- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Radhey Shyam v. Bhanwar Lal (Deceased) & Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ashok Parihar, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges the judgment and decree dated 18.8.1990 of the trial court which dismissed a suit for partition and eviction filed by the plaintiff-appellant (referred to below as the plaintiff). The opinion is authored by Ashok Parihar, J.
Material factual allegations made by the plaintiff: the plaintiff's grandfather, Ganga Ram, died in 1952 leaving substantial movable and immovable properties that came into the possession of the plaintiff's father, Laxmi Narayan, in the capacity of Karta and manager of the family. Among the immovable properties was House No. 1567 at Chokri Modikhana, Rasta Sanghiji, Jaipur. Laxmi Narayan had five sons and two daughters. The plaintiff alleged that Laxmi Narayan purchased other properties in 1956, 1958 and 1959 in the names of the elder son Bhanwar Lal (and Bhanwar Lal's wife and minor son) from ancestral funds and that the plaintiff was entitled to a share by partition. Claims were also made in respect of gold and silver ornaments and a money-decree said to have been left by Ganga Ram.
Defendants' response: the defendants denied the plaintiff's allegations, asserting that a partition had already taken place in October 1963 during Laxmi Narayan's lifetime and that each brother was in possession of his portion. They contended that the properties alleged to have been purchased in the names of Bhanwar Lal (and his family) were acquired out of Bhanwar Lal’s own income and resources. The defendants also relied on a will executed by Laxmi Narayan in favour of defendant Roop Narayan (referred to in the record) which, the defendants said, supported that the properties were not part of the joint family nucleus.
Procedural history and trial outcome: the trial court framed twelve issues (recorded in the opinion). The plaintiff led ten witnesses; the defendants led thirteen witnesses and documentary evidence. The trial court concluded that House No. 1567 belonged to Ganga Ram but found the plaintiff had not proved other properties or claims; it held a partition of Haveli No. 1567 took place in October 1963, and found for the defendants on the remaining disputed issues. Consequently, the trial court dismissed the plaintiff's suit by its judgment dated 18.8.1990. This appeal followed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Ganga Ram at the time of his demise left huge movable and immovable properties which came to Laxmi Narayan as Karta of the family?
- Whether Haveli No. 1567 (Chowkri Modikhana, Rasta Sanghiji) was partitioned by Laxmi Narayan in October 1963 between the plaintiff and defendants No. 1 to 4?
- Whether Laxmi Narayan purchased a house from Ram Chandra dated 7.11.1959 from ancestral movable and immovable property and had the sale deed executed in the names of defendant No. 1, defendant No. 8 and defendant No. 9?
- Whether Laxmi Narayan purchased property on 11.5.1958 for Rs. 6,699/- in the name of defendant No. 8 from ancestral movable and immovable property?
- Whether Laxmi Narayan purchased property on 13.7.1956 in execution of a decree (Johri Lal v. Gulab Chand) at auction in the name of defendant No. 1 from ancestral property?
- Whether defendant No. 1 to 5 recovered a sum of Rs. 1,800/- in a decree against Bhagwan Das Thathera?
- Whether golden ornaments (328 tolas as per list) left by Ganga Ram at his death are in the possession of defendant No. 1 to 5?
- Whether the property mentioned in para 5 of the plaint was purchased by defendant No. 1 by selling a chain of Moti Manak received from his earlier wife's parents and taking money on loan?
- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get 4/21 share from the total movable and immovable joint property valued at Rs. 2,04,450.00?
- Whether the second floor of House No. 1567 is in the possession of the plaintiff and the plaintiff should be allotted that portion in partition because of constructions and payments made by him?
- Whether defendant No. 1 started to earn and live separately since 1950?
- Whether the plaintiff should have paid ad velorem court fee?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The alleged partition of 1963 was not proved: there was no written or registered partition deed; only a blue print map was produced which the plaintiff contended was inadmissible.
- The will attributed to Laxmi Narayan was denied by the plaintiff.
- Evidence showed the father and all sons lived together with joint income; thus properties purchased in the names of Bhanwar Lal (and relatives) were said to be from joint-family funds and the burden lay on Bhanwar Lal to prove purchases were from his independent income; no accounts of separate income were produced by Bhanwar Lal.
- Claims regarding ornaments and the money decree were not pressed by the plaintiff's counsel at the hearing.
Respondents' (Defendants') Arguments
- All family members (except the plaintiff) admitted that a partition took place in 1963 and possession of respective portions had been admitted by the plaintiff as well.
- The will executed by Laxmi Narayan in 1971 (Ex. A.7) was proved by defendant witnesses and supports that partition had occurred and possession was with respective sons.
- Partition can be oral or by family arrangement; the overall circumstances permitted a valid inference of partition even if there was no formal deed.
- No objection to possessions was raised by the plaintiff during Laxmi Narayan's lifetime (Laxmi Narayan died in 1972), indicating acquiescence.
- Defendant Bhanwar Lal proved (by oral and documentary evidence) that the disputed properties were purchased from his own funds and resources: he had started separate business in 1950; he purchased a property in auction in 1956 and later mortgaged or exchanged or used his savings and sale of his wife's ornaments to make subsequent purchases; relevant deeds (mortgage, exchange/transfer and sale deeds) were proved.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Appasaheb Peerappa Chandgade v. Devendra Peerappa Chandgade, (2007) 1 SCC 521 : AIR 2007 SC 218 | The initial burden in a suit for partition and determination of share lies on the plaintiff to show the property was joint Hindu family property; after that initial burden is discharged, it shifts to the defendant alleging self-acquisition to affirmatively prove acquisition without the aid of joint family funds. There is no presumption of a joint Hindu family; cogent evidence is required to establish self-acquisition. | The court applied the burden-shifting principle: it required the plaintiff to prove the properties were acquired out of the joint family nucleus and found the plaintiff failed to do so; the defendants, by cogent oral and documentary evidence, established self-acquisition of the disputed properties. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, closely following the evidence as recorded and the legal principle cited from the Supreme Court:
- Identification of the relevant legal rule: the court relied on the principle stated in Appasaheb Peerappa Chandgade that the plaintiff bears the initial burden to show the property is joint-family property and, if discharged, the burden shifts to defendants to prove self-acquisition by cogent evidence.
- Assessment of plaintiff's evidence on acquisition from joint funds: the court observed that the plaintiff called ten witnesses whose statements were described as vague on the crucial point that disputed properties were purchased from joint-family income. The plaintiff produced no accounts showing pooling of joint family income, nor any evidence of the father's income streams. The court noted the plaintiff himself admitted he had separate business activity from 1953 and had purchased property in his own name in 1963-64.
- Assessment of defendants' evidence on self-acquisition: the court found defendant Bhanwar Lal testified that he started separate business in 1950 and purchased the first property in 1956 at auction, later exchanging it and acquiring other properties in 1958 and 1959 from mortgage, savings and sale of his wife's ornaments. Documentary evidence (mortgage deed, exchange/transfer deed and sale deeds) was proved by defendants, supporting self-acquisition.
- Application of burden-shifting principle: because the plaintiff failed to discharge the initial burden of proving acquisition from the joint family nucleus, the court concluded the burden requirement had not been met and the defendants’ evidence of self-acquisition stood unrefuted on that point.
- Assessment of alleged partition of 1963: the defendants produced Ex. A.1 (a blue print of a map) showing partition with signatures purportedly including the plaintiff’s; Ex. A.7 (a will executed by Laxmi Narayan in 1971) recorded that a partition of House No. 1567 occurred in 1963 and that each son had possession of respective portions. The plaintiff did not file a rejoinder denying the 1963 partition allegation, did not disprove his signatures on the map, and did not dispute possession as indicated in Ex. A.1. The court accepted evidence that the blue print is a mechanical print of an original trace and that signatures would appear on the blue print if present on the original; so the signatures on Ex. A.1 were treated as probative.
- Legal view on family arrangements: the court cited the established approach that partitions or family arrangements can be effected by various modes (family settlement, registered instrument, oral agreement or decree) and that courts prefer to uphold bona fide family arrangements rather than disturb them on mere technicalities. It also noted the doctrine of estoppel where a party who participated in, and benefited from, a family arrangement cannot later unsettle it without justification.
- Conclusion from evidence and law: combining the failure of the plaintiff to produce cogent proof of joint-family funding, the defendants' documentary proof of self-acquisition, the proved blueprint and will indicating partition and possession, and the plaintiff's failure to rebut these materials, the court concluded that the trial court's factual findings and exercise of discretion were proper and free from error.
Holding and Implications
Final Disposition: The appeal is dismissed for want of merits, thereby affirming the trial court's judgment and decree dated 18.8.1990 that dismissed the plaintiff's suit.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The trial court's findings — that the plaintiff failed to prove that the disputed properties (other than House No. 1567) were acquired out of joint-family funds, that a partition of House No. 1567 occurred in October 1963, and that the defendants established self-acquisition of the challenged properties — stand affirmed.
- No orders as to costs were made by the appellate court.
- The appellate court directed that the record be sent back to the trial court.
Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles on burden of proof in partition suits and upholds the validity of family arrangements supported by evidence (including non-registered instruments and proven conduct). The opinion does not purport to establish any new legal precedent beyond applying the cited Supreme Court authority and established principles; it affirms the trial court's factual conclusions on the record before it.
Ashok Parihar, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 18.8.1990, passed by the trial court, by which, a suit for eviction through partition, filed by the plaintiff-appellant (hereinafter to be referred to as the ‘plaintiff’) has been dismissed. It has been alleged that grand father of plaintiff Shri Ganga Ram had left lot of movable and immovable properties at the time of his death in the year 1952. All the properties came in possession of the plaintiff's father Laxmi Narayan in the capacity of Karta and Manager. The immovable properties left by Ganga Ram included a house bearing No. 1567, situated at Chokri Modi Khana, Rasta Sanghiji, Jaipur City. It has further been alleged that father of plaintiff Laxmi Narayan had five sons and two daughters. The plaintiff claimed that plaintiff's father Laxmi Narayan purchased one house at Chaura Rasta vide sale deed dated 7.11.1959 in the name of Smt Nathi, wife of elder son Bhanwar Lal and Devraj, minor son of Bhanwar Lal. One more shop in Gopal Ji Ka Rasta was also purchased by father of the plaintiff Laxmi Narayan in the name of Smt Nathi wife of Bhanwar Lal. Another shop situated at Chaura Rasta had been purchased by father of the plaintiff in auction in the name of Bhanwar Lal, however, the same shop was subsequently exchanged with a shop belonging to one Radheyshyam Paanwala through registered exchange/transfer deed. Since all the properties, referred to above, belonged to Laxmi Narayan as Karta and Manager of the family, the plaintiff was entitled for share in the same by way of partition. The claim in regard to gold and silver ornaments as also money decree left by grand father Ganga Ram has also been raised.
2. In reply, the allegations made by the plaintiff have been denied by the defendants-respondents (hereinafter to be referred to as the ‘defendants’). It has been submitted that so far as immovable properties left by grand father Ganga Ram is concerned, a partition had already taken place in the year 1963 during the life time of father Laxmi Narayan, who died in the year 1972 and all brothers are in possession of the respective portions as per the partition and family arrangement. It has also been submitted that other immovable properties have been purchased by the elder brother Bhanwar Lal (since deceased) from his own income and resources. The claim on decree and ornaments left by grand father Ganga Ram have been denied. It has further been submitted on behalf of the defendants that even Laxmi Narayan had made a will of his immovable property in favour of one of his sons defendant-Roop Narayan on 31.11.1971, which clearly indicates that apart from partition already taken place the properties alleged to be purchased in the name of defendant Bhanwar Lal, his wife and minor son does not belong to the joint family nucleus.
3. As per pleadings of the parties, following issues have been framed by the trial court:—
1. Whether Granga Ram at the time of his demise, left huge movable and immovable properties, which came to the father of plaintiff-Laxmi Narayanji in the capacity of Karta of the family?
2. Whether Haveli No. 1567 facing south at City Jaipur, Chowkri Modikhana Rasta Sanghiji was partitioned by Laxmi Narain in October, 1963 in between plaintiff and defendants No. 1 to 4?
3. Whether father of the plaintiff had purchased a House from Ram Chandra and other against a sum of Rs. 749/- on dated 7.11.1959 from the ancestral movable and immovable property and sale deed was got done in the name of defendant No. 1, defendant No. 8 and defendant No. 9?
4. Whether father of the plaintiff purchased property as mentioned in para No. 5 of the plaint on dated 11.5.1958 for a sum of Rs. 6699/- in the name of defendant No. 8, from ancestral movable and immovable property?
5. Whether the father of the plaintiff had purchased the property mentioned in para No. 6 of the plaint on dated 13.7.56 in the execution of the decree titled as Johri Lal v. Gulab Chand in auction in the name of the defendant No. 1 from the ancestral movable and immovable property?
6. Whether the defendant No. 1 to 5 recovered a sum of Rs. 1800/- in a decree against Bhagwan Das Thathera?
7. Whether the golden ornaments weighing 328 tolas as per enclosed list along with plaint left by Ganga Ramji at the time of his death is in possession and power of defendant No. 1 to 5?
8. Whether the property as mentioned in para no. 5 of the plaint, was purchased by defendant No. 1 by selling a Chain of Moti Manak received from the parents of his earlier wife and taking money on loan?
9. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get 4/21 share from the total movable and immovable joint property of Rs. 2,04,450.00?
10. Whether the IInd Floor of House No. 1567 is in possession of the plaintiff. As mentioned in para No. 10 of the plaint the plaintiff had constructed and made alternation in the houses of this floor at the cost of plaintiff himself and got fixed 16 pairs of doors and get connection of water and electricity which may be allotted to the plaintiff in partition?
11. Whether the defendant No. 1 started to earn and live separately since 1950?
12. Whether the plaintiff should have paid ad velorem Court Fee?
4. Ten witnesses have been examined on behalf of the plaintiff, whereas, thirteen witnesses have been examined on behalf of the defendants. Documentary evidence has also been submitted on behalf of the both the sides. While deciding issue No. 1, 6 and 7 the trial court held that the property situated at house No. 1567, Chokri Modikhana, Sanghiji Ka Rasta, Jaipur belonged to grand father Ganga Ram, however, since it has not been proved that any other property was left by Ganga Ram, the issue No. 6 and 7 were decided against the plaintiff. So far as issue No. 2 is concerned, it has been held that the partition of Haveli No. 1567, situated at Chokri Modikhana, Sanghiji Ka Rasta, Jaipur was done by Laxmi Narayan among his five sons in October, 1963. Thus, the above issue was also decided against the plaintiff. Issues No. 3, 4, 5 and 8 were decided jointly. It has been held that since the defendant Bhanwar Lal has been able to prove the other properties in question been purchased by him from his own income and resources, all the issues were decided against the plaintiff. The issue in regard to Haveli No. 1567 already having been decided against the plaintiff, issue No. 9 and 10 were also decided against him. As per evidence, issue No. 11 was also decided in favour of the defendant Bhanwar Lal. Issue No. 12 was not pressed. In view of conclusions and decision given on the respective issues, the suit of the plaintiff was dismissed by the trial court vide the impugned judgment.
5. Mr. R.P Singh, learned counsel for the plaintiff, submitted that partition alleged to have taken place in the year 1963 has not been proved at all. There was no written agreement, what to say of registered deed. Only a blue print of a map has been submitted which is alleged to be part of partition agreement is not admissible under the law. The execution of the will by father Laxmi Narayan has also been denied. It has been submitted that as per evidence led on behalf of the plaintiff, father and all the sons were living together and had joint income. In case the defendant Bhanwar Lal was claiming purchase of separate properties from his own income and resources, the burden was on him to prove the same, whereas, no accounts of separate income had been produced by the defendant Bhanwar Lal. The issues in regard to ornaments and money decree were not pressed by learned counsel.
6. Mr. R.K Agrawal, learned counsel for the defendants, on the other hand, submitted that all the family members, except the plaintiff, have admitted the partition already taken place in the year 1963 itself and possession of respective portions, in a way, have also been admitted by the plaintiff himself. The will executed by father Laxmi Narayan in the year 1972 in favour of one of his sons not only give the entire history and facts but also have duly been proved by the witnesses produced on behalf of the defendants. It has further been submitted by Mr. Agrawal that partition can even be oral and a valid inference can be drawn from the entire circumstances. It has also been submitted that till death of father Laxmi Narayan in the year 1972 no objection was ever raised by the plaintiff in regard to respective possessions on the properties in dispute. It has been submitted that the defendant Bhanwar Lal has been able to prove, by way of oral as also documentary evidence, that three properties in dispute were purchased by him in his name and in the name of his wife and minor son from his own income and resources and there was no contribution of the father and family in the same. The plaintiff has miserably failed to prove the joint family nucleus in the present matter.
7. After having considered submissions of learned counsel for the parties, I have carefully gone through the material on record as also the judgments cited at the Bar.
8. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in case of ‘Appasaheb Peerappa Chandgade v. Devendra Peerappa Chandgade’ ((2007) 1 SCC 521 : AIR 2007 SC 218) : 2007 (1) RLW 621 (SC), while referring to earlier judgments, has observed that whenever a suit for partition and determination of share and possession thereof is filed, then the initial burden is on the plaintiff to show that the entire property was a joint Hindu family property and after initial discharge of burden it shifts on the defendant to show that the property claimed by them was not purchased out of the joint family nucleus and it was purchased independent of them. The Court further observed that there is no presumption of a joint Hindu family but on the evidence if it is established that the property was joint Hindu family property and the other properties were acquired out of that nucleus, if the initial burden is discharged by the person who claims joint Hindu family, then the burden shifts to the party alleging self-acquisition to establish affirmatively that the property was acquired without the aid of the joint family property by cogent and necessary evidence.
9. In the present case, Haveli No. 1567, Chokri Modikhana, Rasta Sanghiji, Jaipur has been treated as ancestral property belonging to grand father Ganga Ram, however, it was for the plaintiff to prove that other properties were purchased by Laxmi Narayan in the years 1956, 1958 and 1959 in the name of his elder son Bhanwar Lal, his wife and minor son from the income of joint family nucleus. The plaintiff had examined ten witnesses including his neighbours, a journalist friend, brother-in-law and clerk of an Advocate, however, all the statements are vague in this respect. Neither any accounts of joint family income had been produced nor any other proof has been submitted to show that the property as alleged was purchased by father Laxmi Narayan from the joint Hindu family income. On the other hand, defendant Bhanwar Lal has clearly stated that all the properties, as alleged, have been purchased by him from his own income and resources. It has been submitted that he had started his own separate business in the year 1950 itself. The first property was purchased in auction by him in the year 1956, which was subsequently exchanged with another shop after execution of registered deed in his name. Subsequent purchases of property in the years 1958 and 1959 were made either by mortgaging the shop purchased in the year 1956 or his own savings and sale of ornaments of his wife. The mortgage deed as also the exchange/transfer deed and the sale deeds have duly been proved by the defendant Bhanwar Lal. The plaintiff has also admitted that he was having his own separate business since 1953 and also purchased some properties in his own name in the year 1963-1964. There is no evidence at all in regard to pooling of joint family income. Even the income of father of Laxmi Narayan has not been proved. Thus the plaintiff having failed to even discharge his initial burden, the defendants, have by way of cogent and necessary evidence, been able to prove that other properties in dispute were acquired without aid of the joint family income. Even if all the family members are living in the same premises, there cannot be any presumption or inference in regard to joint family nucleus so far as income is concerned until and unless proved by cogent legal evidence.
10. So far as partition alleged to have taken place in the year 1963 is concerned, Ex. A.1 has been produced on behalf of the defendants. It is a blue print of a map indicating signatures of plaintiff as also two brothers; defendant Bhanwar Lal and Roop Narayan. In the will executed by the father Laxmi Narayan in the year 1971 (Ex. A.7) it has been clearly stated that partition of House No. 1567, Chokri Modikhana, Rasta Sanghiji, Jaipur took place in the year 1963 and all the sons are having possession of their respective portions. The will was executed by the father Laxmi Narayan in favour of one of his sons Roop Narayan, who was handicapped and there may not be any dispute in respect of his portion of the house. The will has duly been proved by the attesting witnesses as also the Notary Public. The partition in the year 1963 has been mentioned by defendants in their reply, however, there is neither any rejoinder by the plaintiff nor a single word denying such partition in the statement of the plaintiff also. Defendant Bhanwar Lal as also defendant Roop Narayan have proved signatures of the plaintiff on original map, impression of which are on the blue print of the map Ex. A.1 Though, the plaintiff examined PW-10 in rebuttal as a document expert, who has also clearly stated that blue print is taken by way of a mechanical process and exact print of the original trace of the map and impressions of signatures, if any, on the original trace will come as such on the blue print also. Though, the signatures of the plaintiff have been proved on the map (Ex. A.1) by the witnesses of the defendants, however, the plaintiff did not bother to come in the witness box even in rebuttal to deny his signatures on any such map. The plaintiff has also not disputed the possession on the respective portions as indicated in Ex. A.1
11. The Apex Court, time and again, has held that a partition of a joint Hindu family can be effected by various modes, viz., by a family settlement, by a registered instrument of partition, by oral arrangement by the parties or by a decree of the court. Considering the nature of society and the family bonds the courts have always leaned in favour of upholding a family arrangement instead of disturbing the same on technical or trivial grounds. Where the courts find that the family arrangement suffers from a legal lacuna or a formal defect the rule of estoppal is pressed into service and is applied to shut out plea of the person who being a party to family arrangement seeks to unsettle a settled dispute and claims to revoke the family arrangement under which he has himself enjoyed some material benefits. Thus, the courts have taken a very wider and broad view of the validity of the family settlement and have always tried to uphold it and maintain it.
12. As has come on record, the plaintiff was having his own separate business since 1953-1954 and also purchased some property in his own name in the year 1963-1964. The defendant Bhanwar Lal also started his independent business in the year 1950. The accounts maintained by father Laxmi Narayan has not been proved so far. The possession of the parties having their respective portions during life time of father Laxmi Narayan has also not been disputed. It was only after death of father Laxmi Narayan that suit for partition has been filed by the plaintiff in November, 1973. The signatures on the map Ex. A.1 as per partition alleged to have taken place in the year 1963 have been proved on behalf of the defendants. The mechanism of preparing blue print from the original trace has also been proved by the witnesses of the plaintiff himself and the plaintiff having failed to deny his signatures alleged to have been made on the map Ex. A.1, there cannot be any other inference but the admission of the plaintiff that the partition, in fact, had taken place in the year 1963, more so, when execution of the will by father Laxmi Narayan in the year 1971 and duly proved by the defendants speaks for itself. Though, there may not be a formal deed of family arrangement/settlement or partition but there is enough evidence to infer the same by way of mutual consent of all the parties concerned.
13. Having considered entire facts and circumstances, since on the findings of fact, proper discretion has already been used by the trial court in deciding all the issues, I find no error or illegality in the same so as to take any contrary view. The appeal is dismissed accordingly as having no merits. There will be no orders as to costs. The record be sent back.
Alert