- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Balakrishnan v. Rama Seshan
Varghese Kalliath, J.:-
10. We have said that we will be adverting to the decision reported in 1972 klt f 496. We said so, Since counsel for the appellant in w. A. No. 226 of 1989 submit led that this decision requires reconsideration. It has to be noted two the government proceeded on the basis that after the decision in 1972 klt 496, R. 24 (2) of chapter v of the rules is a dead - letter in the ratios and the power under r. 24 (2) of the rules cannot be exercised. Perhaps that may not be a reason for us to say that the decision does not. 1 require re - consideration. But %ve are of opinion that sufficient reasons have been stated by the learned single judge to say that sub - rule (2) of r. 24 of chapter v of the rules is violative of an. 14 of the constitution of india and that rule is inconsistent with s. 7 (6) of the act. A reading of the judgment, Would show that in fact, The learned single judge has held that it is not the lack of power that made sub - rule (2) of r. 24 of the rules inconsistent with s. 7 (6) of the. Act. When the legislature has enabled the manager to close down the school after complying with s. 7 (6) of the act the rule cannot enlarge the conditions required under s. 7 (6) of the act and if it does, It amounts to enacting an inconsistent rule to override a statutory provision which enfranchised a statutory right to the management. Of course, The learned single judge also adverted to the question whether under the terms of s. 7 (6) of the act the manager's right to close down his school is preserved subject to his complying with the condition laid down in the said section insisting on one year's prior notice, Is subject to what is provided under r. 24 (2) of chap. V of the rules. The learned single judge said that the provision contained in sub - rule (2) of r. 24 of the rules would abridge the freedom of the manager beyond what the parent enactment has authorised to be done by subjecting the right of the manager to close down the institution to a further condition that it will be dependent upon the grant of permission by the director of public instruction.
11. The above decision 1972 klt 496 has been followed in 1986 klt 359. The learned single judge also considered the fundamental right of the manager to closedown the school subject of course to such reasonable restrictions as are permissible under art. 19 (6) of the constitution of india when considering the question of an action taken by the director of public instruction to prevent the manager from closing the school. We feel that there is no reason for us to doubt the correctness of the decision reported in 1972 klt496.
12. In the result, We see no error in the judgment impugned in w. A. No. 226/1989 and w. A. No. 284 of 1989. Both writ appeals arc dismissed.
Alert