- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sewa Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
Tek Chand, J.:— Eleven petitioners who are working as Assistants and Clerks in the Office of Chief Engineer (Canals), Irrigation Works, Punjab, at Chandigarh, have preferred this petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India praying for the issuance of an appropriate writ, direction or order, quashing the order of responcent No. 2 Shri Tirlochan Singh, Chief Engineer, dated 2rd of September, 1967 (Annexure E), by which the petitioner have been ordered to be transferred from the Irrigation Branch, Head Office Chandigarh to Beas Project Administration an undertaking of the Central Government—outside the administrative control of the Punjab Government. Respondent No. 1 is the State of Punjab.
2. It is alleged in the petition that prior to 1st of November, 1961 the petitioners were in the employment of the erstwhile State of Punjab and hive since been provisionally allocated to the reorganised State of Punjab. The conditions of service of the petitioners before 1st of November, 1966 were regulated by the statutory rules framed by Governor of Punjab on 31st of July, 1955, called the Punjab Public Works Department (Irrigation Branch) Head Office Clerical (State Service Class III) Rules 1965 Rule 16 which is relevant for purposes of this case runs as under
“16. Every member of the Service shall be liable to transfer under the orders of:—
(a) the Government, to any other department or office of the Punjab Government;
(b) the appointing authority with the State of Punjab or any other place in India where he may be required to proceed under the administrative control of the Punjab Government in the Service of which he is a member.” The contention of the petitioners is that it was a condition of the service of the petitioners as incorporated in the Service Rules and has been continued after 1st of November, 1966 which is the appointed day for coming into force of the Punjab Rtoreanisation Act, 1966, when the erstwhile State of Punjab was bifurcated into the present State of Punjab and the State of Haryana by the Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966. The relevant provisions which have to be construed are reproduced below;—
“PART VIII
Bhakra-Nangal and Beas Projects.
78. Rights and Liabilities in regard to Bhakra-Nangal and Beas Projects.
(1) Notwithstanding anything cantained in this Act but subject to the provisions of sections 79 and 80, all rights and liabilities of the existing State of Punjab in relation to Bhakra Nangal Project and Beas Project shall, on the appointed day, be the lights and liabilities of the successor States in such proportion as may be fixed and subject to such adjustments as may be made, by agreement entered into by the said States after consultation with the Central Government or, if so such agreement is entered into within two years of the appointed day, as the Central Government may by order determine having regard to the purposes of the projects:
Provided that the order so made by the Central Government may be varied by any subsequent agreement entered into by the successor States after consultation with the Central Government
80. Contraction of Beas Project.
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any other law, the construction (including the completion of any work already commenced) of the Beas Project shall, on and from the appionted day, be undertaken by the Central Government on behalf of the successor States and the State of Rajasthan:
Provided that the Governments of the successor States and the State of Rajasthan shall at all times provide the necessary funds to the Central Government for the expenditure on the Project (including the expenses of the Board referred to in sub-section (2) and such amounts shall be apportioned among the successor States and the State of Rajasthan in such proportion as may be fixed by the Central Government after consultation with the Governments of the said States.
(2) For the discharge of its function under sub-section (1) the Central Government may:
(a) by notification in the Official Gazette aid in consultation with the Governments of the successor states and the States of Rajasthan, constitute a Board to be called the Beas Constiuction Board with such members as it may deem lit and assign to the Board such functions as it may consider necessary; and
(b) issue such direction to the State Governments of Haryana, Punjab and Rsjasthan and the Administrator of the Union Territory of Himachal Pradesh or any other authority, and the State Governments, Administrator or other authority shall comply with such directions.
(3) The notification constituting a Board under clause (a) of sub-section (2) may empower the Board to appoint such staff as may be necessary for the efficient discharge of its functions:
Provided that every person who immediately before the constitution of the Board was engaged in the construction or any work relating to the Beas Project shall continue to be so employed by the ??? in connection with said works on this same terms and Page: 207conditions of service as were applicable to him before such constitution until the Central Government by order directs otherwise:
Provided further that the Board may at any time in consultation with the State Government or the Electricity Board concerned and with the previous approval of the Central Government return any such person for service under that Government or Board.
3. Prior to 1st of November, 1966, and even after that date, the petitioners were working in the off the of Chief Engineer, Irrigation Works, Punjab at Chandigarh. Respondent No. 2 was appointed Chief Engineer on 31st of July, 1967 and on 25th of August, 1967, he was given charge of non-gazstted establishment. It was alleged that immediately after assuming the charge of the non-gazetted establishment, respondent No. 2 decided to transfer the whole staff of the non-gazetted establishment section of Irrigation Branch, Head Office. It may be mentioned that out of the entire staff two women Clerk who were working on three months' basis and another clerk who was posted in the non gazetted section only three months ago, had not been transferred but all others were. The petitioners submitted a number of representations to the Government against their apprehended transfers and made repeated requests but no action was taken on their representations. Copies of these representations are annexed as ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’ and ‘D’ The petitioners case is that with effect from 1st of November, 1966, the construction of the Beas Project has been undertaken by the Central Government on behalf of the successor States and the State of Rajasthan as contemplated by section 80 of the Act. It may be mentioned at this stage that subsequent to the making of writ petition, the Central Government has constituted a statutory Board which inter alia is empowered to appoint such staff as may be necessary for the efficient discharge of its functions. On 23rd of September, 1967, respondent No. 2 ordered posting; and transfers of Assistants and Clerks vide Annexure ‘E’ which is reproduced below:—
“Public Works Department
??? Branch
Office Order.
No. 10599.Admn/1017/45/1015/45 Dated 23rd September, 1967.
The following postings and transfers of Assistants and Clerks ire hereby ordered with immediate effect in public interest.
S. No. Name Designation Section from Section to 1. Shrvshri Sajjan Dass Seda Assistant Central Record NG 2. Ajmer Singh -do- Budget NG 3. Kartar Singh -do- Workshop NG 4. Verinder Sen Chopra -do- General NG 5. Rajinder Singh -do- Pension NG
6. Dess Raj Soi Assistant Construction NG 7. Dev Raj -do- Audit NG 8. Sukh Dayal Metha Clerk Confirmation NG 9. Ram Parkash -do- Construction NG 10. Man Mohan Sahejpal -do- Pension NG 11. jit Singh Philora -do- Audit NG
The above named Assistants and Clerks are temporarily posted. In Non-Gazetted Establishment Section till further orders relieving following Assistants and Clerks of Non-Gazetted Establishment Section who are transferred to Beas Project Administration.
1. Shri Sewa Ram Assistant Assistant 2. Shri Gajinder Singh -do- 3. Shri Rameshwar Dass -do- 4. Shri Nand Singh -do- 5. Shri Arjan Singh Wirdi -do- 6. Shri Mohinder Singh Duggal -do- 7. Shri Gian Singh -do- 8. Shri Mohinder Singh Kahlon -do- 9. Shri Chaman Lal Goyal -do- 10. Shri Raja Ram -do- 11. Shri Charan Singh -do-
(Sd.) ……
Registrar,
for Chief Engineer (C) Irrigation Works,
Punjab, Chandigarh.
4. It is this order which has been impugned in this petition. In the affidavit filed by respondent No. 2 by way of return, most of the facts were admitted it was alleged that rule 310 of the Punjab Civil Services Rules Volume I, Part I, framed under Article 309 of the Constitution made the order of the transfer in accordance with law. This provision runs as under:
“Unless in any case it be otherwise distinctly provided, the whole time of a Government servant is at the disposal of the Government which pays him and he may be employed in any manner lequired by proper authority, without claim or additional remuneration whether the services required of him are such as would ordinarily be remunerated from Union or State revenues, or from the revenues of local fund.” Reference was also made to section 78(1) of the Punjab Reorganisation Act providing that all rights and liabilities of the existing State of Purjab in relation to Beas Project, shall on the appointed day be the rights and liabilities of the successor States; and the staff working in connection with the Beas Project, allocated to Punjab for purpose of confirmation, promotions, reversions, disciplinary action and transfers etc. had been controlled by the Punjab State. On this basis orders of transfer passed in respect of the petitioners were said to be lawful.
5. Preliminary objections have been raised which may be considered first. It is contended that there should have been eleven Page: 209Separate petition of writ and not one Joint petition and that on this ground alone, the petition is liable to be dismissed. Reliance was placed upon a decision of the Division Bench of this court reported in The Revenue Patwaris Union Punjab, Chandigarh v. The State of Punjab (1). That was a case of a writ petition having been filled on behalf of all the Patwaris of the State by the Revenue ??? Union, Punjab, challenging the authority and jurisdiction of the District Boards in the entire State to impose profession tax on the petitioners. It was held that such an omnibus petition did not lie and each of the petitioners had to file an independent petition. It may be mentioned that in that case, it was conceded by the counsel on behalf of the petitioner Union that such a petition was not competent. Reliance was placed upon a decision of a single Judge in S.M. Muhammad Ibrahim v. Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, ??? Tiruchiraipalli District 2 and on M.S. Ganapathi Nadar v. State Of Madras (3). It was held in these decisions that the fact that the relief prayed for by the several individuals whose ??? right was alleged to have been invaded improperly by the impugned order was grounded on a common objection, did not afford any basis for a joint writ petition on behalf of the several petitioners aggrieved by similar orders. In a single Bench decision reported in Vinod Kumar… v. Municipal Committee Pathankot… (4) it has been held that it now appears to be well settled that the mere fact that a common question arises for consideration is not enough to justify the making of a joint petition Similar orders may be passed in dealing with cases of different individuals, but that does not justify the filing of a single writ petition when the orders relate to individual rights of different persons. In that case a Municipal Committee had issued notices demanding tehbazari from different persons under in section 173. This action of the Municipal Committee was contested a joint petition made by five different persons who were in occupation of separate premises and different areas. It was held that this was not ??? and the Division Bench decision in the case of the Revenue Patwaris Union was followed. Another Division Bench in Jiwan Singh v. Consolidation Officer, Sunam (5), where a contrary view was held was distinguished on the ground that the expression of view was in the nature of a Obitor dictum.
6. The facts of these two cases are distinct. The instant case is of one order and not of a similar order. The impugned order has hit every petitioner alike and same relief on identical grounds has been prayed. In my view, this is a case more appropriately covered by the several decisions cited by the learned counsel for the petitioners.
7. In Mrs. J.K Pritam Singh v. The State of Punjab (6). A Division Bench of this Court had expressed the view that where all petitioners had been hit by the same impugned order and were claiming same relief on the same grounds, the objection that separate writ petitions should have been filed could not seriously be pressed. Reliance was placed upon. The State of Punjab v. Kauhar Singh(7). In that case, eighteen different landowners had filed a single petition for quashing acquisition proceedings Page: 210taken in pursuance of the notification under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act Reliance had been placed before the Letter Patent Bench on the Division Bench decision cited above. The Revenue Patwaris Union, Punjab, Chandigarh v. The State of Punjab (1). That case was held to be of no application because a notification was issued for the acquisition of land in a particular village and therefore, all or any of the persons affected by the notification could jointly file a petition challenging its validity. Falshaw, C.J remarked—
“I find it somewhat surprising that this point was pressed at all, since even if the petition could only be entertained as being on behalf of any one of the petitioners the effect in the event of its success would be the quashing of the whole acquisition proceedings once the notification was held to be invalid.”
8. The fact and the decision in the above case are more appropriately applicable by way of analogy. This principle has further been upheld in Khem Karan v. State of Uttar Pradesh (8) Reference may also be made to Extraordinary Legal Remedies by Ferris, para 238 at page 275:
“The rule is that persons having a common and joint interest in the subject matter in controversy may be joined as relators while those having separate and distinct rights may not.”
9. For reasons stated above, there is no force in this preliminary objection which can not prevail.
10. The next objection on behalf of the respondents is that the impugned order is administrative in character and that it was within the discretion of the appointing autority to transfer the Government servant. There is no quarrel whatsoever with this proposition. The question, however, is whether the impugned order is ultra virss of the appointing authority and if so, can it be sustained? Strictly speaking, this is not an objection of a preliminary character as it cannot be disposed of without an enquiry as to whether it is ultra vires or otherwise. This alls for examination of the relevant provision of law. The liability for transfer of every member of the Service is contemplated in rule 16 of the Public Wirks Department Clerical Rules, 1965, referred to above provided it is within the periphery of the provisions. The transfer of the petitioners was admittedly not to any other department or office of the Puajab Government. The appointing authority has also the power to transfer such an employee to any place in India where he may be required to proceed under the administritive control of the Punjab Government. The question therefore, is, have the petitioners been ordered to bj transferred to a place “under the administrative control of the Punjab Government in the service of which he is a member”. It is maintained on behalf of the petitioner that Beas Project administration was not under the administrative control of the Punjab Government when the impugned order (Annexure, E) was made.
11. Two provisions of the Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966, need being considered. Part VIII of the Act contains provisions regarding Biaakra-Nangal and Beas Projects, under Sections 78(1), notwithstanding Page: 211anything contained in the Act but subject to the provision of sections 79 and 80 all rights and liabilities of the existing State of Punjab in relation to these Projects shall, on the appointed day, be the rights and liabilities of the successor States in such proportion as may be fixed. Section 80(1) of the Act provides, that notwithstanding anything contained in the Act or in any other law, the construction of the Beas Project shall, and from the appointed day, be undertaken by the Central Government on behalf of the successor States and the State of Rajasthan. Thus, with effect from 1st of November, 1966, the construction of the Project has become the undertaking of the Central Government. For the discharge of its functions, the Central Government is empowered to constitute the Beas Construction Board after consulting the State concerned. The notification constituting a Board may empower the Board to appoint such staff as may be necessary for the efficient discharge of its functions. The first proviso to section 80(3) ensures that every person who immediately before the Constitution of the Board was engaged in the construction shall continue to be employed by the Board on the same terms and conditions of service as were applicable to him formerly. The second proviso enables the Board, in consultation with the State Government or the Electricity Board concerned, and with the previous approval of the Central Government, to return any such person for service under that Government or Board. The contention of the petitioners is, that they are not in the service of Beas Project Administration on and alter 1st of November, 1966. At all material times, the petitioners were working in the office of the Chief Engineer, litigation Works, Punjab. Their further contention is that although Beas Project Administration was in existence even prior to 1st of November, 1966 but they never worked under that Administration. Alternatively, on the assumption that they were working in Beas Project Administration, they were liable to be transferred from one place to another under that Administration provided, order of transfer was given by an authority having jurisdiction. On 1st of November, 1966, jurisdiction of Punjab Government came to an end and was replaced by that of the Central Government which never was the petitioners employer. They have been and they still are in the service of the Punjab Government. Now that Punjab Government has ceased to have jurisdiction in respect of project which has gone under the administrative control of Central Government, the order of transfer to a Service under that Government is ultra vires.
12. The order of transfer is not in accordance with a statute or a statutory rule. A statutory rule cannot be equated with administrative directions vide State of Uttar Pradesh v. Babu Ram Upadhya (9). Reliance was placed on behalf of the respondents on rule 3.10 of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume I, Part I, which is to the effect, that the whole time of a Government servant is at the disposal of the Government and he may be employed in any manner required by proper authority without claim or additional remuneration. Apart from the doubtful applicability of this provision to the facts of the case, rule 1.4 provides, that these rules shall not apply to any person for whose appointment and conditions Page: 212of service, special provision is made by or under any law for the time being in force. There are special provisions governing the case of the petitioners vide the Punjab Public Works Department (Irrigation Branch) Head Office, Clerical (State Service Class III), Rules, 1965.
13. For the reasons stated above, respondent No. 2 had no jurisdiction to pass the order of transfer which he did on 23rd of September, 1967, after the Punjab Recorganisation Act had come into force. It has been held by Supreme Court in P.J Irani v. State of Madras (10) that the High Courts do not lack power under Article 226 to set aside an ultra vires order. In another case Calcutta Discount Co. Ltd. v. Income-Tax officer, Companies District 1, Calcutta (11), the Supreme Court held that it was well settled that though the writ of probation or of certiorari would not issue against an executive authority, the High Courts and power to issue in a fit case an order prohibiting an executive authority from acting without jurisdiction.
14. It was argued on behalf on the respondents that section 80 referred to constiuction of the Beas Project which meant construction of the dam and other works and such construction work alone was brought under the control of the Central Government and the residuary rights and liabilities of the Punjab State were not adversely affected. It was maintained that construction of Project could not include the administrative control referred to in rule 16. This argument is not free from flaw. What passed on to the Central Government was construction of the Project and not the construction of a particular dam or building. Moreover, the work of the office cannot be dissociated from the work of construction of Project. Office is an integral part of the Project and it comes into being even before the actual construction.
15. Lastly it was urged, that on 1st of October 1967, a notification has been issued constituting the Beas Construction Board, under section 80, the Board has the power to appoint such stiff as may be necessary for the discharge of its functions and such control as the Central Government had, has now been passed on to the Board.
16. The order of transfer passed by respondent No. 2 has become infructuous. He certainly cannot transfer the petitioners to serve under the Bsas Construction Board which is an independent body. The question is whether this Court can take notice of an event subsequent to the presentation of the writ petition. In this connection observations of Gwyer, C.J Lachmeshar Prasad Shukal v. Keshwar Lal Choudhun (12) may be cited with advantage.
“With regard to the question whether the Court is entitled to take into account legislative changes since the decision under appeal was given. I desire to point out that the rule adopted by the Supreme Court of the United States is the same as that which I think commends itself to all three members of this Court. In (1934) 294 U.S 600 at p. 607, Hughes, C.J said:
We have frequently held that in the exercise of our appellate jurisdiction we have power not only to correct error in the judgment under review but to make such disposition of the case as justice requires. Aid in determining what justice does require, the Court is bound to consider any change, either in fact or in law, which has supervened since the judgment was entered.
17. This view of its powers was re-affirmed by the Court in a case decided as recently as March last: (1940) 300 U.S 551 at p. 555.”
18. The learned counsel for the petitioners, also, rested his case on mala fides but I do not find it necessary to go into that question.
19. I feel satisfied, for reasons stated above, that the impugned order (Annexure E) dated 23rd of September, 1967, ordering the transfer of the petitioners, was without jurisdiction and ultravires, and it is, therefore, quashed. The result is that the writ petition is allowed but I leave the parties to bear their own costs.
20. Petition allowed.
Alert