Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Narinder Kumar v. The State Of Punjab .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 1, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was tried, convicted, and sentenced to nine months rigorous imprisonment and fined Rs. 500/- (with a default imprisonment of four months) under section 9 of the Opium Act by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sangrur, via an order dated 9.11.1983. The conviction and sentence were upheld by the lower Appellate Court. The petitioner subsequently filed a revision petition before this Court.

On 13.1.1981, Dilbag Singh (PW 2), along with HC Prem Sagar (PW 1) and one Ram Lal, intercepted the petitioner in the area of village Jharan and recovered 2 kg of opium from his possession. A chemical examination confirmed the substance as opium. The prosecution gave up the sole public witness Ram Lal, alleging he was won over by the petitioner, leaving only two official witnesses to support the prosecution case.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of the petitioner under section 9 of the Opium Act was sustainable in light of the evidence and circumstances?
  2. Whether the animus of the official witness (ASI Dilbag Singh) affected the credibility of the prosecution's case?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner denied the recovery of opium from his possession.
  • He alleged that ASI Dilbag Singh was inimical towards him due to a prior complaint filed by the petitioner’s brother against the ASI under section 325 IPC and other provisions.
  • The petitioner claimed that the ASI had pressured him to ask his brother to withdraw the complaint, but he refused.
  • The petitioner asserted that he was at a different location visiting maternal relations at the time of the alleged recovery.

Prosecution's Position

  • The prosecution relied on the recovery of 2 kg of opium from the petitioner’s possession and the chemical examiner’s report confirming the substance.
  • They initially produced one public witness, Ram Lal, but later gave him up as he was allegedly won over by the petitioner.
  • The prosecution’s evidence rested primarily on two official witnesses, Dilbag Singh (ASI) and HC Prem Sagar.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the evidence, noting that the prosecution had relinquished the only independent public witness, Ram Lal, thereby relying solely on two official witnesses. ASI Dilbag Singh, a key prosecution witness, admitted under cross-examination that a prior complaint had been filed against him by the petitioner’s brother. This admission established a clear animus or hostility of the ASI towards the petitioner.

Given the absence of an independent public witness and the demonstrated enmity between the petitioner and the official witness, the court found the prosecution’s case to be unsafe. The court emphasized that such animus could taint the credibility of the prosecution’s evidence. In light of these circumstances, the court applied the principle of benefit of doubt in favor of the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

The petitioner was acquitted of the charge under section 9 of the Opium Act.

The court ordered that any fine recovered from the petitioner be refunded. This decision directly affects the parties by overturning the conviction and sentence previously imposed. No new legal precedent was established by this ruling.

Show all summary ...

K.P.S Sandhu, J. (Oral):— The petitioner was tried, convicted and sentenced to R.I nine months fine of Rs. 500/-, in default R.I for four months under section 9 of the Opium Act by the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sangrur vide his order dated 9.11.1983 His conviction and sentence were upheld by the lower Appellate Court. The petitioner has come up in revision to this Court.

2. On 13.1.1981 Dilbag Singh PW 2 along with HC Prem Sagar PW 1 and one Ram Lal was present in the area of village Jharan. They intercepted the petitioner and from his possession 2 Kg. of opium was recovered. The sample was sent for chemical examination. According to the report of the Chemical Examiner, the same was found to be opium. Ram Lal, the solitary witness from the public was given up by the prosecution as having been won over by the petitioner. Consequently, the evidence consists of two official witnesses, namely Dilbag Singh ASI PW 2 and HC Prem Sagar PW 1.

3. In his statement under section 313, Cr.P.C the petitioner denied the recovery of opium from him and came out with the following version:—

“ASI Dilbag Singh is inimical towards me. My brother had filed a complaint against him under section 325 IPC etc. and I used to pursue the case along with my brother. He had been pressing me to ask my brother to withdraw the case and I had been very adamant and was not ready to ask him to withdraw the complaint. He had the impression that but for the accused the case could not have been filed and pursued in the Court. I had come to Sangrur and was going to Ralla via Lakhmirwala to see my maternal relations. ASI Dilbag Singh met me at the main road junction where roads to cheeman meet with the road coming from Lakhmirwala in the area of Sunam revenue estate. Mohinder Singh was accompanying me at that time”

4. A.S.I Dilbag Singh PW while being cross-examined has admitted in so many words that complaint Exhibit D-1 was filed against him by brother of the petitioner earlier to the present recovery of the alleged opium. In view of the fact that A.S.I Dilbag Singh PW has a definite animus against the petitioner and the fact that the only non-official witness has been given up, I think it would not be safe to allow the conviction of the petitioner to stay. Consequently, I give him the benefit of doubt and acquit him of the charge. Fine, if recovered, would be refunded to him.

Accused acquitted.