Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Alim And Ors. v. Sh. Mohd. Saeed And Ors.

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Nov 16, 1950
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The short point for decision was whether a certificate issued by this Court that an appeal preferred to the Privy Council (P. C.) or the Supreme Court (S. C.) had not been effectually prosecuted by the appellant could be cancelled or withdrawn by this Court.

On 10-4-1946 the High Court at Lahore permitted Sayed Abdul Alim (the petitioner) to prefer an appeal to the Privy Council and the petitioner deposited the printing charges for preparation of the record. After the partition of the Punjab the case was transferred to this Court. On 24-7-1948 counsel for the petitioner (Mr. Asa Ram Aggarwal) was asked to deposit an additional sum of Rs. 1,783 for printing charges; the letter was also sent to the petitioner. No reply was received from counsel. On 1-9-1948 the petitioner requested that the additional sum be accepted in monthly instalments of Rs. 200. On 18-9-1948 he was directed to move the Court by a stamped petition; no reply was received. A learned Judge directed on 27-10-1948 that the petitioner be called upon to show cause why the appeal should not be dismissed for non-prosecution for failure to show diligence in preparing the record.

The matter came before a Division Bench and on 10-12-1948 the Court ordered that the money be deposited on or before 17-12-1948, failing which the appeal would be deemed dismissed for want of prosecution. The money was deposited on 20-12-1948 (three days late). On 27-12-1948 the Court dismissed the appeal and cancelled the certificate for leave to appeal. On 16-3-1949 the petitioner filed the present application seeking (a) that the order dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution be set aside, (b) that the deposit of 20-12-1948 be accepted, and (c) that the delay in making the deposit be condoned.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a certificate issued by this Court that an appeal to the Privy Council (or the Supreme Court in succession) has not been effectually prosecuted can be cancelled or withdrawn by this Court.
  2. Whether, alternatively, this Court could review its own order under Order 47 or Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code to set aside the dismissal and cancel the certificate.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner's advocate contended that because the petitioner failed to deposit the sum of Rs. 1,783 as required by the Court, Rule 6 of Order 12, F.C. Rules, 1942 required the High Court to report the fact to the Privy Council and that the appeal should not have been dismissed by this Court without such a reference.
  • It was further contended that the Court could, in the exercise of powers under Order 47 or Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code, review its own order and set aside the dismissal (i.e., condone the delay and accept the deposit).

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of opposing party arguments beyond the Court's consideration of legal rules and statutory provisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the matter in two related strands: (A) the applicability of the rules governing appeals to the Privy Council and the statutory changes expanding Privy Council jurisdiction, and (B) the petitioner's factual case on delay and diligence.

A. Legal and procedural analysis:

  • The Court examined Rule 6 of Order 12 of the F.C. Rules, 1942, which prescribes that where an appellant fails to make a required deposit the High Court shall report the fact to the Privy Council and the appeal shall not proceed without further order of that Court. The Court held that Rule 6 was manifestly intended to apply to appeals of the type mentioned in Section 205 of the Government of India Act, i.e., appeals involving substantial questions of law under the Government of India Act, 1935, and not to ordinary civil appeals from High Court judgments where previously a direct appeal to His Majesty in Council had been available.
  • The Court then considered the rules embodied in Rule 12 framed by His Majesty in Council concerning Privy Council appeals, which permit the Court to issue a certificate that the appeal has not been effectually prosecuted; once such a certificate is issued the appeal is to be deemed dismissed for non-prosecution as from the date of the certificate without an express order of the Privy Council.
  • The Court examined statutory changes effected by the F.C. (Enlargement of Jurisdiction) Act, 1947 (referred to with its operative provisions): Section 3 enlarged the Privy Council's jurisdiction as from 1-2-1948 to include appeals from civil cases which previously could have been brought directly to His Majesty in Council; Section 4 declared that orders and certificates granted by a High Court in connection with appeals to His Majesty in Council shall, unless records had already been transmitted, be deemed to be in connection with appeals to the Federal Court; and Section 6 preserved the effect of Civil Procedure Code provisions in relation to appeals to the Federal Court with necessary substitutions.
  • The Court observed Section 112 of the Civil Procedure Code (as amended) which states that nothing in the Code shall be deemed to interfere with rules made by the Supreme Court (previously the Privy Council) for presentation and conduct of appeals. The Court also referred to Article 135 of the Constitution vesting the jurisdiction and powers exercised by the Privy Council in the Supreme Court.
  • From these provisions the Court concluded that the power of review conferred by the Civil Procedure Code (for example, by Order 47 or Section 151) could not be invoked so as to interfere with the special procedural rules made for appeals to the Privy Council / Supreme Court. The rules made by His Majesty in Council (and continued in effect) constituted a special law governing presentation and prosecution of such appeals, and the Civil Procedure Code could not be used to override those rules.
  • Consequently, where the Court had issued a certificate under the applicable rules that the appeal had not been effectually prosecuted, it was not within the competence of this Court to review that order or to cancel or withdraw the certificate.

B. Merits and factual application:

  • The Court reviewed the timeline and documentary matters relied upon by the petitioner. The petitioner had been permitted to prefer the appeal in 1946 and had earlier deposited required amounts in Lahore, but after transfer to East Punjab he failed to deposit the additional Rs. 1,783 on time.
  • The petitioner sought to excuse delay by claiming that his agent in Delhi received information of the Court's order on 16-12-1948 and that the money was sent by telegraphic money order, which reached the Registrar on 20-12-1948 (with 19-12-1948 being a Sunday). The petitioner did not state when the money-order was actually despatched nor explain why counsel present in Court on 10-12-1948 did not inform the agent earlier.
  • The Court emphasised that if the petitioner or his counsel could have shown that the money was deposited with the Post Office in Delhi on 16-12-1948 and that the telegraphic remit could not be disbursed before 20-12-1948, there might have been justification for condonation. No such proof was furnished.
  • Given the explicit direction that the amount be deposited by 17-12-1948 and the absence of a satisfactory explanation for the delay, the Court held that the only order consistent with its prior direction was dismissal of the appeal. The Court found no merit in the grounds advanced in the petition dated 16-3-1949.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is dismissed. The Court held that it is not within its power to review the order under the Civil Procedure Code so as to cancel or withdraw a certificate that an appeal has not been effectually prosecuted; further, on the merits the petitioner failed to make out any case for condonation of the delay in depositing the required sum and for setting aside the dismissal.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the application dated 16-3-1949 was dismissed with costs and the dismissal of the appeal for non-prosecution (and the issuance of the certificate) stands.
  • The Court's reasoning rests on the distinction between special rules governing Privy Council/Supreme Court appeals and the general review powers under the Civil Procedure Code; the opinion emphasises that special procedural rules for such appeals cannot be displaced by invoking Order 47 or Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code.
  • The opinion does not announce or rely upon any new judicial precedent beyond the statutory and rule-based analysis contained in the text; it applies existing rules and statutory provisions to the facts of this case and upholds the dismissal on both jurisdictional and merits grounds.

Disposition: Petition dismissed.

Show all summary ...

Judgement

- The short point for decision in the present case is whether a certificate issued by this Ct. to the effect that an appeal preferred to the P. C. or the S. C. has not been effectually prosecuted by the applt. can be cancelled or withdrawn by this Ct.

2. On 10-4-1946, the H. C. at Lahore permitted Sayed Abdul Alim petnr. to prefer an appeal to the P. C. and the petnr. deposited the printing charges for the preparation of the record. On 24-7-1948, after this case had been transferred to this Ct. after the partition of the Punjab, Mr. Asa Ram Aggarwal, counsel for the petnr. was asked to deposit a sum of Rs. 1783 on account of additional printing charges and a copy of the letter addressed to the counsel was forwarded to the petnr. under registered cover. No reply was received from the counsel, but on the 1st September the petnr. sent a communication to this Ct. in which he requested that the deposit of Rs. 1783 be accepted in monthly instalments of Rs. 200 each. On the 18th September he was directed to move this Ct. by means of a stamped petn. but no reply having been received from him, a learned Judge of this Ct. directed on 27th October that the petnr. should be called upon to show cause why the appeal preferred by him should not be dismissed for non-prosecution on the ground that he had failed to show diligence in the preparation of the record. The case came up for hearing before a D. B. of this Ct. and on 10 10-1948, the Ct. directed that the money should be deposited on or before 17-12-1948 failing which the appeal would be deemed to be dismissed for want of prosecution. The money was deposited on the 20th December, that is three days after the date on which it should have been deposited and on the 27th December the Ct dismissed the appeal and cancelled the certificate for leave to appeal.

3. On 16-3-1949, the petnr. presented the present appln. in which it was prayed that the order dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution be set aside, that the deposit made on the 20th December be accepted and that the delay in making the deposit be condoned.

4. Rule 6 of O. 12, F. C. Rules, 1942, provides that where the applt. fails to make the deposit required under Rr. 2, 3 or 4 of the said Order, the H. C. shall report the fact to the P. C. and the appeal shall not proceed without further order of the said Ct. The learned advocate for the petnr. contends that as his client failed to deposit the sum of Rs. 1783-0-0 as required by this Ct. it was the duty of this Ct. to refer the matter to the P. C. for orders and that this Ct. was not justified in dismissing the appeal and cancelling the certificate for leave to appeal without making this reference. I regret I am unable to concur in this contention. This rule was obviously intended to apply to an appeal of the nature mentioned in S. 205, Govt. of India Act, i. e., an appeal from a judgment, decree or final order of a H. C. in regard to a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Govt. of India Act, 1935, or any Order in Council made thereunder. The help of this rule cannot be invoked in respect of an appeal from a judgment, decree or final order of a H. C. in a civil case in which a direct appeal could have been brought before His Majesty in Council prior to the enactment of the F. C. (Enlargement of Jurisdiction) Act of 1947.

5. Again it is contended that even if it was within the power of this Ct. to direct that the appeal should be dismissed for want of non-prosecution it is open to this Ct., in exercise of the powers conferred by O. 47 or S. 151, Civil P. C. to review its own order. This contention too appears to me to be wholly devoid of force. Rule 12 of the Rules framed by His Majesty in Council concerning P. C. appeals declares that where an applt. whose appeal has been admitted, fails to show due diligence in taking all necessary steps in connection with the preparation of the record, the Ct. may call upon the applt. to show cause why a certificate should not be issued that the appeal has not been effectually prosecuted by the applt., and if the Ct. sees fit to issue such a certificate, the appeal shall be deemed as from the date of such certificate to stand dismissed for non-prosecution without express Order of His Majesty in Council. In the year 1948, the Central Legislature enacted a measure entitled "The F. C. (Enlargement of Jurisdiction) Act, 1947," S. 3 of which declares that as from the appointed day, (that is from 1-2-1948) an appeal shall lie to the P. C. from any judgment to which this Act applies, i. e., any judgment, decree or final order of a H. C. in a civil case from which a direct appeal could have been brought to His Majesty in Council either with or without special leave of the P. C. In other words, this Act enlarged the jurisdiction of the P. C. by directing that the said Ct. shall be competent to hear not only appeals of the nature mentioned in S. 205, Govt. of India Act, 1935, but also appeals from judgments, decrees or final orders in civil cases from which direct appeals could have been taken to His Majesty in Council. S. 4 of the enactment provides that all orders made and certificates granted by a H. C. in connection with an appeal to His Majesty in Council shall, unless the records pertaining to such appeal had before the appointed day been transmitted by the H. C. concerned to His Majesty in Council, be deemed to be orders made, and certificates granted, in connection with the appeal to the P. C. and shall have effect accordingly. S. 6 enacts that the provisions of Civil P. C. and of any other law in force immediately before 1-2-1948 shall have effect in relation to an appeal to the F. C. as if in the said provisions, for all references to His Majesty in Council there had been substituted references to the F. C. S. 112 of the said Code, as amended by the Adaptations of Laws Orders, 1950, declares in an unambiguous language that nothing contained in the Code shall be deemed to interfere with any rules made by the S. C. for the presentation of appeals to that Ct. or their conduct before that Ct. Art. 135 of the Constitution provides that the jurisdiction and powers which were being exercised by the P. C. immediately before the commencement of the constitution shall be exercised by the S. C. In view of these provisions, it seems to me that as the power of review conferred by the Civil P. C. cannot be allowed to interfere with the rules made by the S. C. and as this Ct. has issued a certificate under the said rules that the appeal has not been effectually prosecuted it is not within the competence of this Ct. to review that order.

6. There is another aspect of the matter which needs to be considered. S.4, Civil P. C. declares that in the absence of any specific provision to the contrary, nothing in the Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect any special or local law now in force or any special jurisdiction or power conferred, or any special form of procedure prescribed, by or under any other law for the time being in force. As the rules made by His Majesty in Council for appeals to the P. C. must be deemed to be a special law in regard to the procedure which should be applied in the presentation and prosecution of appeals to the P. C. it seems to me the provisions of Civil P. C. cannot apply to that special law. Indeed the language of S. 112, Civil P. C. makes it quite clear that as mentioned above nothing contained in the Code shall be deemed to interfere with any rules made by the Judicial Committee of the P. C. for the presentation of appeals to His Majesty in Council, or their conduct before the said Judicial Committee. If this section is read in conjunction with S. 6 of Act i [1] of 1948, it is obvious that the help of this Code cannot be invoked for interfering with the rules made by the P. C. either under O. 47, R. 1, or S. 151, Civil P. C. I entertain no doubt whatever that it is not within the power of this Ct. to review its own order or to direct that the certificate that the appeal has not been effectually prosecuted shall be cancelled or withdrawn.

7. Even on merits, it seems to me that no case has been made out for the cancellation of the certificate. As stated above, the petnr. was permitted to prefer the appeal to the P. C. as long ago as 10-4 1946. It is true that he deposited the amounts which were required of him in the H. C. at Lahore, but when the appeal was transferred to the East Punjab and he was required to deposit an additional sum of Rs. 1783 on account of additional printing fee he failed to comply with the orders. On 1-9-1948, he requested that this amount should be accepted in monthly instalments of Rs. 200 each. He was directed to move this Ct. by a stamped appln. but he did not care to send a reply to this communication. The case was taken up by this Ct on 10-12-1948, and the petnr. was specially informed that the money should be deposited in Ct. on or before the 17th December at latest failing which the appeal would be deemed to be dismissed for default of prosecution. The money was not deposited by the due date and the only order that could be passed by this Ct. consistently with the order of 10-12-1948, was that the appeal should be dismissed. In this appln. dated 16-3-1949, the petnr. states as follows :

"(5) That for the said purpose 10-12-1948 was fixed in the H. C. of Judicature for East Punjab at Simla and the petnr. was granted a week that the money be deposited upto 17 12-1948.

(6) That the agent of the petnr. in Delhi received information of this order on 16-12-1948.

(7) That the said agent informed the petnr. of the said order and under instructions from the petnr. the money was duly sent by telegraphic money order to the Registrar of the East Punjab H. C. at Simla, which was received there on 20-12-1948, 19-12-1948 being Sunday."

The appln. does not mention the circumstances which prevented the counsel for the petnr. who was present in Ct. on the 10th December from communicating the order of this Ct. to the agent of the petnr. till the 16th December; nor does it explain the circumstances which prevented the agent from sending a telegraphic money-order to this Ct. on the 16th. The petnr. has carefully refrained from stating the date on which the money-order was actually despatched. Had it been despatched on the 16th December, it would have reached this Ct. on the following day and the order of the Ct. would have been complied with. Unfortunately, it does not appear to have been sent on the 16th December for it did not reach the Ct. till the 20th. Had the petnr. or his counsel satisfied this Ct. that the money was in fact deposited with the Post-Office in Delhi on the 16th December and that the said money could not be disbursed to the addressee till the 20th December there might have been some justification for condoning the delay. As it happens, it seems to me that there is no force whatsoever in any of the grounds mentioned in the petn. of 16-3-1949. Considerable latitude has already been allowed to the petnr. to deposit the additional expenses but he has failed without reasonable cause to comply with the order of this Ct. The petn. must be dismissed with costs.

Petition dismissed.