Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jiewan Kuamar v. State Of Punjab

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 18, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This summary is based exclusively on the provided opinion. The petitioner is a registered pharmacist carrying on business as "Public Medical Hall" at Mansa. He held a licence (marked P-1) to sell, stock, exhibit and offer for sale or distribute drugs under the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945; the licence was issued on 1.1.2003 and renewed up to 25.4.2011.

On 27.5.2005 the District Magistrate, Mansa promulgated an order under Section 144 Cr.P.C. (marked P-2) prohibiting any chemist in the district from selling certain listed medicines (Annexure 1) without a prescription from a registered medical practitioner and requiring chemists to maintain stock/sales/purchase records for inspection. The order was effective from 27.5.2005 to 27.7.2005.

On 16.6.2005 Police registered FIR No. 128 (marked P-3) at Police Station City, Mansa under Section 188 IPC, alleging that the petitioner sold specified narcotic/controlled medicines without prescriptions, based on secret information. The petitioner was arrested and interrogated. After investigation, a challan (final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C.) was presented on 20.12.2005, and charge under Section 188 IPC was framed on 20.1.2006; the case was then fixed for recording prosecution evidence.

The petitioner moved the court seeking quashing of the promulgation Order (P-2) and FIR No. 128 (P-3), contending illegality, arbitrariness, unconstitutionality and breach of natural justice and statutory procedure. Respondents filed replies asserting that the promulgation was in public interest to curb drug misuse and that the FIR was registered on reliable information and duly investigated.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the District Magistrate validly exercised powers under Section 144 Cr.P.C. to regulate the sale and distribution of medicines that are otherwise regulated by the Drugs and Cosmetics Act and the Rules thereunder, or whether such promulgation improperly encroaches upon the field occupied by the special statute.
  2. Whether proceedings for an offence punishable under Section 188 IPC could be initiated by registration of an FIR by the police, or whether Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. requires that cognizance of such an offence be taken only on a written complaint by the public servant concerned (or an administratively superior public servant), thereby precluding police registration and investigation leading to a challan under Section 173 Cr.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The District Magistrate had no valid reason to issue the Section 144 notification regulating sale and distribution of medicines because that area is governed by the Drugs and Cosmetics Act and the Rules framed under it; a special law occupies the field.
  • The promulgation under the general powers of Section 144 would therefore be void as it encroaches upon the specially regulated domain.
  • The FIR (P-3) and consequent proceedings under Section 188 IPC are illegal and should be quashed.

Respondent(s)' Replies

  • Respondent No. 2 (District Magistrate/local administration) stated that the Order (P-2) was issued in public interest because NGOs, media reports and public information showed widespread misuse of prescription medicines—especially by youth and economically weaker persons—and that chemists were selling such drugs without prescriptions; hence necessity justified the Section 144 order and record-keeping directions.
  • Respondent No. 3 (police/prosecution) stated that FIR (P-3) was registered on reliable information from a secret informer; investigation was undertaken, a challan under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was submitted on 20.12.2005, charge under Section 188 IPC was framed on 20.1.2006, and the matter proceeded to prosecution evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagtar Singh v. Union Territory, Chandigarh, 1996 (1) R.C.R. (Crl.) 669 Interprets Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. strictly: no court shall take cognizance of an offence under Section 188 IPC except on a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned or his administratively superior; the provision must be strictly construed to require a written complaint to the court rather than police-initiated prosecution. The court relied on this authority to conclude that registration of an FIR by the police and subsequent submission of a challan under Section 173 Cr.P.C. for an offence under Section 188 IPC is not permissible where the statutory requirement of a complaint in writing to the court by the public servant has not been met.
Sawaran Singh v. The State of Punjab, 1994 (3) Recent C.R. 352 Supports the view that Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. does not contemplate a normal police investigation followed by filing of challan for offences under Section 188 IPC; the complaint must be presented directly to the court. Cited by the petitioner and noted by the court to reinforce the principle that police investigation and filing of a challan are not the appropriate mode for offences requiring a complaint by a public servant under Section 195(1).
Bhagat Ram v. The State of Punjab, 1991 (1) Recent C.R. 192 Also indicates that the scope of Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. excludes ordinary police investigation and challan-filing for offences falling under that provision; complaint must be presented to the court. Relied upon, together with Sawaran Singh, to support the conclusion that the procedure followed (FIR → police investigation → challan) was inconsistent with the statutory requirement for offences under Section 188 IPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in two interrelated strands corresponding to the two principal challenges raised by the petitioner.

First, concerning the Section 144 promulgation (P-2), the court noted the petitioner's objection that the District Magistrate lacked valid reason to regulate sale/distribution of medicines under a general public-order provision when a comprehensive special statute—the Drugs and Cosmetics Act—and rules already regulate the sale and distribution of medicines. The opinion states that this argument "has merit": the existence of the special Act and rules suggests that issuance of a Section 144 notification in this field would amount to encroachment on a field earmarked for special legislation, rendering the general-law promulgation unsustainable in those circumstances.

Second, and more extensively reasoned, the court addressed the legality of registration of FIR No. 128 (P-3) and subsequent criminal proceedings under Section 188 IPC. The court observed the statutory constraint in Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. which, read strictly, requires that cognizance of an offence punishable under Section 188 IPC be taken only upon a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned (or his administrative superior) presented to the court. The opinion cites authority (Jagtar Singh and others) construing Section 195(1) strictly and making clear that the legislature intended complaints for such offences to be presented to the court rather than being initiated by police investigation and challan.

Applying those principles to the facts of the case, the court found that proceedings against the petitioner under Section 188 IPC were initiated on the basis of an FIR registered by the police and not on any complaint in writing presented to the court by the relevant public servant as required by Section 195(1)(a) Cr.P.C. Because the registration of the FIR and the subsequent course of criminal proceedings were not consistent with the statutory procedure, the court held that such proceedings could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling:

The petition is allowed. Promulgation Order dated 27.5.2005 (P-2) issued by the District Magistrate, Mansa is quashed. FIR No. 128 dated 16.6.2005 (P-3) registered at Police Station City, Mansa under Section 188 IPC and all proceedings taken thereunder against the petitioner are quashed and set aside.

Immediate Consequences for the Parties

  • The Section 144 order (P-2) directed at chemists in the district, and the requirement imposed thereby to refrain from selling specified medicines without prescription and to maintain stock/sales/purchase registers (for the stated two-month period), has been quashed as invalid.
  • The FIR (P-3), the investigation culminating in a challan under Section 173 Cr.P.C., the framing of charge under Section 188 IPC and all consequent proceedings against the petitioner have been quashed and set aside; the criminal prosecution under the impugned FIR cannot continue on that basis.

Broader Implications

The opinion does not articulate or purport to establish any novel, wide-ranging precedent beyond its application to the facts before the court. The court's decision is tied to (a) the proposition that a general public-order direction under Section 144 may not validly supplant or encroach upon a field regulated by a special statute (the Drugs and Cosmetics Act) and (b) the settled interpretation of Section 195(1) Cr.P.C. that offences under Section 188 IPC require a complaint in writing by the public servant to the court and are not to be initiated by ordinary police FIR and investigation. The direct effect is the quashing of the order and the FIR; the opinion does not claim to set a broader new principle beyond applying these established rules.


End of summary — prepared strictly from the provided opinion text. No information beyond that text has been introduced.

Show all summary ...

1. The relief sought by the petitioner is the quashing of promulgation order dated 27.5.2005 (P-2) issued by the District Magistrate, Mansa under Section 144 Cr.P.C. and also of FIR No. 128 dated 16.6.2005 registered at Police Station City, Mansa under Section 188 IPC (P-3) and all the proceedings pending thereunder on the ground that the same were illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional, against the principles of natural justice and also against the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

2. According to the petitioner, he is a registered Pharamacist and carrying on business as such under the name and style of Public Medical Hall, Near Bus Stand Thikriwala, Mansa, and authorized vide licence (P-1) to sell, stock, exhibit and offer for sale or distribute by retail and whole sale the drugs as provided under the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945. The said licence was issued on 1.1.2003 and now stood renewed up to 25.4.2011. It is then submitted that District Magistrate, Mansa promulgated an order under Section 144 Cr.P.C. (P-2) that no chemist in the district, whether retailer or whole seller, will sell any drug/medicine mentioned in Annexure 1 thereto, without the prescription from a registered medical practitioner.

3. It was also directed in the said order that all chemists will maintain complete record of their current stock of the specified drugs which record shall be available for inspection to all Executive Magistrate, Police Officials of the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police and above or any other person specially authorized by the District Magistrate in writing. The promulgation was made effective from 27.5.2005 to 27.7.2005. Under the grab of the said order, the police registered an FIR against the petitioner on 16.6.2005 (P-3) with the allegations that it received a secret information against the petitioner of selling narcotic drugs from his shop without the prescription slips of the doctors and these drugs included proxyvon Spasmocip, Finotil, Rexcof etc. Accordingly, he prayed for quashing of the promulgation Order (P-2) and of FIR (P-3).

4. Reply was filed on behalf of respondent No. 2, wherein it was submitted that the promulgation Order (P-2) was issued in the public interest, as it was brought to the notice of the said respondent that many persons, especially the youngsters and the economically weaker classes of the district had become prone to various intoxicant drugs and medicines. Even the media had published many instances in this regard. It was commonly observed that various chemists were selling intoxicant drugs and medicines with out any prescription of medical practitioner. Therefore, necessity was felt to pass the promulgation Order (P-2).

5. Respondent No. 3 also filed a reply wherein it was submitted that on receipt of reliable information from a secret informer, FIR (P-3) was registered against the petitioner on 16.6.2005 and after the completion of the investigation, challan, was presented against the petitioner before learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mansa, on 20.12.2005 and charge under Section 188 IPC stood framed against the petitioner on 20.1.2006 and the case now fixed for recording of prosecution evidence.

6. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the pleadings, besides the various documents brought on the record.

7. On 27.5.2005, District Magistrate, Mansa, while exercising powers under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short 'the Code') promulgated an Order (P-2) that no chemist in the district will sell any drug/medicine as specified in Annexure 1 thereto without a prescription from registered medical practitioner. Further that in the public interest all the chemist/medical/drugs stores (whether retail or wholesaler) will maintain the complete record of their current stock, which will be available for investigation to all Executive Magistrate, Police Officials of the rank of Deputy Superintendent - of police and above or any other person specifically authorized by the District Magistrate in writing. This order was passed in order to check the sale of large number of prescription drugs by chemists over the counter without valid prescription to youth and persons belonging to economically weaker section, who were falling prey to the menace of narcotics and drugs. The promulgation Order (P-2) reads as under:

Office Of The District Magistrate, Mansa (Ma branch) Order under Section 144 Cr.P.C, 1973 Dated:

ORDER

1. Whereas it has been brought to my notice by various social and non-government organizations that a large number of persons, especially youth and those belonging to economically weaker sections are falling prey to the menace of narcotic and drugs. It has also been highlighted in the media that a large number of prescription drugs which are currently being illegally sold by chemists over the counter without valid prescription are being misused for their narcotic effects. The abuse of such drugs and chemicals beyond the prescribed dosage and without prescription of a registered medical practitioner is leading to deterioration in law and order with the increasing incidences of petty crimes and disturbance of peace and tranquility along with disruption in family life.

2. And whereas it has come to my notice that a person is easily initiated in to misuse of drugs due to easy availability of various types of sedatives, Painkillers, anti-allergic, anti-histamines, injections, cough syrups, etc. in regard to which certain medicines are consistently prone to misuse as intoxicants.

3. Whereas in the public interest, I Raj Kamal Chaudhary, I.A.S. District Magistrate, Mansa, being satisfied that sale of medicines without prescription and non-maintenance of the stock registers sale and purchase registers leads to easy availability of intoxicating drugs, which is harmful to the health, mind and life of youth in particular and public in general, and therefore, immediate measures are required in the public interest.

4. Therefore, in exercise of the powers vested in me under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, I order that no chemist in this district, whether retailer or whole seller will sell, whether by retail or wholesale any medicine which are detailed in Annexure 1 (overleaf) without a prescription from registered medical practitioner. It is further directed that in the public interest that all the chemists/medical/drugs store (whether retail or wholesale) will maintain complete record of their current stock, sales and purchase register, which will be available for inspection to all Executive Magistrate, Police Officials of the rank of DSP and above, or any other person specifically authorized by the undersigned in writing.

5. In view of the urgency of the matter, this order is being passed ex-parte and is addressed to the public in general.

6. This order shall remain in force for a period of two months from the date of issue i.e. 27.5.2005 to 27.7.2005.

7. This order shall be affixed on the Notice Board of the District Magistrate, SSP Civil Surgeon, all SDMs Tehsildars in the district and shall be promulgated by announcement through publicity van of the Public Relations Department, Mansa and affixed at conspicuous place.

8. Given under my hand and seal today the 27th day of May, 2005.

Sd/-

Mansa (Raj Kamal Chaudhary) IAS, District Magistrate, Mansa.

Place : Mansa Dated : 27.5.2005

8. The stand of the petitioner is that the District Magistrate did not have any valid reason to issue notification in exercise of powers under section 144 of the code with regard to the sale and distribution of medicines as the sale and distribution of medicines is governed by special Act and Rules. The argument has merit in it. The legislature has already enacted Drugs and Cosmetics Act, besides framing rules thereunder to regulate the sale and distribution of medicines. Under these circumstances the issuance of notification under the general law would be rendered void as it tantamount to encroach upon the field ear-marked for the special law.

9. Coming to the attack of the petitioner in regard to the registration of the FIR, it may be noticed that proceedings under Section 188 IPC can only be initiated on the basis of a complaint in writing of the public servant concerned made to the court or to some other public servant to whom he is administratively subordinate. Section 195(1) of the Code restrains the court from taking cognizance of any offence punishable under Section 188 IPC unless a complaint in writing is made to it by the public servant concerned. In other words, no FIR can be registered by the police. It would not be open to the police to register a case against the offender for offence under Section 188 IPC and then to submit a report under Section 173 of the Code to the concerned court. Reliance in this regard can be placed on Jagtar Singh v. Union Territory, Chandigarh 1996 (1) R.C.R. (Crl.) 669, wherein this Court held as under:

these facts are not disputed. Language of Section 195(1) of the Code does not leave scope for any ambiguity and is the section which has to be construed strictly. In accordance with the settled principles of interpretation applicable to criminal jurisprudence the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code or penal laws have to be strictly construed so as to be given meaning except what is intended by the Legislature in the language used itself. The relevant portion of Section is that,

"No court shall take cognizance except on the complaint in writing of the public servant concerned or of some other public servant to whom he is administratively subordinate"
. The intention appears to be clear that where an offence is committed under Section 188 IPC, the legislature has made it obligatory that the public servant before whom such an offence is committed, he will file a complaint to the Magistrate and the cognizance of the offence by the concerned court is dependent upon the complaint in writing by such officer or an officer superior to such officer.

The counsel for the petitioner has relied upon Sawaran Singh v. The State of Punjab 1994 (3) Recent C.R. 352 and Bhagat Ram v. The State of Punjab 1991 (1) Recent C.R. 192. In both these cases the court has indicated that the scope of Section 195(1) of the Code does not contemplate investigation in a normal way by the police and filing of the challan, but the complaint has to be presented directly to the concerned court. In the present case though the complaint is stated to be addressed to the court, but as it appears it was not presented to the court and the court did not pass any orders at that stage

10. It is admitted case of respondent No. 3 that FIR No. 128 (P3) was registered against the petitioner on 16.6.2005 under Section 188 IPC. The petitioner was thereafter arrested and interrogated. After the completion of the investigation, the challan (final report under Section 173 of the Code) was presented against the petitioner before learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mansa on 20.12.2005 and the charge was framed on 20.1.2006. Further that the case is now fixed for recording of prosecution evidence.

11. It is, thus, clear that the proceedings against the petitioner under Section 188 IPC have been initiated on the basis of the FIR and not on the basis of any complaint in writing of the public servant concerned as is required by Section 195(1)(a) of the Code. The registration of FIR and the launching of proceedings thereafter against the petitioner is not permitted by the Code and thus, cannot be allowed to be sustained. Resultantly, the petition is allowed. Promulgation order dated 27.5.2005 (P-2) issued by the District Magistrate, Mansa is quashed. Similarly, FIR No. 128, dated 16.6.2005 registered at Police Station City Mansa under Section 1-88 IPC (P-3) and all the proceedings taken thereunder against the petitioner are also quashed and set aside.