Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahipalsing Panchanji Jadeja v. State Of Gujarat

Gujarat High Court
Jan 8, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K.J. Vaidya, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 27 April 1989 Smt. Manjulaben Chandulal Ahya lodged a complaint at Jamnagar City Police Station, ‘B’ Division, alleging her daughter Rajeshvari Chandulal Ahya had been missing since 21 April 1989 and was suspected of being abducted by Mahipatsinh Panchanji Jadeja (the applicant-accused). An FIR (No. 170/89) was registered for offences punishable under Sections 363 and 366 of the Indian Penal Code. The accused was arrested on 7 December 1989. He applied for bail (M.C.A. No. 472/89) on 8 December 1989, which was dismissed by order dated 15 December 1989.

When the matter previously came before this Court (on 5 January 1990), two sworn affidavits — one of the complainant (Manjulaben Chandulal Ahya) and one of her daughter Rajeshvari — were tendered by the learned advocate for the accused and were ordered to be kept on the record. The matter was adjourned to 8 January 1990. On 8 January, the applicant-accused renewed the plea for bail, relying principally on those two affidavits and on the fact that the deponents were present in court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a court may straightway accept and rely upon unverified affidavits of prosecution witnesses, tendered by an accused to support a bail application, without giving the investigating agency a fair opportunity to inquire into their genuineness, voluntariness and truthfulness.
  2. Whether presence of the deponents in court (and their having sworn affidavits) is sufficient to justify acceptance of such affidavits to the prejudice of the prosecution and to warrant release on bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant-Accused's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)

  • The two affidavits (of the complainant and her daughter) completely negate the allegation of abduction and effectively "white-wash" the prosecution case, entitling the accused to bail.
  • Because the two deponents were present in court, the affidavits should be accepted as voluntary, truthful and genuine, lending assurance and weight to the accused's claim for release on bail.

State's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State's legal arguments; the record only shows that the learned Additional Public Prosecutor waived service of the Rule and appeared when the matter was heard.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully examined the two affidavits and acknowledged that, prima facie, they might suggest the deponents (important prosecution witnesses) no longer wished to prosecute the accused. However, the Court refused to accept those affidavits at face value without verification for the following reasons and considerations explicitly stated in the opinion:

  1. Institutional role and jurisdiction: The Court held that it cannot assume or usurp the role of the investigating agency. The investigating agency has an independent statutory right to inquire into allegations and to verify evidence; courts should not short-circuit that function.
  2. Risk of coercion, inducement or fabrication: The Court emphasized that affidavits which appear to be "turn-coat" statements can be procured through pressure, threats, promises or other improper means, including actions originating from accused persons or their associates. Such possibilities require "in-depth searching inquiry by the police."
  3. Specific suspicious circumstances observed by the Court: On perusal of the affidavits and the prior order rejecting bail, the Court noted multiple indicia of suspicion that justified verification by the investigating agency. These circumstances included:
    • Both deponents are women.
    • The two affidavits were on Rs. 10 stamp papers appearing to have been purchased on 27-12-1989 (i.e., after the Sessions Judge's order of 15-12-1989), and the affidavits lack clear dates of affirmation before the Executive Magistrate.
    • Signatures of the Executive Magistrate and the identifying advocate are illegible and lack dates; the identity of the identifying advocate is unclear.
    • Accused had been absconding for a considerable period after the alleged offence and could not be arrested despite police efforts.
    • Accused did not surrender even after two anticipatory bail applications were rejected by the Sessions Judge.
    • Accused is about 30 years old, married and his wife is living (noted as part of background facts).
    • The investigating officer's affidavit before the Sessions Judge indicated the accused was involved in multiple theft cases with pending trials.
  4. Public policy and administration of justice concerns: The Court warned that lightly accepting such affidavits without verification could allow criminals to pressure witnesses and subvert investigation and trial processes, thereby undermining the rule of law.
  5. Balancing approach: While the Court would not straightway accept the affidavits without verification, it was also unwilling to reject them outright. The Court recognized that the affidavits introduced fresh circumstances not previously before the Sessions Judge and that the accused should be given an opportunity to have those circumstances considered on merits by the Sessions Judge after verification by the investigating agency.

Holding and Implications

Rule discharged.

Core ruling and directions:

  • The Court refused to accept and place direct reliance upon the two unverified affidavits tendered by the accused without giving the investigating agency a fair and reasonable opportunity to inquire into their genuineness, voluntariness and truthfulness.
  • At the same time, the Court declined to dismiss the affidavits entirely; recognizing that they present fresh material, the Court held that the accused should be given another opportunity to press his bail application before the learned Sessions Judge.
  • The learned Sessions Judge is directed to decide the bail application on its merits after giving the investigating agency adequate opportunity to inquire into the affidavits and to submit its report for the court's consideration.

Practical consequences for the parties:

  • Immediate release on bail was not granted by this Court on the basis of the two unverified affidavits.
  • The accused retains the right to move his bail application afresh before the Sessions Judge, who must consider the new affidavits only after the investigating agency's verification and report.
  • The investigating agency is to be given an opportunity to investigate the circumstances surrounding the affidavits and report to the Sessions Judge (and thereby to the court deciding bail).

The opinion does not state or purport to lay down any new binding precedent; it resolves the immediate procedural question by discharging the Rule and directing further inquiry and reconsideration by the Sessions Judge with involvement of the investigating agency.


Reference in the original text: "Not reported. Only portions approved for reporting by High Court are reported." The above summary is strictly based on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add external information.

Show all summary ...

K.J Vaidya, J.:— Rule. Mr. S.R Divetia, learned Addl. P.P appearing for the opponent State waives service of the Rule.

2. Heard Mr. M.V Solanki, learned advocate for the applicant accused and Mr. Divetia, learned Addl. P.P for the State.

3. Briefly speaking, it was a prosecution case that on 27th April 1989, Smt. Manjulaben Chandulal Ahya lodged a complaint at Jamnagar City Police Station, ‘B’ Division, against one Mahipatsinh Panchanji Jadeja - the applicant-accused herein, alleging that her daughter Rajeshvari Chandulal Ahya was missing since 21st April 1989 and that she had a suspicion of being abducted by the present applicant-accused.

4. On the basis of this fact, the police registered the complaint against the accused, the same being FIR No. 170/89 for the offence punishable under Sections 363 and 366 of I.P.C Thereafter, after a long time, the accused came to be arrested on 7th December 1989, by the police and on 8th December 1989, he submitted a bail application before the learned Sessions Judge, same being M.C.A No. 472/89 which was ultimately dismissed by an order dated 15th December 1989.

5. Earlier, when this matter came up for admission before this Court (Coram: J.U Mehta, J. on 5-1-1990), the learned advocate for the applicant-accused Mr. M.V Solanki had tendered two sworn affidavits that of (i) Smt. Manjulaben Chandulal Ahya (complainant) and (ii) Rajeshvari, daughter of the complainant, which were ordered to be kept on the record. The matter was thereafter stand-over today, i.e 8th January 1990.

6. Today on matter being called out, Mr. Solanki has made following two submissions:—

(1) That the aforesaid two affidavits not only completely white-wash the allegation of the abduction of Rajeshvari by the accused Mahipatsinh, but the same also cut at the very root of the prosecution case giving thereby the clean-bill of innocence to the accused so as to entitle him to be released on bail.

(2) That the aforesaid two affidavits are needed to be accepted by this court as the deponents of the said two affidavits were present before the court to lend added assurance and strength to the voluntary, truthful and genuine nature of the same. As per this submissions, according to Mr. Solanki, the accused deserves to be released on bail.

7. I have carefully perused the aforesaid two affidvaits, a bare reading of which prima facie does give an impression that the deponents of the said affidvaits (who are important prosecution witnesses) do not appear to be any more in any mood either to prosecute, try and/or to get convicted and punished the accused for alleged offences. But ait the same time, it is also too difficult to conclusively hold that whatever stated in the said two affidavits is gospel truth. Under such circumstances, the question of importance that arises for the consideration is “whether it would be just, legal and proper to straightway accept and rely upon unverified affidavits of two prosecution witnesses at its face value, which have been further sought to be supported by keeping two deponents of the said affidavits present before the court — short-circuiting the ordinary procedure by keeping the investigating agency out of the picture to have any say in the matter”.?

8. Now regarding the question raised hereinabove, at the very outset, it can safely be held without slightest hesitation that merely because the accused has tendered duly sworned affidavits of the prosecution witnesses by keeping the deponents of the same present before the court, that by themselves cannot be presumed or permitted to have any direct and binding effect to the prejudice of the prosecution till the time the investigating agency had - (i) a fair and reasonable opportunity to verify and inquire into the genuineness, truthfulness and the voluntary character of the same, and (ii) submit its report for the consideration of the court taking up the matter. It is very clear that neither this court nor any court can ever be expected to assume and/or usurp the role and jurisdiction of the investigating agency which has an independent established statutory right and the role to play in investigating cases. As a matter of fact, it hardly requires to be emphasized that the alleged “tum-coat affidavits” cannot be lightly entertained and as the same can be a matter of serious concern, calling for indepth searching inquiry by the police. It is indeed too, difficult to appreciate and understand as to under what circumstances and in what manner the aforesaid two affidavits came to be sworn by the concerned deponents? Whether same are made voluntarily or made under some unwarranted pressure or coercion flowing directly or indirectly from the accused? Whether the said affidavits are genuinely sworn before the Executive Magistrate, Jamnagar, or are just a fabricated piece? Whether the deponents who solemnly affirmed their affidavits before the Executive Magistrate were in fact identified by the concerned learned advocates? Ordinarily, once the criminal complaint is filed against any person, no complainant ever volunteers any initiative either of herself or himself (as the case may be) to go back from the alleged prosecution case unless so persuaded, pressurized or terrorized by someone directly or indirectly. Mostly and ordinarily the possibility of such affidavits being procured by any means, under some potential threats (emanating either from an accused or his agents and associates but side the jail premises) to the life, liberty and property and/or some promise or inducement held out to the prosecution witness and/or for that purpose other citizens whose affidavits are needed most to be procured cannot be ruled out.

9. Under such state of affairs, how hazardous it can be to straightway accept and rely upon unverified affidavits submitted by the accused! Thus, wisdom warrants that unless the clouds of suspicion and mystery that always surrounds such affidavits are cleared the same should not be given any credence. As against this, if such allegedly procured affidavits are lightly accepted and relied upon without same being duly verified and inquired into, it will create and lead to such a situation wherein hardened criminals living on life of crimes will have a flee handle to pressurize and terrorise the prosecution witnesses and for that purpose any other citizen so as to yield to their illegal demands of swearing any affdiavats they liked which can defuse not only the prosecution interest, but can as well make defunct the investigating agency and the administration of justice. Such a situation ultimately is bound to substitute the rule of law by rule of lawlessness……….

10. As a matter of fact, on a careful perusal of the said two affidavits as well as the impugned judgment and order rejecting the bail application of the accused, the following circumstances surface which would and should prima facie put any court on the guard before placing implicit reliance upon them, till of course the same is greensignalled on verification by the prosecuting agency:

(i) That it appears that both deponents of the said two affidavits are ladies.

(ii) It appears that both the affidavits are sworned on a stamp paper of Rs. 10/- each of them purchased on 27-12-1989. This means both of them came into existence only after the impugned judgment and order dated 15-12-1989 rejecting the bail application of the applicant-accused came to be passed.

(iii) That the aforesaid stamp papers of Rs. 10/- each appear to have been purchased on 27-12-1989 and apart this date, there is no separate date mentioned in the said affidavits as to show exactly on what date and time the said affidavits were solemnly affirmed before the Executive Magistrate.

(iv) That neither the learned advocate who identified the deponents nor the learned Executive Magistrate before whom the affidavits were sworned, have placed any dates below their signatures.

(v) Thus neither the signature of Mr. R.H Patel, Executive Magistrate nor that of the learned advocate who appears to have signed as having identified the deponents before the Executive Magistrate are legible.

(vi) So far as the learned advocate who had identified the deponents is concerned, nor only his signature is illegible, but nothing has been written below in bracket in legible letters so as to indicate as to who in fact was the learned advocate identifying the deponents.

(vii) That the accused has been found to be absconding for a considerable time after the alleged offence and could not be arrested by the police despite its frantic efforts of searching all round.

(ix) That the accused did not surrender even after his two anticipatory bail applications came to be rejected by the learned Sessions Judge.

(x) That the accused is aged 30 years and a married person and appears to have legally married long back with Smt. Hansaba who is living.

(xi) That the affidavit of the investigating officer made before the learned Sessions Judge, ex-facie, reveals that the accused is involved in many theft cases and that trial of the same is pending before the concerned trial courts.

11. The aforesaid catalogue of circumstances are real hurdles in the way of the accused, who on the basis of the two unverified affidavits prays for getting himself to be released on bail.

12. Thus, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, as discussed above, it is not possible to accede to the request of the learned advocate Mr. Solanki to accept two unverified affidavits of deponents. Even the presence of two lady deponents of the said affidavits who are kept present in the court by the accused cannot by themselves be permitted to lend any assurance to accept the same for the simple reason that this court feels risky enough to accept the same in view of the clouds of suspicion and mystery that surround this two affidavits.

13. These days, we do come across cases where at some stage of the criminal proceedings, the accused in order to get enlarged on bail - (i) either produces the affidavits like the one submitted in the present case; and/or (ii) produces the medical certificate. Now the contents of such affidavit and/or medical certificate may be true and therefore the accused would be just within his right to pray for his bail on the basis of said materials. But this right of the accused is always circumscribed by the corresponding right of the investigating agency to have a fair and reasonable opportunity to verify the voluntary, truthful and genuine nature of the pleas advanced by the accused in the said affidavit/certificate, etc. It is always advisable for the court to wait for the report of the investigating agency in the matter before giving any decision on the point.

14. In view of the discussion made hereinabove, this court though not inclined to straightway accept and rely upon the aforesaid two affidavits produced by the accused is equally hesitant to reject the same outright being considered for whatever worth it is. As a matter of fact, the contents of said two affidavits brings forth a fresh circumstance on the record for the first time of which the learned Sessions Judge who rejected the earlier bail application, did not have any opportunity to consider the same. In this view of the matter, the accused deserves to be given one more opportunity to move his bail application before the learned Sessions Judge, who will decide the same on merits after giving adequate opportunity to the investigating agency to inquire into the matter and submit its report on the basis of the same.

15. [Not reported. Only portions approved for reporting by High Court are reported.]

16. Rule discharged.