with law.
10. The order under attack is therefore set aside, And the revision petition allowed. Parties will bear their own costs.
Alert