- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gian Chand v. Union Of India And Ors.
1. The petitioner seeks the issuance of a writ against the respondents who do not reside or have office within the territorial jurisdiction of this court nor have they passed any order within the State adversely affecting the rights of the petitioner. Mr. Malik the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that as the order of the respondents passed in appeal filed by the petitioner was conveyed to him within the jurisdiction of this court therefore this court has the jurisdiction to entertain the petition and grant the appropriate relief.
I have heard the arguments of the learned counsel in detail and perused the relevant provisions of the Constitution applicable.
2. Art. 226 of the Constitution of India was amended and substituted fey a new Article by the 2nd amendment Act 1976. Again in the year 1978 the Article was substituted vide 44th amendment Act with this result that the original Article 226 was restored with some modification. In view of the 42nd amendment, the jurisdiction of the High Court could have been invoked for the enforcement of the fundamental rights or to redress any injury of substantial nature caused by contravention of statutory provisions and to redress any injury by reason of illegality in any proceedings resulting in substantial failure of justice. A comparative study of the original Article and as substituted vide 42nd amendment clearly showed that the scope of writ jurisdiction was much reduced. However 44th amendment specifically omitted all the amendments which had reduced the jurisdiction of the High Court. Art. 226 of the Constitution prescribed a two-fold limitation on the jurisdiction of this court in its territorial aspect, i.e. the power could be exercised Through-out the territories in relation to which the High Court exercised the jurisdiction and to the personal authority to whom the writs are issued within the territories subject to the jurisdiction of the High Court (AIR 1854 SC 207). However after 15th amendment Act, 1963, the High Courts were conferred the powers to exercise jurisdiction against the authorities ir-respective of the residence or location of offices if any part of the cause of action had accrued to the petitioner within the territorial jurisdiction of the court where the petition is filed. It follows therefore that even if the seat of the authority or person concerned is out-side the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, jurisdiction under Art. 225 of the constitution can be exercised in respect of such matter if whole or any part of the cause of action had arisen within such territory. Amendment to Art. 226 by the 15th amendment was only procedural and therefore retrospective. It is now well settled that where a part of the cause of action arose within the jurisdiction of a particular court, that has the jurisdiction to entertain the petition and grant the relief. If the petitioner succeeds in showing that the impugned order affected him or was passed or the authority passing the order resides or is situate within the territorial, jurisdiction of a particular High Court, that High Court would have the jurisdiction to grant the relief. In a case where none of these conditions are shown to be existing the High Court would refuse to entertain the petition for grant of relief under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India.
3. In the instant case all the respondents reside and have their seat of offices outside the jurisdiction of this court, the impugned orders adversely affecting the service career of the petitioner were passed by the authorities outside the jurisdiction of this court when the petitioner was serving in Pune. The petitioner is alleged to have submitted a statutory appeal against the adverse remarks in his ACRs pertaining to the year 1985 to the respondent No. 2 who vide his order dated: 25.11.1986 rejected the same. The order anuexure p-1 was passed by Headquarters Puna sub-area Puna on 7.1.1987. It is submitted that as the impugned order annexure p-1 was received by the petitioner on 2.2.1987 within the territorial jurisdiction of this court, therefore, he was entitled to file the petition in this court for the redress of his grievances It is submitted that as the order of his statutory appeal was passed in Puna was conveyed to him when he stood transferred within the territory of this court therefore, this court has got the jurisdiction to grant the relief under Art. 226. The contention of the petitioner is mis-conceived and cannot be accepted on the facts and circumstances of the case No part of cause of action has accrued to the petitioner within the territorial jurisdiction of this court. The territorial jurisdiction of the court would not change with the change of place of posting of the concerned person. No orders passed by the respondent adversely affected the petitioner within the jurisdiction of this court.
4. " Cause of Action " means a bundle of essential fact, which it is necessary for the parties to prove his justifying the seeking of a judicial remedy. It is always for the petitioner to show that at least one of such essential facts required to be proved to secure an order in his favour had arisen within the territory of the High Court, that court will have jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition " Cause of Action " in the restricted sense mean the circumstances forming the infringment of the right or the immediate occasion for the action and in the wider sense means the necessary conditions for the maintenance of an action, including not only the fraction of the right but the infraction coupled with the right itself. It is acknowledged that the " Cause of Action " means every fact which is necessary for the petitioner to prove, if traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment of the court does not comprise every piece of evidence which is necessary to be proved. A cause of action is something more than a ground or unity of title and it not only includes the facts necessary to support the petitioners title, but also the facts witch entitled him to a relief against a particular preson or authority. Facts of each case would determine as to whether any person has got a cause of action having reference to the substance and the prayers made.
5. Keeping in view the facts and circumstances of this case and in view of the settled preposition of law I have no hesitation to hold that no part of the cause of action accrued to the petitioner within the territorial jurisdiction of this court and the petitioner is not entitled to maintain this petition in a forum of his choice. As this court was no territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petitioner, or grant any relief to the petitioner, this petition is dismissed in limini alongwith CMP Nos. 797/88 and 796/1988.
Alert