Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mukund Bapu Jadhav v. Tanu Sakhu Pawar .

Bombay High Court
Jan 20, 1933
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court Opinion (Beaumont, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a second appeal from a decision of the Assistant Judge of Satara raising a point of practice concerning execution proceedings under Order 21 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Two respondents (respondents 2 and 6) died and their heirs were not brought on the record; accordingly the appeal abates as against them. Mr. Koyajee, appearing for the heirs of respondent 6, admitted his clients were not on the record and assisted as amicus curiae arguing against the appellant.

The material facts are: the applicant obtained a decree for possession in March 1925. On 24 June 1925 a darkhast (application) led to a warrant for possession. The warrant was returned on 29 October 1926 on the ground that possession was obstructed, and the darkhast was struck off the file on 21 January 1927. In March 1927 there was a fresh darkhast which was dismissed for default on 5 July 1927. On 6 July 1927 the present application (darkhast) was filed against the judgment-debtor. The lower Courts held the present application did not lie because the applicant had not taken steps under the previous darkhast.

The procedural rules invoked and discussed in the opinion include Order 21, Rule 35 (warrant for possession), Order 21, Rule 97 (application when possession is obstructed), and Article 167 of the Limitation Act (30-day period for such applications).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a decree-holder who obtained an order for possession under Order 21, Rule 35, and whose possession was obstructed, but who did not complain of the obstruction within 30 days under Order 21, Rule 97 (and Article 167 Limitation Act), is nevertheless at liberty to apply for a fresh warrant for possession under Order 21, Rule 35.
  2. If a fresh warrant under Rule 35 is obtained and possession under that fresh warrant is again obstructed, whether the decree-holder's subsequent application under Rule 97 is barred by Article 167 because the obstruction is in substance a continuation of the earlier obstruction (rather than a fresh obstruction).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vinayahrav Amrit v. Devrao Govind (1887) 11 Bom 473 Held (as interpreted by some lower Courts) that if no objection had been made under the rule corresponding to R.97, the decree-holder could not apply for a fresh order for possession because that would render Article 167 a dead letter. The Court distinguished this decision: it was given in revision and therefore distinguishable on that ground; Beaumont, C.J. expressed disagreement with the view that a fresh R.35 application is impermissible where no earlier R.97 objection was taken.
Kesri Narain v. Abdul Hasan (1904) 26 All 365; (1904) AWN 46 Decision of a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court agreeing with the Bombay High Court view that a fresh application cannot be made and the remedy is a suit. Beaumont notes this authority agreed with the Bombay view but observes the decision is weakened because one Judge (Knox, J.) expressed continuing agreement with Narain Das v. Hazari Lal, a case which conflicts in reasoning.
Narain Das v. Hazari Lal (1896) 18 All 233; (1896) AWN 84 Expressed the view that if a fresh application complaining of obstruction is made under R.97 under a fresh warrant, the very fact of applying under a fresh warrant would render the obstruction a fresh obstruction. Beaumont disagrees with that proposition: he holds that the mere fact that the decree-holder applies under a fresh warrant does not necessarily make the obstruction a fresh obstruction; the obstructing party may nevertheless prove it is the same obstruction, and Article 167 could bar the application in that event.
Raghunandan Prasad Misra v. Ram Charan Manda AIR 1919 Pat 425; 49 IC 150; 4 Pat LJ 94 (FB) Patna Full Bench reviewed authorities and followed the view that a fresh application for an order for possession can be made (i.e., supported the permissive approach). Beaumont cites this case as supporting the view he adopts: the balance of authority (as the Patna Full Bench said) leans in favour of allowing a fresh application for a warrant of possession.
Muthia v. Appasami (1890) 18 Mad 504 Madras High Court decision supporting permissibility of a fresh darkhast/order for possession in circumstances like the present. Beaumont cites Madras High Court authority (followed by Patna) as part of the weight of authority supporting his conclusion that a fresh R.35 application is permissible.
Shoteenath Mookerjee v. Obhoy Nund Boy (1879) 5 Cal 331 Calcutta High Court decision noted as agreeing with the Bombay High Court's position (i.e., against fresh application in certain circumstances). Beaumont records this as part of the line of authorities that agreed with the Bombay decision, but he ultimately holds the lower Courts' reliance on that line was incorrect in the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from the text of the relevant procedural rules and the Limitation Act and applies them to the sequence of events in the record:

  • The Court set out the operative provisions: Order 21, Rule 35 (warrant to put plaintiff in possession and remove any person refusing to vacate); the form of warrant (Form No. 11); Order 21, Rule 97(1) (allowing the holder of a decree to apply to the Court complaining of resistance or obstruction in obtaining possession); and Article 167 of the Limitation Act (requiring such an application to be made within 30 days of the resistance or obstruction).
  • Beaumont, C.J. characterises R.97 as permissive in character: the decree-holder is not compelled to use the summary remedy under R.97, but if he elects to do so the application under that rule must be made within the 30-day period fixed by Article 167.
  • The Court reasons that there may be more than one obstruction in point of fact. Failure to apply under R.97 as to a first obstruction does not logically bar application for relief in respect of a subsequent and distinct obstruction: the decree-holder should have a further 30-day period measured from the date of the later obstruction in which to apply under R.97.
  • To place himself in a position to seek summary relief under R.97 with respect to a later obstruction, the decree-holder must be able to obtain a fresh warrant for possession under R.35. Beaumont holds there is nothing in R.35 requiring the R.35 application itself to be made within 30 days and that Article 167 does not govern an R.35 application (Article 167 applies to applications under R.97).
  • Hence, the lower Courts' conclusion that an applicant who did not take steps under an earlier darkhast is barred from making the present R.35 application was erroneous in law, according to Beaumont.
  • However, the Court qualifies its ruling: if the decree-holder obtains a fresh warrant under R.35 and possession under that warrant is obstructed, and the decree-holder then applies under R.97, the execution Judge should inquire under R.98. In that inquiry the obstructing party can show that the obstruction is in fact the same obstruction (by the same person and in the same character) as the earlier obstruction; if that is proved, Article 167 will then be a bar to the R.97 application. The Court emphasises that the mere fact that the application is made under a fresh warrant does not automatically convert a continuance of the old obstruction into a fresh obstruction.
  • Beaumont surveys authorities: he distinguishes Vinayahrav Amrit (given in revision) and rejects the view that the inability to make a fresh R.35 application follows from failure to use R.97 earlier; he notes a split in High Court authority and finds the balance (including Patna Full Bench and Madras authority) supports his interpretation that a fresh R.35 application is permissible. He also critiques the reasoning in Narain Das which equates a fresh warrant-based application with a fresh obstruction.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed. The Court holds that the applicant is entitled to obtain a fresh warrant for possession under Order 21, Rule 35. The lower Courts were wrong to hold that the present darkhast was untenable because the applicant had not taken steps under the previous darkhast.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the decree-holder (applicant) may obtain a fresh warrant for possession under O.21, R.35. The appeal is allowed with costs as against the party served.
  • Limitation and subsequent summary remedy: if possession under any such fresh warrant is obstructed, and the decree-holder then makes an application under R.97, the obstructing party may seek to prove at the R.98 inquiry that the obstruction is the same as the earlier obstruction; if so, Article 167 (the 30-day bar) will operate to defeat the R.97 application. Conversely, if the obstruction is genuinely a new obstruction (different person or different character), the decree-holder will have a fresh 30-day period under Article 167 to invoke R.97.
  • On precedent: the Court reviewed conflicting High Court authorities and followed the line of authority (including the Patna Full Bench and Madras decisions) that supports permissibility of a fresh R.35 application in appropriate circumstances. The judgment clarifies how Article 167 interacts with fresh warrants and subsequent summary applications, but it also explains that the limitation bar remains available as a defence where the obstruction is shown to be the same as before.

Disposition: Appeal allowed. (Murphy, J. and Broomfield, J. agreed with Beaumont, C.J.; Broomfield J. added that Vinayahrav Amrit did not in his opinion decide the contrary point.)

Show all summary ...

Beaumont, C.J:— This is a second appeal from a decision of the Assistant Judge of Satara raising a point of practice which has given rise to some difference of opinion amongst the High Courts. Bo far as respondents 2 and 6 are concerned, they have died and their heirs have not been brought on the record. Therefore, as against them, the appeal abates, and car decision does not affect them. Mr. Koyajee, who appeared for the heirs of respondent 6, admits that, as his clients are not on the record he has no locus standi, but he has been good enough to assist is in the capacity of amicus curiae by arguing against the appellant. The point which arises for decision is whether the applicant, having obtained an order for possession under O. 21, R. 35, which has been obstructed, and having raised no objection to the obstruction within 30 days, is at liberty to apply for a fresh order for possession. The facts giving rise to the application are these: In March 1925 the applicant obtained a decree for possession of an immovable property. On 24th June 1925, there was an application, for a darkhast, and a warrant for possession was given. On 29th October 1926, the warrant was returned on the ground, that possession was obstructed, and on 21st January 1927, the darkhast was struck off the file. In March 1927 there was a fresh darkhast, which, on 5th July, was dismissed for default. Then Page: 458on 6th July 1927, the present application for a darkhast was filed against the judgment-debtor. The lower Courts have held that the application does not lie, because the applicant did not take any steps under the previous darkhast. Now, O. 21, R. 35(1), provides:

“Where a decree is for the delivery of any immoveable property, possession thereof shall be delivered to the party to whom it has been adjudged, or to such person as he may appoint to receive delivery on his behalf, and if necessary, by removing any person bound by the decree who refuses to vacate the property.”

2. The form of warrant which is issued under that rule is Form No. 11 in App. R. It is addressed to the bailiff of the Court, recites that property in the occupancy of so and so has been decreed to the plaintiff, and then directs the bailiff to put the plaintiff in possession and to remove any person bound by the decree who refuses to vacate. R. 97, O. 21, deals with the case of obstruction to possession. Sub-r. (1) of that rule provides:

“Where the holder of a decree for the possession of immoveable property or the purchaser of any such property sold in execution of a decree is resisted or obstructed by any person in obtaining possession of the property, he may make an application to the Court complaining of such resistance or obstruction.”

3. Then Article 167, Lim. Act, provides that any such application must be made within 30 days from the date of the resistance or obstruction. The question for our decision is, whether an application complaining of an obstruction not having been made within 30 days, the judgment-creditor is barred from making a fresh application for a writ of possession under R. 35 and is limited to the remedy of filing a suit. It is stated in Sir Dinshaw Mulla's Civil Procedure Code, Edn. 9, p. 773, that the High Courts of Madras and Patna have held that a fresh application for delivery of possession on a fresh warrant may be applied for, and that the High Courts of Bombay and Allahabad have held that such an application cannot be made, and that the only remedy is a suit.

4. Looking at the words of R. 97, it is clear that it is permissive in character. The party obstructed is not bound to make an application to get the obstruction removed by the summary process laid down in the rule succeeding R. 97, though, if he does make such an application, he must make it within the 30 days Said down by Article 167. But it seems to me clear that there may be more than one obstruction, and the fact that the decree-holder has chosen to make no application under the summary process in respect of the first obstruction would not debar him from making such an application in respect of a second obstruction. The first obstruction might be by a stranger and the decree-holder might consider that any application to remove such stranger summarily would probably fail, having regard to R. 99. But then that stranger might go out of possession, and there might be a subsequent obstruction by the judgment-debtor in respect of which the decree holder might desire to take summary proceedings. In my opinion the decree-holder would have an additional 30 days from the date of that second obstruction within which to make his application, and the fact that he had failed to make an application in respect of a previous obstruction would be immaterial. If the decree-holder is to be entitled to make an application in respect of a second obstruction, it seems to me that he must be entitled, in order to put himself into a position to make such an application, to obtain a fresh warrant for possession under R. 35. There is nothing in R. 35 which requires an application under that rule to be within 30 days from the obstruction, since Article 167 plainly has no reference to an application under R. 35. That being so, looking at the matter, apart from authority, it seems to me that the lower Courts were wrong in saying that this application does not lie.

5. All that the applicant is asking at the moment is that a fresh warrant for possession may issue under R. 35, and to that, I think, he is entitled. That really disposes of the appeal, because we are not dealing today with the rights which may accrue under that fresh warrant. But, as the whole question has been argued, and as the rights accruing under the warrant will arise for decision at a later stage of these proceedings, it is, I think, desirable that we should indicate our opinion upon the point. If under the fresh warrant possession is obstructed and the decree holder then applies under R. 97 complaining of the obstruction, and if the execution Judge then starts an inquiry under R. 98, in my opinion it will be open to the party obstructing to show Page: 459that his obstruction is by the same person and in the same character as the former obstruction in respect of which do proceedings were taken, and if he succeeds in proving that Article 167 will then be a bar to the decree-holder's application. The mere fact that the application is made in respect of a fresh warrant for possession does not, in my view, involve that the obstruction is a fresh obstruction.

6. Mr. Gajendragadkar on behalf of the appellant has referred us to all the cases on this subject. The decision of this Court in Vinayahrav Amrit v. Devrao Govind (1887) 11 Bom 473, a decision which both the lower Courts felt themselves bound to follow, was given in revision, and on that ground can be distinguished from the present case. But the learned Chief Justice did there, as it seems to me, express the view that if no objection had been made to an obstruction under the section of the Code, which then corresponded to R. 97, it would not be permissible for the decree-holder to apply for a fresh order for possession because that would render Article 167, in effect, a dead letter. For the reasons which I have given, I do not think that view is correct. It seems to me, that Article 167 has nothing to do with an application for a warrant for possession under R. 35, and that the article would still be applicable, notwithstanding the fresh order for possession, to a subsequent application in respect of the same obstruction. The Division Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in Kesri Narain v. Abdul Hasan (1904) 26 All 365 , (1904) AWN 46 and a Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Shoteenath Mookerjee v. Obhoy Nund Boy (1879) 5 Cal 331 agreed with the decision of the Bombay High Court. But the case in Kesri Narain v. Abdul Hasan (1904) 26 All 365 , (1904) AWN 46 is rather weakened by the fact that Knox, J., one of the Judges, expressed himself as still agreeing with the decision in Narain Das v. Hazari Lal (1896) 18 All 233 , (1896) AWN 84, to which he had been a party, and which appears to me to conflict certainly in its reasoning with the later decision in Kesri Narain v. Abdul Hasan (1904) 26 All 365 , (1904) AWN 46.

7. On the other hand a different view was taken by the Patna High Court in a case in which all the authorities are reviewed, Raghunandan Prasad Misra v. Ram Charan Manda AIR 1919 Pat 425 , 49 IC 150 , 4 Pat LJ 94 (FB), and this case followed a decision of the Madras High Court in Muthia v. Appasami (1890) 18 Mad 504. The balance of authority, as the learned Judges of the Patna High Court say, is rather in favour of the view which I am taking that a fresh application for an order for possession can be made in the circumstances of this case. With regard to the case in Narain Das v. Hazari Lal (1896) 18 All 233 , (1896) AWN 84 the learned Judges there expressed the view that if a fresh application complaining of obstruction were made under R. 97 under a fresh warrant of possession, the mere fact that the application was made in respect of a fresh warrant for possession would involve that the application was in respect of a fresh, obstruction. I am not myself disposed to agree with that view. I think that if in fact the obstruction is by the same person and in the same character, the mere fact that the decree-holder is applying under a fresh warrant of possession would not make the obstruction a fresh obstruction. For these reasons, I think that the decisions of the lower Courts were wrong, and that the appeal must be allowed with costs as against the party served.

Murphy, J.:— I agree.

Broomfield, J.:— I agree. I am of opinion that the lower Courts were wrong in holding that the darkhast was untenable and barred in limine. The case they profess to follow, Vinayahrav Amrit v. Devrao Govind (1887) 11 Bom 473, does not, in my opinion, really decide that.

8. On the facts of that case it was held that the decree-holder's application was virtually an attempt to renew the old proceedings, i.e, it was a case of the continuance of an obstruction which might have been, but had not been, dealt with by an application under the rule corresponding to R. 97, O. 21. The suggestion was made that the obstruction was a fresh one and as to that the Court said this (p. 475):

It has however been stated before us that the original obstruction was by a third person, and that the present obstruction is by the judgment-debtor himself. No point was made of this before the Subordinate Judge. But assuming it to be the case, and that the present obstructor does not claim in any way through the third person who was in possession in 1877, which however is denied by the vakil for the opponent, it may be Page: 460that, as three years have not elapsed since the applicant came of age, summary proceedings might be taken, under the Code of Civil Procedure, to remove such an obstruction notwithstanding what occurred in 1877.

9. The reference to three years' limitation seems to show that the learned Judges thought that in the case of an obstruction by a different person, at any rate if that person is the judgment-debtor, a fresh darkhast followed by a fresh summary application is permissible. The question of the bar of limitation under Article 167 can only arise, in my opinion, if and when the darkhastdar having got his writ of possession makes a fresh application under R. 97 and I agree with the learned Chief Justice in holding that question must depend on whether the obstruction now offered is an obstruction by a different person, or an obstruction by the same person in different circumstances, that is a fresh obstruction, or whether it is merely a continuance of the same obstruction.

K.S

10. Appeal allowed.