Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Bajaj Hindusthan Ltd. v. Union Of India & Ors.

Allahabad High Court
Mar 8, 2013
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise under Section 35‑G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 challenging orders of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi dated 6.6.2012 and 26.9.2012 that rejected certain CESTAT appeals and rectification applications. The appeals were filed against the order dated 19.5.2006 of the Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut‑I which disallowed CENVAT credit claimed by three units of M/s. Bajaj Hindustan Limited (Bhaisana, Thanabhawan and Bilai) for steel items (M.S. angles, channels, plates, sections, beams, flats, etc.) allegedly used in fabrication of plant and machinery for manufacture of sugar. The Commissioner adjudicated in a common order disallowing the claimed credits (amounts specified per unit), charging interest and imposing penalty equal to the demand. The appellant had obtained Central Excise registration in 2004 and started manufacturing in October 2005; they had submitted ER‑1 returns and other intimation letters. Show cause notices were issued for the relevant periods in 2005 and 2006. The appellants appealed to CESTAT under Section 35‑B, which dismissed the appeals on the ground that no evidence was produced to establish usage of the items in the manufacture of capital goods. Rectification applications under Section 35‑C(2) were dismissed by CESTAT on 26.9.2012, giving rise to the present appeals to this Court under Section 35‑G.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants were entitled to CENVAT credit for structural steel items claimed as inputs used in the manufacture of capital goods that were further used in the factory for manufacture of sugar, given the requirements of the CENVAT Credit Rules (including Explanation 2 to the definition of "input") and the record produced before the adjudicating authority.
  2. Whether the penalty equal to the amount of duty (under Section 11AC read with Rule 15 of the CENVAT Credit Rules) imposed on the appellants was legally sustainable and whether the adjudicating authority/Tribunal had discretion to reduce the quantum of penalty.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Shri S.K. Bagaria)

  • The steel items in question were received and used in the factory in the manufacture of capital goods; there was no diversion or non‑receipt of goods and the factories were established and producing.
  • Detailed documentation (requisition/issue slips, store ledger entries, section‑wise end use lists, descriptions of capital goods, and notes showing credit amounts and department placement) was filed and these documents were not disputed by the Commissioner or Tribunal.
  • The Commissioner’s and CESTAT’s findings that names, descriptions, quantities and usage were not mentioned were perverse and contrary to the record; the authorities did not properly apply their minds to the documents presented.
  • At the admission stage the Tribunal had granted interim relief indicating a strong case for the appellants and had waived pre‑deposit requirements; there was no factual change thereafter.
  • The capital goods manufactured and used within the factory were fully exempt from excise duty under Notification No. 67/95‑CE, and no further formalities or records were required; this notification was not considered by the authorities and the appellants were not given an opportunity to address it in the show cause notices.
  • The revenue could not be permitted to raise new pleas not raised in the show cause notice; reliance was placed on Supreme Court decisions (Ballarpur Industries and Shital International) to this effect.
  • On penalty, there was no fraud, collusion, willful mis‑statement or suppression of fact; the show cause was based on the appellants’ own ER‑1 returns and therefore penalty under Section 11AC was not attracted (relying on Pepsi Foods decision).
  • The items fell within the definition of capital goods under Rule 2(a)(A)(iii) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 (components, spares and accessories), supported by CBEC Circular No. 276/110/96‑TRU dated 2.12.1996; there was never any dispute as to the nature and description of the goods.

Respondent's Arguments (Shri R.C. Shukla, Standing Counsel for Union of India)

  • The appellants’ ER‑1 returns did not declare the use of these items in the manufacture of capital goods and the appellants could not satisfy the Commissioner or CESTAT with documentary proof showing specific usage.
  • During adjudication the appellants produced invoices and a chart which were vague and did not specify quantities of structural steel used for manufacture of particular machines, parts, components or accessories; the onus of proof was on the appellants, who had exclusive knowledge of how the items were used.
  • The appellants failed to lead evidence despite opportunities; store ledgers and issue slips did not establish the use of structural steel items claimed for CENVAT credit.
  • Even if items were used at commissioning, the appellants were required to prove that each claimed CENVAT credit related to items actually used in the processes of commissioning and that the items fell within the definition of capital goods.
  • The Commissioner and CESTAT were justified in disallowing the credit and in imposing penalty where the claimed credits were taken without satisfying required conditions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner Of Central Excise, Nagpur v. Ballarpur Industries Ltd. (2007) 8 SCC 89 Principle that revenue cannot raise a new plea not contained in the show cause notice; a new plea cannot be entertained. The appellants relied on this case to argue that the revenue could not build a new case. The Court recorded that appellants relied on it but upheld the factual findings of CESTAT and the Commissioner that appellants failed to prove usage; the Court did not find an error of law based on this precedent.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Shital International (2011) 1 SCC 109 Same proposition as Ballarpur — limitations on raising new pleas not in the show cause notice. Relied upon by the appellants for the same purpose; the Court noted the reliance but concluded that the outcome turned on facts (absence of proof) and found no legal error in the impugned orders.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Pepsi Foods Limited (2011) 1 SCC 601 Authority cited by appellants in support of the submission that penalty under Section 11AC should not be levied in absence of suppression or mala fide conduct. Appellants relied on it on the penalty issue. The Court, however, affirmed the penalty in this case based on a separate line of authorities (via Majestic Auto) and found no error in the penalty imposition given the factual findings of violation of CENVAT rules.
Saraswati Sugar Mills v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Delhi‑III, AIR 2011 SC 3286 Test for whether an article is a component part of another article; examination of whether iron and steel structures form part of vacuum pans/crystallizers; some structural items held to be capital goods in that context. The Court noted this Supreme Court decision and the appellant’s attempt to distinguish it as relating to the earlier unamended position. The Court observed the decision but held that the present appeals turned on the appellants’ failure to prove factual usage, not on the broader legal test alone.
Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise v. Majestic Auto Limited, Central Excise Appeal no. 142 of 2004 (6.7.2012) Held that when Section 11AC is attracted, the quantum of penalty equal to the duty determined is mandatory and there is no discretion to impose a different amount. The Court expressed respectful agreement with this coordinate‑bench decision and applied its ratio to uphold the mandatory nature of penalty quantum under Section 11AC in the present appeals.
Union of India v. Dharmendra Textile Processors, 2008 (231) E.L.T 3 Authority cited in the Majestic Auto reasoning concerning penalty quantum under Section 11AC. Referred to in the Majestic Auto reasoning which this Court adopted in relation to the mandatory quantum of penalty; used indirectly to support the view that Tribunal/authority has no discretion to reduce the penalty once Section 11AC conditions are satisfied.
Dilip N. Shroff v. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai, 2007 (8) Scale 304 Authority cited in Majestic Auto on principles relating to penalty quantum/mandatory nature. Referenced through Majestic Auto; formed part of the jurisprudential basis accepted by this Court for holding that penalty quantum equal to duty is mandatory where Section 11AC applies.
Union of India v. Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills, 1998 (99) ELT 33 Principle that penalty under Section 11AC can be imposed only when the conditions mentioned in Section 11AC exist; and discussion of limits on discretion in fixing quantum. Cited in the Majestic Auto decision and accepted as part of the foundation for the holding that once conditions for Section 11AC are fulfilled, penalty equal to the duty must be imposed. This Court followed that reasoning to uphold the penalties here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by examining both the factual record and the legal framework governing CENVAT credits and penalties and set out the reasons for affirming the orders of the Commissioner and the Tribunal.

1. Factual character of the dispute: The Court treated the central contest as one of fact. It observed that the CESTAT had affirmed the factual findings of the Commissioner that the appellants had not produced sufficient evidence to establish that the structural steel items on which CENVAT credit was claimed were actually used in the fabrication of capital goods which were further used for manufacture of the final product. The Court found no error of law or perversity in those factual conclusions and held that the issues raised were factual in nature, not substantial questions of law.

2. Legal requirements for CENVAT credit: The Court relied on the statutory scheme — particularly Explanation 2 to Rule 11(k) (the definition of "input") and the requirements in Rule 9 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 regarding maintenance of invoices and records — to explain why the entitlement to credit depends on proof that inputs were used in manufacture of capital goods that were then put to use in manufacture of the final product. Explanation 2 excludes certain items (e.g., cement, angles, channels, CTD/TMT bars) when used for construction of factory sheds, foundations or structures for supporting capital goods. Thus, the Court emphasized that eligibility hinges on establishing that the items "went into" manufacture of capital goods and that those capital goods were actually used in production.

3. Evidentiary deficiencies found by authorities: The Court summarized the findings of the Commissioner and CESTAT: the appellants did not specifically declare the fabrication details in ER‑1 returns; drawings and designs and material usage showing how much structural steel went into which capital goods were not produced; store ledgers and issue slips did not satisfactorily demonstrate use; and the jurisdictional officers lacked an opportunity to verify the fabrication claims. The Court accepted these factual findings as unimpeached factual conclusions and declined to interfere.

4. On the precedents relied upon by the parties: The Court noted that appellants invoked precedents (e.g., Ballarpur, Shital) to argue that the revenue could not raise new pleas not in the show cause notice, and also cited Saraswati Sugar Mills to challenge the view that structural items could not be capital goods. The Court recorded these submissions but concluded that the dispute in the present appeals was driven by absence of satisfactory proof of the factual usage; thus those authorities did not alter the outcome where the adjudicating authorities found inadequate evidence.

5. On penalty: The Court considered the appellants’ submission that penalty under Section 11AC should not have been imposed because no suppression or fraudulent conduct was shown. The Court, however, relied on a coordinate‑bench decision (Majestic Auto) which, after discussing several authorities, held that where conditions of Section 11AC are fulfilled, the penalty equal to the duty determined is mandatory and there is no discretion to impose a lesser amount. This Court expressed respectful agreement with that reasoning and found no error in the imposition and quantum of penalty in the impugned orders given the factual finding that appellants had taken CENVAT credit in violation of the CENVAT Credit Rules.

6. Conclusion of analysis: Because the Tribunal had affirmed factual findings of insufficiency of proof and the Court found no error of law or perverse findings of fact, the Court concluded that no substantial question of law arose and there was no basis to interfere with the CESTAT's decision or the Commissioner’s order.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: All three appeals are dismissed.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The orders of the Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut‑I dated 19.5.2006 disallowing the claimed CENVAT credits for the three units remain affirmed.
  • The CESTAT's dismissal of the appeals and refusal of rectification under Section 35‑C(2) are upheld.
  • The imposition of interest and penalty (penalty equal to the amount of demand under Section 11AC read with Rule 15) as ordered by the Commissioner and affirmed by CESTAT is sustained; the Court followed the Majestic Auto line of authority that the quantum of penalty under Section 11AC is mandatory where the provision applies.

Broader implications addressed by the Court:

  • The Court emphasized that the matter primarily turns on factual proof of usage of inputs for manufacture of capital goods and maintenance of statutory records; because this is a factual determination affirmed by the Tribunal, no substantial question of law arose for its consideration in these appeals.
  • The Court indicated agreement with the view that when the statutory conditions for imposition of penalty under Section 11AC are satisfied, the penalty quantum equal to duty is mandatory, thereby limiting discretion to reduce penalty in such cases (as per the coordinate‑bench decision adopted).

Final formal result: The appeals are dismissed in limine; parties to bear their own costs was the disposition in the related coordinate‑bench authority referenced by the Court, and this Court found no reason to alter the outcome here.

Show all summary ...

Hon'ble Sunil Ambwani, J.

Hon'ble Bharat Bhushan, J.

1. We have heard Shri S.K Bagaria assisted by Shri Sanjay Kumar Singh and Shri Ashish Mishra for the appellants. Shri R.C Shukla, Standing Counsel, Union of India appears for the respondents.

2. These three appeals under Section 35-G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 arise out of the orders dated 6.6.2012 and 26.9.2012 passed by Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi rejecting Central Excise Appeal No. 3141/2006-EX(DB) and Application No. E/ROM/2981/2012-EX(DB) (giving rise to Central Excise Appeal No. 815 of 2012); Central Excise Appeal No. 3111/2006-EX(DB) and Application No. E/ROM/2980/2012-EX(DB) (giving rise to Central Excise Appeal No. 816 of 2012) and Central Excise Appeal No. 3046/2006-EX(DB) and Application No. E/ROM/2979/2012-EX(DB) (giving rise to Central Excise Appeal No. 817 of 2012) filed against the order dated 19.5.2006 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise, Meerut-I, Uttar Pradesh disallowing the CENVAT Credit.

3. In Central Excise Appeal No. 815 of 2012 the Commissioner by the impugned order confirmed the CENVAT credit demand of Rs. 1,65,69,326; In Central Excise Appeal No. 816 of 2012 he had confirmed CENVAT credit demand of Rs. 1,90,52,382/- and in Central Excise Appeal No. 817 of 2012 the CENVAT credit demand of Rs. 2,02,96,271/- was confirmed against the appellants along with interest imposing penalty of equal amount. The CENVAT credit had been taken by the three units of the appellant during the period from January, 2005 to June, 2005 in respect of M.S Angles, Channels, Plates, Sections, Beams, Flats etc. claimed to have been used for fabrication of plant and machinery, for manufacture of sugar.

4. Brief facts, giving rise to these three appeals, are that M/s. Bajaj Hindustan Limited-the appellant is engaged in the manufacture of V.P Sugar and Molasses falling under Chapter 17 of the First Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. The company has set up a unit in village Bhaisana, District Muzaffarnagar for manufacture of cane sugar, with installed cane crushing capacity of 7000 tonnes; a unit in village Thanabhawan, District Muzaffarnagar with installed cane crushing capacity of 7000 tonnes crushing per day and a third unit in Village Bilai, District Bijnor with installed cane crushing capacity of 7000 tonnes crushing per day. All the three units started manufacturing from October, 2005.

5. The units submitted their formal start up intimation to all the Government departments, and to the Range Superintendent, Central Excise before starting the commercial production. They intended to avail CENVAT credit on inputs and capital goods received during the period/process of setting up of their new manufacturing factory and obtained Central Excise registration from the office of Assistant Commissioner, Division Muzaffarnagar in the month of August, 2004 for Bhaisana and Thanebhawan units in District Muzaffarnagar and for Bilai unit in District Bijnore. The appellants vide intimation letters dated 6.4.2005 informed the Range Superintendent with the list of statutory and internal records maintained by them as per Rule 22(2) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.

6. The Superintendent, on scrutinizing of ER-1 returns, found that the appellant availed CENVAT credit on angles, channels, sections, plates as inputs. They were required by the Superintendent, Range Shamli and Bijnor by his letters dated 22.7.2005, 11.7.2005 and 16.6.2005 respectively to explain use of these items as inputs in the plant.

7. The appellants confirmed that these items were being used by them in the manufacture of capital goods and in view of Explanation 2 to Rule 2(k), the steel items are inputs as the same were used in the manufacture of capital goods, which were further used in the appellant's factory for manufacturing sugar. The appellants also confirmed that they were maintaining proper records, showing receipts and consumption of each input.

8. The appellant received show cause notices dated 7.2.2006 and 30.3.2006 (for the period from January, 2005 to March, 2005 & April, 2005 to December 2005) from the Commissioner, Central Excise, Meerut-I in respect of Bhaisana unit in District Muzaffarnagar. It also received show cause notice dated 3.3.2006 (for the period from February 2005 to December, 2005) from the Commissioner, Central Excise, Meerut-I in respect of Thanebhawan unit of District Muzaffarnagar. For the Bilai unit of District Bijnor a show cause notice was issued on 7.2.2006 for the period from January, 2005 to June, 2005.

9. The appellants contested the show cause notices in all the three units on common grounds, alleging that these notices have been framed without verification of any records and physical verification of machineries and structures fabricated by the appellants in connection with the setting up of the new manufacturing units. The break-up of the entire CENVAT credit according to use of steel items in various sections of the plant is alleged to have been given along with the replies. The appellants submitted that they had not taken CENVAT credit on various steel items, which were earmarked from the very beginning for use in the civil/foundation purposes. The appellants did not take CENVAT credit on the base plates used between the mill equipments and foundations for the bolting of various machinery with base plates. Wherever the steel items were used for raising civil foundation/structure of for non-capital goods items such as staircases, purlins, partitions, buildings and roofing etc., the appellants have not taken CENVAT credit.

10. By a common order dated 19.5.2006 the Commissioner, Central Excise, Meerut-I adjudicated the matter in respect of all the three units and disallowed the entire CENVAT credit of Rs. 2,02,96,271/- availed by the appellants on inputs and cable goods for Bhaisana unit; Rs. 1,90,52,382/- for Thanebhawan unit in District Muzaffarnagar, and Rs. 1,65,69,326/- for Bilai unit in District Bijnor under Rule 14 of the CENVAT Credit Rule, 2005 read with Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944. He also ordered charging of interest under Rule 14 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944 at the appropriate rate in respect of all the three units and also imposed penalty of the amount equal to demand in respect of all the three units under Rule 15 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 read with Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944.

11. Aggrieved the appellants preferred appeals under Section 35-B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 in the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi. All the three appeals were dismissed by the common order dated 6.6.2012 confirming the findings of the Commissioner, Central Excise Meerut-I dated 19.5.2006 The CESTAT dismissed all the appeals on the ground that no evidence was produced by the appellant with respect to the usage of the items for the manufacture of the capital goods.

12. The appellants filed applications under Section 35-C(2) of the Central Excise Act, 1944 in the CESTAT for rectification of mistakes. The applications were dismissed on 26.9.2012, giving rise to these three appeals under Section 35-G of the Central Excise Act, 1944 in this Court.

13. Shri S.K Bagaria, appearing in all the three appeals for the appellants submits that it is not disputed that the items in manufacturing of capital goods were received and used in the factory. There is no allegation of these items not being received in the factory or for any diversion of these items out of the factory. It is also not denied that the new factory has been established and has commenced production. The inputs were used in the manufacture of capital goods. The requisition-issue slip from the departments to the stores gives full details of inputs and the connected capital goods manufactured. They also give the details of the concerned department/section in the plants. The entries of despatch from store for particular goods is also pasted in the stores ledger. The detailed documents were submitted, giving section-wise end use details giving the name and description of all capital goods. The section/department, in which these goods were installed, is also mentioned in these details. The credit amount is also mentioned and a separate note is filed on each capital good manufactured. The documents also disclosed the nature of contract work, and the name of capital goods. The Commissioner or the Tribunal has not disputed the correctness of these documents.

14. Shri Bagaria submits that the findings of the Commissioner and CESTAT, that the names, description, quantities and usage are not mentioned, are perverse and contrary to the records. It is one thing to say that out of claims made by the appellants, some items did not answer the definition of capital goods; it is a completely different thing to disallow the whole of the credit as if no capital goods were manufactured at all and as if the factory itself was not established. The Commissioner and the CESTAT did not even apply their minds to the documents on record. There is no findings with reference to these documents. The entire credit has been disallowed arbitrarily and illegally.

15. Shri S.K Bagaria submits that the Tribunal had granted interim orders staying orders of the Commissioner in all the matters with the findings that the use of items in the manufacture/fabrication in the capital goods was not disputed by the revenue. The capital goods manufactured out of items in question were further used in the manufacture of excisable goods. A very strong case was found by the CESTAT at the admission stage in favour of appellants and pre-deposit of whole of the demand and penalty was waived of for hearing of the appeal. There was no change in the factual position thereafter.

16. It is submitted that the capital goods manufactured in the factory and used within the factory in manufacture of excisable goods were fully exempt from central excise duty under Notification No. 67/95 C.E No other formality was required, nor there is any provision requiring any further records. This notification was not considered by the authorities and the CESTAT and since in the show cause notices, no other violation was alleged, the appellants did not get any opportunity to make submissions on the notification.

17. It is submitted that the Commissioner has relied upon Section 6 of the Central Excise Act, 1944; Rules 9, 10, 11, and 12 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 and Rule 9 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. These provisions have to be read, with the fact situation in that the capital goods in question were fully exempt from central excise duty under Notification no. 67/95-CE. The Commissioner exceeded in exercise of his jurisdiction in relying upon these provisions for the first time in his order. He has relied on the opinion expressed by Supreme Court in Commissioner Of Central Excise, Nagpur v. Ballarpur Industries Ltd.(2007) 8 SCC 89 and in Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Shital International(2011) 1 SCC 109 and submits that where a plea has not been raised in the show cause notice, the revenue cannot be permitted to build up a new case against the assessee nor is allowed to take a contradictory stand in relation to the same assessee. A new plea in such case cannot be entertained.

18. It is submitted that the Tribunal admitted that there are no columns in ER1 nor there are any instructions or circular for maintaining any other documents and thus, the credit could not be denied.

19. So far as imposition of penalty is concerned, Shri S.K Bagaria submits that in a case like this there is no scope for levying any penalty under Section 11AC read with Rule 15 of Central Excise Rules. None of the ingredient of Section 11AC namely fraud, collusion, any willful mis-statement, suppression of fact, or contravention of the Act or Rules with intention to evade the tax has been made out. The entire show cause notice is on the basis of appellants own ER-I. He has relied upon Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh v. Pepsi Foods Limited(2011) 1 SCC 601 in support of his submission.

20. It is submitted that there was no suppression at all made by the appellants to impose any penalty. The Tribunal had itself consistently allowed CENVAT credit on inputs in similar cases.

21. Shri S.K Bagaria submits that all the items in question were clearly covered by the definition of capital goods in Rule 2(a)(A)(iii) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. These are all components, spares and accessories of capital goods. There was no necessity or requirement of these being covered by any heading or sub heading. This position is clear from the rule itself and has been clarified by Central Board of Excise and Customs in Circular No. 276/110/96-TRU dated 2.12.1996 The goods in question were Bagasse Elevator Roller Chain, cane carrier, steam boiling sheet, Delta therm, Channel, Thread locker, aluminum sheets/coils, rubber sheet, nichel screen etc. as per show cause notices themselves. There was never any dispute about the nature and description of these goods. The only ground taken in the show cause notices was that these items are not covered by the definition of capital goods. The allegation is ex-facie contrary to the definition itself.

22. Shri R.C Shukla, appearing for the department, has defended the orders passed by the Commissioner, Central Excise, Meerut-I and CESTAT. He submits that in their ER1 returns the appellant did not declare the use of these items in manufacture of capital goods. They could not satisfy the Commissioner, Meerut-I and the CESTAT nor could explain from the chart as to whether these items were actually used in manufacture of capital goods. A specific finding has been recorded by the Tribunal, that on being asked the learned counsel appearing for the appellants as to what is boiler staging, he could not give any explanation. He submits that during adjudication proceedings the appellants placed on record only invoices and a chart vaguely indicating how the items in question were utilised without giving specific details as to how much quantity of structural steel items was used in manufacture of which machineries or its part, component or accessories. The onus of proof was on the appellants. The appellants had purchased the items and had utilised them. It was within their exclusive knowledge as to how and in what manner these items were put to use. In the adjudication proceedings the appellants, despite the fact that they were given opportunity, did not lead evidence to indicate as to which items of structural steel plates, and what quantities were used for fabrication of machineries. The Commissioner had no option but to disallow the CENVAT credit.

23. Shri R.C Shukla submits that even if the items, which had subject matter of appeals, were used at the time of commissioning of new plant for production of final product, the appellant was required to prove that all the items regarding each CENVAT credit has been used in the processes of commissioning of manufacturing unit. These items were not covered by the definition of capital goods for being eligible for CENVAT credit. The appellant was required to establish that the items were actually used for manufacturing of capital goods.

24. We have considered the submissions and do not find any error of facts or of law, nor do we find that any substantial question of law arises from the order of the CESTAT to interfere in these appeals, raising common facts and grounds.

25. Explanation 2 to Rule 11(k) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 provides:- “Input includes goods used in manufacture of capital goods while and further used in the factory of manufacture but shall not include cement, angles, channels, CTD or TMT bars, and if the item used for construction of factory shed, building or laying of foundation or making of structures for support of capital goods.” In view of this Explanation, if the inputs have gone into the manufacture of capital goods, then only they are eligible for CENVAT credit. Such capital goods must be put to actual manufacture of final product. The CENVAT Credit Rules in order to avail CENVAT credit, require the assessee to establish that the items in question were actually put to use for manufacture, or in relation to manufacture of final product, or the capital goods for which the assessee seeks to avail CENVAT credit. The CESTAT did not find any error in the order of the Commissioner, Meerut-I in denying the CENVAT credit as the appellant had failed to prove that the items, on which the CENVAT credit was claimed, were actually used for fabrication of capital goods used for manufacture of final product. In the order dated 26.9.2012 rejecting the application under Section 35-C(2) of the Act the CESTAT has given reasons as to why it had affirmed the order of the Commissioner, Meerut-I. The CESTAT observed that there is no dispute about the facts, that in fabrication of capital goods, the CENVAT credit was taken for M.S angles, channels, plates etc. The appellant, however, neither specifically intimated the department at any point of time nor the details of these items of capital goods fabricated was declared in ER-I, returns filed by the appellant. The drawings and designs of the capital goods claimed to have been fabricated along with the plant of the material used were not produced before the Adjudicating Authority on the basis of which it could be ascertained as to how much quantity of structural steel material was used for various items of capital goods claimed to have been fabricated. The store ledgers and the store issue slips did not establish the use of structural steel items issued.

26. The CESTAT further found that the appellant had neither intimated the department regarding use of structural steel material for fabrication of various items of capital goods, nor the details of the capital goods fabricated could be found in the ER-1 return. The Jurisdictional Central Excise Officers did not have opportunity to verify these claims.

27. In Saraswati Sugar Mills v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Delhi-Iii., Delhi-IIIAIR 2011 SC 3286 the Supreme Court, in a case of manufacture of sugar and molasses availing MODVAT credit facility on excise duty paid for capital goods used in factory, held that for determination as to whether a particular article is a component part of another article, the correct test is to look both at article which is said to be the component part and completed article and come to a conclusion whether first article is a component part of whole or not. The iron and steel structures were not found to go into the composition of vacuum pans, crystallizers etc. It was held that such items used for raising structure to support various machines, parts of machineries of plant, would be covered by explanation to Rule 57Q as a capital goods, was partly allowed, disagreeing with the reasoning given by the Tribunal. Shri S.K Bagaria has tried to distinguish the judgment on the ground that it relates to the old position under the unamended Act. He submits that by Notification no. 23/2004-CE (NT) dated 10.9.2004 in excise of powers under Section 37 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and Section 94 of the Finance Act, 1994, the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 were notified and which would be applicable to the present case. In these Rules the definition of capital goods under Rule 2(a) would include under A, the goods, namely….. (iii) components, spares and accessories of the goods specified at (i) and (ii), and which would include in (i) all goods falling under Chapter 82, Chapter 84, Chapter 85, Chapter 90, heading No. 68.02 and sub-heading No. 6801.10 of the First Schedule to the Excise Tariff Act and (ii) pollution control equipments. It is submitted that the CENVAT credit is applicable for a manufacturer under Rule 3(1) or purchaser of final product or a provider of taxable service to take credit of excise duty or the duties specified in Rule 3(1)(i) to (xi) paid on any inputs or capital goods received in the factory for manufacturer of final product or premises of the provider, to output service on or after 10th day of September, 2004. The definition of the word “input” in Rule 2(k) is to be understood with Explanations 1 & 2. Explanation 2 provides that input includes goods used in the manufacture of capital goods which are further used in the factory of the manufacturer.

28. There is no dispute that the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 have undergone change to the effect, as provided in Explanation 2 to Rule 2(k) to include in the definition of input to include goods used in the manufacture of capital goods. We are, however, not concerned here with the legal position as to whether goods used by the appellant will be treated as input in the manufacture of capital goods, which are further used in the factory for manufacturer. The CESTAT has confirmed the findings of fact recorded by the Commissioner that the appellant could not satisfy the Commissioner, Meerut-I as Adjudicating Authority, in pursuance to the reply given and the material produced to the show cause notice, as to whether the goods on which CENVAT credit was taken, were actually used in the manufacture of capital goods.

29. The conditions of availing CENVAT credit include the maintenance of documents and accounts under Rule 9 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 and which include under sub-rule (i)(a), the invoices used by a manufacturer for clearance of (I) inputs for or, the capital goods from his factory or depot or from the premises of the consignment agent of the said manufacturer or from any other premises from where the goods are sold by or on behalf of the said manufacturer; (II) inputs or capital goods as such. In the present case the appellants could not satisfy by producing relevant evidence that the inputs on which CENVAT credit was taken was actually used for manufacture of capital goods, as no good or sufficient material was made available to satisfy the Adjudicating Authority.

30. In the facts and circumstances, we find that questions raised in these appeals are questions of fact, and thus no substantial questions of law arise for consideration by us in these appeals.

31. So far as the imposition of penalty is concerned, we do not find any error in the findings that the penalty is attracted in this case as the appellants had taken CENVAT credit without satisfying the conditions set out and in violation of the CENVAT Credit Rules. Further on the issue, as to whether Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 gives for any discretion on imposition, and on the determination of quantum of penalty, we find that the question has been considered by a coordinate Bench of this Court in Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise v. Majestic Auto Limited, Central Excise Appeal no. 142 of 2004 decided on 6.7.2012 This Court, considering the judgments in Union of India v. Dharmendra Textile Processors2008 (231) E.L.T 3; Dilip N. Shroff v. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai2007 (8) Scale 304, and the Union of India v. Rajasthan Spinning & Weaving Mills, 1998 (99) ELT 33, held as follows:-

“From the proposition as laid down in above cases, the ratio deducible is that the quantum of the penalty equal to the duty determined as contemplated by Section 11AC is mandatory and there is no discretion in the adjudicating authority or the Tribunal to impose different amount of penalty. In a case where penalty is leviable under section 11AC on fulfilment of the conditions as enumerated in Section 11AC, the penalty equal to the amount of duty determined is mandatory and there is no discretion in the Tribunal to reduce the said penalty. However, as laid down by the apex Court in Union of India v. Rajasthan Spinning and Weaving Mills (supra), the penalty under section 11AC can be imposed only when conditions mentioned in Section 11AC exist. The authorities have no discretion in fixing the quantum of penalty and penalty equal to the duty must be imposed once section 11Ac is made applicable.

In view of the foregoing discussions, the question of law is answered in favour of the revenue in following manner.

“The appellate Tribunal had no discretion to reduce the amount of penalty as specified under section 11 AC”

The appeal is allowed. Parties shall bear their own cost.”

32. We are in respectful agreement with the reasons given in Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise v. Majestic Auto Limited (supra) and do not find any error of law in the impugned orders imposing penalty.

33. For the aforesaid reasons all the three appeals are dismissed in limine.