Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K.C Thomas v. Supt. Of Police

Kerala High Court
Dec 20, 1979
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner obtained an injunction (Ext. P1) from the District Judge's Court, Thodupzha, restraining the 3rd respondent and others from enclosing a 3-foot space adjacent to the northern wall of the petitioner's building and from constructing a shade abutting the petitioner's roof. The petitioner alleges the 3rd respondent, an influential political figure, was violating that injunction and, after perceived inaction by the police, approached this court seeking relief. The court notes that there is an existing civil court injunction, that no violation has been established on the record, and that counsel for the 3rd respondent represented he would not violate the injunction. The court disposed of the petition and awarded no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this court should direct the police to enforce or act upon orders of civil courts (such as injunctions) in disputes concerning possession, easements or similar civil rights.
  2. Whether the police are competent to determine and act upon questions of possession, rights to enjoyment of property, easements or nuisances that are essentially civil disputes.
  3. Whether the petitioner established a breach of the existing injunction sufficient to warrant directions by this court against the 3rd respondent or police intervention.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The 3rd respondent was violating the injunction by enclosing the 3-foot space and constructing a shade abutting the petitioner's roof.
  • The police were indifferent or inactive in the face of the alleged violation, compelling the petitioner to approach this court.

3rd Respondent's Arguments

  • Counsel for the 3rd respondent assured the court that the 3rd respondent did not propose to violate the injunction order.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court treated the dispute as essentially civil and emphasised that matters of possession, easements, nuisance and similar rights are for civil courts to adjudicate rather than for the police to decide. It reasoned that empowering police to determine such civil rights would risk abuse and jeopardise the rule of law. The court observed that civil courts possess statutory mechanisms under the Civil Procedure Code to enforce injunctions (including compulsory measures such as civil imprisonment to secure compliance) and that injunctions—especially ex parte or interlocutory orders—may be modified, reversed or confirmed by courts on full hearing or appeal. Given these considerations, the court found no established violation on the record and accepted the 3rd respondent's counsel's assurance against breach. On that basis, the court concluded there was no need to issue directions to the police; if a violation occurs despite the assurance and order, the petitioner may then seek appropriate relief.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF — no directions issued; no costs.

Direct effect: The petition was dismissed/ disposed of and no order was made directing police action. The court required a factual showing of breach before intervening and accepted the 3rd respondent's counsel's assurance as sufficient in the circumstances.

Broader implications explained by the court: civil courts are the appropriate forum to adjudicate disputes over possession, easements and similar rights; police are not to be vested with judicial functions in such matters; civil courts have statutory powers under the Civil Procedure Code to enforce injunctions, and routine recourse to this court to direct police to enforce civil orders is unjustified.

Show all summary ...

1. The dispute between the parties is essentially one of a civil nature and perhaps I could have summarily disposed of this O.P, but I am proposing to deal with it on the merits only because petitions of this nature appear to be quite common these days and therefore it would be profitable to define the limits of discretionary exercise of the power of this court in such matters. Before I set down my views on the principle involved let me deal with the case before me.

2. Having obtained an order for injunction. Ext. P1, from the District Judge's Court, Thodupzha, restraining the 3rd respondent herein and others from enclosing the space of 3 feet touching the northern wall of the petitioner's building and constructing the shade “abutting over the petitioner's roof”, the petitioner came to this court complaining that the 3rd respondent, who is highly influential as Chairman of a political party, is misconducting himself by violating the letter and spirit of the injunction order.

3. It is said that the petitioner approached the police and because of the indifferent inaction by the police, he was driven to this court.

4. As it is there is an order of the civil court in force and the 3rd respondent has no case that he has violated the order. It has not been established that the 3 feet way has been enclosed nor has it been shown that any shade has been constructed “abutting over the petitioner's roof”. Certainly the petitioner cannot expect the police to exercise themselves because of apprehensions of the petitioner in a matter of this nature. To dispose of this case it is sufficient to record the submission of counsel for the 3rd respondent that he does not propose to violate the injunction order. If, despite such assurance and the order of injunction, there is violation, it would be time enough then for the petitioner to seek appropriate relief. Hence as it is no direction is called for.

5. Questions of possession, right to enjoy property or easements without obstruction, nuisances and similar other matters are best adjudged by a civil court. These are not certainly matters for the police to sit in judgment upon. The rule of law in this country is likely to be jeopardised if policemen are to decide whether they should recognise rights of easements, rights of possession and other similar civil rights and use their force to help one party or other in whose favour they reach a decision. Resort to this court seeking police assistance in matters where decisions on such questions are called for would certainly be ill-advised. To recognise policemen as competent to decide such disputes would be giving them powers which are capable of abuse. If there is a genuine dispute between the parties that has to be resolved by the civil courts. If the police feel that there is a genuine dispute which should normally call for decision by an appropriate court, they will be right in refusing to interfere.

6. From the number of petitions that are filed in this court complaining that despite orders of injunction police are ineffective, it would appear that the civil courts which grant orders of injunction are impotent in the matter of enforcing them. If a court passes an order of injunction, it has powers to see that such injunction is respected. The Civil Procedure Code empowers the court to make an erring party comply with the order of the court and to take effective action against infringement or violation of an order of injunction passed by the court by even keeping the offender in civil prison so as to compel him to comply. Therefore it would certainly be inadvisable for this court to embark upon the exercise of issuing directions to police officers, whenever some order or other is obtained from a court, to enforce such order. More so, when, as it quite happens, the orders are ex parte interim orders, for by their very nature they are liable to be modified or reversed or confirmed when the other party appears and contests. Even injunction orders passed after hearing both sides are liable to be reversed in appeal. The long and short of it is that though this court is not without power to issue directions in a very appropriate case of inaction by the police in such matters the resort to this court as a matter of course would be unjustified.

7. So far as the case on hand is concerned I have indicated that the stand taken by the 3rd respondent is sufficient answer and in view of this there is no scope for complaint on the part of the petitioner.

8. Disposed of accordingly. No costs.