- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M.K.N.N Kannappa Chettiar v. S.P.P Srinivasan Chettiar And Another.
Factual and Procedural Background
A decree was obtained by Panchaksharam Chettiar on 25th September 1942 against the appellant's father in O.S. No. 4 of 1942 (Subordinate Judge, Sivaganga) for recovery of approximately Rs. 3,300. The appellant's brother filed I.A. No. 18 of 1950 (14th September 1949) under S. 19 of Madras Act IV of 1938 to have the debt scaled down; the Subordinate Judge passed an order on 28/29th August 1950 scaling down the debt to approximately Rs. 2,100.
The appellant's brother appealed to the District Judge (A.S. No. 3 of 1951). On 20th August 1951 the District Judge disallowed the claim to further scaling down and declared the amount payable to be the original amount due under the 25th September 1942 decree. That order was impugned before this Court in C.M.S.A. No. 29 of 1952.
Meanwhile, on 26th October 1951 the decree-holders initiated execution proceedings (E.P. No. 116 of 1951) to sell the appellant's and his brother's residential house to recover about Rs. 5,200 then claimed due. Because there was no stay and the amount claimed exceeded the statutory threshold at the time of sale (20th October 1953), the sale was held and the 2nd respondent, who had been permitted to bid, purchased the property at the Court sale for Rs. 4,500. The executing Court recorded part satisfaction and later confirmed the sale on 24th August 1955.
However, this Court (on 17th January 1955) had in C.M.S.A. No. 29 of 1952 restored the Subordinate Judge's order of 28th August 1950, thereby scaling the debt down to about Rs. 2,100 — a fact which the decree-holders did not inform the executing Court of. Acting in ignorance of the scaling-down order, the executing Court confirmed the sale and recorded part satisfaction for Rs. 4,500.
The appellant filed an application on 26th January 1956 under Ss. 47, 144 and 151 CPC praying that the sale in E.P. No. 116 of 1951 be set aside, the property redelivered, and that he be permitted to pay the decree amount in instalments under Act I of 1955. The lower Court dismissed that application, and the appellant appealed to the present Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the order of confirmation of the Court sale dated 24th August 1955 — which recorded part satisfaction of the decree to the extent of Rs. 4,500 — was legally valid where the decree had been scaled down to about Rs. 2,100 by this Court on 17th January 1955 (prior to confirmation) but the executing Court was not informed.
- Whether the principles of Order 21, Rule 72 (and related rules such as Rr. 82, 90, 91 and 92) permit confirmation of a sale where the decree-holder purchaser has set off purchase money exceeding the amount then actually due under an amended decree without depositing the difference in Court.
- What remedial steps should follow if the confirmation is held illegal — i.e., whether the sale should be set aside, the execution petition restored to the file, and what procedure should be followed regarding deposit of any difference and redelivery of the property.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant sought the setting aside of the sale confirmed in E.P. No. 116 of 1951 on the ground that the decree had been scaled down to approximately Rs. 2,100 before confirmation, and thus the purchase money (Rs. 4,500) exceeded the amount actually recoverable under the amended decree.
- The appellant sought redelivery of the property and permission to pay the decree in instalments as provided by Act I of 1955.
- Implicit in the application was that the decree-holders' failure to inform the executing Court of the scaling-down order and their failure to deposit the difference rendered the confirmation of sale improper.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents (through their counsel) contended that the sale was bound to be confirmed under Order 21, Rule 82 in the absence of any application under Order 21, Rules 83, 90 or 91.
- They relied on the principle that where the purchase money is duly set off and is equal to or less than the decree amount, it is to be deemed deposited in Court, and the relevant rules (Rr. 82, 90, 91, 92) operate on that basis.
- They did not bring to the executing Court's attention the fact that this Court had scaled down the decree prior to confirmation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kuppu Sankara Sastri v. Kakimanu Varaprasad (1947) 1 M.L.J. 369 = 6 L.W. 307 (also cited later in the text as 60 L.W. 307) | Authority for the proposition that a Court sale was legal where, on the date of sale and at the time proceedings were taken, the amount recoverable on the decree exceeded the relevant statutory threshold and the sale had to be held. | The Court held that the precedent did not cover the present point because in that case the order scaling down the decree debt was passed after confirmation of the sale. In the present case the scaling down occurred prior to confirmation, so the precedent was not controlling on the legality of confirmation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in these steps:
- The Court accepted that on the date of the actual sale (20th October 1953) the amount recoverable on the decree exceeded the statutory threshold (over Rs. 5,000) and that, because there was no stay and the amounts unpaid, a sale at that stage was proper. The Court referenced the cited precedent to support the proposition that a sale may be legal where, at the time of sale, the debt exceeded the threshold.
- The critical legal question, however, was the legality of the subsequent confirmation of the sale on 24th August 1955 where, before confirmation (on 17th January 1955), this Court had reduced the decree to about Rs. 2,100 and that fact had not been reported to the executing Court.
- The Court examined Order 21, Rule 72(1)–(2). It noted that sub-rule (2) imposes an obligation on the executing court to enter up satisfaction of the decree to the extent of the purchase money set off by a decree-holder purchaser. But such an entry can be made only on the date of confirmation because title vests in the purchaser only upon confirmation (subject to relation-back principles).
- The Court reasoned that, if on the date of confirmation the amount set off by the decree-holder purchaser exceeds the amount actually due under the decree (as amended), satisfaction of the decree up to the amount set off cannot be recorded unless the difference between purchase money and the actual amount due is deposited in Court. The rationale is that no purchaser at a Court sale is entitled to have his sale confirmed until the judgment debtor is paid the price in full; there can be no "purchase on credit" in a Court sale. The executing Court must ensure that the judgment debtor receives the correct amount due under the decree as amended.
- The Court observed that Rules 82, 90, 91 and 92 presuppose that purchase money has been deposited or is deemed deposited (when set off and not exceeding the decree amount). If purchase money has not been deposited and the set off exceeds the amount actually due, the basis for confirmation under those rules disappears.
- Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the executing Court's confirmation on 24th August 1955 — recording part satisfaction for Rs. 4,500 when, by virtue of this Court's earlier (17th January 1955) order, the decree was for a much smaller sum — was erroneous and illegal because the decree-holders had not drawn the executing Court's attention to the scaled-down decree nor deposited the difference between the purchase money and the reduced decree amount.
- Consequently, the Court set aside the confirmation order and prescribed remedial steps: restore the execution petition to the stage before confirmation; direct parties to file statements as to amounts recoverable under the amended decree; call upon the decree-holders to deposit the difference between purchase money and the amount recoverable under the amended decree within a specified time; confirm the sale if the deposit is made, or else set aside the sale and order a fresh sale. Pending further proceedings, redelivery to the judgment debtor was directed upon payment of requisite fees.
Holding and Implications
The Court held that the order of confirmation of the sale dated 24th August 1955 — and the recording of part satisfaction to the extent of Rs. 4,500 — was illegal and set that order aside; the appeal was allowed to that extent.
Consequences and remedies ordered by the Court (direct effects on the parties):
- The Subordinate Judge is directed to restore E.P. No. 116 of 1951 to his file and to proceed from the stage reached immediately before the confirmation and part-satisfaction order was made.
- The Subordinate Judge will invite decreeholders and judgment debtors to file statements of the amount recoverable under the decree as amended and will ascertain the correct amount recoverable on the date of sale.
- The decreeholders who purchased at the sale must deposit in Court, within a specified time, the difference between the purchase money and the amount recoverable on the basis of the amended decree as on the date of sale. If the deposit is made, the sale will be confirmed; if not, the sale will be set aside and a fresh sale ordered.
- Because the confirmation is set aside, the judgment debtor is entitled to redelivery of the property pending fresh confirmation; such redelivery is subject to payment of requisite fees.
- The appellant is awarded costs in all the proceedings specified (E.A. No. 50 of 1956, A.S. No. 57 of 1957 and the present appeal). The respondents are entitled to recover in the execution petition the full costs of the execution inclusive of the costs of sale and poundage.
- No leave was granted (the order concludes with "No leave").
Broader implication: The opinion applies established procedural rules (Order 21 and its sub-rules) to protect judgment debtors from being disadvantaged where a decree is reduced prior to confirmation of a sale. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond the application of those rules to the facts; its immediate effect is to set aside the specific confirmation and prescribe the remedial steps stated above.
The defendant judgment debtor in O.S No. 4 of 1942 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Sivaganga, was the appellant in the lower appellate Court and in the appeal in this appeal.
One Panchaksharam Chettiar obtained a decree on 25th September 1942, against the appellant's father for recovery of Rs. 3300 odd in O.S No. 4 of 1942, on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Sivaganga. The appellant's brother filed I.A No. 18 of 1950 on 14th September 1949 under S. 19 of Madras Act IV of 1938 to have the Page: 311debt scaled down. An order was passed in that application on 29th August 1950 scaling down the debt to Rs. 2100 odd. The appellant's brother preferred an appeal A.S No. 3 of 1951 to the District Judge, Ramanathapuram, praying that the debt be scaled down to a lower figure. The District Judge passed an order on 20th August 1951 not refusing merely that further scaling down that was prayed for, but disallowing altogether the appellant's claim to scaling down. He declared that the amount payable by the appellant and his brother under the decree was the amount due on the decree dated 25th September 1942 in accordance with its apparent tenor. That was a wholly wrong order to make because the respondents, the legal representatives of Panchaksharam Chettiar, who had obtained the decree, had themselves not appealed from the order passed by the Subordinate Judge scaling down the debt to Rs. 2100 odd. The District Judge had either to accede to the request of the appellant's brother to have the debt scaled down further or to dismiss the appeal thereby maintaining the debt at the level to which it had been scaled down by the Subordinate Judge in I.A No. 18 of 1950. Against the order of the District Judge, the appellant's brother preferred C.M.S.A No. 29 of 1952 on the file of this Court.
On 26th October 1951, that is about two months after the District Judge's order dated 20th August 1951, in A.S No. 3 of 1951, the respondent filed E.P No. 116 of 1951 for sale of the residential house of the appellant and his brother to recover Rs. 5200 odd due on the decree dated 25th August 1942. In C.M.S.A No. 29 of 1951 the appellant's brother applied for stay of execution, but he was not able to furnish the security required. The execution proceedings in E.P No. 116 of 1951 proceeded to the stage of sale. The 2nd respondent had obtained permission to bid at the sale and set off the amount due on the decree. The 2nd respondent purchased the property at the Court sale held on 20th October 1953 for Rs. 4500. Since the amount recoverable on the decree as it stood on that date was over Rs. 5000 the 2nd respondent set off the purchase money against a part of the decree debt and paid only poundage. Confirmation of the sale was delayed by reason of proceedings which need not be set out here. While the sale was pending confirmation, C.M.S.A No. 29 of 1952, which had been filed by the appellant's brother against the order of the District Judge, Ramanathapuram, in A.S No. 3 of 1951, was allowed by this Court on 17th January 1955 and the debt was scaled down to the level of at which it stood, namely, Rs. 2100 odd, under the order passed by the Subordinate Judge on 28th August 1950 in I.A No. 18 of 1950. The decree-holders did not report to the executing Court that the debt had been so scaled down. In the belief that a sum in excess of Rs. 4500 continued to remain due on the decree, the executing Court passed an order on 24th August 1955 confirming the sale and recording part satisfaction of the decree to the extent of Rs. 4500. In due course, a sale certificate was issued and, in pursuance of the sale certificate, the decreeholder purchasers took delivery of the property on 8th October 1955. On 26th January 1956 the appellant filed the application which has given rise to this appeal under Ss. 47, 144 and 151 C.P.C praying that the sale which had been held in E.P No. 116 of 1951 be set aside, that the property be redelivered to the appellant and that he be permitted to pay the decree amount in instalments, as provided by Act I of 1955. The application was dismissed by the lower Court. The appellant has hence preferred this appeal.
On 20th October, 1953, the date on which the sale was held, the amount recoverable on the decree exceeded Rs. 5000. Even according to the appellant's case, an amount in excess of Rs. 1500 was payable. Since the amount payable was not paid and there was no stay of execution, the sale had necessarily to be held. The decreeholders took the necessary steps for such sale and the sale which was held by the Court was legal [Please see Kuppa Sankdra Sastri v. Kakimanu Varaprasad (1947) 1 M.L.J 369=6 L.W 307]
The 2nd respondent had obtained permission under 21 O.R 72 to bid for and purchase the property and to set Page: 312off the purchase money against the amount due under the decree. The respondents' bid for Rs. 4800 was the highest and the property was sold to the 2nd respondent. Since the amount due under the decree was in excess of Rs. 4500, she set off the purchase money against that part of the decree amount and paid only poundage. But confirmation of the sale was delayed until September 1955. On 17th January, 1955, this Court had passed an order in C.M.A No. 29 of 1952 restoring the order passed by the Subordinate Judge on 28th August, 1950 and scaling down the debt to a sum far below the sum of Rs. 4500 for which the 2nd respondent had purchased the property at the court sale. The decree holders did not bring it to the notice of the Court that the decree debt had been scaled down and that the purchase money exceeded the amount payable on the decree. In ignorance of the fact that the decree debt had been scaled down, the Court passed an order on 24th August 1956 confirming the sale and recording part satisfaction as to Rs. 4500. If the Court had known the facts relating to scaling down of the decree, the Court could not, on that date, have recorded part satisfaction to the extent of Rs. 4500 of the decree on which very much less was due and would not have passed an order confirming the sale, unless the difference between the purchase money and the amount due on the decree had been deposited in Court. The point is whether the order of confirmation is legal.
That point is not covered by Kuppu Sankara Sastri v. Kakimanu Varaprasad (1947) 1 M.L.J 369=60 L.W 307 because, in that case, the order scaling down the decree debt was passed after the confirmation of the sale. In this case, if the decree debt had not been scaled down prior— indeed 8 months prior—to the order of confirmation, the order of confirmation would be legal. Any further relief which the judgment debtor might seek by reason of scaling down subsequent to corfirmation would have to be sought on the basis of a sale which was duly confirmed and under which title had passed to the purchaser. The position is different if the order scaling down the debt to a level below the purchase money is passed before the confirmation of sale. O. 21. R. 72 enacts):—
“(1) No holder of a decree in execution of which property is sold shall, without the express permission of the court, bid for or purchase the property;
(2) Where a decree holder purchases with such permission, the purchase money and the amount due on the decree may, subject to the provisions of S. 73, be set off against one another, and the Court executing the decree shall enter up satisfaction of the decree in whole or in part accordingly.”
Sub-rule (2) of R. 72 lays the obligation on the Court to enter up satisfaction of the decree upto the amount of the purchase money which had been set off. Such an order entering up satisfaction can be passed only on the date on which the sale is confirmed, because until the sale is confirmed, the decree holder does not get title to the property (although when once the rule is confirmed title relates back to date of sale), and, therefore, until the sale is confirmed and he obtains title, his decree cannot be recorded as satisfied to the extent of the amount set off. If, on the date on which the sale has to be confirmed, the amount that has been set off is in excess of the amount due on the decree, satisfaction of the decree upto the amount set off cannot be recorded. It follows that the sale itself cannot be confirmed unless the difference between the amount that has been set off and the amount that is due on the decree is deposited by the decreeholder purchaser into Court. That is because no purchaser at a Court sale is entitled to have his sale confirmed until the judgment debtor is paid the price in full. Payment is usually by appropriation in satisfaction of the debt due to the decreeholder in execution of whose decree the property was sold and of other decreeholders, if any, who have obtained orders of rateable distribution and resolution of the value for payment to the judgment debtor or other persons entitled to receive the money by reason of transfers made by him. In a Court sale, there can be no purchase on credit. In a case where the amount due on a decree is varied to the judgment debtor's advantage after the Court sale in execution of the decree and the amount as thus varied is less than the purchase money in a case in which the decreeholder purchases Page: 313the property at the Court sale and sets off the purchase money against the amount due to him, the sate cannot fee confirmed unless the decreeholder invites the attention of the Court to the alteration made in the decree and deposits the difference between the purchase money and the amount recoverable under the decree as altered. The obligation lies on the Court to ensure that degree of justice to judgment debtors whose properties are sold through Court by reason of their inability to pay their decree debt. That relief, judgment debtors are entitled to under S. 151 C.P.C
The respondents' learned Counsel contends that the sale was bound to be confirmed under O. 21, R. 82, in the absence of any application being made under O. 21, R. 83, R. 90 or 91. But these rules, namely, Rr. 82, 90, 91 and 92, proceed on the basis that the purchase money has been deposited in Court subject to the proviso that where the purchase money is duly set off, being equal to or less than the decree amount, the purchase money would be deemed to be deposited in Court. Where the purchase money is not so deposited, the basis of those rules disappears and there can be no confirmation under O. 21, R. 92.
I hold that the error confirming the sale passed by the Subordinate Judge on 24th August, 1955 and recording part satisfaction as to Rs. 4,500 was illegal. That order is hereby set aside. The appeal is allowed to that extent-The Subordinate Judge will restore the E.P to his file and will proceed to deal with it from the stage reached immediately before the order confirming the sale and recording part satisfaction was made. He will call on the decreeholders and judgment debtors to file statements of the amount recoverable by the decreeholders under the decree as amended and ascertain such amount and will call upon the decree-holders to deposit in Court within a time to be specified the difference between the purchase money and the amount recoverable on the basis of the amended deoree on the date of the sale. If the amount is deposited within the time allowed, the sale will be confirmed. If the amount is not so deputed, the sale will be set aside and a fresh sale will be ordered. Since the order confirming the sale is set aside, the judgment debtor becomes entitled to redelivery of the property, pending fresh order of confirmation. Such redelivery will be effected in his paying the requisite fees. The appellant will have his costs in all these proceedings, viz., in E.A No. 50 of 1956, A.S No. 57 of 1957 and in this appeal. The respondents will be entitled to recover in the execution petition full costs of the execution inclusive of the costs of sale and poundage. No leave.
V.C.S
Alert