Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Joseph v. State Of Kerala

Kerala High Court
Jun 19, 1991
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Paripoornan, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two appeals challenge orders of the Subordinate Judge, Sulthan Bathery dated 30-6-1990 in I.A. No. 436/90 in L.A.R. No. 208/85 and I.A. No. 488/90 in L.A.R. No. 279/85. The appellants are claimants in references made under the Land Acquisition Act. When the references were heard before the trial court, the appellants (claimants/petitioners) were absent. On the basis of the evidence available on the record, the court below passed an award rejecting the claim for enhancement of compensation and upheld the award of the Land Acquisition Officer.

Thereafter the appellants filed petitions under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.) seeking restoration of the reference applications to file, treating the dismissal as one for default. The Subordinate Judge held that the court had passed an award on the basis of the available evidence in the absence of the appellants and that the cases were not dismissed for default, hence the petitions were not maintainable. The claimants appealed to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an award passed by a Civil Court on a reference under the Land Acquisition Act, in circumstances where the claimant is absent, can be treated as an order "passed on default" so as to permit restoration under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C.
  2. Whether an award passed by the Court on such a reference is an "order" under Order 9 Rule 8 C.P.C., thereby attracting the remedy under Order 9 Rule 9 for restoration of proceedings dismissed for default.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The court below should have held that, in substance, the award passed by it amounted to an order passed on default; therefore the provisions of Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C. would apply.
  • The appellants had shown sufficient cause for their non-appearance and the reference applications should have been restored to file.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced by the opposite party (respondent) before this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishna Pillai v. State of Kerala (1988 (2) K.L.T 898) Supports the proposition that when a reference is made under the Land Acquisition Act the Court must determine the amount of compensation and cannot dismiss the reference for default; an award in such reference is not an order under Order 9 Rule 8 C.P.C. The Court relied on this decision as one from which the stated propositions are discernible and concurred with its reasoning to hold that petitions under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C. were not maintainable in the circumstances.
M.S. Ramaiah v. Spl. Land Acquisition Officer (AIR 1974 Karnataka 122) Same principle as above: recognition that the Civil Court must pass an award on a reference under the Land Acquisition Act irrespective of presence/absence of the claimant, and such an award is not equivalent to an order dismissing proceedings for default under Order 9 Rule 8 C.P.C. The Court cited and accepted the reasoning of this decision (a judgment of a learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court) in support of its conclusion that the petitions to restore proceedings were not maintainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded from the legal character of references under the Land Acquisition Act (specifically section 18 as mentioned in the opinion). It explained that when a reference is made to the Civil Court under the Act, the duty of the Court is to determine the amount of compensation payable for the land acquired. This duty exists regardless of whether the claimant is present to adduce evidence.

Because the Court is obliged to determine compensation on the reference, it must pass an award even if the claimant remains absent or fails to give evidence; it cannot treat the matter as dismissed for default. From that premise the Court drew the corollary that an award passed by the Court in such a reference is not an "order" within the meaning of Order 9 Rule 8 C.P.C. Consequently, remedies available for restoration of proceedings dismissed for default under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C. do not apply to such awards.

The Court also expressly relied on and adopted the reasoning of earlier decisions (Krishna Pillai and M.S. Ramaiah) which enunciate the same propositions. On that basis the Court held that the petitions filed under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C. were not maintainable and the trial court's dismissal of those petitions was justified.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED IN LIMINE

Holding: The appeals are without merit and are dismissed in limine. The Court affirmed the Subordinate Judge's conclusion that the award passed on the reference was not an order dismissing the case for default and therefore petitions under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C. to restore the proceedings were not maintainable.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the award passed by the trial court (which upheld the Land Acquisition Officer's award and rejected the claim for enhancement of compensation) stands and the claimants' petitions to restore the reference proceedings have been dismissed. The opinion confines itself to applying existing principles (as reflected in the cited authorities) and does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond affirming those authorities.

Show all summary ...

Paripoornan, J.:— Identical questions arise for consideration in these two cases. The appeals are preferred against the orders passed by the Subordinate Judge, Sulthan Bathery dated 30-6-1990 in I.A No. 436/90 in L.A.R No. 208/85 and in I.A No. 488/90 in L.A.R No. 279/85. The appellants are claimants in the references made under the Land Acquisition Act. On the day when the references came up for hearing before the Sab Court, the appellants (claimants/petitioners) were absent. On the basis of the available evidence on record, the court below passed an award rejecting the claim for enhancement of compensation pleaded by the appellants. The award by the Land Acquisition Officer was upheld. Thereafter, the appellants filed petitions under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the C.P.C to restore the reference applications to file treating the dismissal as one for default. By orders passed on the same day, the learned Subordinate Judge held that the Court has passed an award on the basis of the available evidence on record in the absence of the appellants/claimants and the cases were not dismissed for default as wrongly alleged by the appellants. Stating that when a reference is made to the Civil Court, under the Land Acquisition Act, the reference has to be answered irrespective of the presence or absence of the applicant, the learned Subordinate Judge hold that since the court had passed an award in the cases, the applications filed on the basis that they were dismissed for default, are not maintainable. The petitioners in the court below (the claimants) have come up in appeals.

2. The same counsel appeared for the appellants, in both the cases. We heard counsel. It was argued that the court below should have held that in substance the award passed by it is an order passed on default and so the provisions of Order 9 Rule 9 read with Sec. 151 CPC will apply. The appellants having shown sufficient cause for non-appearance, the reference applications should have been restored to file. We see no force in this plea. When a reference is made to the Court under section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, it is the duty of the Court to determine the amount of compensation payable for the land acquired. The Court cannot refuse to determine the amount of compensation even where the claimant remains absent or fails to adduce evidence. The court is bound to pass an award. It cannot dismiss the applications for default.

3. Consequently, an award passed by the court is not an order under Order 9 Rule 8 C.P.C The court below was justified in holding that the petitions filed under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Sec. 151 C.P.C are not maintainable. The propositions stated above are discernible from the decision of a learned single Judge of this Court in Krishna Pillai v. State Of Kerala (1988 (2) K.L.T 898) and the judgment of a learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court (Govinda Bhat, C.J) in M.S Ramaiah v. Spl. Land Acquisition Officer (AIR 1974 Karnataka 122). We concur with the reasoning and conclusion of the court below that the petitions filed before it are not maintainable and that they were rightly dismissed.

4. The appeals are without merit. They are dismissed in limine.