Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lala Paite v. State Of Manipur & Ors.

Gauhati High Court
Jul 26, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (D.N. Chowdhury, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Habeas Corpus petition challenges a detention order dated 5 November 1998 passed by the District Magistrate, Imphal East District, Manipur, detaining Mr. Yangminthang Haokip (also known as Thangboi or Wilson). The detention order was made under section 3(2) and 3(3) of the National Security Act, 1980.

At the time of the detention order (5-11-98) the detenu was in prison in connection with FIR No. 322(8)98 of Imphal Police Station under sections 121/121-A/400/212 IPC read with section 13 of the U.A. (P) Act and 25(1-B) of the Arms Act. The grounds of detention were communicated to the detenu on 7-11-98 with information about his right to submit representations to the Central and State Governments.

The State Government approved the detention on 16-11-98. While in jail the detenu submitted representations dated 25-11-98 addressed to the Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs (Department of Internal Security), and to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Manipur. The State Government confirmed the detention on 14-12-98. There is a factual discrepancy in the record as to whether the State disposed of the representation on 1-12-98 or 2-12-98, but the court found no undue delay by the State Government in disposing of the detenu's representation.

The representation to the Central Government was forwarded by the State Government by Speed Post on 27-11-98. According to the Central Government's affidavit, the Ministry of Home Affairs received the representation on 7-12-98, sent a "crash" message to the State Government on 9-12-98 requesting additional information, received the requested information (the State Government's letter dated 8-12-98) on 15-12-98, processed the matter internally on 17-12-98 and 18-12-98, and the Home Minister rejected the representation on 26-12-98.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay in disposal of the detenu's representation (particularly by the Central Government) violated Article 22(5) of the Constitution and thereby vitiated the detention.
  2. Whether the State Government unduly delayed disposal of the representation addressed to it.
  3. Whether the procedural history and explanations put forward by the Central Government justified the time taken to consider the detenu's representation in the circumstances of preventive detention under the National Security Act, 1980.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Mr. N. Kerani Singh, Senior Counsel)

  • The principal contention was that there was an undue and inexcusable delay in disposing of the representation submitted by the detenu, particularly by the Central Government.
  • The petitioner argued that the time taken by the Central Government to dispose of the representation (about twenty-nine days as argued by counsel) violated Article 22(5) of the Constitution.

State Government's Position

  • The State Government's affidavit indicated that the representation dated 25-11-98 addressed to the State Government was forwarded to the Central Government on 27-11-98 by Speed Post.
  • The State Government also stated (in varied statements) that it disposed of the representation on either 1-12-98 or 2-12-98; the court found that the State took the decision to dispose on 1-12-98 and concluded there was no undue delay by the State Government.

Central Government's Arguments (as presented by Mr. N. Ibotombi Singh, CGSC)

  • The Central Government disputed the petitioner's contention of unreasonable delay and furnished a timeline: receipt of the representation in the Ministry of Home Affairs on 7-12-98; issuance of a WT (wire/telegram) message on 9-12-98 requesting vital information from the State Government; receipt of the requested information on 15-12-98 (by reference to the State Government's letter dated 8-12-98); internal processing on 17-12-98 (Director and Joint Secretary) and presentation to the Home Minister on 18-12-98; rejection of the representation by the Home Minister on 26-12-98.
  • The Central Government contended that the representation required additional vital information and therefore the processing steps and the time taken had a justificatory basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sri Ram Sukrya Mhatre v. VRD Tyagi, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 65 ; AIR 1994 SC 1134 Cited by Central Government counsel in support of his contentions concerning disposal of representations (specific principle from the case not detailed in the opinion). Noted as referred to by the Central Government's counsel; the court considered it among authorities cited but relied on its own examination of the facts and other authorities concerning delay.
Tarik Mashkur v. State of UP, 1999 Cri LJ 1069 (Allahabad High Court) Cited by Central Government counsel in support of his contentions (specific principle not set out in the opinion). Considered as one of the authorities referred to by the Central Government's counsel; the court did not adopt any differing principle from it on the facts before it.
Thounaojam Lukhoi Singh v. District Magistrate, (1997) 1 GLR 115 Cited by Central Government counsel in support (specific principle not detailed in the opinion). Referred to among the decisions relied upon by the Central Government; the court relied primarily on its own analysis and other Supreme Court authority on delay.
Mrs U. Vijylakshmi v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1994 SC 165 Authority holding that unexplained delay in dealing with a detainee's representation (specifically delay by the Minister of five days in the cited extract) can be fatal to continued detention. The court expressly relied on this decision to demonstrate that unexplained delay in disposing of a detainee's representation may vitiate further detention; it quoted the relevant extract and applied the principle to the eight-day delay before the Minister in the instant case.
Rajammal v. State of Tamilnadu, 1999 Cri LJ 826 Referred as a case in which the Supreme Court relied on the principle that representations must be disposed of expeditiously. The court cited this case as another authority supporting the proposition that delays defeat the mandate of Article 22(5).
Prabhu Dayal Deorah etc. v. District Magistrate, Kamrup, (1974) 1 SCC 103 ; AIR 1975 SC 183 Observation emphasizing that invasion of personal liberty must conform strictly to constitutional procedure and that observance of procedure is essential to protect personal liberty. The court quoted Justice K.K. Mathew's observations from this decision to underline the constitutional importance of procedural safeguards in preventive detention matters.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the documentary record and the timelines presented by the parties, with particular focus on the requirement in Article 22(5) of the Constitution that a detained person be afforded the earliest opportunity to make a representation and that such representation be considered "as soon as may be."

On the State Government's conduct: the court reviewed the records and concluded that the State Government decided to dispose of the representation on 1-12-98 and that, therefore, there was no undue delay by the State Government in disposing of the detenu's representation.

On the Central Government's conduct: the Central Government's affidavit stated the representation was received in the Ministry of Home Affairs on 7-12-98 and that on 9-12-98 a crash message was sent to the State Government requesting "vital information." The court noted that the Central Government did not indicate specifically what that "vital information" was, nor were the records produced to show precisely what was requested at that stage. The State Government's records, however, indicated that the crash message sought para-wise comments from the State Government and the report of the Advisory Board.

The court observed that seeking an Advisory Board report is different from disposing of a representation under Article 22(5) and that there could not be valid justification for delaying the disposal of the representation by awaiting an Advisory Board report for the purpose of considering a detainee's representation. According to the Central Government's own chronology, the requested information was received (per the record) on 15-12-98; thereafter the case was put before the Director (17-12-98), then the Joint Secretary (17-12-98), and then the Home Minister (18-12-98), with the final rejection occurring on 26-12-98.

The court found that there was no satisfactory explanation from the Central Government for the time taken at various stages, particularly the eight days the representation remained with the Home Minister before disposal. The court referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Mrs U. Vijylakshmi (quoted in the opinion) where a five-day unexplained delay at ministerial level was held to be fatal. The court also invoked broader constitutional reasoning from Prabhu Dayal Deorah about the primacy of procedure in protecting personal liberty.

Weighing these factors, the court concluded that the Central Government had not demonstrated adequate urgency, diligence or responsibility in handling the representation and had not satisfactorily explained the delay. The unexplained delay in disposal of the detenu's representation by the Central Government therefore vitiated further detention.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the Habeas Corpus petition and directed that the detenu, Mr. Yangminthang Haokip (also known as Thangboi or Wilson), be released forthwith unless he is required to be detained in connection with any other case.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate consequence is the release of the detenu from detention under the National Security Act insofar as the challenged detention continued solely on the basis of the order under challenge; release is subject to any lawful detention in other connected cases.
  • Legal implication noted by the court: The decision reaffirms the constitutional expectation under Article 22(5) that representations by persons detained under preventive detention laws must be considered expeditiously and that unexplained delays — including unexplained days in ministerial consideration — can vitiate continued detention.
  • No broader new precedent was expressly declared by the court beyond its application of existing constitutional safeguards and the authorities it cited; the court applied established principles concerning prompt disposal of detainees' representations to the facts before it.

Judge: D.N. Chowdhury, J. (as stated at the head of the opinion)

Show all summary ...

D.N Chowdhury, J.:— In this Habeas Corpus petition, the petitioner has assailed the detention order dated 5th November, 1998 passed by the District Magistrate, Imphal East District, Manipur detaining the detenu, Mr. Yangminthang Haokip alias Thangboi alias Wilson son of late Lalkholun Haokip of Nungmanbi village, RS. Saikul, Senapati district. By the aforesaid order date 5-11-98, the detenu was ordered to be detained by the District Magistrate, Imphal East District in exercise of the powers under section 3(2) and 3(3) of the National Security Act, 1980 which is under challenge in this petition.

2. In the Habeas Corpus petition though numerous grounds are taken by the petitioner questioning the order of detention, the learned senior counsel, Mr. N. Kerani Singh, appearing on behalf of the petitioner mainly emphasised on the point of delay in disposing of the representation filed by the detenu before the concerned appropriate authority. The order of detention, as mentioned earlier, was passed on 5-11-98 when the detenu was in prison in connection with FIR No. 322(8)98 of the Imphal Police Station under sections 121/121-A/400/212 IPC read with section 13 of the U.A (P) Act and 25(1-B) of the Arms Act. The grounds of detention was furnished to the detenu on 7-11-98. By the said communication, the detenu was informed about his right to submit representation against the order of detention before the Central Government and the State Government. The detention order was approved by the State Government on 16-11-98. While the detenu was in Jail, he submitted representations on 25-11-98 one addressed to the Secretary to the Govt, of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Department of Internal Security, and another to the Chief Secretary to the Govt, of Manipur. The order of detention was confirmed by the State Government on 14-12-98. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the representation dated 25-11-98 addressed to the State Government was disposed by the State Government on 1-12-98.

3. An affidavit was filed on behalf of respondents Nos. 1 and 2 through the Deputy Secretary to the Govt, of Manipur, Department of Home Affairs. From the affidavit, it transpires that the representation dated 25-11-98, was rejected on 2-12-98 and the order was issued on 2-12-98. However, from the records placed before us by the learned Govt. Advocate, Manipur, it appears that the representation dated 25-11-98 was in fact disposed of on 1-12-98. We have gone through the records and from the records it transpires that the appropriate authority took the decision to dispose of the representation on 1st of December, 1998 itself. Whether the representation was disposed of on 2-12-98 or on 1-12-98, is not material so far as the State Government is concerned since we do not find any undue delay on the part of the State Government in disposal of the representation of the detenu.

4. Mr. N. Kerani Singh, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner, however, seriously assailed the sluggishness of the Central Government in the disposal of the representation of the detenu. The learned senior counsel submitted that the detenu sent representation to the Central Government. The State Government in its affidavit has confirmed that the representation submitted by the petitioner to the Central Government was forwarded to the Central Government on 27-11-98 by Speed Post. The fact that it took the Central Government about twentynine days, according to the learned senior counsel for the petitioner, itself is violative of Article 22(5) of the Constitution.

5. Mr. N. Kbotombi Singh, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Central Government, on the other hand, denied and disputed and contentions raised by Mr. N. Kerani Singh, learned senior counsel for the petitioner. Mr. N. Ibotombi Singh, the learned CGSC referring to the affidavit filed on behalf of the Central Government by the Under-Secretary to the Govt, of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, submitted that the Representation dated 25-11-98 preferred by the detenu was received by the Central Government on 7-12-98 through the State Government of Manipur. The representation was processed for consideration and at that stage it was found that certain vital information required for further consideration was needed from the State Government and accordingly a WT Message was sent to the State Government for furnishing the aforesaid information. The aforesaid information was received by the Central Government on 15-12-98 vide the State Government's letter dated 8-12-98 vide the State Government's letter dated 8-12-98. That on receiving the information on 15-12-98, the case of the detenu was put up before the Director concerned in the Ministry of Home Affairs on 17-12-98, who on consideration of the same, made comments thereon and put it up before the Joint Secretary on 17-12-98 alongwith his comments. The Joint Secretary in his turn put up the representation of the detenu with his own comments thereon before the Home Minister, Government of India, on 18-12-98, who on consideration of the representation, rejected the same on 26-12-98.

6. In support of his contentions, Mr. N.I Singh, learned CGSC, referred to the decisions of the Supreme Court in Sri Ram Sukrya Mhatre v. VRD Tyagi reported in 1992 Supp (3) SCC 65 : AIR 1994 SC 1134 of the Allahabad High Court in Tarik Mashkur v. State of UP, reported in 1999 Cri LJ 1069, and the decision in Thounaojam Lukhoi Singh v. District Magistrate, reported in (1997) 1 GLR 115.

7. From the facts narrated above, it appears that the representation of the detenu dated 25-11-98, was disposed by the Central Government finally on 26-12-98. The National Security Act provides for passing of an order of detention of preventive nature in certain cases. The National Security Act as well as the Constitution of India provides some procedural safeguards to such detenus against whom detention order(s) is/are passed. Article 22(5) of the Constitution enjoins that when a person is detained in pursuance of an order made under law providing for preventive detention, the authority making the order shall, as soon as may be, communicate to such person the grounds basing on which the detention order has been made and shall afford him the earliest opportunity to make a representation against the order. Any detention effects the liberty of a citizen and in that view of the matter, an obligation is cast on the detaining authority to communicate to such person the grounds of detention with utmost dispatch and afford him the earliest opportunity of making a representation against such order. The Constitutional safeguard extends to the consideration of the representation of a detenu as soon as received. The Constitution has not indicated as to any time frame, but at the same time, it expresses its concern to provide opportunity to such persons for representing against such orders at the earliest instance. It is a procedural protection which is required to be assiduously followed a representation of a detenu for release from detention against inappropriate and unjustified exercise of power of detention requires early disposal and that is the concern showed in Article 22(5) of the Constitution. No hard and fast rule can be pronounced. Nonetheless, it envisions for expeditious disposal of the representation filed by a detenu. The time frame is not the consideration, the consideration is as to the concern that is shown by the authority in dealing with the liberty of a citizen. A representation that is sent by a detenu from Jail requires expeditious consideration. There may be valid ground for non-disposal of the representation, but those must be adequately explained.

8. On the own showing of the Central Government in its affidavit, the representation of the detenu dated 25-11-98, was received in the Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt, of India, on 7-12-98. ON 9-12-98, it sent a crash message to the State Government that the representation did not contain certain vital information (emphasis given). What was the vital information was not indicated by the Central Government, nor were the records produced. However, from the records of the State Government, it transpires that by the Crash message dated 9-12-98, the Central Government sought para-wise comments form the State Government as also the report of the Advisory Board. There could not have been any valid justification for delaying the disposal of the representation for a report of the Advisory Board for disposal of a representation under Article 22(5) of the Constitution is different from that of a decision of the Advisory Board. On their own showing, the Central Government received those vital information, as indicated above, on 15-12-98. It took two days for the representation to reach the table of the Director in the Ministry of Home Affairs and after the matter was processed by the Director, it reached the table of the Joint Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, on 17-12-98. The Joint Secretary deliberated on the matter and with his comments, sent it to the Home Minister on 18-12-98 which was finally disposed on 26-12-98 by the Government. No valid reason so far is furnished by the central Government for sitting over the matter relating to the liberty of a citizen for those days. On the own showing of the Central Government in its affidavit, the matter was put up before the Home Minister, Govt, of India on 18-12-98 and it took eight days for the concerned authority to dispose of the representation. There is no explanation as to why the representation could not be disposed prior to it. Even a five days' delay in keeping a representation in the table of the concerned Minister was held to be fatal by the Supreme Court in the case of Mrs U. Vijylakshmi v. State of Tamil Nadu, reported in AIR 1994 SC 165, the relevant extract of which is quoted below:

“We have perused the stages through which the file containing the representation was dealt with promptly and there was no indifference lethargy of negligence in dealing with the same. The file was not unnecessarily held up at any level but moved from level to level promptly. We are, therefore, satisfied that the explanation tendered by the Deputy Secretary in this behalf is acceptable and does not betray any lack of sense or urgency in dealing with the representation. We, therefore, do not see any merit in the first contention. In the present case, however, there is no explanation forthcoming as to why the representation could not be dealt with by the Minister concerned from 9-2-1998 to 14-2-1998.”

9. The above decision of the Supreme Court was referred and relied upon by the Supreme Court in the case of Rajammal v. State of Tamilnadu, reported in 1999 Cri LJ 826. A right to make representation is not only a Statutory right under the National Security Act, it is a Constitutional right as well. The words “as soon as may be” as enjoined in Article 22(5) of the Constitution reflects the concern of the makers of the. Constitution for individual liberty which made it incumbent on the authority to act with promptitude, diligence and responsibility without the least possible delay. Expeditious disposition is the rule and delay in disposal defeats the mandate of Article 22(5) of the Constitution. Therefore, the authority is obliged to explain every day's delay. The framers of the Constitution being alive to the fact that preventive detention involves serious inroads on the right of personal liberty, took care in incorporating clauses (4) and (5) in article 22 of the Constitution and provided the minimal safeguards for the protection of persons sought to be detained on preventive ground. Its rigorous cannot be softened on the basis of the nature of the activities of a particular person. In this connection we may recall the following observations made by Hon'ble Mr. Justice KK Mathew in the case of Prabhu Dayal Deorah etc. v. District Magistrate, Kamrup, reported in (1974) 1 SCC 103 : AIR 1975 SC 183 (Para 67, Page 199) which reads as follows:

“The facts of the cases might induce mournful reflection how an honest attempt by an authority charged with the duty of taking prophylactic measures to secure the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community has been frustrated by what is popularly called a technical error. We say and we think it necessary to repeat, that the gravity of the evil to the community resulting from anti-social activities can never furnish an adequate reason for invading the personal liberty of a citizen, except in accordance with the procedure established by the Constitution and the laws. The history of personal liberty is largely the history of insistence on observance of procedure. And observance of procedure has been the bastion against wanton assaults on personal liberty over the years. Under over Constitution, the only guarantee of personal liberty for a person is that he shall not be deprived of it except in accordance with the procedure established by law”

10. As indicated earlier, in this case, no reason of whatsoever manner was shown as to why it took so much of time to dispose of the representation relating to detention of preventive nature. We, are, therefore, of the opinion that the unexplained delay in disposal of the representation vitiated further detention of the detenu and thus, we are of the view that further detention of the detenu, Mr. Yangminthang Haokip @ Thangboi @ Wilson, cannot be allowed. We, therefore, allowed the Habeas Corpus petition and other release of the above-named detenu unless he is required to be detained in connected with any other case.