- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lal Behari Das v. Ranga Mohan Das Ranga Das
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Criminal Appeals Nos. 8 & 15 of 1995
Factual and Procedural Background
By a Sessions Court judgment dated 25.4.1995 in Sessions Case No. S.T. 107 (WT/A)/93 (West Tripura at Agartala), six of nine accused were acquitted of offences under Sections 148/149/354/326/302 IPC. Three accused were convicted: Gurupada under Section 324 IPC (one year R.I.), Lal Behari under Section 326 IPC (five years R.I. and fine Rs.2,000, in default six months R.I.), and Ranga Mohan under Section 302 IPC (life imprisonment).
The State did not appeal against the acquittals. Gurupada did not appeal his conviction. Two accused filed appeals: Lal Behari (Criminal Appeal (J) No. 8 of 1995) and Ranga Mohan Das (Criminal Appeal (J) No. 15 of 1995). By order dated 26.7.1996 the court directed that both appeals be heard analogously by a Division Bench and they were heard together.
The prosecution case (briefly) concerned an incident on 4.8.1989 where members of a family were allegedly attacked at night by several accused armed with lathi, dao, spear, etc. The deceased received fatal injuries and later died. Specific allegations in the trial record attributed a chopper blow to Lal Behari and a dao blow to Ranga Mohan; Gurupada was alleged to have assaulted another witness with a spear. FIR (Ext. P-1) was lodged the same night; inquest and post-mortem were conducted; eighteen prosecution witnesses were examined; the Investigating Officer charge-sheeted the accused under Sections 148/149/326/354/302 IPC and the case was committed to the Sessions Court where charges were framed (including Sections 148/149/302/326 IPC; Gurupada additionally under 354 IPC).
At trial, the accused were examined under Section 313 Cr. P.C. The Sessions Judge proceeded to hear argument (citing Section 234 Cr.P.C.) and to deliver judgment (citing Section 235 Cr.P.C.), following procedural stages that the opinion describes as those envisaged under Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, after taking prosecution evidence and examining the accused, the Sessions Judge complied with Section 232 Cr.P.C. by hearing the prosecution and the defence "on the point" whether there was no evidence that the accused committed the offence.
- Whether failure to record a finding under Section 232 and to call the accused to enter on defence under Section 233 Cr.P.C. vitiates conviction, or is curable (for example, under Section 465 Cr.P.C.), and under what circumstances.
- Whether any non-compliance with Sections 232/233 Cr.P.C. caused prejudice to the accused in the particular case, and if prejudice is shown, what relief should follow.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The appellants submitted that the Sessions Judge failed to comply with Section 232 Cr.P.C. (i.e., did not hear prosecution and defence on the specific point whether there was no evidence against the accused) and failed to call the accused to enter on their defence under Section 233 Cr.P.C.
- Counsel for the appellants relied on precedents (Kumar Naik 1976 Cr. L.J. 925, Sivamani 1993 Cr. L.J. 23, Parameswara Kurup 1982 Cr. L.J. 899) and submitted that on this procedural ground alone the convictions and sentences should be set aside.
- Learned counsel (Mr. D. Sarkar for Ranga Mohan Das) examined the record in detail and argued that the failure to call the accused to enter on defence caused specific prejudice to the appellants' case.
State's Arguments
- The learned Public Prosecutor (Mr. A. Ghose) did not contend that the Sessions Judge had complied with Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C., nor could he demonstrate that no prejudice had been caused to the accused by the procedural lapse.
- Earlier, in the interlocutory stage, the Public Prosecutor (Mr. S. Das) agreed with the request that both appeals be heard by the same Division Bench.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sivamani's case, 1993 Cr. L.J. 23 (Kerala) | Explains that under Section 232, after examining the accused, the Judge must hear both sides "on the point" whether there is no evidence that the accused committed the offence; only if there is no evidence can the accused be acquitted under s.232. | The court quoted and applied this reasoning to show what Section 232 requires; it used Sivamani to assess whether the Sessions Judge had followed the required procedural step. |
| Kumar Naik, 1976 Cr. L.J. 925 (Karnataka) | Used by appellants to support the proposition that non-compliance with Section 232/233 can invalidate a conviction (as cited by appellants). | The court noted that appellants relied on this decision but did not adopt it outright; instead the court compared contrary authorities before reaching its conclusion on cure and prejudice. |
| Parameswara Kurup, 1982 Cr. L.J. 899 (Kerala) | Cited by appellants as authority supporting that failure to comply with Sections 232/233 may vitiate conviction. | The court recorded that appellants referred to this decision but considered other authorities and the question of prejudice in the present case. |
| ILR (1987) Bom 962 (DB) (Bombay High Court) | Held that an irregularity in not recording a finding under Section 232 is curable under Section 465 Cr.P.C. | The court expressed agreement with this view (that certain procedural irregularities can be cured) and treated it as a counterpoint to authorities that would automatically vitiate conviction for procedural lapse. |
| Karnataka High Court, 1995 Cr. L.J. 907 | Held that failure to comply with Sections 232/233 does not ipso facto vitiate conviction; where no prejudice is caused to the accused, the conviction can stand. | The court endorsed this approach conditionally: it agreed such failure is not necessarily fatal, but emphasized that where prejudice is shown, the conviction must be set aside. The court applied this test and found prejudice in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise analytical fashion strictly on the record before it:
- Observation of record: The Sessions Judge, after prosecution evidence and examination of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C., proceeded to hear arguments under Section 234 Cr.P.C. and to deliver judgment under Section 235 Cr.P.C., following the two-stage process envisaged by Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C.
- Identification of procedural omission: The record contained no material showing that, after examining the accused, the Sessions Judge had heard the prosecution and the defence "on the point" whether there was no evidence against the accused, as required by Section 232 Cr.P.C. There was also no record showing that the accused were called upon to enter on their defence and to adduce defence evidence under Section 233 Cr.P.C.
- Particular omission in practice: The court noted that the customary question put at the end of a Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination — "Do you want to adduce any defence evidence?" — was not put to the accused. Had that question been asked, it could have operated to summon the accused to enter on their defence in substantial compliance with Section 233(1).
- Consideration of precedent conflict: The court acknowledged conflicting authorities. Some decisions (referred to by appellants) supported setting aside convictions for non-compliance; other courts (Bombay DB ILR (1987) Bom 962 and Karnataka High Court 1995 Cr.L.J. 907) took the view that such procedural irregularities are curable and do not automatically vitiate conviction, particularly where no prejudice is shown.
- Prejudice analysis: Applying the test from the authorities that allow cure where no prejudice is shown, the court examined the trial record. Counsel for the appellants (Mr. D. Sarkar) persuaded the court that in this case the failure to call the accused to enter on their defence had caused prejudice to the appellants. The Public Prosecutor could not demonstrate either compliance with Sections 232/233 or an absence of prejudice.
- Remedy: Because prejudice was established on the record, the court concluded that the convictions and sentences of the two appellants (Lal Behari Das and Ranga Mohan Das) should be set aside and the case should be remitted for re-trial from the stage of Section 232 Cr.P.C., with explicit directions to comply with Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C.
- Ancillary directions: The trial court was directed to dispose of the case within six weeks from receipt of the record. Bail directions were specified for both appellants pending retrial.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: Both appeals (Criminal Appeal (J) No. 8 of 1995 and Criminal Appeal (J) No. 15 of 1995) are allowed insofar as they relate to the two appellants; the convictions and sentences imposed on Lal Behari Das and Ranga Mohan Das are set aside and the matter is remitted for re-trial from the stage of Section 232 Cr.P.C., with directions to comply with Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C.
Direct consequences and orders made by the court:
- The impugned judgment and order stand set aside so far as they relate to the two accused appellants (Lal Behari Das and Ranga Mohan Das).
- The case is sent back to the trial court for re-trial beginning at the stage of Section 232 Cr.P.C., with directions to duly comply with Sections 232 and 233 Cr.P.C.
- The trial court is directed to dispose of the matter within six weeks from receipt of the case record.
- Bail directions pending re-trial: Lal Behari Das (who was on bail) shall remain on bail. Ranga Mohan Das shall be released on bail of Rs. 10,000 with a surety of like amount to the satisfaction of the trial court.
- Both appeals were allowed in the terms described above.
Broader implications: The opinion discusses and applies existing authorities about when procedural non-compliance under Sections 232/233 Cr.P.C. is curable. The judgment does not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond applying those authorities to the facts of this case; the remedial outcome here follows from the court's finding of prejudice on the record.
P.C Phukan, J.:— By the judgment and order dated 25.4.95 in Sessions Case No. S.T 107 (WT/A)/93, the learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura at Agartala acquitted 6 (six) of 9 (nine) accused persons of offence under Sections 148/149/354/326/302 IPC, but convicted the accused Gurupada under Section 324 IPC and sentenced him thereunder to one year's Rigorous Imprisonment, convicted the accused Lal Behari under Section 326 IPC and sentenced him thereunder to five years Rigorous Imprisonment and also to pay a fine of Rs. 2,000/-, in default, to six months' R.I and convicted the accused Ranga Mohan under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him thereunder to imprisonment for life.
2. No appeal has been presented by the State against the order of acquittal of the aforesaid six accused persons. Accused Gurupada also preferred no appeal against his conviction and sentence. However, accused Lal Behari filed criminal Appeal (J) No. 8 of 1995 and accused Ranga Mohan Das filed Criminal Appeal (J) No. 15 of 1995 against their respective conviction and sentences.
3. This court by an order dated 26.7.96 in Criminal Appeal No. 8/1995 directed as follows:
“Mr. B.B Deb, learned counsel for the appellant submits that this appeal and Criminal Appeal No. 15/95 arose out of same judgment. In Criminal Appeal No. 15/95, appellant challenged his sentence of life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC and hence that appeal can be heard only by a Division Bench. Appellant of the instant appeal was sentenced to R.I for 3(5?) years under Section 324(326?) IPC. However, he submits that both cases should be heard by the same Bench, namely, a Division Bench of this Court. Mr. S. Das, learned Public Prosecutor also submits that the prayer is reasonable.
Accordingly, I direct that this appeal should be heard analogously along with Criminal Appeal No. 15/95 by a Division Bench of this Court. Therefore, list this appeal along with Criminal Appeal No. 15/95 before a Division Bench;”
4. Pursuant to the above order, Criminal Appeal Nos. 8 and 15 of 1995 have been heard analogously and we propose to dispose of both these Appeals by this common judgment.
5. We have heard Mr. B.B Deb, learned counsel for the accused appellant Lal Behari Das in Criminal Appeal No. 8 of 1995 and Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel for the accused Appellant Ranga Mohan Das in Criminal Appeal No. 15 of 1995 as well as Mr. A. Ghose, learned Public Prosecutor appearing for the State-Respondent.
6. The prosecution case may be stated briefly as follows. On 4.8.89 at about 4. P.M P.W 1, Amrita Bhowmik along with other members of his family and two tribal girls was engaged in planting paddy in his field at Durganagar under Jirania Police Station. The accused Gurupada appeared there and tried to forcibly take one of the two tribal girls, named Smti. Rani Deb Barma P.W 11 and removed herpasra. P.W 2 Ranjit Bhowmik freed her from him and reported the incident to his father (since deceased) who, in turn, went to the house of the accused Gurupada to complain against him before his father.
7. According to the prosecution, the above incident was prelude to the actual occurrence. On the same day at about 8.30 PM when P.W 1 was discussing the above incident with the members of his family, they heard hue and cry in front of the house of one Bidhu Bhowmik (not examined) raised by P.W 4, Indrajit Bhowmik. Then P.W 1 his brother, P.W 2, mother P.W 3, Smti. Saraswati Bhowmick, uncle P.W 8, Agni Bhowmick and father (deceased) rushed to the scene and saw there all the accused persons along with 7/8 others armed with lathi, dao, spear etc. They attacked them causing injuries in their persons. The deceased succumbed to his injuries. Accused Lal Behari hit him on the head with a chopper and accused Ranga Mohan inflicted the fatal dao blow in his abdomen. Accused Gurupada injured P.W 2 Ranjit with a spear.
8. On the day of occurrence itself at about 11.45 PM P.W 1 lodged the FIR, Ext. P-1 at Jirania Police Station. In the meantime the dead body of the deceased was taken to Ranirbazar out post under Jirania Police Station. A Sub-Inspector of Police, P.W 13 held the inquest, P.W 6 the Doctor performed the post mortem examination, P.W 16, Investigating Police Officer visited the place of occurrence, Collected blood-stained earth and then went to the G.G Hospital where accused Ranga Mohan was undergoing treatment. The I.O P.W 16 examined the witnesses and on completion of investigation charge-sheeted all the accused persons under Sections 148/149/326/354/302 IPG. The learned Judicial Magistrate committed the case to the Court of Sessions under the aforesaid Sections of law.
9. In the Court of Session, charges were framed against all the accused persons under Sections 148/149/302/326 IPC, against Gurupada under Section 354 IPC and against accused Lal Behari and Ranga Mohan under Section 302 IPC. The charges were framed, read over and explained to accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
10. In the trial, the evidence of 18 witnesses for prosecution was taken and the accused persons were examined under Section 313 Cr. P.C Regarding such examination the Sessions Court's order dated 9.4.95 reads as under:
“9.4.95 All the 9 (nine) accd. persons, on bail, are present.
Ld. Addl. PP is present.
All the accd. persons are examined u/s. 313 Cr. P.C
Ld. Addl. PP verbally prays for time for argument.
Considered, prayer for time is allowed.
Fix 6.4.95 for argument.”
11. Accordingly, arguments were heard in part on 6.4.95, 10.4.95 and 13.4.95 and concluded on 20.4.95 The learned Sessions Judge fixed 25.5.95 for judgment and on that date delivered the impugned judgment acquitting the six accused persons and convicting and sentencing the remaining three including the two accused appellants as stated above.
12. It transpires from the Sessions Court's order dated 9.4.95 quoted above and the subsequent orders that the learned Sessions Judge after taking the evidence for prosecution and examining the accused persons proceeded to hear argument (under Section 234 Cr. P.C) and to deliver the judgment (under Section 235 Cr. P.C) by passing the two stages as envisaged under Sections 232 and 233 Cr. P.C
These two sections read as under:
“232. Acquittal. - If, after taking the evidence for the prosecution, examining the accused and hearing the prosecution and the defence on the point, the Judge considers that there is no evidence that the accused committed the offence, the Judge shall record an order of acquittal.
233. Entering upon defence. - (I) Where the accused is not acquitted under Section 232, he shall be called upon to enter on his defence and adduce any evidence he may have in support thereof.”
13. In the instant case there is nothing on record to show that after taking evidence for prosecution and examining the accused persons, learned Sessions Judge heard the prosecution and the defence on the point whether there is no evidence that the accused committed the offence as required under Section 232 Cr. P.C
14. In this regard, it was held in Sivamani's case 1993 Criminal Law Journal 23 as follows:
“11. Under the first Section (S. 232) after examining the accused, the Judge has to hear both sides “on the point”. The point is whether the Judge can consider that there is no evidence in the case that the accused committed the offences. The manner of examination of the accused is provided in S. 313 of the Code. The commencing words in S. 233 of the Code i.e “Where the accused is not acquitted under S-232……..” would make it clear that an accused has to be directed to enter upon his defence if he cannot be acquitted under S. 232. An accused can be acquitted under S. 232 only when I there is no evidence that he committed the offence.”
15. Although in the instant case the accused persons were not acquitted under Section 232 Cr. P.C there is nothing on record to show that they were ever called upon to enter on their defence and to adduce any defence evidence. What is worse, the learned Sessions Judge while examining the accused persons under Section 313 Cr. P.C did not put to them the usual question “Do you want to adduce any defence evidence ?” invariably put at the end of such examination with rare exception. Had the learned Sessions Judge put this question to the accused persons, it could have been construed an amounting to calling upon him to enter on their defence and adduce defence evidence in substantial compliance with the requirements of Section 233(1) Cr. P.C
16. Learned counsels appearing for the accused appellants have submitted that on this score alone, the conviction and sentences awarded to the accused appellants by the impugned judgment and order are liable to be set aside and in support thereof have referred to the decisions in Kumar Naik's case 1976 Cr. L.J 925 (Karnataka), Sivamani's case, 1993 Cr. LJ 23 (Kerala) and Parameswara Kurup's case, 1982 Cr. LJ 899 (Kerala). We are, however, inclined to agree with the different view taken by the Bombay High Court in ILR (1987) Bom 962 (DB) that an irregularity in not recording a finding under Section 232 Cr. P.C that it is not a case of no evidence would not vitiate the trial but is curable under Section 465 Cr. P.C We are also in agreement with the view taken by the Karnataka High Court in 1995 Cr. LJ 907 wherein it has been held, inter alia,—
Section 232/233 Cr. P.C lay down the procedure to be followed by the Sessions Court in the process of trial of an accused person. It is one thing to say that the said procedure should be complied with. However, it is quite another thing to say that failure on be part of the Sessions Court to comply with the said procedure would ipso facto vitiate the conviction. The failure on the part of the Judge to call upon the accused persons to enter on his defence in terms of S. 233, Cr. P.C, would not in all cases vitiate the conviction, if there are materials to indicate that no prejudice what-so-ever has been caused to the accused. In other words, if on the facts of a particular case, no prejudice can be said to have been caused on account of the failure to comply with the procedure as laid down under S. 233 Cr. P.C conviction cannot be said to be vitiated.
17. On the question of prejudice, Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel for the accused appellants, has led us minutely through the record of the case and has succeeded in convincing us that in the instant case failure to call upon the accused persons to enter on their evidence and to adduce defence evidence has caused prejudice to them in their defence. Learned Public Prosecutor could not submit that in this case learned Sessions Judge complied with the requirements of Section 232 and 233 Cr. P.C nor could he show us that there were materials on record to indicate that no prejudice had been caused to the accused persons.
18. In view of what has been stated above, we set aside the conviction and sentence awarded to the two accused appellants and send back the case to the trial court for re-trial from the stage of Section 232 Cr. P.C duly complying with the provisions of Section 232 and 233 Cr. P.C The impugned judgment and order stands set aside so far as it relates to two accused appellants.
19. The learned trial Court shall dispose of this case within six weeks from the date of receipt of the case record.
20. The accused Lal Behari Das is on bail, he shall remain on bail pending disposal of this case by the learned Session Judge. Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel for the other accused Ranga Mohan Das prays that he be released on bail pending disposal of this case by the learned trial Court. On this point we have heard Mr. A. Ghose, learned Public Prosecutor and after careful consideration of the entire matter, it is ordered that the accused Ranga Mohan Das shall be released on bail of Rs. 10,000/- with a surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned trial court.
Both the appeals are allowed as indicated above.
Alert