Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Damodaran v. Lakshmikutty Amma

Kerala High Court
Dec 21, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns two criminal revision petitions (Crl. R. P. No. 57/77 filed by the husband and Crl. R. P. No. 64/77 filed by the wife). The parties married in 1963 and had two daughters (Vanaja and Thulasi, aged 11 and 9 at the relevant time). The wife originally obtained a maintenance order from the Additional Judicial Magistrate on 1 July 1974: Rs. 40 per month to the wife and Rs. 20 per month to each child. In 1975 the wife filed an application under Section 127 CrPC (M.C. No. 57/75) seeking enhanced maintenance alleging change of circumstances. The husband resisted, relying on an agreement marked ext. D1 by which, he contended, the wife and children had given up rights to claim enhanced maintenance. The magistrate granted enhanced maintenance (Rs. 70 to the wife and Rs. 40 to each child). Both parties challenged orders in the Sessions Court (each filed revision petitions), and that court altered the awards: it held the wife bound by ext. D1 (reducing the wife's maintenance to Rs. 40), but enhanced maintenance for the minors to Rs. 70 and Rs. 60 respectively. Both parties then challenged that common order; the present opinion decides those challenges.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a party can contract out of the statutory obligation to give maintenance arising under Sections 125 and 127 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (i.e., whether ext. D1 can deprive the wife/children of the statutory right to claim enhanced maintenance).
  2. Whether the maintenance awarded in the case is disproportionate to the husband's income (i.e., whether there has been a change in circumstances and whether the quantum awarded is excessive).

Arguments of the Parties

Wife's Arguments

  • ext. D1 is hit by Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act and is therefore inoperative/unenforceable.
  • A statutory right conferred on the wife under Sections 125 and 127 CrPC cannot be taken away by a contract between the parties.
  • Cited authorities in support of the principle that one cannot contract out of a statutory obligation (examples cited in the opinion: Sadasivan Nair v. Kamalakshi; Abubacker v. Katheesa; Woman Shrinivas v. R. B. & Co.).

Husband's Arguments

  • ext. D1 is supported by valid consideration: the husband paid Rs. 500 and gave ornaments (weighed 9.5 sovereigns) to the wife.
  • Because the agreement was supported by consideration and did not contain absolute restraint of legal proceedings, Section 23 of the Contract Act does not apply.
  • Relied on judicial authorities said to support enforceability of the agreement (Sone Singh v. State Industrial Court and Firm Praiapachant v. Firm Kotrike).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sone Singh v. State Industrial Court (1974 Lab I.C. 784) Cited by husband's counsel regarding applicability of Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act to the agreement relied upon. The court observed this decision concerned the question whether the agreement in that case fell within the purview of Section 23; the court found it inapplicable to the facts here.
Firm Praiapachant v. Firm Kotrike (AIR 1975 SC 1223) Cited by husband's counsel (court notes the case dealt with wagering contracts). The court held this decision (concerning wagering contracts) was not applicable to the present facts.
Sadasivan Nair v. Kamalakshi (1975 (1) ILR Ker. 531) States the general principle that when a statute enjoins or directs a thing to be done it is not open to a person to contract out of that obligation. The court relied on this decision to support the conclusion that a party cannot contract out of statutory obligations under Sections 125 and 127 CrPC.
Abubacker v. Katheesa (1961 KLT 581) Held that a father cannot divest himself of his liability to maintain a child by agreement with the mother. The court applied this principle analogously to hold that a waiver/agreement cannot extinguish statutory maintenance rights.
Woman Shrinivas v. R. B. & Co. (AIR 1959 SC 689) Authority for the proposition that enforcement of an agreement which results in contravention of statutory provisions will not be permitted. The court cited this decision to support refusal to enforce ext. D1 because its enforcement would contravene statutory maintenance provisions.
Pollock & Mulla, Indian Contract and Specific Relief Acts (Ninth edition) Discusses that a plea of waiver cannot be given effect to if it results in enforcement of an agreement in contravention of a statutory provision; collateral illegality renders contract unenforceable. The court quoted and relied on this statement to reinforce the legal proposition that an agreement indirectly connected to illegality is unenforceable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two stages corresponding to the two main issues.

First, on whether ext. D1 can bar a claim under Section 127 CrPC: the court observed that Sections 125 and 127 CrPC confer statutory rights on a wife and children to receive maintenance and to claim enhancement upon change of circumstances. Section 127(1) authorises the magistrate, on proof of change of circumstances, to alter allowances granted under Section 125. The court therefore framed the legal question whether a private agreement (ext. D1) could deprive the beneficiaries of the statutory right to seek enhanced maintenance.

The court examined the factual context in which ext. D1 was executed: it followed a compromise of a suit for recovery of past maintenance and delivery expenses; the purported consideration (Rs. 500) related to amounts claimed in the plaint, and the ornaments were found to be the wife's own property previously taken by the husband. The court concluded that the alleged payments and return of ornaments did not constitute consideration that could validly license the wife to forgo a statutory right to enhanced maintenance.

On the applicable legal doctrine, the court invoked Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act (which renders void agreements whose object is forbidden by law or defeats provisions of any law, or is opposed to public policy). The court reasoned that permitting parties to contract out of statutory maintenance obligations would defeat statutory provisions designed as measures of social justice (to prevent vagrancy and starvation). Therefore, a contract like ext. D1—which would take away the statutory right to enhanced maintenance under Section 127—was opposed to public policy and void.

The court surveyed authorities supporting this principle (Sadasivan Nair; Abubacker; Woman Shrinivas) and rejected the husband's cited decisions as inapplicable to these facts (Sone Singh concerned the applicability of Section 23 in a different factual setting; the other Supreme Court decision dealt with wagering contracts).

The court thus concluded that the wife (petitioner in Crl. R. P. No. 64/77) was not bound by ext. D1 and could claim enhanced maintenance under Section 127.

Second, as to change of circumstances and appropriate quantum, the court found that change in circumstances had been proved: the children were school-going (7th and 4th standards) and the husband’s income evidence varied (wife said salary Rs. 526 plus property income; husband said Rs. 420 after deductions and no other income). The court relied on a certificate and affidavit (education officer) showing the husband’s salary as Rs. 651 as of 26-11-1975. Taking the evidence as a whole, the court determined reasonable monthly maintenance amounts: Rs. 50 for the wife and Rs. 60 and Rs. 50 respectively for the two minor children.

The court set aside the orders of the lower courts and substituted its own order awarding the revised maintenance. It specified the effective date of the award as 14-6-1976 (the date of the magistrate's earlier order).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that ext. D1 is unenforceable insofar as it purports to deprive the wife and children of the statutory right to claim enhanced maintenance under Sections 125 and 127 CrPC. The petitions were disposed of by setting aside the orders below and substituting an order awarding maintenance at the rate of Rs. 50 per mensem to the wife and Rs. 60 and Rs. 50 per mensem respectively to the two children, effective from 14-6-1976.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: previous orders of the lower courts were set aside and replaced by the court's award of maintenance in the specified amounts and with the specified effective date.
  • On precedent and broader law: the opinion reasons from established authorities that statutory maintenance obligations under Sections 125 and 127 cannot be contracted away; the decision enforces that principle in the facts of this case. The opinion does not purport to create any novel legal principle beyond applying Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act and existing case law to the facts, and no broader new precedent-setting language is stated beyond applying those principles to ext. D1.

Result: The petitions are disposed of in accordance with the substituted order described above.

Show all summary ...

1. The two questions which arise for determination in these criminal revision petitions, Crl. R. P. No. 57/77 filed by the husband and crl. R. P. No. 64/77 filed by the wife, Are whether a party can contract out of the statutory obligation to give maintenance arising under s. 125 and 127 of the code of criminal procedure and whether the maintenance awarded in the case is disproportionate to the income of the husband.

2. The petitioner in crl. R. P. No. 57, Now a headmaster in an upper primary school, Married the petitioner in crl. R. P. No. 64/77 in the year 1963 and during their wedlock two daughters vanaja and thulasi, Now aged 11 and 9 respectively, Were born to them. Alleging neglect on the part of the husband to maintain, A petition was filed by the wife before the additional judicial magistrate of the first class, Tellicherry claiming maintenance for herself and the children. The magistrate passed an order on july 1, 1974 granting maintenance at the rate of rs. 40/ - per mensem to the wife and rs. 20/ - each to the minor children. Thereafter, In the year 1975, The wife filed m. C. No. 57/75 before the same court under s. 127 of the code of criminal procedure claiming enhanced maintenance for herself and for her two minor children alleging change in their circumstances. This application was resisted by the husband on the

ground that as per ext. D1 contract, The wife and the children have given up their right to claim enhanced maintenance and there has been no change of circumstance to warrant interference with the order of maintenance previously passed. The learned magistrate, On a consideration of evidence adduced on both sides, Held that the wife and children are not bound by ext. D1 agreement and that there has been a change in the circumstance since the passing of the first order and awarded maintenance at the rate of rs. 70/ - per mensem to the wife and rs. 40/ - each to the two minor children. This order was challenged by both the parties before the court of session, Tellicherry, The husband filing crl. R. P. No. 65/76, And the wife crl. R. P. No. 77/76. That court disposed of these petitions by a common order holding that, Although there has been a change in the circumstances, The wife is bound by ext. D1 agreement and reduced the amount of maintenance granted to the wife to rs. 40/ - per mensem, But enhanced the maintenance granted to the minors by awarding rs. 70/ - and rs. 60/ - respectively per mensem.

3. This order is challenged by both parties, The husband on the ground that the minors are not entitled to enhanced maintenance and the quantum of maintenance awarded to them is excessive and the wife con tending that ext. D1, Which is inoperative and unenforceable under the indian contract act cannot take away her right to claim enhanced maintenance under s. 127 of the code of criminal procedure.

4. The first question arising for decision is whether the wife is entitled to claim enhanced maintenance in view of the agreement in ext. D1. It was contended on behalf of the wife that ext. D1 agreement is clearly hit by s. 23 of the indian contract act and that a statutory right conferred on the wife cannot be taken away by a contract entered into between the parties.

5. It is not disputed that the wife was receiving a monthly allowance as ordered by the magistrate. It is only on the ground that the wife is bound by ext. D1 agreement that the husband is refusing to give her anything more than what has been agreed to in ext. D1. Under s. 127 (1) of the code, On proof of a change in the circumstances of any person, Receiving under s. 125 a monthly allowance, Or ordered under the same section to pay a monthly allowance to his wife, Father or mother, As the case may be, The magistrate can make such alteration in the allowance as he thinks fit. The child or mother receiving maintenance under s. 125 of the code has been given a right under s. 127 to claim enhanced maintenance on proof of change in their circumstances. Before considering the validity and enforceability of ext. D1 against the claim of the wife and the children, It is necessary to notice the circumstances under which this agreement was said to have been executed. The wife filed a suit for recovery of past maintenance and delivery expenses before the munsiff's court. This suit was compromised and it was thereafter that ext. D - 1 happened to be executed. The counsel for the husband vigorously argued that ext. D1 agreement is fully supported by consideration in as much as the husband paid an amount of rs. 500/ - and also given to the wife ornaments weighting 91/2 sovereigns, That the wife had clearly agreed not to claim enhanced maintenance, That there is no absolute restraint of any legal proceedings incorporated in the agreement and therefore s. 23 of the act cannot apply to the facts of this case. In support of this contention, The counsel relied on the decisions reported in sone singh v. State industrial court (1974 lab i. C. 784) and firm praiapachant v. Firm kotrike (air. 1975 sc. 1223) ; while the counsel for the wife cited sadasivan nair v. Kamalakshi 1975 (1) ilr. Ker. 531, Abubacker v. Katheesa (1961 klt. 581) and woman shrinivas v. R. B. & co. (air. 1959 s. C 689) to support his contentions, A reading of ext. D1 clearly shows that the amount of rs. 500/ - agreed to be paid by the husband was towards the amount claimed in the plaint and that the ornaments said to have been given to the wife were those which belonged to her and had been taken away by the husband from her. It cannot therefore be said that it was on receiving the amount and ornaments that the wife agreed to forgo her right to claim enhanced maintenance. S. 23 of the indian contract act reads:

"the consideration or object of an agreement is lawful, Unless it is forbidden by law; or is such a nature that, If permitted, It would defeat the provisions of any law, Or is fraudulent; or involves or implies injury to the person or property of another; or the court regards it is immoral, Or opposed to public policy. In each of these cases, The consideration or object of an agreement is said to be unlawful. Every agreement of which the object or consideration is unlawful is void"
.

a statutory obligation has been imposed on a husband to maintain his wife and children unable to maintain themselves and also to give enhanced maintenance to them under s. 127 of the code. No party can be permitted to contract himself out of such an obligation and if permitted, It would certainly be defeating a legal right statutorily conferred under s. 125 and 127 of the code. The primary object of the salutory provisions in s. 125 and 127 in chapter ix of the code of criminal procedure', Specially enacted as a measure of social justice to protect women and children, Is to provide a speedy and summary remedy ensuring some supply of food, Clothing and shelter to a deserted or discarded or neglected wife and children and thus prevent vagrancy and save them from starvation and misery. A contract of the nature in ext. D1 taking away the statutory right of claiming enhanced maintenance under s. 127 of the code of criminal procedure is certainly one opposed to public policy.

6. In sadasivan nair v. Kamalakshi (1975 (1) ilr. Ker. 531) this court while considering almost a similar question held that the general principle is that when a statute enjoins or directs a thing to be done by a person, It is not open to him to contract out of that obligation. In abubacker v. Katheesa (1961 klt. 581) this court has taken a similar view. There it was a case where a father paid a lump sum to the mother towards the maintenance of a minor child and entered into an agreement with her that he need not pay anything more towards maintenance. It was held that a father cannot divest himself of bis liability to maintain his child by an agreement with his wife. A plea of waiver of rights under s. 125 and 127 of the code of criminal procedure cannot be sustained because as a result of giving effect to that plea, The court would be enforcing an illegal agreement and thus contravening the statutory provisions. A waiver in derogation of a statutory right is not favoured. So also a waiver which offends public policy will be inoperative and void. It is not permissible to any person to rely upon a contract the making of which the law prohibits. By enforcing ext. D1 contract, The consequence will be enforcement of an illegality and infraction of a statutory provision which cannot be condoned by any contract or agreement of parties. (see woman shrinivas v. R. B. & co., Air. 1959 sc. 689).

"a plea of waiver cannot be given effect to if the consequence is the enforcement of an agreement in contravention of a statutory, Provision and produce the very result which the statute prohibits and makes illegal: if unlawfulness or illegality is even indirectly connected with a perfectly innocent and legal contract, The contract is rendered unlawful or illegal, The court would refuse to enforce it. This would include a collateral or an earlier illegality"
. (see pollock & mulla, Indian contract and specific relief acts, Ninth edition, P. 249). Both the decisions cited by the counsel for the husband have no application to the facts of the case under consideration. In sone singh v. State industrial court (1974 lab lc. 784) the question that arose for consideration was whether the agreement relied on in that case was one coming within the purview of s. 23 of the indian contract act. In. The other case, The supreme court was dealing with wagering contracts.

7. It follows from the above that the petitioner in crl. R; p. No. 64 of 1977 (the wife) is not bound by ext. D1 agreement and the statutory right of a wife to get enhanced maintenance cannot be deprived of or denied by an agreement of the nature found in ext. D1.

8. The next point for consideration is whether there has been any proof of change in circumstances and the maintenance awarded to the wife and the two minors is in any way excessive. The first child at the material time was studying in the 7th standard and the second in the 4th standard. The evidence on record clearly establishes that there has been change of circumstances. According to the wife, The husband was getting an amount of rs. 526/ - per month as salary besides the income which he gets from the properties; while the husband would state that his salary was rs. 420/ - after the deductions and that he has no other source of income. It is seen from the certificate issued by the educational officer produced in this court accompanied by an affidavit that the husband was getting a salary of rs. 651/ - as on 26 - 11 - 1975. In the light of the relevant facts and circumstances disclosed in evidence, I think an amount of rs. 50/ - to the wife and 60/ - and rs. 50/ - per mensem respectively to the minor children will be quite reasonable.

in the result, The orders of the courts below are set aside and instead an order awarding maintenance at the rate of rs. 50/ - per mensem to the wife and rs. 60/ - and 50/ - per mensem respectively to the two children is passed. This order will take effect from 14 - 6 - 1976 the date of the order passed by the magistrate.

the petitions are disposed of as above.