Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jeeto v. State Of Haryana .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Dec 11, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (P.K. Jain, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a conviction dated 18 December 1995 by the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, under Section 15 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 ("the Act"). The appellant was sentenced to 10 years' simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 10,000, with a default sentence of 2 years' simple imprisonment.

The prosecution's case at trial was that on 16.6.1993 a police party led by ASI Om Parkash was present near the Railway Station at Loharu. The appellant, carrying a bag on her head, was observed and, on being approached by the police party, changed direction and was apprehended. The appellant allegedly disclosed that the bag contained poppy husk. The appellant and the bag were taken before Shri Randhir Singh Boora, Naib Tehsildar (acting as Executive Magistrate), where a search yielded 25 kgs. of poppy husk. A 100 gram sample was separated and both sample and remaining material were sealed as separate parcels with the seal 'HS'. The ruqa (Exhibit PC) was prepared and Exhibit PC/1 is a carbon copy of the first information report. The sealed sample parcel was sent to the Chemical Examiner and report Exhibit PE was received. A charge-sheet was filed and a charge under Section 15 of the Act was framed; the appellant pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.

At trial the prosecution examined five witnesses: PW 1 Shri Randhir Singh Boora (Executive Magistrate), PW 2 ASI Om Parkash (searching and investigating officer), PW 3 Constable Mahender Singh, PW 4 MHC Satbir Singh and PW 5 HC Rampal (the latter three tendered affidavits Exhibits PG, PH and PJ). The appellant denied the allegations under Section 313 CrPC and pleaded false implication; no defence evidence was led. The trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant, and the appellant appealed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the provisions of Section 50 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 were complied with before conducting the search, and if non-compliance vitiates the trial.
  2. Whether the prosecution established an unbroken chain of custody and excluded the possibility of tampering with the seized sample between seizure and its receipt by the Chemical Examiner.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as summarized from the opinion)

  • Non-compliance with Section 50 of the Act: The appellant's counsel argued that Section 50 was not complied with and that failure to comply vitiates the trial. Reliance was placed on several Supreme Court decisions (listed below) in support of this submission.
  • Non-examination of independent public witness: The prosecution did not examine Satbir Singh, the independent public person allegedly present, which undermines proof of compliance with Section 50.
  • Presence of Lady Constable Amita: The presence of a Lady Constable Amita (allegedly involved in the search) was not established at trial.
  • Seizure memo and signatures: It was contended that the seizure memo (Exhibit PA) appeared to have been signed after the writing over signatures was added, suggesting fabrication or later preparation.
  • Chain of custody/tampering: The prosecution failed to rule out the possibility that the sealed sample was tampered with before reaching the Chemical Examiner — the seal was handed to the public witness whose evidence was not produced, and use of another officer's seal (HC Hari Singh) was unexplained.

State's Arguments (as summarized from the opinion)

  • The search was conducted in the presence of the Executive Magistrate (PW 1), which, the State contended, satisfied the requirements of Section 50 of the Act.
  • Testimony of the Executive Magistrate (PW 1) supported the State's case and, in the State's submission, the non-examination of Satbir Singh or Lady Constable Amita was immaterial in view of PW 1's evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh, (1994) 3 SCC 299; AIR 1994 Supreme Court 1872 Relied upon by appellant to support the proposition that Section 50 of the Act must be complied with; treated as authority on mandatory nature of Section 50. The appellant relied on this as part of the argument that non-compliance vitiates the trial; the court accepted the principle that Section 50 is sacrosanct and mandatory in nature and found non-compliance.
Saiyed Mohd. Saiyed Umar Saiyed v. State of Gujarat, 1995 Cri. L.J. 2662 Relied upon by appellant in support of the mandatory nature of Section 50 compliance. Advanced by appellant to show Section 50 compliance is essential; the court's conclusions about mandatory compliance are consistent with the legal position invoked.
State of Punjab v. Jasbir Singh, 1996 SCC (Cri) 1 Relied upon by appellant on the necessity of compliance with procedural safeguards (Section 50) under the Act. Used by appellant to buttress the contention that non-compliance vitiates prosecution; the court upheld non-compliance as fatal to the prosecution case.
State of H.P. v. Pirthi Chand, 1996 SCC (Cri) 210 Relied upon by appellant for the same general principle regarding Section 50's mandatory nature. Included among authorities cited by appellant; the court applied the overarching principle that non-compliance of Section 50 undermines the prosecution.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a fact-based analysis focused on two principal strands: (1) compliance with Section 50 of the Act, and (2) the integrity of the seized sample (chain of custody).

  1. Examination of documentary record (ruqa Exhibit PC and FIR Exhibit PC/1): The court noted that the ruqa and the FIR contained no indication that the appellant had been informed of her rights under Section 50 of the Act or that she had been allowed to exercise an option regarding the mode of search. That absence was significant to the court.
  2. Testimony of the investigating officer (ASI Om Parkash, PW 2): Although PW 2 deposed that he had served a notice (Exhibit PB) informing the appellant of her choice and that the appellant put her thumb impression on the endorsement (Exhibit PB/1), the court found this testimony unconvincing because the ruqa did not corroborate such compliance and because the independent public witness alleged to be present (Satbir Singh) was not examined.
  3. Failure to call independent public witness: The prosecution gave up Satbir Singh's evidence as unnecessary; the court held this unexplained omission significant because Satbir Singh's testimony would have been the best evidence on the point of compliance with Section 50.
  4. Reliability of the Executive Magistrate's testimony (PW 1): Although PW 1's signature appears on the seizure memo, the court observed that the writing over his signature seemed to have been added after the signature was affixed. PW 1 admitted searches were conducted before him in four other cases on that day but could not reliably say whether those cases related to the same investigating officer or to the appellant's relations. This undermined confidence in PW 1's testimony.
  5. Chain of custody and possibility of tampering: The court highlighted that the seal used ('HS') was stated to have been handed to the public witness Satbir Singh, whose testimony was not produced; there was no record indicating when the seal was returned. The sealed sample was allegedly recovered on 16.6.1993 but was sent to the Chemical Examiner only on 1.7.1993. The court noted that the seal used belonged to HC Hari Singh (who was not examined), and there was no explanation why the seizing officer's own seal was not used. Taken together, these gaps left open the possibility of tampering between seizure and analysis.
  6. Legal burden and standard of proof: The court reiterated that the prosecution bears the un-shifting burden to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and that strong suspicion does not suffice. One essential fact the prosecution must affirmatively establish is that the seized material remained free from the possibility of change or tampering from seizure to analysis. Given the evidentiary lacunae identified, the court found that this essential link was not proved.
  7. Conclusion from the analysis: On the combined effect of (a) non-mention of Section 50 compliance in contemporaneous documents, (b) the non-examination of key independent witnesses, (c) questionable sequencing and signatures on the seizure memo, and (d) unexplained gaps in the custody of the seal and parcel, the court concluded that the prosecution had failed to discharge its burden and that the trial was vitiated by the procedural and evidentiary defects.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the appeal and set aside the conviction and sentence. The opinion states: CONVICTION AND SENTENCE SET ASIDE; APPELLANT ACQUITTED.

Direct implications for the parties:

  • The appellant's conviction under Section 15 of the NDPS Act and the associated sentence (10 years' simple imprisonment and fine of Rs. 10,000 with default sentence of 2 years) were set aside.
  • The appellant was acquitted of the charge and ordered to be released forthwith if not required in any other case.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasizes that non-compliance with Section 50 of the Act is sacrosanct and mandatory and that failure to exclude possibilities of tampering in the chain of custody fatally undermines a prosecution. The judgment does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond application of these principles to the facts of this case.

Appeal allowed.
Show all summary ...

P.K Jain, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment/order dated December 18, 1995, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, whereby the appellant has been convicted under section 15 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic, Substances Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) and sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 2 years.

2. The prosecution case, as can be gathered from the record of the trial court, is that on 16.6.1993, a police party headed by ASI Om Parkash, including one Satbir Singh son of Ramji Lal, was present at the crossing near Railway Station, Loharu. The appellant was sighted, having a bag on her head, coming from the front side. On seeing the police party, the appellant took a turn. She was apprehended at the spot. On an enquiry the appellant disclosed that there was poppy husk in the bag. On this reply, ASI Om Parkash along with others took the appellant before Shri Randhir Singh Boora, Naib Tehsildar (exercising the powers of an Executive Magistrate), Loharu. The search of the bag was conducted before the said Executive Magistrate and poppy husk weighing 25 kgs. was recovered. A sample of 100 gms. of the contents was separated. The sample as well as the remaining contents were converted into two separate sealed parcels with the seal of ‘HS’. Ruqa (Exhibit PC) was sent to the Police Station, on the basis of which formal first information report, carbon copy of which is Exhibit PC/1, was recorded. The appellant along with the case property was produced before SI Ranbir Singh, Officer Incharge of Police Station, Loharu. After verification, the said SHO put his seal on both the parcels and then the case property was deposited in the malkhana. The sealed sample parcel was sent to the Chemical Examiner and the report-Exhibit PE was received. After completing the investigation, a charge-sheet was filed in the Court.

3. A charge under section 15 of the Act was framed against the appellant, to which she pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.

4. In support of its case, the prosecution examined 5 witnesses. Shri Randhir Singh Boora (PW 1) is the Executive Magistrate, before whom the search of the bag, carried by the appellant, was conducted. ASI Om Parkash (PW 2) is the searching and investigating officer. Constable Mahender Singh (PW 3), MHC Satbir Singh (PW 4) and HC Rampal (PW 5) have tendered their affidavits Exhibits PG, PH and PJ, respectively.

5. In her examination under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the appellant denied the allegations of the prosecution and pleaded false implication. No evidence in defence was produced. On an appraisal of the evidence produced by the prosecution, the learned Addl. Sessions Judge convicted and sentenced the appellant, as stated above. Hence this appeal.

6. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties, who have taken me through the record of the trial court also.

7. Shri R.P Dhir, Advocate, learned counsel for the appellant, while assailing the order of conviction, has vehemently argued that the provisions of Section 50 of the Act have not been complied with at all and, therefore, the entire trial is vitiated. In support of this plea, the learned counsel has placed reliance upon well-known judgments of the Apex Court rendered Page: 766in State Of Punjab v. Balbir Singh., (1994) 3 SCC 299 : AIR 1994 Supreme Court 1872, Saiyed Mohd. Saiyed Umar Saiyed v. State of Gujarat, 1995 Cri. L.J 2662, State of Punjab v. Jasbir Singh, 1996 SCC (Cri) 1, and State of H.P v. Pirthi Chand, 1996 SCC (Cri) 210. It has also been argued by the learned counsel that the prosecution has not examined Satbir Singh, the only independent public person present in the police party, to prove the compliance of the said provision. It has also been contended that the presence of Lady Constable Amita has not been established and the seizure memo Exhibit PA was got signed from Shri Randhir Singh Boora (PW 1), later on.

8. On the other hand, learned State counsel, has argued that the search of the bag carried by the appellant was conducted in the presence of the Executive Magistrate, which fulfils the requirements of Section 50 of the Act. It has been further argued that in view of the testimony of Shri Randhir Singh Boora (PW 1), non-examination of Satbir Singh or Lady Constable Amita is immaterial.

9. I have given my careful thought to the respective arguments advanced at the Bar.

10. From a bare reading of the ruqa (Exhibit PC), it is evident that ASI Om Parkash never apprised the appellant of her right to be searched either before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate at all. There is nothing either in this ruqa or the first information report (copy of which is Exhibit PC/1) to show even that the appellant was apprised of her right under Section 50 of the Act and she was made to exercise her option. It is correct that ASI Om Prakash (PW 2) has deposed at the trial that after apprehending the appellant on suspicion, he had served her with a notice (Exhibit PB) asking her choice about the search to be conducted, and that the appellant opted for search before a Magistrate or a gazetted officer and put her thumb mark on the endorsement (Exhibit PB/1). According to the prosecution case, at that time an independent public person Satbir Singh son of Ramji Lal was present. This material witness has not been examined by the prosecution and has been given up as being unnecessary. Lady Constable Amita who is also stated to be present at that time and who is stated to have been involved in conducting search has also not been examined at the trial. The entire prosecution case regarding the compliance of Section 50 of the Act hinges upon the bald statement of ASI Om Prakash (PW 1), the Investigating Officer. The statement of ASI Om Prakash (PW 2) does not inspire any confidence. If he had apprised the appellant about her rights under Section 50 of the Act and had prepared Exhibit PB at that time, and if the appellant had exercised her option and put her thumb impression on the endorsement (Exhibit PB/1), the same must have been found to be mentioned in the ruqa (Ext. PC), which was prepared much later on after the alleged recovery of the poppy husk. Since there is no mention regarding compliance of Section 50 of the Act either in the ruqa or in the first information report, it appears that Exhibit PB had been prepared later on just to fill up the lacuna. The learned State counsel has not been able to give any explanation as to why the independent public witness whose evidence could have been the best on the point, had been given up. The testimony of Shri Randhir Singh Boora (PW 1) regarding conducting of the search of a bag being carried by the appellant before him also does not inspire confidence. The obvious reason is that the seizure memo does contain his signatures but the same appears to have been obtained first and thereafter the seizure memo appears to have been prepared.

11. A bare look at this document would go to show that the writing over the signatures of Shri Randhir Singh Boora (PW 1) has been made after the signatures had been put thereon. Further this witness admits that on that very day in four other cases search was conducted before him but was unable to say as to whether all those cases related to the relations of the appellant or to the same Investigating Officer. It is interesting to note that in his cross-examination, ASI Om Prakash (PW 2), the Investigating Officer, has shown lack of memory relating to the question if on that very day he had produced any other accused under the Act before this very witness before conducting search.

12. In view of the above discussion, the only conclusion is that ASI Om Prakashdid not comply with the provisions of Section 50 of the Act before conducting the search of the bag alleged to have been carried by the appellant. It is not disputed that non-compliance of Section 50 of the Act, which provision has been held to be sacrosanct and mandatory in nature, strikes at the core of the prosecution case, and vitiates the trial itself.

13. Another weighty argument advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant is that the prosecution has failed to rule out the possibility of the so-called sealed sample having not Page: 767been tampered with till it reached the hands of the Chemical Examiner. To appreciate this argument, it may be noted that the seal after use is stated to have been handed over to the public witness Satbir Singh who has been withheld by the prosecution for the reasons best known to it. According to the prpsecution case, the alleged contraband was recovered on 16.6.1993 and the sealed sample parcel was sent to the office of Chemical Examiner on 1.7.1993 There is nothing on the record to show as to when the alleged seal was returned by Satbir Singh, the independent public person. It is also important to note that the seal used by ASI Om Prakash belonged to HC Hari Singh, who has also not been examined. There is no explanation forthcoming as to why the seal of HC Hari Singh was used instead of the seal of the seizing officer himself. In other words, there was ample time and opportunity with the police to tamper with the sample parcel and it cannot be said that the sample which reached the hands of the Chemical Examiner was the same which is stated to have been prepared at the spot of occurrence.

14. At the conclusion of the trial, the prosecution can succeed only on discharging the un-shifting burden of proving its case against the accused and strongest of suspicion does not constitute the proof required. One of the essential facts to be proved affirmatively by the prosecution is that right from the stage of the seizure till it reaches the hands of the Chemical Analyst, there was no possibility to change or tamper with the recovered material. In the present case, the prosecution has failed to prove this essential ingredient to prove the guilt of the appellant. In the absence of this vital link, the conviction of the appellant is flawed. It is well known in criminal law that “fouler the crime, the greater the evidence.” The word ‘greater’ does not signify ‘in quantity’ but denotes ‘in quality’. In my considered view, the prosecution has failed to prove its case against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt.

15. For the reasons mentioned above, this appeal succeeds. The conviction and sentence of the appellant are set aside and she is acquitted of the charge under section 15 of the Act. The appellant be released forthwith, if not wanted in any other case.

Appeal allowed.