Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mission Ranjan Das v. Hafiz Rashid Ahmed Choudhury

Gauhati High Court
Jan 12, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ranjan Gogoi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

An objection to the maintainability of an election petition was raised by the applicant (the returned candidate). By an order dated 19.10.2001 the Court framed two preliminary issues to decide maintainability: (1) whether the petition was presented by the petitioner in person in compliance with Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 read with Rule 1 of Chapter VIIIA of the Gauhati High Court Rules and, if not, whether it must be dismissed under Section 86; and (2) whether a copy of the election petition was served on the returned candidate in compliance with Section 81(3) of the Act and, if not, whether the petition should be dismissed.

Because the issues involved mixed questions of fact and law, parties were permitted to adduce evidence. The election petitioner (opposite party) examined three witnesses (PW-1 the petitioner, PW-2 a junior counsel, and PW-3 the Stamp Reporter). No witnesses were examined for the applicant/returned candidate.

After examining the evidence and authorities, the Court decided both preliminary issues in favour of the election petitioner, held the election petition to be maintainable and ordered that it proceed to trial. A miscellaneous case was rejected.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election petition was presented by the election petitioner in accordance with Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 read with Rule 1 of Chapter VIIIA of the Gauhati High Court Rules; and if not, whether the election petition is liable to be dismissed under Section 86 of the Act of 1951.
  2. Whether the copy of the election petition was served on the returned candidate in compliance with the provisions of Section 81(3) of the Act of 1951; and if not, whether the election petition is liable to be dismissed.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant / Returned Candidate (as represented by Mr. G.P. Bhowmick)

  • Contended that pages 1 to 40 of the election petition were not certified to be true copies by the election petitioner.
  • Relied on decisions of the Apex Court (Jyoti Basu & others v. Debi Ghosal, 1982(1) SCC 691, and D.R. Shipra v. Shanti Lal Khoiwal, AIR 1996 SC 1691) to argue that, because of the lack of certification required by Section 81(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the election petition did not conform to statutory requirements and therefore should be dismissed under Section 86 as not maintainable.

Opposite Party / Election Petitioner (as represented by Mr. A.M. Mazumdar)

  • Contended that the law on compliance with Section 81(3) had been settled by the Apex Court in T. Phunzathang v. Hangkhanlian and others (2001 AIR SCW 3892; 2001(3) GLT (SC) 20), and that preliminary Issue No. 2 should be decided in favour of the election petitioner in light of that authority.
  • Adduced primary evidence through three witnesses (the petitioner himself, a junior advocate, and the Stamp Reporter) to show that (a) the election petition was presented in person on 27.6.2001; (b) procedural acts (execution of affidavit, presentation to the Stamp Reporter, handing over to Filing Assistant, entry in filing register, check slip markings and seals) were performed; and (c) a copy (Ext. R-1) was served on the returned candidate that contained identifying endorsements and verifications.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jyoti Basu and others v. Debi Ghosal, 1982(1) SCC 691 Relied on by the returned candidate to support the contention that non-certification of pages meant non-compliance with Section 81(3) and warranted dismissal under Section 86. The Court noted this authority as relied upon by the returned candidate but proceeded to apply the law as summarized by the Apex Court in T. Phunzathang, ultimately finding substantial compliance and holding absence of attestation not fatal.
D.R. Shipra v. Shanti Lal Khoiwal, AIR 1996 SC 1691 Relied on by the returned candidate in support of the argument that the election petition was not in conformity with Section 81(3) due to lack of certification. Recognized as a cited authority by the returned candidate; the Court nevertheless resolved the issue by applying the principles in T. Phunzathang and concluded substantial compliance rendered the petition maintainable.
T. Phunzathang v. Hangkhanlian and others, 2001 AIR SCW 3892; 2001(3) GLT (SC) 20 Summarized and reaffirmed the law on substantial compliance with Section 81(3), stating the object of serving a true copy, the test for whether a copy is true (whether variation would mislead a reasonable person), that "copy" need not be absolutely exact, and that substantial compliance suffices; distinguished Section 81(3) defects from Section 83 defects; allowed flexibility. The Court applied the summarized principles from this decision as authoritative. It used T. Phunzathang to decide that the absence of attestation on the copy served was not a total defect and that there had been substantial compliance with Section 81(3), leading to a finding in favour of the election petitioner on Issue No. 2.
Murarka Radhey Shyam Ram Kumar v. Roop Singh Rathore, (1964) 3 SCR 573; AIR 1964 SC 1545 One of the Constitution Bench authorities cited by T. Phunzathang establishing the doctrine of substantial compliance for Section 81-related requirements. Referred to as a foundational authority (via T. Phunzathang). The Court accepted the doctrine of substantial compliance as applicable to Section 81 and applied it to the facts, finding substantial compliance.
Ch. Subbbarao v. Member, Election Tribunal, Hyderabad, (1964) 6 SCR 213; AIR 1964 SC 1027 Another Constitution Bench authority cited by T. Phunzathang supporting the tests for substantial compliance under Section 81. Used (through T. Phunzathang's restatement) to support the proposition that only violations of Section 81 that cause prejudice or are calculated to mislead can attract dismissal under Section 86; the Court applied this reasoning to hold that no such prejudice was shown.
T.M. Jacob v. C. Poulose, (1999) 4 SCC 274; AIR 1999 SC 1359 Cited (via T. Phunzathang) among authorities confirming the approach that substantial compliance with Section 81(3) is sufficient and that flexibility is required. Referenced through the T. Phunzathang formulation; contributed to the Court's acceptance of substantial compliance as decisive in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a two-part analysis corresponding to the two preliminary issues:

Issue No. 1 — Presentation in Person (Section 81(1) and Rule 1)

  • The statutory requirement is that an election petition must be presented by the election petitioner in person before the Stamp Reporter within 45 days of declaration of result (the Court fixed the declaration date as 28.6.2001).
  • The opposite party/election petitioner led oral and documentary evidence through three witnesses: PW-1 (the petitioner), PW-2 (a junior advocate), and PW-3 (the Stamp Reporter). The petitioner testified to signing pages, executing the affidavit before the Oath Commissioner (who was the Stamp Reporter), endorsing the petition "Filed by Hafiz Rashid Ahmed Choudhury, the petitioner in person - 27.6.2001", handing the petition to the Stamp Reporter who then passed it to the Filing Assistant for entries and seals, and inspecting the check slip and first page bearing a round seal dated 27.6.2001 and an initial dated 28.6.2001.
  • PW-2 corroborated PW-1; PW-3 (the Stamp Reporter) also deposed that the petitioner presented the petition in person on 27.6.2001, that requisite checks were performed, and that the filing register entry (Ext. P-3 and Ext. P-3(1)) records the petition for 27.6.2001. PW-3 explained the delay in submitting the formal report (2.7.2001) as due to heavy work pressure.
  • The Court found the testimony of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 to be consistent, cogent and unrebutted (no meaningful cross-examination by the returned candidate), and accepted their evidence as establishing presentation in person on 27.6.2001.
  • Consequently, the Court held that the presentation requirement of Section 81(1) and Rule 1 was satisfied and decided Issue No. 1 in favour of the election petitioner.

Issue No. 2 — Service of a True Copy (Section 81(3))

  • A copy of the election petition served on the returned candidate was exhibited (Ext. R-1). The returned candidate did not dispute that the signature contained in the served copy was that of the election petitioner. The alleged defect concerned the absence of certain attestation on pages 1 to 40 rather than an allegation that the copy was not a true copy in substance.
  • The returned candidate's counsel relied on earlier Apex Court decisions (Jyoti Basu and D.R. Shipra) to argue that the lack of certification made the copy non-compliant with Section 81(3) and therefore fatal under Section 86.
  • The Court examined and applied the principles summarized by the Apex Court in T. Phunzathang, which re-affirmed earlier Constitution Bench authorities (Murarka Radhey Shyam, Ch. Subbbarao, T.M. Jacob) and articulated key points: the object of serving a true copy is substantive (to enable the respondent to understand and meet charges); the test is whether any variation would mislead a reasonable person; "copy" need not be absolutely exact; substantial compliance with Section 81(3) is sufficient; defects that are calculated to mislead are fatal, but insignificant variations are not; a distinction exists between Section 81(3) defects (governed by substantial compliance) and Section 83 defects (curable under civil procedure principles).
  • Applying those principles to the facts, the Court found no allegation or proof that Ext. R-1 was in substance not a true copy of Ext. P-1; the only complaint was absence of attestation. The Court concluded that the absence of attestation was not a total defect and did not render the petition void. There had been substantial compliance with Section 81(3).
  • On that basis, the Court decided Preliminary Issue No. 2 in favour of the election petitioner and against the returned candidate.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The Court held that both preliminary issues were decided in favour of the opposite party/election petitioner and against the applicant/returned candidate. The election petition was found to be maintainable and was ordered to proceed to trial. The miscellaneous case was rejected.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The returned candidate's objection to maintainability failed; the election petition survives preliminary challenges and will continue to trial on its merits.
  • The Court applied and followed the Apex Court's articulation of the doctrine of substantial compliance (as summarized in T. Phunzathang and the earlier authorities cited therein). The decision turned on findings of fact (presentation in person; content and service of the copy) and application of established principles on substantial compliance with Section 81(3) rather than setting a new principle of law.
  • No broader novel precedent was asserted by this judgment; the Court relied on and applied existing Supreme Court authorities to the facts before it.

Disposition: The election petition is held maintainable and shall proceed to trial. Miscellaneous case stands rejected.

Show all summary ...

RANJAN GOGOI, J.

An objection to the maintainability of the election petition having been put on record by the applicant/returned candidate, this Court by order dated 19.10.2001 has framed the following two preliminary issues for deciding the question of maintainability of the election petition.

1. Whether the election petition was presented by the election petitioner in accordance with Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 read with Rule 1 of Chapter VIIIA of the Gauhati High Court Rules. If not, whether the election petition is liable to be dismissed under Section 86 of the Act of 1951?

2. Whether the copy of the election petition was served on the returned candidate in compliance with the provisions of Section 81(3) of the Act of 1951. If not, whether the election petition is liable to be dismissed?

2. As the aforesaid two issues framed by order dated 19.10.2001, involve mixed questions of fact and law, parties were allowed to adduce evidence. The opposite party/election petitioner has examined three witnesses to establish that the election petition filed by him is maintainable. No witness has been examined on behalf of the applicant/ returned candidate.

3. In so far as Issue No. 1 is concerned, the requirement of Section 81(1) of the Act read with Rule 1 of Chapter VIIIA of the Gauhati High Court Rules is that an election petition must be presented by the election petitioner in person before the Stamp Reporter within 45 days of the date of declaration of result which in the instant case can be determined to be 28.6.2001. PW-1 is the election petitioner himself. According to him, after the decision to file the election petition was taken, on or about 25.6.2001 the election petitioner was informed by his advocates that the election petition has been made ready for filing. Accordingly, on the evening of 25.6.2001, the election petitioner visited the office of his counsel and the election petitioner satisfied himself as regards to the contents of the election petition. On 26.6.2001, the election petitioner took away the election petition and nine copies thereof from the office of his counsel and requested one Jainul Abedin, PW-2, a junior counsel to come to his residence in the morning of 27.6.2001 so that the election petition could be filed. PW-l/the election petitioner has further stated that in the morning of 27.6.2001, when PW-2 came to his residence, he in the presence of PW-2 signed all pages of the election petition and the copies thereof except the first pages and the affidavit. At about 1 p.m. of 27.6.2001, the election petitioner alongwith PW-2 came to the High Court with the election petition and copies thereof for presentation before the Stamp Reporter. On reaching the office of the Stamp Reporter (PW-3), he met his engaged counsel Shri A.B. Choudhury who was busy with some other work. Thereafter, the election petitioner occupied a chair in front of the Stamp Reporter and executed the affidavit before the Oath Commissioner. The Stamp Reporter was working as the Oath Commissioner also. After the affidavit was executed and necessary seals and signatures were affixed, the election petitioner/PW-1 signed on the first pages of the election petition and the copies with the following endorsement - Filed by Hafiz Rashid Ahmed Choudhury, the petitioner in person - 27.6.2001 . Thereafter, the election petition and the copies were placed on the table of the Stamp Reporter and the Stamp Reporter was informed that the election petition is being presented. The Stamp Reporter examined the contents of the election petition and counted the copies and informed PW-1 that the election petition was found to be alright. Thereafter, according to PW-1, one Rajkumar Singh, believed to be the Filing Assistant, was called by the Stamp Reporter and the election petition and the copies alongwith all enclosures were handed over to the Stamp Reporter to the said person. The aforesaid person was asked to affix necessary seals and endorsement and enter the particulars in the filing register. PW-2 accompanied the Filing Assistant Rajkumar Singh and came back to the table of the Stamp Reporter after about 15/20 minutes. The election petition and the copies were handed back to the Stamp Reporter. PW-1 has further deposed that he had a look at the check slip as well as the first page of the election petition. In so far as the election petition is concerned, he found a round seal somewhere in the bottom of the first page with the date - 27.6.2001. PW-1 has also deposed that on the left side of the top portion of the check slip there is an initial with the date 28.6.2001, Thereafter, as the Stamp Reporter had informed the PW-1 that the presentation had been done as required, PW-1 alongwith his counsels left the office. PW-1 has proved the Election petition filed by him which has been marked as Ext. P-l. He has also proved the endorsement with the signature and date appearing on the first page of the election petition as Ext.P-1(1). The round seal of the Filing Assistant has been proved as Ext.P-1(2). This witness has proved Ext.P-2 namely the check slip and P-2(1) namely the initial of the Filing Assistant. He claims to be conversant with the signature and initials of the Filing Assistant as in the course of his legal practice in the High Court, he had the occasion to deal with the aforesaid Filing Assistant in the normal course of office work. No cross examination of PW-1 has been made by the opposite party/returned candidate except a mere suggestion to the effect that the election petition was not presented in person before the Stamp Reporter on 27.6.2001.

4. PW-2 Jainul Abedin, a practicing Advocate of the High Court, has corroborated the evidence of PW-1. The opposite party/returned candidate has declined to cross examine the said PW-2.

5.The Stamp Reporter/PW-3 one Jadav Deka has deposed that on 27.6.2001, the election petitioner had presented the election petition in question in person before him. The same was handed over to the Filing Assistant for entering the serial number and putting the date, seal, etc. as the Stamp Reporter/PW-3 did not have any separate seal. PW-3 has admitted the execution of the affidavit in support of the election petition in his presence and has also stated that when the election petition was presented before him, he had checked the contents thereof to satisfy himself that all requisites have been filed alongwith the election petition. PW-3 has identified the check slip Ext.P-2 as well as the signature of the Filing Assistant namely Ext.P-2(1) whose signature he claims to be familiar with. PW-3 has further admitted that as the Stamp Reporter, he submitted the formal report on 2.7.2001 only. The delay has been sought to be explained by him as having occurred due to heavy pressure of work. PW-3 has also proved the filing register maintained in the office of the Stamp Reporter as Ext. P-3. The relevant entry in the filing register in respect of the election petition has been proved as Ext. P-3( 1).

6. An appraisal of the evidence of the three witnesses examined by the opposite party/election petitioner would go to show that PW-1 the election petitioner and PW-2 a junior advocate representing the election petitioner has been consistent with regard to the events that had occurred on 27.6.2001 in respect of the presentation of the election petition. There is no inconsistency or material contradictions or any other cogent reason for this Court to disbelieve the evidence of the aforesaid two witnesses. In so far as PW-3 is concerned, a perusal of the evidence adduced by the said witness would go to show that the said witness namely PW-3 has been equally categorical that the election petition was presented by PW-1 before him on 27.6.2001. PW-3 has further fortified the evidence tendered with effect to the date of presentation of the election petition by exhibiting the filing register an Ext.P-3 and by proving the relevant entry in respect of the election petition as Ext. P-3(l) which is one of one entries in the filing register in respect of 27th June, 2001.

7. In view of the aforesaid position, this Court has no hesitation in accepting the evidence of PW-3 also.

8. In view of the aforesaid conclusions, reached, preliminary Issue No. 1 as framed is decided in favour of the opposite party/ election petitioner and against the applicant returned candidate.

9. Adverting the second preliminary issue framed in the case, the copy of the election petition served on the applicant/ returned candidate has been duly exhibited and marked as Ext.R-1. A perusal of the aforesaid copy of the election petition duly exhibited would go to show that in the first page of the election petition, the following words are inserted: Filed by Hafiz Rashid Ahmed Choudhury-Petitioner uvperson - 27.6.2001 . In the rest of the election petition, there is a signature which the petitioner in his evidence claims to be his. That the aforesaid signature is of the election petitioner is not disputed on behalf of the returned candidate. The verification in support of the election petition; schedule of corrupt practices and the verification and affidavit in support of the corrupt practices alleged as well as the other enclosures and the verifications in support thereof, are certified to be true copy under the signature of the election petitioner.

10. Mr G.P. Bhowmick, learned counsel appearing for the applicant/returned candidate, relying on the ratio of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Jyoti Basu and others-Vs-Debi Ghosal and others reported in 1982(1) SCC691, as well as the decision of the Apex Court in the case of D.R. Shipra-Vs-Shanti Lal Khoiwal reported in AIR 1996 SC 1691, has sought to contend that, inasmuch as pages 1 to 40 of the election petition has not been certified to be true copy by the election petitioner, the election petition in question is not in conformity with the provisions of Section 81(3) of the RP Act, 1951 and therefore, deserves to be dismissed as not maintainable under the provisions of Section 86 of the Act.

11. Mr A.M. Mazumdar, learned senior counsel appearing for the opposite party/ election petitioner, has contended that the law relating to compliance with the requirements of Section 81(3) of the Act has been settled by a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Appellant, T. Phunzathang- Vs-Respondents, Hangkhanlian and others, reported in 2001 AIR SCW 3892: 2001(3) GLT (SC) 20. According to the learned senior counsel, preliminary Issue No. 2 ought to stand decided in favour of the election petitioner by virtue of the law laid down by the Apex Court as aforesaid.

12. I have considered the rival submissions. The Apex Court in the case of T. Phunzathang-Vs-Hangkhanlian and others (supra), has re-affirmed and reiterated the law laid down by the Constitution Benches of the Apex Court in the case of (i) Murarka Radhey Shyam Ram Kumar-Vs-Roop Singh Rathore, (1964) 3 SCR 573: (AIR 1964 SC 1545); (ii) Ch. Subbbarao-Vs-Member, Election Tribunal, Hyderabad, (1964) 6 SCR 213: (AIR 1964 SC 1027) and (iii) T.M. Jacob-Vs-C. Poulose (1999) 4 SCC 274: (1979 AIR SCW1156: AIR 1999 SC 1359) and has summed up the law in this regard as follows:

(i) The object of serving a true copy of an election petition and the affidavit filed in support of the allegations of corrupt practice of the respondent in the election petition is to enable the respondent to understand the charge against him so that he can effectively meet the same in the written statement and prepare his defence. The requirement is of substance and not of form. (Para 35)

(ii) The test to determine whether a copy was a true one or not was to find out whether any variation from the original was calculated to mislead a reasonable person. (Para 33)

(iii) The word 'copy' does not mean an absolutely exact copy. It means a copy so true that nobody can by any possibility misunderstand it. (Para 34)

(iv) Substantial compliance with Section 81 (3) was sufficient and the partition could not be dismissed, in limine, under Section 86(1) where there had been substantial compliance with the requirements of Section 81(3) of the Act. (Para 34)

(v) There is a distinction between non-compliance with the requirement of Section 81(3) and Section 83. A substantial compliance with the requirements of Section 81(3) read with the proviso to Section 83(1) of the Act is enough. Defects in the supply to true copy under Section 81 of the Act may be considered to be fatal, where the party has been misled by a copy on account of variation of a material nature in the original and the copy supplied to the respondent. The prejudice caused to the respondent in such cases would attract the provision of Section 81 (3) read with Section 86(1) of the Act. The same consequence would not follow from non-compliance with Section 83 of the Act. (Para 37)

(vi) The argument that since proceedings in election petitions are purely statutory proceedings and not civil proceedings as commonly understood, there is no room for invoking and importing the doctrine of substantial compliance into Section 86(1) read with Section 81 (3) of the Act, cannot be accepted and has to be replied. (Para 38)

(vii) It is only the violation of Section 81 of the Act which can attract the application of the doctrine of substantial compliance as expounded in Murarka Radhey Shyam (AIR 1964 SC 1545) and Ch. Subbarao cases. (AIR. 1964 SC 1027). The defect of the type provided in Section 83 of the Act, on the other hand, can be dealt with under the doctrine of curability, on the principles contained in the Code of Civil Procedure. This clearly emerges from the scheme of Sections 83(1) and 86(5) of the Act. (Para 38)

(viii) A certain amount of flexibility is envisaged. While an impermissible deviation from the original may entail the dismissal of an election petition under Section 86(1) of the Act, an insignificant variation in the true copy cannot be construed as a fatal defect. It is, however, neither desirable nor possible to catalogue the defects which may be classified as of a vital nature or those which are not so. It would depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case and no hard and fast formula can be prescribed. The test suggested in Murarka Radhey Shyam case (1964 (3) SCR 573: AIR 1964 SC 1345) are sound tests and are now well settled. (Para 40)

13. It is neither alleged nor proved that Ext. R-l served on the returned candidate is in any way not a true copy of the original election petition (Ext. P-l). The complaint is only as regards the lack of attestation to stipulated in the later part of Section 81(3) of the Act. In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court as discussed herein above, the absence of the attestation, not being a total defect, in the considered view of the Court, does not render the election petition void and not maintainable. There has been substantial compliance with the requirements of Section 81(3) of the Act in the instant case. Preliminary Issue No. 2 is therefore decided in favour of the election petitioner and against the returned candidates.

14. In view of the forgeoing discussions and for the reasons recorded the instant election petition is held to be maintainable and shall now proceed for trial.

15. Misc. case stands rejected.