- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ebrahim Sulaiman Sait v. M.C.Mohammed
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal under s. Ii6 - a of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The appellant had been elected to the Lok Sabha from the Manjeri Parliamentary Constituency in Kerala. On an election petition presented on May 3, 1977 by the first respondent (an elector in that constituency), the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam declared the appellant's election void on the ground that the returned candidate was guilty of the corrupt practice specified in subsection (3a) of section 123 of the Act. The appellant contested the election as a candidate of the Muslim League. The second respondent before the Supreme Court had contested as a nominee of a dissident group described as "Muslim League (Opposition)" supported by, as stated in the election petition, the Janata Party and Marxist Party.
The High Court's decision rested solely on an allegation that the appellant, during the election campaign, made a speech in English at Pullickal within the constituency; a Malayalam translated report of that speech appeared in the local daily Chandrika on March 17, 1977 (exhibit P-6). The election petition contained other allegations but the High Court convicted on the basis of the reported speech alone. The appellant challenged the High Court's decision in this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant's speech (as reported in exhibit P-6) amounted to the corrupt practice described in section 123(3a) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (promotion or attempt to promote feelings of enmity or hatred between different classes of citizens on grounds of religion, race, caste, community or language by a candidate or his agent).
- Whether subsection 123(3a) should be read in the light of section 125 of the Act so as to require proof of incitement to violence or a likelihood of public disorder (as argued by the appellant relying on Kedar Nath Singh).
- Whether a political party can be treated as a "class" for the purposes of section 123(3a), and whether criticism directed at a political party (rather than a religious community) falls outside the mischief of section 123(3a).
- Whether truth is a defence to a charge under section 123(3a) and whether historical allegations (years-old events) justify the classification of the speech as a corrupt practice.
- Whether a corrupt practice under section 123(3a) can be committed where both the speaker and the targeted rival are of the same religion.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (as presented through Mr. Nariman)
- The full text of the speech was not available; only a translated report (exhibit P-6) existed, and it would be unsafe to draw conclusions solely from that report.
- Section 123(3a) must be read with section 125 of the Act; reading them together (and by analogy to the Court's interpretation in Kedar Nath Singh concerning sedition) requires a showing of intention or tendency to create disorder or incitement to violence—an ingredient absent in the present case.
- A political party cannot be described as a "class" within the meaning of section 123(3a); the speech was directed at a political party (Muslim League (Opposition)) and therefore did not fall within 123(3a).
- The inapplicability of 123(3a) because both the appellant and the rival candidate belonged to the same religion (Muslim) — i.e., the appeal was not on religious grounds between different religious classes.
- As to allegations of killings and burning of mosques, those assertions were based on facts (the appellant relied on a report of a Commission of Inquiry regarding the Tellicherry disturbances of 1971) and truth should be relevant to the assessment.
Petitioner's / First Respondent's Position (as reflected in the record and High Court findings)
- The election petition alleged that the translated report of the appellant's speech (exhibit P-6) promoted feelings of enmity or hatred between different classes of citizens on the ground of religion, and thus constituted a corrupt practice under section 123(3a).
- The petitioner produced witnesses (Pw.2 and Pw.4) to show the speech's effect on voters and relied on exhibit P-6 as a faithful record of what the appellant had said; no suggestion was made in the written statement or evidence that other portions of the speech mitigated the reported content.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jumuna Prasad Mukhartya & Others v. Lachhi Ram & Others (1955) 1 SCR 608 | Upheld provisions in the Representation of the People Act (sections similar to present provision) as intra vires Article 19(1)(a); the statute regulates conditions for entering Parliament and does not violate freedom of speech as applied to candidates. | The Court relied on this authority to reject the contention that section 123(3a) is vulnerable to the freedom of speech challenge; the Court held section 123(3a) intra vires and therefore did not adopt the appellant's restrictive construction based on Art. 19(1)(a). |
| Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar (1962) Suppl. 2 SCR 769 | Limited the scope of sedition (Section 124A IPC) to acts involving intention or tendency to create disorder, disturbance of law and order, or incitement to violence (to save the provision from constitutional challenge). | The appellant invoked this case to argue that similar limiting construction should apply to section 125 and thus to the interpretation of section 123(3a). The Court rejected the argument that Kedar Nath Singh required construing section 123(3a) as importing an element of incitement to violence or public disorder. |
| Kultar Singh v. Mukhtiar Singh (1964) 7 SCR 790 | Held that a corrupt practice under section 123 can be committed by appealing to voters on the ground of religion even though the rival candidate belongs to the same religion; includes analysis (Gajendragadkar J.) about political parties whose membership is predominantly from particular communities. | The Court relied on this decision for two points: (1) that a corrupt practice may be committed even where both candidates share the same religion; and (2) to explain how appeals by communal parties should be viewed in the context of corrupt practices. |
| Kanti Prasad Jaysahanker Yagnik v. Purshottamdas Ranchhoddas Patel & Others (1969) 3 SCR 400 | Recognized that the law does not place a bar on describing a political party as irreligious. | The Court cited this authority to note that calling a party "anti-religious" is not barred by law; however, the Court proceeded to assess whether the speech promoted enmity or hatred between classes on religious grounds. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through a structured analysis grounded in evidence and statutory interpretation:
- Reliability of Exhibit P-6: The High Court and this Court found the translated newspaper report (exhibit P-6) admissible and reliable. The appellant had admitted in an affidavit that the reporter's version "more or less tally[ed]" with what he said, and no suggestion was made in the written statement or at evidence that other portions of the speech would mitigate the reported passages. The Court therefore rejected the contention that reliance on the report was unsafe.
- Interpretation of section 123(3a) vis-à-vis section 125: The appellant argued that section 123(3a) should be read alongside section 125 and thereby limited to speech that incites violence or public disorder. The Court distinguished the provisions: section 123(3a) defines a corrupt practice by a candidate (or his agent or with his consent) for electoral advantage, while section 125 creates a criminal offence applicable to any person and does not require proof of motive. The Court concluded there was no reason to read section 123(3a) through the lens of section 125 and refused to import the Kedar Nath Singh limitation into section 123(3a).
- Constitutional vires and earlier authority: Relying on Jumuna Prasad Mukhartya, the Court held that regulations governing candidates' conduct (such as section 123(3a)) are permissible constraints on the statutory right to contest elections and are intra vires Article 19(1)(a). This foreclosed the appellant's argument that section 123(3a) should be narrowly construed on free speech grounds.
- Scope of "class" and alleged communal effect: The Court declined to decide the abstract question whether a political party is a "class" for section 123(3a) purposes, observing instead that an attack aimed at a political party may still promote enmity between classes if its likely effect on voters is to provoke such feelings. The Court noted prior authority that a corrupt practice may be committed even if both candidates are of the same religion (Kultar Singh).
- Truth as defence: The Court explicitly held that truth is not a defense to a charge under section 123(3a); what matters is whether the speech promoted or attempted to promote feelings of enmity or hatred on the enumerated grounds. Whether the allegations were factually true (and even if supported by past Commission reports) did not absolve the appellant if the effect was to promote enmity.
- Evaluation of the speech and evidence of effect: The Court examined the reported text. The report contained statements alleging that the "anti-religious league people" allied with the Jansangh had killed many Muslims and burnt mosques, accused them of betraying Muslim "secrets" to Marxists and Hindu leaders, and urged that such parties should not hope for Muslim votes "in whose head the Islam's blood was flowing." The Court acknowledged the speech's communal tone but emphasized the need to assess likely effect on ordinary voters. The petitioner's witnesses testified about feelings after the speech, but on cross-examination their statements either qualified themselves or reduced the speech's effect to mere political criticism (e.g., persuading voters the opposition candidate must be defeated).
- Standard of proof: The Court reiterated the well-established principle that an allegation of corrupt practice must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. Having considered the text of the speech and the witness evidence, the Court concluded that the speech, viewed as a whole, sought to criticize the policy of the Muslim League (Opposition) in aligning with certain parties and emphasise alleged past atrocities, rather than to promote or attempt to promote the enmity or hatred between different classes in the sense required by section 123(3a).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed; the election petition is dismissed and costs are awarded to the appellant.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The High Court's order declaring the appellant's election void was set aside. The election petition which had invalidated the appellant's election on the basis of section 123(3a) was dismissed; costs were awarded in favour of the appellant.
- On broader law: The Court applied existing authorities to interpret section 123(3a) and refused to read into it an additional requirement of incitement to violence or public disorder (as in Kedar Nath Singh for sedition). It also reaffirmed that truth is not a defense to a corrupt practice under this provision and relied upon earlier precedents to treat statutory restrictions on candidates' conduct as intra vires Article 19(1)(a). The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel precedent beyond these applications.
1. This is an appeal under s. Ii6 - a of the representation of the people act, 1951.
2. The election of the appellant to lok sabha from the manjeri parliamentary constituency in kerala was declared void by the high court of of kerala at ernakulam on an election petition presented on may 3, 1977 by the first respondent who was an elector in that constituency on the ground that the returned candidate was guilty of corrupt practice mentioned in subsection (3 a) of s. 123 of the act. The appellant was a candidate of the muslim league; the second respondent before us contested the election as as a nominee of a dissident group of the muslim league described as "muslim league (opposition) supported by, As stated in the election petition, "janata party and marxist party".
3. S. 123 (3a) reads:
"123. Corrupt practices. The following shall be deemed to be corrupt practices for the purposes of this act:
xx x x
(3a) the promotion of, Or attempt to promote, Feelings of enmity or hatred between different classes of the citizens of india on grounds of religion, Race, Caste, Community, Or language, By a candidate or his agent or any other person with the consent of a candidate or his election agent for the furtherance of the prospects of the election of that candidate or for prejudicially affecting the election of any candidate. "
it is said that during the election campaign the appellant made a speech in english at a place called pullickal within the said constituency and a report of this speech translated into malayalam appeared in the local daily chandrika in its issue of march 17,1977 which, It is alleged, Falls within the mischief of s. 123 (3a). The election petition contains several other allegations but as the decision of the high court is based on this ground only, It is not necessary to refer to them. As already stated, The report of the speech (ext. P - 6) is a translated version in malayalam of the substance of the speech delivered in english.
4. Mr. Nariman appearing for the appellant contended that as the full text of the speech was not available, It would be unsafe to draw any conclusion from the speech as reported. This contention which was also raised before the high court is in our opinion, Adequately answered in the impugned judgment. The high court says:
"it is true that ex - p6 does not purport to contain the full speech, But the important aspect which has to be noted is that no contention has been raised in the written statement to the effect that there were other portions in the speech of the first respondent which mitigated the evil contained in ext. P6 when the 1st respondent gave evidence as rw. 1 there was not even a distant suggestion that for want of production of the entire speech ext. P6 could not be relied on. Again, When the petitioner gave evidence as pw. 1 no question was asked to him regarding the other matters, If any, Spoken by the first respondent."
the first respondent in high court is the appellant before us. In his affidavit answering the allegations made in the election petition, The appellant admits that though it was not possible for him "at this distance of time to recall" what exactly he had stated in the speech, "the reporter's version of the speech does more or less tally" with the views expressed by the appellant in the meeting. We are therefore unable to agree that the report of the speech, Ext p6, Cannot be relied on.
the speech as reported in chandrika is as follows:
"the indian union muslim league president sulaiman sait said at pullickal today that the society will never forgive the anti - religious league people. It is because these people had helped the jansangh which had killed many muslims in northern india and at tellicherry and had burnt the sacred mosques. There people have also been leading the poor muslims towards the camp of communal reactionaries and therefore society can never forgive them.
he said that these anti - religious people were by spreading lies and false propaganda blackening the faces of the leaders and giving away the secrets of our society to marxists and the hindu leaders. He reminded the anti - religious league that by doing this they were destroying that institution which was fed and brought up by marhyum khaede millat ismail sahaib and bafaki thangal.
he continued that janata party, Which is formed under the guidance of jansangh is an orphanage of all those political leaders who did not secure any seats or who had separated from their original party. These parties, He said, Will not be allowed to see the assembly or parliament. He made it very clear that the anti - religious parties must not entertain the fat hopes of securing the votes of any muslim, In whose head the islam's blood was flowing.
janab sait sahib was addressing a large gathering at the public meeting of the united front held at pullickal. The meeting was presided over by cherukavu panchayat president p. P. Abdul gafoor moulavi. The meeting was inaugurated by p. P. Ummar - koya. "
mr. Nariman submitted that it was necessary to ascertain the true scope and effect of sub - section (3a) of the s. 123 before considering whether the speech fell within the mischief of that sub - section and for that purpose, According to mr. Nariman, S. 123 (3a) must be read with s. 125 of the act. Part vii of the representation of the people act, 1950 deals with "corrupt practices and electoral offences". S. 123 is in chapter i of part vii which catalogues the corrupt practices and s. 125 is in chapter iii of that part which lists the electoral offences. S. 125 provides:
"125. Promoting enmity between classes in connection with election. Any person who in connection with an election under this act promotes or attempts to promote on grounds of religion, Race, Caste, Community or language, Feelings of enmity or hatred, Between different classes of the citizens of india shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years, Or with fine, Or with both."
it is true that the act that is called a corrupt practice in s. 123 (3a) is also what constitutes an electoral offence under s. 125 but to attract s. 123 (3a) the act must be done by the candidate or his agent or any other person with the consent of the candidate or his agent, And for the furtherance of the election of that candidate or for prejudicially affecting the election of any candidate, But under s. 125 any person is punishable who is guilty of such an act and the motive behind the act is not stated to be an ingredient of the offence. We do not find any reason why the two provisions, S. 123 (3a) and s. 125, Must be read together to ascertain the scope and effect of s. 123 (3a). Mr. Nariman's contention is that reading s. 123 (3a) in the light of s. 125 we should hold that incitement to violence or likelihood of public disorder is one of the requirements of the corrupt practice mentioned in s. 123 (3a) and that in the absence of any evidence in this case on that aspect, The corrupt practice alleged against the appellant cannot be said to have been established. Mr. Nariman referred to kedar nath singh v. State of bihar (1962 suppl. 2 scr. 769 in support of his contention. In kedar nath's case, In order to save s. 124a of the indian penal code, (which makes sedition an offence) from being questioned as infringing the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the constitution, This court limited the application of the provision to acts involving intention or tendency to create disorder, Or disturbance of law and order, Or incitement to violence. Whether the electoral offence mentioned in s. 125 of the act should be read as requiring a similar ingredient does not arise for consideration in this case; in our opinion the provisions of s. 125 are not relevant to ascertain the scope and application of s. 123 (3a). As to whether s. 123 (3a) can be impugned on the ground that it violates art. 19 (1) (a) of the constitution, The question has been answered in jumuna prasad mukhartya & others v. Lachhi ram & others (1955) 1 scr. 608. In that case this court overruled the contention that s. 123 (5) and 124 (5) of the representation of the people act, 1951, As the provisions stood at the time, Were ultra vires art. 19 (1) (a) of the constitution. S. 124 (5) which made "systematic appeal to vote or refrain from voting on grounds of caste, Race, Community or religion" a'minor' corrupt practice is similar to s. 123 (3) of the act as it stands now. Bose j. Speaking for the court in jumuna prasad's case observed: "these laws do not stop a man from speaking. They merely prescribe conditions which must be observed if he wants to enter parliament. The right to stand as a candidate and contest an election is not a common law right. It is a special right created by statute and can only be exercised on the condition laid down by the statute. The fundamental rights chapter has no bearing on a right like this created by statute. The appellants have no fundamental right to be elected members of parliament. If they want that they must observe the rules. If they prefer to exercise their right of free speech outside these rules, The impugned sections do not stop them. We hold that these sections are intra vires. " we are therefore unable to accept the construction of s. 123 (3a) as suggested by mr. Nariman.
5. Mr. Nariman's next contention was that a political party could not be described as a "class" in the sense in which the expression "classes of the citizens of india" has been used in s. 123 (3a), That whatever the appellant had said in his speech was directed against a political party, Muslim league (opposition), And therefore the speech did not fall within the mischief of that provision. We do not find it necessary to consider whether a political party is a 'class' within the meaning of s. 123 (3a). The question for decision is whether the speech delivered by the appellant promoted or attempted to promote feelings of enmity or hatred between different classes of the citizens of india on the ground of religion. A speech, Though its immediate target is a political party, May yet be such as to promote feelings of enmity or hatred between different classes of citizens. It is the likely effect of the speech on the voters that has to be considered. We also find no substance in the contention urged by mr. Nariman that s. 123 (3a) was inapplicable to this case because the appellant and the candidate of the muslim league (opposition) were both muslims. This court in kultar singh v. Mukhtiar singh (1964) 7 scr 790 held that a corrupt practice under s. 123 "can be committed by a candidate by appealing to the voters to vote for him on the ground of his religion even though his rival candidate may belong to the same religion. "
6. The following portions of the speech reproduced above have been alleged as objectionable:
the first paragraph of the speech as reported contains a statement that the society will not forgive the anti - religious league people, Meaning the muslim league (opposition), Because of their alliance with janasangh that had killed many muslims in northern india and also at tellicherry and had burnt mosques and, Further, That these people had been driving the poor muslims to the camp of the communal reactionaries. In the second paragraph of the report, It is alleged that these anti - religious people were giving away the secrets of "our society" to "marxists and hindu leaders". The third paragraph states that the speaker made it clear that these anti - religious parties must not entertain the hope of securing the votes of muslims "in whose head the islam's blood was flowing. " mr. Nariman submitted that the allegations as regards the killing 'of muslims and the burning of mosques were based on facts and he referred to the report of the commission of inquiry that investigated the facts relating to the disturbances which took place in tellicherry in 1971. In our opinion truth is not an answer to a charge of corrupt practice under s. 123 (3a) ; what is relevant is whether the speech promoted or sought to promote feelings of enmity or hatred as mentioned in that provision. If it is found that this was so, Then it is immaterial whether what was said was based on facts or not, Especially when in this case the events mentioned occurred years ago.
7. Turning now to the speech, The allegations of killing of muslims and burning of mosques appear to have been made against janasangh which is a political party. It is not claimed that this is a party whose membership is restricted to hindus only. The members of the muslim league (opposition) are described as "anti - religious people" but as held by this court in kanti prasad jaysahanker yagnik v. Purshottamdas ranchhoddas patel and others (1969) 3 scr. 400 the law does not place any bar on describing a party as irreligious. Then it is said that these people were "giving away" the "secrets" of the muslim society to "marxists and the hindu leaders". It is not clear what was the nature of the "secrets" which were being passed on to the hindu leaders and to the marxists. It is to be noted that the recipients of the information were not only the hindu leaders but the marxists as well. The speech appears to have ended with the assertion expressed in rather high flown language that the anti - religious parties had no hopes of securing the vote of any muslim "in whose head the islam's blood was flowing".
8. Reading the speech as a whole it cannot be denied that its tone is communal, But in this country communal parties are allowed to function in politics. That being so, How an appeal to the voters, Such as the one made in the speech in question, Should be viewed in the context of corrupt practices mentioned in the act, Has been explained by gajendragadkar q. Speaking for the court in kultar' singh v. Mukhtiar singh (1964) 7 scr. 790:
"it is well - known that there are several parties in this country which subscribe to different political and economic ideologies, But the membership of them is either confined to, Or predominantly held by, Members of particular communities or religions. So long as law does not prohibit the formation of such parties and in fact recognises them for the purpose of election and parliamentary life, It would be necessary to remember that an appeal made by such candidates of such parties for votes may, If successful, Lead to their election and in an indirect way, May conceivably be influenced by considerations of religion, Race, Caste, Community or language. This infirmity cannot perhaps be avoided so long as parties are allowed to function and are recognised, Though their composition may be predominantly based on membership of particular communities or religion".
9. To indicate the effect of the speech on the minds of the ordinary voters, The election petitioner examined two witnesses, Pw. 2 and pw. 4. Pw. 2 pc. Mohammed said that after listening to the appellant's speech, "the muslim voters looked with hatred at those people who stood against them, But when questioned as to which sentence in the speech attempted to promote the feeling of hatred, The witness referred to the first sentence and he himself went on to say that "what the sentence really means is that it is not proper to unite with jansangh". Pw 4 hidre also said in the beginning that the speech was "intended to destroy communal harmony" but he himself admitted later in his testimony that the only effect of the speech was that after the meeting people were saying that "the opposition league candidate must be defeated. " it seems to us that the speech sought to criticise the wrong policy of the muslim league (opposition) in aligning with parties that were allegedly responsible for atrocities against the muslims and not just to emphasise the atrocities. In our opinion it cannot be said that the speech falls within the mischief of s. 123 (3a) of the act; we have reached this conclusion keeping in mind the well established principle that the allegation of corrupt practice must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
10. The appeal is allowed with costs and the election petition is dismissed.
allowed.
The address is not valid
Most likely causes:
There might be a typing error in the address.
If you clicked on a link, It may be out of date.
What you can try:
Retype the address.
Alert