Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Achyut Chandra Pathak v. State Of Assam

Gauhati High Court
Dec 18, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Brijesh Kumar, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These appeals arise from a common judgment and order dated 23.9.1998 of a learned Single Judge disposing of a number of Civil Rule petitions (including Civil Rule No. 4411 of 1995). The appeals were bunched because they involved common questions concerning the regularisation of services of employees engaged on contingent/daily wages/work charge/muster roll basis.

The petitioners were employees of various Government of Assam departments (Public Works Department, Irrigation, Forest, Public Health Engineering, etc.) who had worked continuously for long periods in non-regular positions and sought regularisation of their services. The Single Judge considered the merits, particularly with reference to regulatory provisions in the Assam Public Works Department Code (where available), and found that long continuance alone did not entitle one to regularisation unless there were sanctioned posts available.

The appeals challenge that part of the Single Judge's order which declined to regularise employees appointed after the cut-off date of 1.4.1993. The High Court heard counsel for the appellants and the Additional Senior Government Advocate for the State and delivered this common judgment disposing of the 34 writ appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether employees engaged on contingent/daily wages/work charge/muster roll basis after 1.4.1993 are entitled to regularisation of service.
  2. Whether regularisation is legally possible in the absence of duly sanctioned posts or a governmental scheme or statutory rule permitting such regularisation.
  3. Whether the fixation of the cut-off date of 1.4.1993 (for regularisation eligibility) was arbitrary or discriminatory and therefore liable to be struck down.
  4. Whether the State's policy decision (fixing a cut-off date and restricting further recruitment) is amenable to judicial interference.
  5. Whether the Government letter dated 20.4.1995 could serve as the basis for fixing a different cut-off date (viz. 20.4.1995) or otherwise alter entitlement to regularisation.
  6. Whether persons appointed after 1.4.1993 could at least be given consideration for regular appointment (including relief such as age relaxation or weightage for experience) when bona fide vacancies are filled in future.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The cut-off date of 1.4.1993 is arbitrary and discriminatory; all contingent/daily wage/work charge/muster roll employees form one class and long service should entitle them to equal consideration for regularisation irrespective of date of appointment.
  • If a cut-off date is to be fixed, it should be 20.4.1995 because the Chief Secretary’s letter dated 20.4.1995 reiterated directions for early absorption/regularisation and action against officers who appointed workers after the relevant date.
  • Even if full regularisation cannot be directed, appellants appointed after 1.4.1993 should at least be considered for regular appointment when vacancies arise; their long service ought to justify age relaxation and weightage for experience.

Respondent (State) Arguments

  • Regularisation cannot be directed in the absence of duly sanctioned posts or a governmental scheme/statutory provision permitting such regularisation; reliance is placed on Supreme Court precedents to this effect.
  • The State had taken a policy decision (from 1983 and further reviewed in 1993) to regularise certain categories and to fix 1.4.1993 as the cut-off after parleys with unions; policy decisions of this nature should not be judicially disturbed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. & others vs. Ajay Kumar, (1997) 4 SCC 88 Daily wage/contingent appointments relate to contingent establishment where there is no post; regularisation requires existence of a post and either administrative instructions or statutory rules; direction to regularise was held illegal in those facts. The Court relied on this principle to hold that mere long continuance as daily wage/contingent worker does not entitle one to regularisation in absence of sanctioned posts or rules permitting regularisation.
Union of India vs. Uma Maheswari & others, (1997) 11 SCC 228 In absence of any scheme framed by the Government for regularisation of casual workers, courts cannot direct regularisation; if a scheme exists the State should consider eligible persons under it. Applied to support the view that without a statutory scheme or policy for post-1993 appointees, the court cannot direct their regularisation; the matter rests with the State if it frames a scheme.
Ashwani Kumar & others vs. State of Bihar & others, (1997) 2 SCC 1 Appointments in excess of sanctioned posts are bad; regularisation is not possible unless posts exist; entry into service against procedure and without budgetary backing gives no right to regularisation. Used to reinforce that over-strength or unauthorised appointments do not create a right to regularisation; the Court emphasised the need for sanctioned posts or proper procedure.
State of Haryana & others vs. Raichand Jain & others, (1997) 5 SCC 167 Policy decisions of the State (for example, restricting back wages by policy) are generally not interfered with by courts. Invoked to support the proposition that the State's policy decisions about regularisation and related financial/administrative choices are not ordinarily subject to judicial interference.
State of Punjab & others vs. Ram Lubhaya Bagga & others, (1998) 4 SCC 167 Wisdom of a policy decision by the State is not to be judicially scrutinised; policy decisions (e.g., restricting assistance within resources) may be upheld, subject to being non-arbitrary and lawful. Relied upon to affirm that the Court should not substitute its judgment for the State’s in matters of policy, while retaining the power to ensure that policy is not arbitrary or legally violative.
State of Orissa & others vs. Mamtarani Sahoo & another, (1998) 8 SCC 753 If the State frames a scheme for regularisation, the benefit of such a scheme should not be denied to persons who are eligible under it. Cited to indicate that if the State creates a regularisation scheme for post-1993 appointees, those appellants should not be excluded from consideration under that scheme.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner, adhering closely to the Single Judge's findings and the Supreme Court authorities cited:

  1. The factual premise: the petitioners had been working continuously on contingent/daily wages/work charge/muster roll basis in various Departments for long durations and sought regularisation.
  2. Legal threshold: the Court emphasised the long-established legal requirement that regularisation presupposes the availability of duly sanctioned posts or an enabling statutory/administrative scheme; mere long service in contingent appointments is insufficient. The Court relied on the cited Supreme Court precedents to support this threshold proposition.
  3. Categorisation: petitioners were split into two groups—appointed prior to 1.4.1993 and appointed thereafter. The State had itself formulated and pursued a scheme for phased regularisation of those appointed prior to 1.4.1993, and the Single Judge properly directed adherence to that scheme; there was no grievance as regards that category.
  4. Validity of cut-off date: appellants challenged 1.4.1993 as arbitrary. The Court examined the material (decision of parleys between State and unions in April 1993, circulation by letter dated 16.4.1993 (Annexure B/2), and an Office Memorandum dated 11.10.1993) and concluded the cut-off date resulted from a policy decision in consultations and so was not arbitrary or without basis. The Court rejected the submission that the 20.4.1995 letter fixed the cut-off date, finding that letter merely reiterated earlier directions regarding pre-1.4.1993 appointees.
  5. Scope for judicial review of policy: relying on precedents, the Court observed that policy decisions (such as fixing eligibility and financial limits) are primarily within the executive domain and are not to be lightly interfered with by courts, subject to non-arbitrariness and legality.
  6. Discretion left to the Government: the Single Judge had left the consideration of post-1.4.1993 appointments to the State Government, in consultation with the Finance Department, making clear that such workers have no right to regularisation as a matter of course; the High Court found no error in leaving the matter to the executive.
  7. The Court addressed equitable considerations: while denying a right to regularisation, the Court observed that, should sanctioned posts and vacancies arise in future, eligible persons (including appellants) would be entitled to consideration on an equal footing. It noted that, consistent with Ashwani Kumar (para 19), appropriate sympathetic relaxations (such as age relaxation for time served or weightage for experience) may be given if such persons are considered eligible alongside other candidates—but emphasised this is consideration, not an automatic entitlement to regularisation.
  8. Accountability of appointing officers: the Court criticised appointments made in excess of requirement and in disregard of Government instructions, noting such flouting creates problems; the Court observed that disciplinary action was suggested by government communications, but whether such action was taken was not known to the Court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: All 34 writ appeals are dismissed.

Direct consequences and specific orders:

  • The part of the Single Judge's order declining to regularise employees appointed after 1.4.1993 is upheld.
  • The State's policy decision to regularise appointees prior to 1.4.1993 is sustained and remains applicable across Departments.
  • The Court left the question of consideration of post-1.4.1993 employees entirely to the State Government (in concurrence with the Finance Department) if it chooses to make any policy or scheme; no judicial direction to regularise such employees was issued.
  • No order as to costs; interim orders, if any, are discharged.

Broader implications: The decision reaffirms established legal principles (as reflected in cited Supreme Court authorities) that regularisation requires sanctioned posts or a valid scheme and that policy decisions of the State on such administrative matters are primarily for the executive to take; the Court did not announce any new legal principle or depart from the cited precedents.

Show all summary ...

Brijesh Kumar, C.J.

This bunch of appeals arises out of the judgment and order dated 23.9.98, passed by the learned Single Judge disposing of a number of Civil Rule No. 4411 of 1995 and others, by above noted common judgment, since the points involved for consideration were common to all the petitions. The appellants are aggrieved by a part of the order of the learned Single Judge, which relates to the question of regularisation of services of the employees working on contingent/daily wages/muster roll/work charge basis, having been appointed after 1.4.1993. In all the appeals same questions are involved, hence they have been bunched together and they are being disposed of by this common judgment.

2. We have heard Shri AK Phukan, Shri N, Dutta, Shri KN Choudhury, Shri R. Gogoi, Shri BK Sharma, Dr H. Das, Shri BP Kataky, Shri MK Choudhury, Shri DR Gogoi, and Shri DS Bhattacharyya, learned counsel appearing for the appellants in the respective appeals, as well as Shri BC Das, learned Addl Senior Govt Advocate, Assam appearing for the respondents.

3. In all the petitions filed by the employees they are working on contingent/ daily wages/work charge/muster roll basis continuously for long periods, the petitioners had prayed for their regularisation in the services. Such employees were engaged by different Departments of the Govt, namely, Public Works Department (PWD), Irrigation Department, Forest Department, Public Health Engineering Department (PHE Department), etc. Learned Single Judge has gone into the merit of the matter in some detail, more particularly, in reference to the provisions as contained in the Assam Public Works Department Code, relating to engagement oh contingent work charge daily wage basis. In the other departments, it has been found that no such code or regulatory provisions are available. However, there was no denial of the fact that in all these Departments thousands of employees had been appointed and have been working since long durations. It has also been found that in the PW Department, persons in excess of requirement had been engaged by the officers concerned at their level. Learned Single Judge has found, and rightly, that mere fact of long continuance by itself would not be sufficient to regularise the services of an employee unless posts duly sanctioned exist and are available for their being filled up on regular basis. The petitioners, as found, had been engaged for performing work on non regular basis according to the exigency and the need of the moment for doing the work till the completion of a particular project or to meet any other requirement of temporary nature.

4. So far the position as it stands under the law relating to ad hoc or contingent engagements and regularisation of such employees is concerned, it is clear that regularisation in service of such employees may not be possible in absence of posts duly sanctioned being available, against which one can be regularised. Learned counsel for the State has referred to certain decisions of Hon'ble Supreme Court on the above proposition, as reported in (1997) 4 SCC 88, State of UP & others vs. Ajay Kumar. The Court observed thus in para 3 of the judgment as follows:

The admitted position is that the respondent came to be appointed on daily wage basis on 14.2.85 as class IV employee, Nursing Orderly, in the Medical College by the Medical Superintendent. When the respondent filed a writ petition in the High Court for his regularisation, the learned Single Judge pointed out that the respondent has not brought to the notice of the Court, any statutory rule under which the respondent could be regularised, on the basis of the service rendered by him as a daily wage earner. Even the' method of recruitment adopted by the Superintendent was not proper inasmuch as he did not call for applications. The Division Bench reversed the decision of the learned Single Judge and had given directions. It is now settled legal position that there should exist a post and either administrative instructions or statutory rules must be in operation to appoint a person to the post. Daily wage appointment will obviously be in relation to contingent establishment in which there cannot exist any post and it continues so long as the work exists. Under these circumstances, the Division Bench was clearly in error in directing the appellant to regularise the service of the respondent to the post as and when the vacancy arises and to continue him until then. The direction in the back drop of the above facts is, obviously, illegal.

5. In (1997) 11 SCC 228, Union of India vs. Uma Maheswari & others, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that in absence of any scheme having been framed by the Govt for regularisation of casual workers or any other provision under the law, it would not be possible to issue any direction for regularisation of such employees as no regular work would be available for the posts for which a claim was advanced by the petitioners. It was further held that if some scheme has been framed, as was given out, the State would consider the cases of all eligible persons entitled for regularisation under the scheme.

6. In yet another decision reported in (1997) 2 SCC 1, Ashwani Kumar & others vs. State of Bihar & others, it has been held that where the appointments have been made in excess of sanctioned posts such appointments were bad. It was further held that there could not be any regularisation unless posts exist against which such regularisation could be made. It was held that where the entry into the service was against the procedure and there was no existing vacancy with any backing of budgetary provision, it would be totally unauthorised and would give no right to the incumbent for being regularised.

7. In view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court through

various decisions, as indicated above, it is difficult to be persuaded that the

appellants would be entitled for regularisation in service in absence of any posts duly sanctioned under any scheme or in the strength of the Department in which they have been working.

8. So far the matter in hand is concerned, the petitioners had been categorized in two categories one consisting of those who were appointed prior to 1.4.1993, and the other, appointed thereafter. In respect of appointees prior to 1.4.1993, the State Govt itself formulated a scheme for their regularisation in a phased manner. It was indicated before the learned Single Judge that the Govt was accordingly taking steps in pursuance of the said scheme. The learned Single Judge also accordingly directed for acting upon the scheme as provided by the Govt. Obviously, there is no grievance in respect of such employees.

9. In these appeals, the grievance is in respect of the persons appointed after 1.4.1993. Learned counsel for the appellants have first of all submitted that the fixation of cut off date as 1.4.1993 is arbitrary and unreal. Hence, the barrier of date must be struck down as discriminatory. It is submitted that all those persons engaged on account of temporary needs on daily wages/contingent/ work charge or muster roll basis, they constitute one class and on the ground of long duration for which they worked, all should be entitled for regularisation without any distinction regarding date of their appointment. The argument, though seems to be attractive, but it is devoid of any merit. Needless to emphasise that classification is permissible within the legal framework. If persons fall in two different categories, they can legally be treated on different footing. In the present case, the State Govt, it appears, had taken a decision in the year 1983 itself for regularising the services of muster roll and work charge employees in the PW Department on their completion of 15 years and 5 years of service, respectively. But, since rampant appointments were made irrespective of the need, there was excess staff; but at the same time there was pressure for regularisation of their services. In these circumstances, the State Govt took up the matter and hold parleys with the unions of the employees of the PW Department and as a result of mutual talks held, a cut off date was fixed as 1.4.1993, deciding to regularise the services of appointees prior to the aforesaid date. The decision was taken in the meeting held on 9.4.1993. At that time a decision also seems to have been taken that no further recruitment of such workers in any Department was to be made. It also seems to have been decided that whenever work charge employees are needed, they will be shifted from one project to the other. As discussed in paragraph 11 of the judgment of the learned Single Judge, the decision was circulated by letter dated 16.4.93 (Annexure B/2). A list of such employees was also called for by the Finance Commissioner. The said decision saying that no further recruitment was to be made, was again circulated vide office memorandum No.BW 65/95/1 dated 11.10.93. Apart from the material indicated above, the: fact also remains that the cut off date, 1.4.1993, was fixed as a result of parleys between the employees' union of certain departments and the State Govt in April, 1993. This being the position, there is hardly any scope to say that cut off date has been fixed in an arbitrary manner or without any basis. Once a decision was taken in April, 1993 that no further such appointment was to be made, it would be a safe ground to categories the employees appointed prior to and after 1.4.1993. A perusal of the order of the learned Single Judge also indicates that some of the petitioners had challenged the validity of fixing the cut off date by filing some separate petitions which had already been rejected by this Court. We therefore, hardly find any good reason to strike down the fixation of cut off date.

10. The policy decision of the State Govt taken for regularising the services of the appointees prior to 1.4.1993 is obviously applicable to all the Departments, irrespective of any other benefit which may be available to such an employee under any rules, or executive instructions in absence of rules of a particular Department.

11. Learned counsel for the State has referred to two decisions of the Hon'ble

Supreme Court on the proposition that policy decision of the Govt may not be

interfered with. One of the decisions is reported in (1997) 5 SCC 167, State of

Haryana & others vs. Raichand Jain & others. In this case, the payment of

back wages was restricted by a policy decision to a specified period only. Such

a decision was not interfered with, being a policy decision of the State. The other

decision is reported in (1998) 4 SCC 167, State of Punjab & others vs. Ram

Lubhaya Bagga & others. It has been held that wisdom of a policy decision

taken by the State is not to be judicially scrutinised. By means of a policy decision, the financial assistance to the employees for medical treatment was restricted within the resources of the State. Such a decision was held to be policy decision and not interfered with; it is though held that it can always be seen and considered that policy decision may not be arbitrary or violative of law.

12. In the present case, we have found that the State Govt has taken a

policy decision to regularise the services of the appointees prior to 1.4.1993. So

far the cut off date is concerned, it cannot be held to be arbitrary or discriminatory.

13. According to the submission made on behalf of the appellant, if at all,

cut off date should have been April 20, 1995, when the Chief Secretary to the

Govt of Assam had issued letter to different Departments to take necessary

action in consultation with Finance Department for early absorption regularization of workers engaged prior to 1.4.1993 and appropriate action to be taken against the officers who had made the appointments after the said date or had indulged in manipulation of records etc. In our view, the contention raised on behalf of the appellants is misplaced. The letter dated 20.4.95 cannot be made basis of fixing cut off date. This letter is addressed to all Commissioners and Secretaries to the Govt of Assam. It was indicated that the State Govt had been issuing instructions from time to time fot regularisation of services of work charge and muster roll employees. It was brought to the notice of the Govt by Sadou Assam Karmachari Parishad that no action in pursuance of such direction was being taken by certain Departments. It was also indicated that some of such employees was also not getting their salaries regularly. In that view of the matter, it was reiterated by means of letter dated 20.4.95 that all concerned Departments should take necessary action in consultation with the Finance Department in respect of employees appointed prior to 1.4.1993. By no stretch of imagination it can be said that cut off date has been fixed by the said Govt letter dated 20.4.95. By means of this letter only the earlier decision had been reiterated for early regularisation of services of employees engaged prior/to 1.4.1993. Hence, the contention that letter dated 20.4.95 be made basis of cut off date has no force.

14. The learned Single Judge in the concluding part of the order had observed that regarding regularisation of employees engaged on or after 1.4.93, the matter is left to the Govt to consider their cases in view of their long continuation in service. It may be done in concurrence with the Finance Department. It has also been made clear by the learned Single Judge and, in our view, rightly, that such workers cannot claim regularisation as a matter of right. It is also observed that in case the Government would like to discontinue the engagement of such employees appointed after 1.4.1993, it would be done on the basis of last come, first go. We feel that the learned Single Judge has rightly left the matter completely with the State Govt.

15. In view of the discussions held above, it is quite obvious that no directions of any kind can legally be given in this regard. It is in the realm of taking a policy decision of the State Govt. There cannot be any justification for making appointments in excess of the requirements and against the clear directions of the State Govt not to appoint any such staff after a particular date. Flouting of such instructions by some officers creates problems for all. So far employees are concerned, they hang on in uncertainty without accrual of any right for regularisation in absence of any sanctioned post, or in some cases, entry into the service against the rules. Though it was indicated in the order issued by the Govt dated 20.4.95 that action be taken against the erring officers, but, in fact, whether any action was taken or not is not known. The officers who have authority to appoint must act responsibility. The problem arising out of such breach is manifold. Those who are working since long can be considered for regularisation only under any valid scheme, statutory provisions or policy decision, not otherwise. But it cannot be said that it does not affect others, at all. The right to be considered for public employment available to all, stands restricted. Therefore, the concerned officers have to realise the seriousness of the matter and must act in accordance with law and the instructions of the Govt, so that, all concerned may be saved of avoidable problems. If the Govt sets any guidelines or issues any instructions for compliance of the officers of the Govt, it is also for it to see that they are faithfully complied with.

16. Learned counsel for the appellants had, however, submitted that in any case the appellants who have been appointed after 1.4.1993, they may be considered for regular appointment, as and when such recruitment is made against available vacancies. We hardly feel that there is any need to issue any such direction. In case sanctioned posts and vacancies exist and the recruitment is made, all eligible persons would be entitled for consideration. No exception in that regard can be made in respect of the appellants. It is submitted that some of them may have become over aged having continued for long time in the services of the Govt. So, for no fault of theirs, they would be disentitled for consideration. It is also submitted that they have also gained some experience of working and some weight age of the same can be given to such persons.

17. In this connection, our attention has been drawn to the observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 19 of the judgment in the case of Ashwani Kumar (supra), reported in (1997) 2 SGC1. While laying down the manner in which the employees were to be considered for regularisation, it was provided , that if some of them had become eligible to be appointed besides other competing candidates, condition of age bar may be relaxed appropriately, they having worked in the Department for a long time. Similarly, it was also to be considered that their experience etc may also be given some weight age qua other candidates.

18. In connection with the above, it may be observed that the Hon'ble

Supreme Court had made above provisions in regard to those who were found to be entitled for consideration for the purpose of regularisation. Hence, that may not be squarely applicable in the present case. However, in case such persons are considered for recruitment against any sanctioned vacancy, if and when available, some sympathetic consideration may be made for relaxation of their age for the period they worked, as well as, where other things being equal, their experience if of any use, may also be taken into account.

19. Learned counsel for the appellants also referred to a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in (1998) 8 SCC 753, State of Orissa & others vs. Mamtarani Sahoo & another. Our attention has been drawn to the observations made in paragraph 12, where the request of the petitioners was accepted to the effect that if the State makes any scheme for regularisation, then the benefit of that scheme may not be denied to them. Suffice it to observe that it is always open to the State Govt to frame any such scheme and in case the Govt prepares any scheme for regularisation of appointees after 1.4.1993, obviously, the appellants could not left out of consideration. The learned Single Judge has left this matter entirely to the State Govt and we find no good reason to interfere in that part of the order.

20. In view of the discussion held above, subject to the observations made in the preceding paragraphs, we find no reason to interfere in the order passed by the learned Single Judge.

21. All the above noted 34 Writ Appeals are therefore, dismissed. There

would, however, be no order as to costs. Interim orders, if any, operating stand discharged.