Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Devajit Chaliha…(Petitioner); v. Harendra Nath Baruah And Ors.…(S).

Gauhati High Court
Apr 12, 1971
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Goswami, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is an electrical engineer who obtained B.S.E.E and M.S.E.E degrees from Purdue University (1952), worked in the United States and with Assam Oil Company, and later joined the Government of Assam's Electricity Department and various engineering colleges as a professor and head of department. From June 1967 he was "allowed to hold charge" of the duties of the Principal of an engineering institute, and this arrangement was extended in July 1968.

On 5 June 1968 the Assam Public Service Commission advertised the post of Principal. The petitioner applied and was interviewed on 29 January 1969 along with other candidates. The interview was conducted by the Chairman and one Member of the Commission, with an external expert present. The Commission recommended only the Respondent No. 1 for appointment.

The petitioner made a representation to the Education Minister (18 February 1969) objecting to the nomination; the Government replied that they found "no apparent reason" to reject the Commission's nomination. The petitioner then obtained a returnable Rule on 23 May 1969 under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging the nomination on various grounds, principally that the interview was unlawful because insufficient members of the Commission participated.

The matter was initially heard by a Division Bench (22 September 1969), and due to a question about a prior Division Bench decision (A.C. Sarkar v. State of Assam), the case was placed before the Full Bench for final hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an interview conducted by the Chairman and one Member of the Assam Public Service Commission (when Regulation 4, as amended, provided for a Commission consisting of a Chairman and two or more Members not exceeding three) is invalid and, on that account, the recommendation arising from that interview cannot be treated as the recommendation of the Commission.
  2. Whether the application under Article 226 challenging the Commission's recommendation is maintainable (a preliminary objection raised by the learned Senior Government Advocate).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. S.M. Lahiri)

  • The Assam Public Service Commission had been constituted under Article 316(1) and Regulation 4 (as amended) provided that the Commission should consist of a Chairman and two or more Members not exceeding three. In the instant case the Commission was allegedly manned by the Chairman and three other Members.
  • Because the interview was conducted only by the Chairman and one Member (i.e., only two members participated), the recommendation of only two members did not amount to a recommendation of the Commission and was therefore invalid and without jurisdiction.
  • Initially suggested that the Division Bench decision in A.C. Sarkar's case might require reconsideration but ultimately did not press for reconsideration and instead relied upon that decision to support his submissions.
  • Relied upon various precedents (including U.C. Bank v. Their Workmen, A.K. Kraipak, SB Kishorilal, and Sheik Hussain & Sons) in support of the contention that composition requirements can render a decision invalid.

Respondent / Government Arguments

  • The petition did not originally challenge the constitution of the Commission or the Board of Interview in the petitioner’s earlier representation to the Education Minister.
  • The Government informed the petitioner that they found "no apparent reason" to reject the Commission's nomination.
  • A preliminary objection was taken by the learned Senior Government Advocate that the application was premature and that the petitioner had no legal right to invoke Article 226 (i.e., maintainability of the petition was contested).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.C. Sarkar v. State of Assam (Assam LR (1969) Assam & Nagaland 202; appeal dismissed in Assam LR 1970 SC 8) Earlier Division Bench holding that a Commission consisting of the Chairman and another member could lawfully exercise functions where vacancies existed; question of composition was raised in appeal to the Supreme Court but the appeal was dismissed without dealing with the composition issue. The Court adopted the view in A.C. Sarkar, found no reason to reconsider it, and held it did not support the petitioner's contention that the interview in the present case was invalid due to composition.
U.C. Bank v. Their Workmen, AIR 1951 SC 230 Case under Section 7 of the Industrial Disputes Act where a three-member tribunal's award made by only two members was held to be without jurisdiction and void. The Court distinguished this case as inapplicable because the Industrial Disputes Act contained specific statutory provisions governing tribunal composition and operation; hence it was of no assistance to the petitioner.
A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 262; AIR 1970 SC 150 Held that a Selection Board's decision was vitiated by bias, and recommendations were set aside on that ground. The Court stated this authority could not assist the petitioner on the facts, as the challenge in the present case was composition/vacancy related rather than bias-based.
SB Kishorilal v. The State, AIR 1931 Assam 169 Case under the Preventive Detention Act where detention was quashed because the Advisory Board's consideration by all three members led to a finding that fundamental rights under Article 21 had been infringed. The Court found this precedent inapplicable to the present controversy, as the nature of adjudicatory/quasi-judicial proceedings affecting fundamental rights differs from advisory/consultative functions of the Public Service Commission.
Sheik Hussain & Sons v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1964 Andh. Pra. 36 (Full Bench) Held that a tribunal whose composition did not conform to statutory requirements had no jurisdiction to decide questions under the statute. The Court held this decision was not helpful. It distinguished judicial/quasi-judicial tribunals from the Commission's advisory role in recommending suitability for appointment, particularly where consultation under Article 320(3) is not mandatory.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the principal point: whether the interview conducted by the Chairman and a single Member (in the absence of the other Members) was invalid and thereby the Commission's recommendation void.

The Court examined the constitutional provisions relevant to the Commission's functioning, specifically Articles 316(1), 316(1-A) and 317(2), and the Assam Public Service Commission Regulations, 1951 (Regulation 4 as amended in 1968). Regulation 4 (as amended) provided that "The Commission shall consist of a Chairman and two or more Members not exceeding three, as may be determined by the Governor from time to time and shall be appointed by the Governor."

The Court observed that Articles 316(1-A) and 317(2) contemplate contingencies in which the Chairman may be unavailable and provide for the Commission to continue to function with remaining members, including appointment by the Governor of one of the other members to perform Chairman's functions temporarily. From these provisions the Court concluded that the Commission does not automatically cease to function upon vacancies or temporary unavailability of members.

The Court reasoned that conducting an interview to recommend candidates for appointment "need not require the presence of all the members of the Commission." It stated that, in the absence of any rule to the contrary, any one or two members may be entrusted with interviewing duties. This arrangement was characterized as an internal working matter of a responsible body that can be trusted to act with propriety and fairness.

The Court further noted that the petitioner had not challenged the constitution of the Commission, and the petitioner's stated objection was limited to the contention that the recommendation resulted from an "illegal interview." The Court found this objection "devoid of substance."

The Court reviewed and distinguished the authorities relied on by the petitioner (e.g., U.C. Bank, A.K. Kraipak, SB Kishorilal, Sheik Hussain & Sons), explaining that those decisions arose under different statutory schemes or involved judicial/quasi-judicial bodies where composition rules were of a different and more stringent character. The Court relied on the earlier A.C. Sarkar decision of this Court and noted the Supreme Court had dismissed appeals in that matter; it concluded there was no reason to depart from that view.

Finally, the Court stated that because it resolved the case on the merits against the petitioner, it was unnecessary to consider the preliminary objection as to maintainability raised by the Senior Government Advocate.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the petition challenging the Commission's recommendation fails and is dismissed; the Court made "no order as to costs."
  • The Court treated the Commission's recommendation as valid despite the interview having been conducted by only the Chairman and one Member; the Court relied on constitutional provisions (Articles 316(1-A) and 317(2)) and prior authority (A.C. Sarkar) to reach this conclusion.
  • The opinion does not undertake to state broader legal consequences beyond the decision in this case; it does not purport to lay down a new or general precedent beyond its application to the facts and legal materials before the Court.

Disposition: Petition dismissed. No order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

Goswami, C.J:— In this application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner states that he obtained the Degree of Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering (B.S.E.E) from the Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana (U.S.A) and thereafter obtained the Degree of Master of Science in Electrical Engineering (M.S.E.E) from the same University in the year 1952, specializing in High Voltage Engineering. The petitioner bad worked in the United States as well as in the Assam Oil Company before he was appointed as an Engineer-in-charge of Erection at the Umtru Hydel Project site in the Electricity Department of the Government of Assam. He was sent on deputation for six months to the Assam Engineering College Gauhati, as Assistant Professor of Electrical Engineering and he chose to continue in that post. In August, 1960 he was transferred to the Jorhat Engineering College: In 1962 he was transferred again to the Assam Engineering College at Gauhati and was placed in charge of the Electrical Engineering Department there. In November of the same year, he was selected by the Government of India for a Teacher Training Programme in U.S.A under the U.S Agency for International Development (T.C.M) Programme. On return from U.S.A he joined as a Professor of Electrical Engineering in the Jorhat Engineering College in 1964. By Annexure ‘A’ dated June, 1967, he was “allowed to hold. In addition to his own duties, the charge of the current duties of the post of Principal of the same Institute for a period of six months or till the post of Principle is filled up by regular appointment whichever is earlier with effect from 1-6-67”. This was necessary because Prof. R.J Thaker, who was earlier allowed to bold charge of the current duties of the Principal, was released on expiry of the term of his contract service. By Annexure ‘B’ dated 18th July, 1968, the petitioner was “allowed to hold charge of the current duties of the post of the Principal of the same Institute in addition to his own duties for a further period till the appointment of the Principal……”

2. On 5th June, 1968, an advertisement was made in the Assam Gazette (vide Annexure ‘C’) by the Assam Public Service Commission, hereinafter called ‘the Commission’ inviting applications for the post of the Principal, along with some other posts, prescribing the qualifications etc., for the post. The petitioner applied for the post in answer to the aforesaid advertisement and he along with three other candidates including the Respondent No. 1 were interviewed for the said post by the Commission on 29th Jauuary, 1969. The interview of the petitioner and the other candidates was held by the Chairman and another Member of the Commission. There was also Sri A.Z Ahmed, Retired Chief Engineer, present in the Interview with the Members as an expert. After the interview, the Commission recommended only one name, that of the Respondent No. 1 for the appointment.

3. The petitioner represented to the Education Minister objecting to the nomination and praying for considering his case favorably. The petitioner did not object to the constitution of the Commission or to the Board of interview in this representation dated 18th February, 1969. The petitioner was Informed that “the Government do not find any apparent reason for not accepting the said nomination of the Assam Public Service Commission”. The petitioner then obtained the present returnable Rule on 23rd May, 1969 challenging the nomination of the Commission on various grounds.

4. When this Rule was heard by a Division Bench of this Court on 22nd September, 1969, the petitioner's counsel submitted that a Division Bench decision of this Court since reported in Assam LR (1969) Assam and Nagaland 202 (A.C Sarkar v. State of Assam) would require reconsideration and that is bow this case has come before this Full Bench. When, however, the matter came up before us for final hearing Mr. S.M Lahiri, the learned counsel, clearly submitted that be does not want reconsideration of the aforesaid decision and, according to his submission, the same does not require reconsideration. On the other hand, the learned counsel submits that he will rely upon this decision in support of his submission which he wants to advance before this Court. In the course of the argument, we indicated to the learned counsel that it would be perfectly open to him to give us any reasons he chooses to reconsider the aforesaid decision, but he did not make any attempt in that respect. The learned counsel took us through the decision and we do not find any reason to reconsider the same, which, according to us, is correct.

5. Mr. Lahiri submits that the Commission has been constituted by the Governor under Article 316(1) of the Constitution. The Governor has also made a Regulation known as ‘The Assam Public Service Commission Regulations, 1951’ under Art. 318 of the Constitution. Regulation 4 as amended by the Assam Public Service Commission (Amendment) Regulations, 1968, reads as follows:

“The Commission shall consist of a Chairman and two or more Members not exceeding three, as may be determined by the Governor from time to time and shall be appointed by the Governor.”

6. The previous Regulation 4 provided for ‘one or more Members not exceeding two’. Mr. Lahiri submits that the Commission under the amended Regulation was constituted of the Chairman and three other Members and since the interview was conducted only by the Chairman and another Member, in absence of the remaining two Members, the recommendation of only two Members was not the recommendation of the Commission and the same is invalid and without jurisdiction. Secondly he submits that Assam LR (1969) Assam and Naga 202 (supra) to establish that the Commission with the minimum number namely the Chairman and the two Members provided for under the Regulation must participate in the interview in order to confer the status of recommendation of the Commission under the law. It should be observed that this point in this form was not taken in the petition at the time of obtaining the Rule. Even so, we have allowed the learned counsel to address us on the two points, notwithstanding the objection of the learned Senior Government Advocate.

7. This Court granted a certificate to appeal to the Supreme Court in A.C Sarkar's case, Assam LR (1969) Assam and Naga 202 (supra) and the Supreme Court dismissed the appeals by the decision in Assam LR 1970 SC 8 (A.C Sarkar v. State of Assam). The Supreme Court observed that ‘the appellants questioned the composition of the Public Service Commission’, but did not deal with the submission, while dismissing the appeals.

8. The principal point therefore, that calls for a decision is whether in this particular case the interview being conducted by the Chairman and a Member of the Commission, without the two other remaining Members, is invalid and on that account cannot be said to be a recommendation of the Commission.

9. The constitution of the Commission as such has not been challenged by the learned counsel and indeed it cannot be challenged in view of the submission of the learned counsel that our earlier decision (A.C Sarkar's case) Assam LR (1969) Assam and Naga 202 does not require any reconsideration and on the basis of which he seeks to make out a case. Further, the petitioner does not deny that the nomination of the Respondent No. 1 was made by the Commission, His whole objection as can be seen from paragraph 28 of his application is that the Commission made recommendation ‘pursuant to the aforesaid illegal interview dated 29-1-69 for its acceptance by the Government of Assam’. This objection is devoid of substance. Mr. Lahiri submits that in A.C Sarkar's case, the Commission was manned by the Chairman and another Member, but the vacancy on the retirement of the Third Member was not filled up. Since, however, under the Regulation then in force, the minimum number was two namely the Chairman and another Member, the interview conducted by two members was unexceptionable. The learned counsel submits that in the instant case, the interview being conducted by the Chairman and another Member when the minimum number under the amended Regulation is three, is absolutely invalid and without jurisdiction. This argument however does not bear scrutiny when we take into consideration Articles 316(I-A) and 317(2) of the Constitution. Omitting the portion that is not necessary for our purpose, Articles 316(I-A) and 317(2) read as follows:

“If the office of the Chairman of the Commission becomes vacant or if any Chairman is by reason of absence or for any other reason unable to perform the duties of his office, those duties shall, until some person appointed under Clause (1) to the vacant office has entered on the duties thereof or, as the case may be, until the Chairman has resumed his duties be performed by such one of the other members of the Commission………. and the Governor of the State in the case of a State Commission, may appoint for the purpose.”

Article 317(2):

“………the Governor, in the case of a State Commission, may suspend from office the Chairman or any other member of the Commission in respect of whom a reference has been made to the Supreme Court under Clause (1) until the President has passed orders on receipt of the report on the Supreme Court on such reference”.

10. The above are the contingencies in which the Chairman of the Commission may become unavailable. The Commission shall be continued to function with the remaining members, one of whom will be appointed by the Governor to exercise the functions of the Chairman under Article 316(I-A) during the period. The Commission does not come to an and the moment the Chairman becomes unavailable. This would go to show that the Commission can function and carry out its various duties even though there may be a vacancy on a certain member or members becoming unavailable either permanently or temporarily. It is understandable that sometime, although not inordinately long time, may be taken by the Governor in filing up the vacancies. Besides, conducting of an interview for recommending certain candidates for appointment on the ground of suitability, need not require the presence of all the members of the Commission. Any one or two members may be entrusted with the duty in absence of any rules to the contrary. This is an internal working of the Commission which is highly responsible body and can be trusted to discharge their duties with due regard to high propriety and fairness to all concerned. We are, therefore, clearly of opinion that the interview conducted by the Chairman and another Member in the case of the petitioner is not without jurisdiction, nor is the recommendation as a result of that interview can be said to be invalid under the law. We have not been shown any rules which debiar the Commission to work in compartments while interviewing candidates for appointment.

11. In the earlier case (A.C Sarkar's case), Assam LR (1969) Assam & Naga 202 also we took the same view as will appear from the following passage at Para 12:

“The Governor at a particular time may not think it fit to fill in the vacancy and yet the Commission which is existing with the Chairman and another member does not cease to be a Commission under Article 316(1) read with 318(a) and Regulation 4. The Commission which interviewed the petitioners was perfectly competent under the law to exercise its functions.

We may also in this context notice that the Article 316(1-A) provides for the contingency when the office of the Chairman of the Commission becomes vacant. This would go to show that there is no illegality per se of the Commission continuing to function with one member less under certain circumstances. Article 317(2) also makes provision for another contingency under some other specified circumstances.”

12. We are, therefore, unable to accede to the argument that A.C Sarkar's case supports the contention of the learned counsel.

13. Mr. Lahiri relied upon the decision in AIR 1951 SC 230 (U.C Bank v. Their Workmen). This was a case with regard to the constitution of a tribunal of three members under Section 7 of the Industrial Disputes Act, whereas the award was made by two of them. The Supreme Court held that the award by two members in absence of adjudication by all the three constituting the tribunal was without jurisdiction and void. The Court came to this conclusion after examining the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act and made a reference to Section 5(4) of the Act where a provision has been made with regard to a Board of Conciliation enabling it to act “notwithstanding the absence of the chairman or any of its members or any vacancy in its number.” This decision is therefore of no assistance to the learned Counsel.

14. Another decision cited is (1969) 2 SCC 262 : AIR 1970 SC 150 (A.K Kraipak v. Union of India). The Court held in this case that the decision of the Selection Board was vitiated on account of bias and therefore the final recommendations made on the selection made by the Selection Board were also vitiated and the Court set aside the impugned selection. This decision can hardly come to the assistance of the learned counsel.

15. The learned counsel also referred to AIR 1931 Assam 169 (SB) Kishorilal v. The State) which was a case under the Preventive Detention Act, 1950. The order of detention was quashed as the detenu's case was considered by all the three members of the Advisory Board. This was a matter where the fundamental right of the detenu as guaranteed under Art. 21 of the Constitution has been held to be infringed. This case is not at all applicable to the present controversy.

16. Mr. Lahiri also referred to AIR 1964 Andh. Pra. 36 (FB) which is Full Bench decision (Sheik Hussain & Sons v. State of Andhra Pradesh). This was a case under the Motor Vehicles Act with regard to an appeal before the State Transport Authority constituted and composed provided under Section 44(2) of the Act. The Court held that a tribunal, whose composition is not in accordance with the statutory requirement, has no jurisdiction to decide a question arising under the statute. This decision is also of no assistance in the present controversy. Action of a judicial or quasi-judicial authority affecting the rights of parties is altogether on a different plane from that of the Commission in the matter of advising upon suitability of candidates for appointment in the service of the State. This is particularly so when consultation under Article 320(3) of the Constitution is not even mandatory.

17. In the view we have taken on the merits, it is not necessary to consider the preliminary objection of the learned Senior Government Advocate to the maintainability of the application on the ground of it being premature and also because the petitioner has no legal right to move this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.

18. In the result, the application fails and is dismissed. We will however, make no order as to costs.

M.C Pathak, J.:— I agree.

B.N Sarma, J.:— I agree.

19. Petition dismissed.