- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mani Ram Jandial & Ors. v. Chairman, J&K Special Tribunal & Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
(Narrative drawn solely from the provided opinion.)
The petitioners are residents of Gandhi Nagar, Jammu. They challenged an order of the J&K Special Tribunal dated 6.6.1989. The Tribunal, proceeding on the assumption that Respondent No. 2 had raised a shopping complex in violation of the sanctioned site plan, held the violation to be of a minor nature and compounded the offence under Rule 3 of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal (Unauthorized Construction) Rules, 1977 by imposing a compounding fee of Rs. 4,500.
Respondent No. 2 had obtained sanction No. 108 dated 3.5.1988 to construct a canteen block on the eastern side of Swaran Cinema in Gandhi Nagar. According to the petitioners, while construction began as sanctioned, the shutters/shops were opened towards the road that bifurcated the Cinema Complex and the nearby housing colony rather than facing the Cinema, in breach of the sanctioned plan.
The petitioners complained to the Jammu Municipality (Respondent No. 4). The Municipality issued order MJ/Estt/19999/1604 dated 22-6-1988 directing dismantling of the violating portion and keeping the original sanction in abeyance until production of No Objection Certificates from the District Magistrate, Traffic Advisory Board and Fire Service. Respondent No. 2 challenged the Municipality's order before the J&K Special Tribunal. The petitioners were allowed to appear as interveners in the Tribunal proceedings by this Court's order dated 13-3-1989 in Writ Petition No. 322/89. The Tribunal ultimately declined the interveners' complaints and compounded the construction under Rule 3 by directing Respondent No. 2 to pay Rs. 4,500, a decision the petitioners impugned before this Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the construction by Respondent No. 2 violated the sanctioned site plan and, if so, whether that violation constituted an offence under the Municipal Act.
- Whether the J&K Special Tribunal acted lawfully and with proper application of mind in determining that the offence (if any) was of a minor nature and in compounding it under Rule 3 of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal (Unauthorized Construction) Rules, 1977.
- Whether the Tribunal was justified in treating the Municipality's order of 22-6-1988 (keeping the sanction in abeyance and directing dismantling) as beyond law.
- Whether the petitioners (as interveners) had locus standi to challenge the Tribunal's order in this Court.
- Whether the Tribunal committed procedural improprieties (e.g., deciding the case and announcing the order at Srinagar though the matter belonged to Jammu).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (as recorded)
- The original and revised site plans did not permit shops on the ground floor facing the road; the sanctioned plan envisioned a composite canteen/kitchen with a blind wall toward the road and openings toward the Cinema complex; the construction as raised violated the sanctioned site plan and constituted an offence under the Municipal Act.
- The Tribunal acted in violation of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal (Unauthorized Construction) Rules, 1977.
- The Tribunal failed to record satisfaction or properly determine whether the offence was of a minor nature before compounding it.
- The Tribunal disposed of the case without proper application of mind and without examining the implications of its decision.
- The Tribunal decided the case and announced the order at Srinagar though the matter belonged to Jammu (allegation of improper venue or procedure).
Respondent No. 2's Arguments (as recorded)
- The petitioners lacked locus standi, as they were not parties before the Tribunal and no rights of theirs were violated.
- The matter raised disputed questions of fact which could not be decided in writ jurisdiction of this Court.
- The revised sanction plan permitted construction of a generator-cum-shopping complex; the construction did not violate the sanctioned plan. The order in Annexure 'P-2' (Municipality order) was allegedly the result of pressure from an individual (Shri Kulbhushan Jandial).
Respondent No. 4 (Municipality) — Pleadings (as recorded)
- The Municipality pleaded that the construction was against the sanctioned plan and contravened the Municipal Act.
- Although an appeal under Section 229 of the Municipal Act was pending against the action taken, the Appellate authority (Respondent No. 1 in the appeal) compounded the unauthorized construction; this was contended to be contrary to law and done without recording necessary satisfaction. The Municipality maintained that the offence was a major one and could not be compounded.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1982 SC 149 | Support for the broadening of the rule of locus standi and greater access to courts (public interest / liberal locus-standi). | The Court referred to this authority (alongside AIR 1981 SC 344) to justify a liberal construction of locus-standi and concluded the interveners had sufficient interest to maintain the writ petition. |
| AIR 1981 SC 344 | Support for the broadening of the rule of locus standi and public interest litigation principles. | The Court relied on the tendency endorsed by this authority to broaden locus-standi and thereby accepted the petitioners' right to file the writ petition as interveners. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a multi-step analysis, as recorded in the opinion:
- Jurisdiction / Locus-standi: The Court first addressed whether the petitioners, who had been permitted to appear as interveners in the Tribunal proceedings by this Court's earlier order, had locus to challenge the Tribunal's order. Relying on authorities (cited as AIR 1982 SC 149 and AIR 1981 SC 344), the Court observed that the rule of locus-standi has been broadened to facilitate public interest litigation and therefore accepted that the interveners had a sufficient interest to maintain the writ petition.
- Examination of the impugned Tribunal order: The Court identified several "silent features" and defects in the Special Tribunal's order:
- The Tribunal appeared to be influenced by the mere presence of the words "shopping complex" in the sanction plan and concluded (without proof, according to this Court) that the shops would necessarily open towards the road rather than towards the Cinema complex.
- The Tribunal criticized the Municipality's order for putting the sanction in abeyance, holding that no law permitted such an abeyance; simultaneously it rejected the interveners' complaints as misplaced or premature.
- The Tribunal characterized questions of nuisance, disturbance and violation of petitioners' rights as questions of fact to be agitated before a proper forum, thereby deferring substantive factual determination.
- The Tribunal's reasoning was internally inconsistent: it on one hand held the construction to conform with the sanction plan, and on the other proceeded on the assumption that it was an encroachment and compounded the offence — a contradiction indicating a lack of application of mind.
- The conclusion that the Municipality would be satisfied by imposing a compounding fee of Rs. 4,500 for 1,725 sq.ft. was not supported by evidence on record and appeared to be based on conjecture.
- Under Rule 3 of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal (Unauthorized Construction) Rules, 1977, a finding that the offence was of a minor nature was required before compounding; the Tribunal did not record any such finding nor state grounds for it, despite the opinion noting that "minor offence" lacks an express statutory definition.
- Policy and institutional considerations: The Court emphasized that the Municipal Act provides a detailed machinery for dealing with unauthorized constructions and that the Executive Officer of the Municipality is the primary official with knowledge of sanctioned plans, nature of violations, nuisance and obstruction issues, and spot position. The Court warned that frequent or indiscriminate compounding by appellate fora can negate the statutory machinery and deprive parties of their proper forum.
- Guidance to appellate fora: The Court expressed that appellate bodies should be cautious and reluctant ("loath") to compound such offences routinely and in a perfunctory manner without assigning reasons.
- Disposition: On the basis of these defects — lack of recorded satisfaction as to minor nature, contradiction in findings, absence of evidence for the compounding fee and an apparent failure to apply mind — the Court concluded that quashing of the Tribunal's order was warranted. The Court also provided remedial directions regarding the Municipality's earlier order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court quashed the order of the Member Special Tribunal dated 6-6-1989.
The Court further modified the Municipality's order dated 22-6-1988 by directing that Respondent No. 4 (the Executive Officer) shall, after hearing the parties on their interpretation of the site plan, pass fresh and reasoned appropriate orders within one month from the date of this opinion. Until such fresh orders are passed, the status quo is to be maintained. The Court made no order as to costs.
Implications (as articulated in the opinion)
- Direct consequence: The Tribunal's compounding order was set aside; the Municipality is directed to re-hear the matter and decide afresh with reasons within a time limit, preserving the status quo in the interim.
- Institutional guidance: Appellate authorities should not routinely exercise the power to compound offences without recording satisfaction, providing reasons, and ensuring that such exercise does not undermine the statutory machinery vested in the municipal executive authorities.
- On precedent: The Court relied on existing precedents to permit a liberal view of locus-standi; the decision also emphasizes procedural and evidentiary rigor when compounding is contemplated, but the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond these applications to the facts of the case.
1. Petitioners who are the residents of Gandhi Nagar, Jammu have through the medium of this petition assailed order of the J&K Special Tribunal passed on 6.6.1989. This order of the Tribunal has while proceeding on the assumption that the respondent No. 2 bad raised the shopping complex in violation to the sanctioned site plan held this violation to be of a minor nature and while invoking the clemency of Rule-3 of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal (Unauthorized construction) Rules, 1977 (hereinafter called the Rules) compounded the offence after imposing a compounding tee of Rs. 4, 500/- (Rs. Four thousand and five hundred only).
2. The brief facts of the case are that respondent No. 2 obtained sanction No. 108 dated 3.5.1988 to raise construction of canteen block on the eastern side of Swaran Cinema building situated at Gandhi Nagar Jammu. Opposite to the Swaran Cinema, the residential houses of the petitioners along with other houses constitute a newly raised Posh Housing Colony. Respondent No. 2 started the sanctioned cons traction, but instead of facing the opening of Canteen Block Shops towards the Cinema, respondent No. 2 opened the shutters towards the road which bifurcated the Cinema Complex from the aforementioned housing colony. The petitioners while feeling aggrieved of this violation on the part of respondent No. 2 approached the Jammu Municipality (respondent No. 4 in this petition) who swung interaction and passed the orders under No. MJ/Estt/19999/1604 on 22-6-88 (Annexure-2) asking the respondent No. 2 to dismantle the building of the extent of its violation. This order also kept in abeyance the original sanction till the production of 'No Objection Certificate' from the District Magistrate, Traffic Advisory Board and Fire service. This order of respondent No. 4 was challenged by respondent No. 2 before the J&K Special Tribunal. The petitioners were in compliance with the order passed by this court on 13-3-1989 in writ petition No. 322/89 treated as interveners in the proceedings of the Tribunal and were also heard. The Tribunal has thus while taking refuge from Rule-3 (supra) com pounded the offence and while refuting the claim of the petitioners regularized the action of respondent No. 2 giving a cause to the petitioners for approaching this court in its extraordinary jurisdiction.
The order of the Tribunal has been challenged on the grounds:-
a) That the original site plan read with the revised site plan as sanctioned by the Municipality on May, 3, 1988 does not permit the constructions of any shops on the ground floor and on the other hand, a composite structure of canteen and kitchen with a blind wall towards the road and its doors and windows opening towards the Cinema's complex. The constructions raised as per the Commissioner's report are squarely in violation of sanctioned site plan and this constitutes an offence in terms of Municipal Act.
(b) That the Tribunal has acted in violation of the provisions of J&K Municipal (Unauthorized Construction) Rules, 1977.
(c) That the satisfaction with regards to violation or determination of the issue whether or jot this was an offence of minor nature has not been recorded.
(d) That the Tribunal has acted in a slip shod manner in disposing of the case without proper application of mind on its facts and the contours of its implications.
(e) That the Tribunal decided the case and the order was announced at Srinagar while this case belongs to Jammu.
3. Notice of such hearing was given to the parties. Besides refuting some factual assertions, Respondent No. 2 has challenged the petition on the following grounds:-
(i) That the petitioners have no locus-standi to maintain the present petition as they were neither party before the Tribunal nor was any of their rights violated.
(ii) That the petition rises disputed question of fact, which cannot be decided in writ jurisdiction of this court.
(iii) That the revised sanction plan clearly permits the construction of a Generator-cum-shopping complex which was noticed and referred to by the Sanctioning Authority, the construction raised by the respondents do not violate the sanction plan. On the other band, the order passed in terms of annexure P'-2' was the outcome of pressure that was mounted by one Shri Kulbhushan Jandial who works as Deputy Director in Information Department of the State.
4. Respondent No. 4 has filed a separate counter and has detailed out the main features and particulars of the sanction plan. He has pleaded that the construction raided was against the sanction plan and was vocative of the provisions of Municipal Act. It has also been pleaded that even though appeal was pending against the action being taken u/s 229 of the Municipal Act, respondent No. 1 in the appeal against Order No. MJ/Estt/1799-1807 dated 22-8-1988 compounded the unauthorized and illegal construction. This according to respondent No. 4 was done against the mandate of law, it has also been asserted that respondent No. 1 has not recorded the satisfaction while passing the said order. The offence committed by respondent 2 was a major offence and could not be compounded.
5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. In this case the foremost question that should attract the attention of the court is that of an intervener's locus to assail an order passed in proceedings in which he was not formally made a party. Mr. Gupta has vehemently urged that the rule of locus-standi has been broadened and its amplified contours can safely take this case into its compass. He has referred to historical cases reported in AIR 1982 SC page 149 and AIR 1981 S.C. 344.
6. The apex court of the country approved the tendency of broadening of rule of locus-standi rather than restricting it. This has been done to ensure growth I of healthy system of administrative law. In a developing socio-economy, with a growing awareness of corporate interest and social rights, the need for throwing the gates of justice open for public interest litigation was over-felt. Law and law courts from machinery, which can successfully be enhaged to bring about the much converter socio-economic change.
7. This court had allowed the applicants to be heard as interveners only after finding that they had an interest in the matter. The interveners do have an interest in the lis and in view of the liberal construction of the rule Of locus as laid down in the above rulings, t have no hesitation on their behalf is maintainable.
After I come to the conclusion that the petitioners have a right of filling this writ petition, I would like to detail out some silent features of the order impugned in this petition:-
a) That the Special Tribunal seems to have been influenced by the existence of words "shopping complex" in the sanction plan. According to the Tribunal, the site plan does not show that the shops were ever intended to be opened on any side other than the road. The Tribunal proceeds to observe as under:-
"Once it is agreed that the plans were meant for construction of shops and that the sanction was also granted for the same, it does not appeal to common sense that the shops would have opened towards the parking area of the Cinema house instead of road side. The argument of the respondents has no merit and is accordingly rejected"
(b) That the Tribunal has considered the order impugned before it to be beyond law in so for as it kept in abeyance the sanction already issued because no law permits that. The grievances of the interveners have been turned down as the same have bean said to be misplaced and pre-mature.
(c) That the Tribunal has observed that the question as to whether the alleged construction in the said locality would amount to nuisance and disturbance and would violate the legal rights of the petitioners was a question of fact which the interveners could agitate before a proper forum.
(d) The Tribunal has on one hand held the construction to be quite in accordance with the law and on the other proceeded on the assumption of that being an encroachment, hold the same to be of minor nature and compounded the same by directing the respondent No. 2 to deposit a compounding fee of Rs. 4500/-.
8. I am tempted to reproduce para 24 of the impugned order as under.-
"The argument is not without, merit. Even though it has been held that the construction is not in violation of the sanctioned building plans for the reasons given earlier, yet even if the same were treated to be so, the Municipality would be satisfied if the appellant is directed to deposit a compounding fee of Rs. 4500/- (Rupees four thousand and five hundred only) of the area measuring 1725 sq.ft. as per following details:
(1) Shop six nos: 75'x 20 = 1500 Sq.ft.
(2) Balcony: 77'x1½' = 112.50 Sq. ft.
(3) -do- : 75'x½ = 112.50 Sq. ft.
1725.00 Sq ft
as per the report of Khilafwazri Inspector which is on the file of the Municipality, as per rules framed u/s 29 of j&k municipal act."
On a bird's eye view, the order impugned suffers from the following flaws:
(I) It seems to have been passed on a surmise. Member Special Tribunal has interpreted
"the plan as expressed earlier in such a way which has suited respondent No. 2 and forgotten the nature of the issue on which the parties were at variance, i.e."to which side was the shopping complex to be opened?”
(II) That the interpretation that the shopping complex was meant to be opened towards the road also has been based upon a conjecture and a surmise. I am at a loss to understand as to why did the assertion, that the shopping complex was required to be opened towards the Cinema complex, not appeal to the common sense of the member Tribunal. It could have been taken to be 'constructed for the visitors of the Cinema and thus if the mind of the learned Tribunal would have been open to objectivity, there was nothing to prevent this view from appealing to common sense. However, let me hasten to observe that this observation should not be taken to be like one made by the member Special Tribunal and should not prejudice the competent authority to find an answer to the required question. However, let me also make it clear that the interpretation placed upon the site plan by the Tribunal is based upon no proof.
(III The order impugned is a contradiction in terms. If the buikding had been raised in accordance with the sanction plan as is claimed by respondent No. 2, then it would be an authorised construction and the question of compounding the case would not arise. In case the sanction plan has been violated, then alone the order of compounding the offence could have been passed. Blowing hot and cool in the same breath exposes lack of application of mind on the part of the author of the impugned order.
(IV) The finding that the Municipality would be satisfied by imposing a compounding fee of Rs. 4500/- also is not borne out by any proof and seems to have been passed on the impsodixi of the learned member Tribunal
(V) While exercising power in terms of rule 3 of the Rules a finding with respect to the offence being that of a minor nature should have been returned by the Tribunal Let me observe here that a minor offence has nowhere been defined. It was incumbent upon the Tribunal to return a finding indicating the grounds on which such finding was based.
9. Besides aforementioned observations, there is yet another aspect of the case. Municipal Act provides a full fledged machinery for dealing with a situation like the one giving rise to this case.
The Tribunal, as Appellate authority is the last ladder in the hierarchy. Power of the Tribunal to compound offences cannot be denied. But frequent and indiscriminate exercise of this power can result in refusing to make use of the aforementioned machinery. The Executive Officer of the Municipality knows what was the sanctioned plan. He knows what sort of violation was being made. He also is presumed to have the knowledge as to whether the construction causes nuisance and obstruction. He is supposed to act as a representative of the community interest and also has the benefit of knowing the spot position. This is how perhaps the Municipal Act invests vast powers in him.
10. Compounding of offences by Appellate Forum in a routine manner, without assigning any reasons has the effect of negativing the exercise of powers by the Municipality, use of original powers by an appellate Forum is fraught with the vice of visiting the parties with loss of a forum, Basing my observations upon the aforementioned reasoning. It will be proper for every appellate Forum to be loath in compounding the offenses of this nature in a perfunctory manner.
11. Keeping in view the above observations, I find this to be a fit case where the Order pf the Member Special Tribunal passed on 6-6-1989 needs to be quashed. I accordingly while allowing this petition quashes the order impugned.
However, in the circumstances of this case, I modify the order passed by the respondent No. 4 (Executive Officer) on 22-6-1988 to the extent that the said respondent shall after hearing the parties with respect to their interpretation of the site plan pass fresh and reasoned appropriate orders within one month from today. Till then only status-quo be maintained.
No order as to costs.
Alert