Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Raja Rai Bhagwat Dayal Singh v. Ram Ratan Sahu And Others

Privy Council
Nov 11, 1921
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

In November 1895 Raja Rai Bhagwat Dayal Singh purchased three villages — Chianki, Ganki, and Lalgara — within the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge of Palamau (District of Ranchi). The purchaser encountered occupants claiming absolute title under conveyances made by a Hindu widow who had only a limited estate. The Raja sued to obtain possession. The Subordinate Judge granted possession and mesne profits. The High Court of Judicature at Fort William reversed that judgment on appeal, but their Lordships in a subsequent appeal restored the Subordinate Judge's decision, ordering possession and mesne profits and allowing certain mortgage claims (two aggregate sums of Rs. 11,198 and Rs. 6,400) with interest at 6% per annum. Disputes arose about (1) the date from which the 6% interest should run, and (2) whether deductions should be made from mesne profits for permanent improvements executed on Lalgara. The matter was further considered on review and remand, including clarification by their Lordships on 11 February 1909 about the intended meaning of the interest allowance. The court finally varied the High Court's order to reflect that clarification and resolved the dispute over allowance for improvements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. From what date should the 6% interest awarded on the mortgage-related sums run (i.e., the starting date for the interest)?
  2. Whether and to what extent deductions or allowances should be made against mesne profits to account for permanent improvements (specifically irrigation tanks and a dyke) that increased the rental value of the village Lalgara.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents / Judgment-debtors (possession claimants and persons in possession)

  • On remand, they objected to the allowance of any money at all on account of improvements.
  • They specifically argued that an allowance could not be made because the improvements had been executed by a prior purchaser (the original purchaser from the widow) and not by the person who was in possession at the time the final purchase (by the Raja) was made.
  • Respondents later applied for a modification of the earlier judgment, seeking clarification as to what was meant by interest at 6%.

The opinion does not set out detailed affirmative arguments made by the Raja (the purchaser who sued for possession) in respect of these specific points in the text provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in two principal parts corresponding to the two main disputes.

Interest at 6% — date from which it runs

  • The Subordinate Judge originally construed the order as directing that interest run from the date of his original decree.
  • The High Court of Patna interpreted the order as taking the interest back to the date of the mortgages.
  • Their Lordships declined to settle the contested temporal construction in exhaustive detail because the earlier order of their Lordships (on the former appeal) had been the subject of a review application. On 11 February 1909, when the respondents sought modification, their Lordships clarified that their earlier intention was that the interest should run concurrently with the mesne profits — i.e., the interest award is to be contemporaneous with and coextensive with the mesne profits award.
  • Because of that clarified meaning, their Lordships modified the High Court's order to bring it into conformity with the declared intention in the earlier proceedings. The court regretted that this clarification had not been sought earlier in the litigation and noted that it was only placed before their Lordships late in the hearing process.

Allowance for Permanent Improvements against Mesne Profits

  • The Commissioner had found that the purchaser (from the widow) had made permanent improvements in Lalgara — specifically the erection of seven or eight large tanks for irrigation and construction of a dyke — and that these works raised the jama (rentable value) of the village to Rs. 2,400.
  • The Commissioner initially computed mesne profits for Lalgara at Rs. 35,057 and indicated that if entitled to a deduction for improvements, a deduction of Rs. 4,000 should be made; however, the Commissioner in effect attempted to deduct the capital spent rather than the increase in mesne profits attributable to the improvements.
  • The Subordinate Judge confirmed the commissioner's report as a matter of form. The High Court at Fort William remanded with directions restricting the parties from challenging the commissioner's figures and findings, except that judgment-debtors could show on the record that the Commissioner had omitted any particular improvement to which they were entitled; no fresh commission or further evidence was to be permitted.
  • On remand, the respondents objected first to any allowance and second to allowance on the ground that the improvements had been executed by a prior purchaser rather than by the person in possession at the time of the final purchase.
  • Their Lordships held these objections to be without substance. They reasoned that the increased rent properly attributable to the improvements can be set off against mesne profits even if the actual works were executed by someone who was not the immediate person in possession when the decree was made — the critical factor is the enhancement of value attributable to the improvements.
  • The Subordinate Judge had held that no sum should be allowed; the High Court at Patna fixed an allowance of 10% on the rents. Their Lordships said they could not, on the record before them, judge the precise adequacy of 10% because detailed circumstances were not before them, but considered 10% to be a perfectly fair and reasonable allowance given the commissioner's factual findings that the improvements increased the value.
  • Accordingly, their Lordships affirmed the High Court's decision to allow 10% on rents for the improvements and thus affirmed the High Court's approach in that respect.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The court varied the order of the High Court to the extent that the interest at 6% shall run concurrently with the mesne profits (as clarified by their Lordships on 11 February 1909). The judgment of the High Court with respect to allowance for permanent improvements (a 10% allowance on rents fixed by the High Court at Patna) was affirmed. The final disposition is recorded as: Appeal Partly allowed.

Implications / Consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the purchaser (Raja) recovers possession as earlier directed, mesne profits are to be ascertained and paid, interest on the mortgage sums at 6% is to be calculated so as to run concurrently with the mesne profits, and an allowance for improvements in respect of Lalgara of 10% on the rents (as fixed by the High Court at Patna) is to be given.
  • Costs: their Lordships ordered that there should be no costs of the appeal or cross-appeal, and that the costs order of the High Court should remain in force.
  • Broader precedent: the opinion does not purport to establish a new legal doctrine beyond its application to the facts; no binding precedential statements beyond the resolution of the issues in this record are identified in the opinion.

Other Observations Made by the Court

Their Lordships expressed regret at the protracted and recurring litigation, noting the serious administrative and social costs of protracted suits that may outlive the original purchaser and be pursued across multiple generations. They observed delay in bringing the matter from the High Court to their Court (four years) and lamented the absence of explanation for such delays, urging the removal of this "serious blot upon the administration of justice."

Order varied. Appeal Partly allowed.

Show all summary ...

Lord Buckmaster:-

Twenty-six years ago in the month of November, 1895, one Raja Rai Bhagwat Dayal Singh bought three villages known as Chianki, Ganki, and Lalgara, which were situate within the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge of Palamau in the District of Ranchi. Together with these villages he bought litigation, which has ensued from that day until this. He found that the villages were occupied by persons who claimed an absolute title under conveyances that had been made by a Hindu widow with a limited estate. It was consequently necessary for the Raja to take proceedings for the purpose of obtaining possession. He accordingly instituted a suit which was heard before the Subordinate Judge, who allowed his claim to possession and also mesne profits as from the proper date.

That judgment was made the subject of an appeal to the High Court of Judicature at Fort William in Bengal, and upon that appeal the judgment was reversed. From the decree of the High Court at Fort William an appeal was bought before their Lordships, who restored the judgment of the Subordinate Judge. They advised that the appeal should be allowed, and that the appellant should recover possession, together with mesne profits, which were to be ascertained in the execution proceedings, but they did something more, which has caused the first of the questions that has been argued upon the present appeal.

It appeared that although the person whom the purchaser in 1895 ejected had no title to the property against the Raja, yet the widow had, before the sale under which they claimed, raised money for necessities, ancestral worship, and other similar matters, for all of which she was perfectly entitled to charge the estate. Mortgages had been executed to secure these monies, and when the properties were sold by the widow, these mortgages were paid off.

The Subordinate Judge, when the matter first came before him, decided that certain parts of these mortgages which he gathered together under two heads, amounting in the one case to Rs. 11,198, and in the other to Rs. 6,400, should be allowed, and that these sums should carry interest at the rate of 6 per cent. When the matter was before their Lordships they confirmed the finding of the Subordinate Judge, both as to possession and as to those sums and found that the sums that were to be paid should carry interest at 6 per cent. pur annum.

The first question that has been raised upon this appeal is as from what date the 6 per cent should run. The proceedings have emerged from a finding originally made by the Subordinate Judge, who held that according to the true construction of this order the interest should run from the date of his own original decree, but the High Court of Judicature at Patna has said that the effect of the order is to take the interest back to the date of the mortgages.

It is unnecessary for their Lordships to settle in detail the question which led to that conclusion, for this reason : that the order of their Lordships on the former appeal was the subject of review, and an application was made to them for the purpose of ascertaining what it was that was meant by the allowance of interest at 6 per cent.

When no date was mentioned as the date from which it should run, and upon matter coming again before their Lordships on the 11th February, 1909 upon an application by the respondents for modification of the judgment, they made it clear that what they meant was that the interest should run concurrently with the mesne profits; that as one sum was allowed on the one hand for the mesne profits, the sum for interest should be allowed upon the other.

This relieves their Lordships entirely from the necessity of considering what, without the assistance of that interpretation, they might have decided that the order meant, and they can only express their sincere regret that the litigant parties in these proceedings did not think right at the earliest moment to have obtained the information which has not been placed before a single one of the Courts from whom this dispute has proceeded, and indeed was only placed before their Lordships this morning after the case had been partly heard.

It, at any rate, disposes entirely of the first part of the appeal, and the order that is appealed from in that respect must be modified so as to bring it into agreement with the declared intention of their Lordships in the earlier proceedings. But this does not dispose of the whole of the appeal, for there still remains a further matter for consideration that arises in this way.

When the inquiry was directed with regard to the mesne profits, a question arose as to whether part, at least, of the mesne profits had not been due to permanent improvements that had been executed upon the property by the purchasers, whose title had been dispossessed by the Raja, who had bought in November, 1895. There has never been any contention before their Lordships as to the right to obtain some allowance in respect of these improvements, if in the circumstances of this case such a right was capable of being established.

The Commissioner before whom the matter was first heard disposed entirely of the two villages, Chianki and Ganki, with regard to which no further question now arises : but with regard to Lalgara, he stated that the purchaser from the widow had made improvements, and that in consequence of these improvements the jama of the village was raised to Rs. 2,400.

There seems no doubt that these improvements were in their very nature of a permanent character. They were the erection of tanks for the purpose of irrigation, and the construction of a dyke. It seems quite impossible to believe that any estate that had received the advantage of seven or eight big tanks and the irrigation consequent upon their use would not have had the jama thereby increased. The learned Commissioner in his determination made a finding that the amount of the mesne profits for which the person in possession would be made liable amounted to a sum which in respect of this village was Rs. 35,057, and he then added that if he was entitled to a deduction for the improvement, then a deduction of Rs. 4,000 should be made therefrom, and if not, it should not.

In other words, what he attempted to do was to make the deduction for the capital spent in the improvements and not the amount by which the mesne profits themselves had been increased by the expenditure. The matter then went back before the Subordinate Judge, and he confirmed the report of the commissioner as a matter of form. The case then came before the High Court of Judicature at Fort William, and they dealt with the objection and remanded the matter with this direction :-

"Neither party will be entitled to challenge the figures arrived at by the Commissioner nor the findings arrived at by him, except that with regard to the improvements, the judgment-debtors will be at liberty to show on the materials on the record that the Commissioner has not given them credit for any particular improvement which they are justly entitled to. But they will not be entitled to take exception to the findings of the Commissioner as to their value, and no fresh commission will be issued nor any further evidence to be given by the parties."

It appears that the further objections that were taken upon this remand were first of all to the allowance of any money at all, and secondly, it was argued that an allowance could not be made because the improvements had in fact been executed by the person, who had been the original purchaser from the vendor who had the limited estate, and that he had again sold and that it was the purchaser from him who was in possession at the time when the final purchase of the property was made.

Their Lordships are of opinion that there is no substance in these contentions. The increased rent that is properly attributable to the improvements can be properly set off against the mesne profits, even although it was not actually executed by the person in possession at the moment when the decree for possession was made, and the only question that is left is to determine whether or no any sum should be allowed. The Subordinate Judge held that there should be no sum allowed at all and the High Court at Patna has fixed a sum of 10 per cent on the rents.

With regard to the adequacy or the accuracy of a 10 per cent allowance, their Lordships are not in a position to speak they cannot possibly know the circumstances, but the sum of 10 per cent. appears to be a perfectly fair and reasonable sum to allow in the circumstance of this case. The facts found by the Commissioner are those upon which all the judgments must proceed, and among these is the statement that the improvement have increased the value.

Their Lordships are clearly of opinion that that is not only the finding of the Commissioner, but that it is the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the character of the improvements, and they therefore think, in, that respect, that the judgment of the High Court must be affirmed.

That disposes of all the matters upon this appeal,but their Lordships cannot part with this case without expressing once more their regret as to the interminable course of litigation in India. It cannot be for the welfare of any community that the purchaser of property bought in good faith should be liable to endless quarrels arising out of his purchase, which continue, as they do in this case, and as they must in many, beyond the period of his natural life. The man who bought this property never knew that it was to be free from the anxiety of a law suit until the day he died; even then the litigation was not ended, and has been pursued until the present appeal.

This has itself taken four years to come here from the High Court, and of course no explanation has or ever can be offered of why these delays occur. Their Lordships refer once more to this matter in the earnest hope that a condition of things which they regard as constituting a serious blot upon the administration of justice should be removed.

With regard to the costs of this appeal, their Lordships have given careful consideration to what order justice requires, and they have come to the conclusion that there ought to be no costs of the appeal or of the cross appeal; that the costs of the High Court, although the order of the High Court has been varied, should in the circumstances of this case be allowed to stand.

They will, therefore, humbly advise His Majesty that the order of the High Court be varied to the extent that has been already indicated, namely, by declaring that the interest of 6 per cent should run concurrently with the mesne profits, but that the costs should be dealt with as above mentioned.

Order varied

Appeal Partly allowed.