Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ved Pal Anand v. Union Of India .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Feb 27, 1991

G.S Chahal, J.:— This order will dispose to two connected petitions, Cr. W.P No. 68 of 1991 and Cr. W.P No. 69 of 1991. Both these petitions are under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India for quashing of the detention order dated 13-3-1989, Annexure P-3

2. I will draw the from Cr. W.P No. 68 of 1991. Ved Pal Anand petitioner has urged that the respondnent, Union of India, purporting to exercise powers under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (the ‘Act’ in brief) order the detention of the petitioner by passing an order dated 30-9-1988 in pursuance of which, he was dentained on 6-10-1988. Copy of the detention order is Annexure P-1. On 2-11-1988, the Additonal Secretary to Government of India. Ministry of Finiance, Department of Revenue made declaration No. 308/88 under Section 9(1) of the Act that he was satisfied with regard to the fact that the petitioner was likely to abet the smuggling of the goods into Bombay. Copy of this declaration is Annexure P-2 After making of the declaration, the under Sectary of Revenue, exercising powers under Section 8(f), read with Sectoin 9(2) of the Act, confirmend the detention order of the petitioner Annexure P-1 and futher directed that under Section 10 of the Act, the petitioner be detained for a period of 2 years from the date of his detention, i.e from 6-10-1988. Copy of the order is Annexure P-3. The grounds for detention relate to the import of Polyster Filament Yarn and Polyster Fibre in the name of M/s Jasmine and M/s Expo Internationl, under the duty exemptin entitlement certificate scheme. It had been alleged that the said two concern obtained five actual user's advance licences, each in the financial year 1984-1988 from the Joint Chief Controller of Expor and Imports, New Delhi for import of said good free from custom duty subject to the condition that they would manufacture (a) readmade garments out of the imported yarn, (b) ployster spun yarn out of imported polyster fibre and export the resultant products aborad within a period of six months from the date of first clearance of imported consignment. It is alleged that both the said concerns had imported the said material. But did not export the resultant productes. The petitioner states that he had no connection whatsoever with the two concerns. That the order of detention had been passed with a mala fide intention, with the sole purpose of harassing and humilitating the petitioner and his family members by assuming that the petitioner and his son Ashok Anand were actually controlling these firms and had takend active part in rsn hadd the import and sale of filament yarn and plyster fibre. The firm M/s Jasmine is stated to be a partnership firm between Naresh Chanda and Krishan Lal Chawla. The respondents had passed the detention order of Naresh Chand and Krishal Lal Chawla on the same grounds, as alleged qua the parter, but these detention orders were revoked by the Advisory Borad. The petitioner had challenged the detention order and declaration order, thought ??? W. No. 545/88 and 576/88 but the same had been dismissed on 17-3-1989. The petitioner had thus suffered the entire period of detention and had come out on 5-10-1990. The declaration Annexure P-2 and the detention order Annexure P-3 are being challenged on fresh grounds which were not taken in the earlier petition.

3. The petitioner now pleads that the declaration Annexure P-2 violated the rights of the petitioner under Articles 22(5) of the Constitution Page: 420of India. It was the duty of the concerned respondent to inform the petitioner that he bad got a right to make a representation against his detention to a particular authority, but he was not made aware of it.

4. The name of the authority to which such a representation was to be made had neither been mentioned in the detention order (Annexure P 3), nor was it intimated to the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner was handicapped in making representation against the detention order at the earliest available opportunity. So the Constitutional right of the petitioner to make representation against the detention order and declaration is violative of the Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India.

5. In spite of the opportunity allowed, no return was filed by the respondent and as such, it may be assumed that the facts stated in the writ petition are correct

6. The sole ground of attack on the detention order is that it did not mention the fact that the petitioner had the right to make a representation against the detention order, nor was it described to which other authority such a representation was to be made. In support of this legal proposition, reliance has been placed on a Division Bench judgment of the Delhi High Court in Cr. W.P No. 4 of 1990, Mandan Lal Anand v. Union of India, 1990 (2) Recent Criminal Reports 395. There Lordships, relying on the observations of the Supreme Court in Jagprit Singh v. Union of India, Criminal Appeal No. 29 of 1990 decided on 28-3-1990, 1990 (3) Recent Criminal Reports 311, held the declaration to be illegal and the detention of the petitioner beyond the original period of one year to be unjustified. I am in respectful agreement with the observations of the Judges of the Division Bench. I hereby allow both the criminal writ petitions and declare that the declaration order Annexure P-2 and the detention order Annexure P-3 are illegal.