Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

D.P. Jangra v. State Information Commission And Ors.

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jan 6, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Mehin­der Singh Sullar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, D.P. Jangra, was posted as District Food and Supplies Controller (DFSC), Yamuna Nagar. On 18.01.2010 Shamsher Singh (respondent No.5) filed an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005 seeking information relating to the petitioner's expenditure, movable and immovable properties and copies of permissions obtained by the petitioner to purchase/sell property. The State Public Information Officer (SPIO) did not supply the information and the appellant (respondent No.5) filed a first appeal; the First Appellate Authority (FAA) also did not provide the information.

The appellant filed a second appeal before the State Information Commissioner, Haryana (SIC). The SIC passed an order dated 21.07.2010 (Annexure P-4) recording arguments and granting the petitioner an opportunity of personal hearing on 09.08.2010. Subsequently, by order dated 09.08.2010 (Annexure P-14) the SIC directed the SPIO to obtain and furnish details of movable and immovable assets of D.P. Jangra, his wife and family members to the appellant within 25 days and made broader observations recommending that the public authority consider publishing asset details of employees on its website.

The FAA and the SPIO did not challenge the SIC orders, but the petitioner filed the present writ petition under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution challenging Annexures P-4 and P-14. After hearing counsel and considering the record, the High Court dismissed the writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the information sought (expenditure, movable and immovable properties and permissions to acquire property relating to the petitioner) is exempt from disclosure under Section 8(j) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 as "personal information" the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or would cause unwarranted invasion of privacy unless the larger public interest justifies disclosure?
  2. Whether the petitioner, as a purported "third party", was entitled to a prior opportunity of hearing before the SIC directed disclosure of the information?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (D.P. Jangra)

  • The information sought regarding movable and immovable properties and expenditure is personal information and therefore exempt from disclosure under Section 8(e)(j) of the RTI Act (the submission being that disclosure would amount to an unwarranted invasion of privacy).
  • The petitioner contended that, as a third-party, he was entitled to a hearing before any order was passed directing disclosure; reliance was placed on the Gujarat High Court's observations in Reliance Industries Limited v. Gujarat State Information Commission and others (A.I.R. 2007 Gujarat 203).

Respondents' Positions (SPIO, FAA, SIC and State)

  • SPIO and FAA initially declined to furnish the information on the ground that it was covered under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act and would invade the petitioner's privacy.
  • The SIC rejected that plea, recorded the appellant's allegations of corruption against the petitioner, observed the public interest in transparency and accountability, and directed the SPIO to obtain and furnish the petitioner's movable and immovable asset details (including those of his wife and family members) to the appellant within 25 days; the SIC also suggested that the public authority consider publishing asset details of employees on its website to reduce corruption.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Reliance Industries Limited v. Gujarat State Information Commission and others, A.I.R. 2007 Gujarat 203 Held that a time-bound schedule under the RTI Act will not oust a right of hearing vested in a "third party"; authorities should protect third-party rights by satisfying themselves about the applicant's credentials and pass a speaking order after affording hearing. The High Court considered Reliance but held it was not applicable on the facts: the petitioner could not be treated as a "third party" under Section 2(n) in the present circumstances, and therefore the obligation to afford a prior hearing to the petitioner did not arise here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, based strictly on the material and statutory text recited in the opinion:

  1. Identification of issue: The sole legal question was whether the information sought (sanctions, expenditure, movable and immovable properties of the petitioner and permissions to acquire property) fell within the exemption of Section 8(e)(j) of the RTI Act.
  2. Statutory framework: The court reviewed the object and purpose of the RTI Act (to ensure access to information and accountability under Article 19 of the Constitution). The court reproduced and discussed Section 8 (including proviso), Section 2(f) (definition of "information"), Section 2(j) ("right to information"), Section 2(n) ("third party"), and related provisions (Sections 3, 4, 6 and 7 being described as the statutory scheme for right to information and procedure).
  3. Evidence of public interest connection: The court noted that the petitioner was a public servant (DFSC) and, under Conduct Rule 18, government employees are required to submit returns of assets and liabilities (property statements) detailing movable and immovable properties of the employee, spouse and family. The information sought was limited to such property statements and related permissions.
  4. Application of the exemption: The court held that for Section 8(e)(j) to apply the information must (a) have no relationship to any public activity or interest, or (b) cause unwarranted invasion of privacy, and in either event disclosure is permitted if the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies disclosure. The court found that the information here had a direct relationship with the petitioner's public employment and therefore did not fall within the shelter of the exemption clause.
  5. On the entitlement to hearing: The court examined the petitioner's reliance on the Gujarat High Court decision in Reliance Industries and the concept of a "third-party" under Section 2(n). The court concluded that because the information-seeking process here was between respondent No.5 (the RTI applicant), the SPIO and the FAA, and because the petitioner was not a "third-party" in the operative circumstances, the requirement to afford the petitioner a prior opportunity of hearing did not arise.
  6. Conclusion from statutory and factual matrix: The court emphasized that all essential ingredients of the exemption clause were lacking; the information in the property statement had a nexus with public employment and could not be termed an unwarranted invasion of privacy. Consequently the authorities were legally bound to supply the information as directed by the SIC.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition filed by the petitioner was dismissed. The High Court found no merit in the challenge to the SIC orders (Annexures P-4 and P-14) and upheld the direction to supply the information.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the SIC orders directing the SPIO to obtain and furnish details of the petitioner's movable and immovable assets (including those of his wife and family members) remain operative and the writ challenge to those orders failed.
  • The court's reasoning is confined to the facts before it: the court held that property statements required under conduct rules and connected with public employment do not attract exemption under Section 8(e)(j) absent satisfaction that larger public interest does not justify disclosure.
  • The opinion does not purport to establish a novel, binding precedent beyond these facts; the court expressly distinguished the Reliance decision and concluded that the petitioner was not a "third party" in the relevant sense, thus obviating the requirement for a prior hearing in this instance.

This summary is limited to and strictly derived from the contents of the provided opinion; no additional facts or inferences beyond the text have been added.

Show all summary ...

JUDGEMENT :-

Mehinder Singh Sullar, J.

1 The matrix of the facts, which needs a necessary mention for a limited purpose of deciding the core controversy involved in the instant writ petition and emanating from the record, is that petitioner-D.P. Jangra was posted as District Food and Supplies Controller, Yamuna Nagar. Shamsher Singh (respondent No.5) son of Kathu Ram sought information under The Right to Information Act, 2005 (hereinafter to be referred as the "Act"), relating to the expenditure, movable and immovable properties of the petitioner, vide application dated 18.01.2010. He has also sought copies of the permissions obtained by the petitioner" to purchase/sell the property. The same were not supplied to him by the State Public Information Officer (for short the "SPIO"). Dissatisfied with it, the private respondent filed the first appeal, but the information was not supplied to him as well by the First Appellate Authority (for brevity the "FAA").

2 Aggrieved by the action of the SPIO and the FAA, respondent No.5 filed the second appeal before the State Information Commissioner, Haryana (for brevity the "SIC"). During the course of hearing of the second appeal, the SIC passed the impugned order dated 21.07.2010 (Annexure P-4). The operative part of which is, as under:-

"In the hearing today, the appellant and the respondents were present and heard. The appellant submitted that requisite information has not been provided to him by the respondents so far. The respondents submitted that the informations sought by the appellant cannot be furnished since it is covered under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act on the plea that it is invasion on the privacy of individual. The learned Judges of Supreme Court are furnishing details of their movable; immovable assets, so are the Legislators before filing their nomination papers. The Commissioner had ordered official of M.C.F., Faridabad to furnish details of their movable, immovable assets. Likewise, an order has been issued in respect of officials of Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board. However, still Sh. D.P. Jangra is being extended an opportunity and a personal hearing on 09.08.2010 to make his submissions in case he has any specific reason for not furnishing details of his movable, immovable assets. The next date of hearing is fixed for 09.08.2010 at 11.00 hours."

3 Not only that, instead of supplying the requisite information, the FAA and the SPIO contended that as per arguments of the petitioner, the information sought by respondent No.5, cannot be furnished, since, the same is covered under Section 8(e)(j) of the Act. However, their plea was negatived and the SIC directed them to supply the information vide impugned order dated 09.08.2010 (Annexure P-14). The operative part of which is, as follows:-

"Today in the hearing, both the appellant and respondents were present and heard. With the existing levels corruption in our system, we cannot create world class assets/ infrastructure for our future generations despite the funds/liquidity at our disposal currently.. The appellant had alleged various charges of corruption against Sh. D.P. Jangra who has been DFSC, Yamuna Nagar on several occasions in the hearing before Commission. The corruption in respondent department could be more pronounced due to its. interaction with general public and more so with BPL population. We should attempt to reduce if not totally eliminate the source of corruption from out Society. India is at position No.134 on the UN Human Development Index since 1994 despite a 15 times increase in budget allocation over this period for social sector and poverty alleviation programmes by the Government.

It is hereby directed that the respondent/public authority i.e. The Director Food & Supplies Deptt. could consider obtaining the details of movable; immovable assets of all employees in respondent department/public authority starting from the level of sub inspector in the field offices and details should be accessible to the general public on the web site of respondents/public authority. RTI Act seeks to make those who govern accountable to the governed and also seeks to reduce corruption in our system. It is expected that corruption will be considerably reduced in the system if proposed details of assets of individuals are available to the general public on website as very few officials would like to create benami properties. SPIO is hereby directed to obtain the details of movable, immovable assets of Sh. D.P. Jangra, his wife and family members and furnish the same to the appellant within 25 days of issue of order with copy to the appellant and the Commission in term of appellant's application dated 18.01.2010. The case will be closed only after receipt of the above information.

4 Neither the FAA, nor the SPIO-respondents, assailed the impugned orders, but the petitioner did not feel satisfied and filed the present writ petition challenging the impugned orders (Annexures P-4 and P-14), invoking the provisions of Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

5 Having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, having gone through the record and the relevant legal provisions with his valuable assistance and after bestowal of thoughts over the entire matter, to my mind, there is no merit in the instant writ petition in this regard.

6 Ex facie, the argument of the learned counsel that since the information with regard to movable and immovable properties and expenditure etc. is a personal information of the petitioner, which cannot be supplied and is exempted under Section 8(e)(j) of the Act, so, the impugned orders are liable to be set aside, is not only devoid of merit but misplaced as well.

7 As is evident from the record that the petitioner was working as District Food and Supplies Controller, Yamuna Nagar, at the relevant time. As per conduct Rule 18, every Government employee was required to submit a return of his assets and liabilities (property statements) in such form, as may be prescribed by the Government, giving the full particulars of his movable and immovable properties, inherited, owned, acquired or held on lease or mortgaged by him or his spouse or any member of his family, either in their own name or in the name of any other person, besides the details of movable property. Respondent No.5 has sought the information relating to the expenditure, movable and immovable properties of the petitioner and permission of the competent authority to acquire the property and nothing (confidential) else.

8 Above being the position on record, now the sole question that arises for determination in this writ petition is whether such informations fall within the exemption clause, as contemplated under Section 8(e)(j) of the Act or not.

9 Having regard to the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, to my mind, the indicated informations sought by the private respondent do not squarely fall within the ambit of exemption clause, as envisaged under Section 8(e)(j) of the Act.

10 At the very outset, the basic purpose, aims and objects of the Act have to be kept into focus, while deciding the present controversy. The Act was enacted in order to ensure smoother and deep access to information and provides an effective framework for effecting the right to information, recognised under Article 19 of the Constitution of India.

11 Section 8 of the Act is as under:-

"Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, there shall be no obligation to give any citizen,- (a) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(b) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(d) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(e) Information available to a person, in his fiduciary relationship, unless the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information.

(f) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(g) XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX XX

(h) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(i) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx

(j) Information which relates to personal information the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual unless the Central Public Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer or the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information."

12 The word "Information" has been defined under Section 2(f) of the Act to mean any material in any form, including records, documents, memos, emails, opinions, advices, press releases, circulars, orders, logbooks, contracts, reports, papers, samples, models, data material held in any electronic form and information relating, to any private body which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law for the time being in force and word Record includes - (i) any document, manuscript and file; (ii) any microfilm, microfiche and facsimile copy of a document; (iii) any reproduction of image or images embodied in such microfilm (whether enlarged or not); and (iv) any other material produced by a computer or any other device.

13 Section 2(j) of the Act defines, "right to information" means the right to information accessible under this Act which is held by or under the control of any public authority and includes the right to-(i) inspection of work, documents, records; (ii) taking notes, extracts, or certified copies of documents or records; (iii) taking certified samples of material; and (iv) obtaining information in the form of diskettes, floppies, tapes, video cassettes or in any other electronic mode or through printouts where such information is stored in a computer or in any other device.

14 Sequelly, Section 3 of the Act postulates that subject to the provisions of this Act, all citizens shall have the right to information and obligations of public authorities to maintain all its record is listed in Section 4 of the Act. Every person is entitled to information, as per procedure prescribed under Section 6 of the Act, which will be disposed of by the competent authorities under Section 7 of the Act.

15 Likewise, Proviso to Section 8 of the Act envisaged that the information, which cannot be denied to the Parliament or the State Legislature, shall not be denied to any person.

16 A co-joint reading of the aforesaid provisions would reveal, only that information is exempted, the disclosure of which, has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual, unless the authorities are satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information. Meaning thereby, as all the essential ingredients of exemption clause are totally lacking, therefore, the petitioner cannot claim its exemption. The information contained in the property statement has direct relationship with the public employment of the petitioner and cannot possibly be termed as unwarranted invasion of his privacy. Therefore, to my mind, the information sought by the respondent with regard to the sanctions, expenditure, movable and immovable properties of the petitioner, cannot possibly be termed to be exempted information, as escalated under Section 8(e)(j) of the Act, particularly when, what is not disputed here is that the petitioner being a public servant was required and submitted his detailed properties statement, as per conduct rules and the authorities under the Act, are (legally) duty bound to supply such information to respondent No.5 in this relevant behalf.

17 Again, the next submission of the learned counsel that as the petitioner was a third-party, therefore, the impugned orders cannot be passed, without affording him an opportunity of hearing, is neither tenable, nor the observations of Gujarat High Court in case Reliance Industries Limited v. Gujarat State Information Commission and others, A.I.R. 2007 Gujarat 203, are at all applicable to the facts of the present case. In that case, Rasiklal Mardia filed as many as 55 applications, for getting the following information about the petitioner and its group of companies:-

"2.2 Informations demanded by the original applicant i.e. Rasiklal Mardia (in Special Civil Application No. 16073 of 2007), are as under:-

(1) You have recommended for sales tax exemption as per Government Policy for Reliance Petrochemicals Ltd. and your department has confirmed that they have complied with terms and conditions of the Govt, as to local employment etc. Please provide complete copy, verification report done to the labourers working there with proof whatever is available with you and whether genuinely local people are employed is verified or not.

(2) Any complaint received by you that they have not complied with the local people and false certificate is issued by your office, If yes, copies of all the correspondence and copy of compliance received by you.

(3) Year-wise inspection done by your Dept. and confirmation that local people are continuously checked, confirmed their eligibility for sales tax exemption benefits and other benefits given to them for putting up the industry.

(4) If they have not complied with the terms and conditions whatever action has been initiated by your Dept. and the recommendations made by your Dept. for action to be taken against the company for not complying with terms and conditions, entire copy of the correspondence and present status.

(5) Several people died during the time of construction of Refinery. Status of that and copy confirming how many people died, action initiated by your Dept. and the present status of the cases and copy of the case papers. (Emphasis supplied)

Thus, the aforesaid informations were demanded by the original applicant i.e., Rasiklal Mardia.

These informations were pertaining to the petitioner-company and its group companies."

18 On the peculiar facts and circumstances, it was observed in that case that time- bound schedule given under the Act, will not oust a right of hearing, vested in a "thirdparty" before imparting the information, the authorities are required to satisfy about the credentials of the applicant and has to pass a speaking order and the third-party rights have to be protected.

19 Possibly, no one can dispute with regard to the aforesaid observations, but the same would not come to the rescue of the petitioner in the instant case. The word Third- Party has been defined under Section 2(n) of the Act, to mean a person other than the citizen making a request for information and includes a public authority (and not otherwise).

20 It is not a matter of dispute that respondent No.5-Shamsher Singh sought the information from the SPIO and it was the SIC, which directed the SPIO to supply the information, vide impugned speaking orders (Annexures P-4 and P-14). Since, the matter was between respondent No.5, SPIO and FAA, so, the question of providing any opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, did not arise at all, as he cannot possibly be termed to be a third-party, as defined under Section 2(n) of the Act, in the obtaining circumstances of the case. If the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner is accepted as such, then no information is permissible, which would certainly nullify the aims and objects of the Act. Therefore, the contrary arguments of the learned counsel for the petitioner stricto sensu deserve to be and are hereby repelled under the present set of circumstances.

21 No other legal point, worth consideration, has either been urged or pressed by the learned counsel for the petitioner.

22 In the light of aforesaid reasons, as there is no merit, therefore, the instant writ petition is hereby dismissed as such.