Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Punjab State Through Land Acquisition Collector v. Gurbachan Singh And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jul 27, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

State Appeal No. 1628 of 1979 and the connected cross-objections were heard together because they involved identical questions of law and fact. Following a Section 4 notification dated 20 January 1971, the State acquired 31 acres 1 kanal 14 marlas at Kapurthala for establishing a grain market. The Collector valued different portions at Rs. 30,000 and Rs. 16,000 per acre. On reference under Section 18, the District Court awarded compensation at Rs. 270 per marla. The State challenged the enhancement, while the landowners filed cross-objections seeking further relief. [1]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What was the appropriate market value of the acquired land in light of the earlier Collector’s award and the comparative location and development potential of the properties? [2][3][4]
  2. Whether compensation was payable for severance of the unacquired portion of Khasra No. 2352, which had allegedly become inaccessible. [5][6]
  3. Whether additional amount, solatium, and interest were calculable on both market value and severance damages, or only on the market value. [7][8]

Arguments of the Parties

State

  • The State challenged the District Court’s enhancement of compensation to Rs. 270 per marla. [1]

Landowner-Claimants

  • The landowners argued that the earlier 1968 acquisition could not be treated as comparable because of the intervening time and the superior location and development potential of the land acquired in 1971. [2][3]
  • They claimed compensation for severance because 19 kanals 9 marlas left out of Khasra No. 2352 had become completely inaccessible. [5]
  • They further argued that the statutory additional amount, solatium, and interest should be calculated on the entire compensation, including severance damages. [7]

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Norinder Kaur v. State of Punjab, 1980 PLR 473 Where acquisition renders unacquired land completely inaccessible and causes total loss, severance damages may be measured by diminution in value, with at least 50% of the unacquired land’s market value payable. The Court applied this principle and awarded Rs. 170 per marla for the severed land. [5][6]
State of Madras represented by Collector of Madras v. Mohamed Mustafa, AIR 1971 Madras 213 Recognizes the distinction between market value and damages payable for severance. The Court relied on the distinction to hold that additional amount and solatium are payable only on market value. [7][8]
State Of Bihar… v. Rameshwar Singh…, AIR 1973 Patna 123 Supports the distinction between market value and severance damages under Section 23. The Court cited the decision in concluding that severance damages do not form part of market value for calculating additional amount and solatium. [7][8]

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court found no merit in the State’s appeal and considered the landowners entitled to further relief. [9]

The District Court had relied entirely on an earlier 1968 Collector’s award fixing compensation at Rs. 270 per marla. The Court held that the comparison was inadequate because the present land was situated on the main Kapurthala-Sultanpur Lodhi Road, surrounded by industrial establishments, close to the railway station, and had significant residential and commercial potential. [2][3][4]

Considering these differences and the available objective material, the Court allowed an increase of approximately 25% over the earlier rate and fixed the market value at Rs. 340 per marla. It recognized that valuation necessarily involves an element of estimation based on the evidence available. [4]

The evidence established that the unacquired area of 19 kanals 9 marlas in Khasra No. 2352 was inaccessible. The alleged passage referred to by the District Court was unsupported by the site plan or other testimony. Applying the principle stated in Smt. Norinder Kaur v. State of Punjab, the Court awarded severance compensation at Rs. 170 per marla, representing one-half of the market value. [5][6]

The Court distinguished market value under clause first of Section 23(1) from severance damages under clause thirdly. It therefore held that the additional amount under Section 23(1-A) and solatium under Section 23(2) are payable only on market value, whereas interest is payable on the entire compensation, including both market value and severance damages. [7][8]

Holding and Implications

The State appeal was dismissed, and the landowners’ cross-objections were allowed with proportionate costs. The market value was fixed at Rs. 340 per marla, and the unacquired severed land was compensated at Rs. 170 per marla. [4][6][10][11]

Additional amount and solatium apply only to market value, while interest applies to the full compensation amount, including severance damages. The opinion identifies no broader implication or new precedent beyond applying the cited principles to these parties. [8]

Show all summary ...

I.S Tiwana, J. (Oral) — State Appeal No. 1628 of 1979 and Cross Objections to the same No. 15.C-I/80 are disposed of together, as concededly, in both identical questions of law and fact arise for consideration. As a result of the notification published under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, on 20th of January, 1971, 31 acres 1 kanal 14 marlas of land including that of the objectors was acquired by the State Government for setting up a grain market at Kapurthala,. a district headquarter. For evaluating this land, the Collector categorised it as urban and suburban and determined its market value at Rs. 30,000/- and Rs. 16,000/- per acre respectively. Since the objector-landowners did not feel satisfied with the adequacy of this compensation, they sought a reference under section 18 of the Act and as a result of that the District Court, Kapurthala, directed the payment of compensation at a flat rate of Rs. 270/- per marla. The State authorities make a grouse of this enhancement. On the other hand, the objectors still not feeling satisfied with the extent of the amount allowed to them have chosen to file their cross-objections.

2. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties at some length in the light of the evidence on the record, I find no merit in the State Appeal. On the contrary, the objectors deserve relief for the following reasons.

3. For evaluating the acquired land at Rs. 270/- per marla, the lower Court has entirely depended upon an earlier award of the Collector Exhibit P. 20. Vide this award, the market value of certain land acquired in pursuance of a notification published under Section 4 of the Act on 28th November, 1968 was determined at the same very rate i.e Rs. 270/- per marla. This acquisition was effected for the construction of godowns by the Food Corporation of India. It is seriously contended by Mr. Aggarwal, the learned counsel for the objector-landowners that the two acquisitions could not possibly be treated at par on account of the time lag that intervened the same. This according to the learned counsel is more so, in view of the following findings recorded by the Court itself. In paragraph 18 of its judgment the Court has observed:

Page: 548“I have considered the arguments and the locations of the two lands. It is to be noted that the Abadi of Kapurthala city extends up to the railway station and the land covered by award is across the railway station and the railway lines. It is not connected by the road excepting the road leading to the railway station. As against this land in question is located on the main Kapurthala-Sultanpur Road and is surrounded by Industrial Complexes like Tanneries, Rice Shellers and Palson Industry. The area is fast developing and the construction of the grain market had added to its charm and value. It is also close to the railway station. Even by a zigzag road, the railway godowns are about two furlongs from the land in question. In this way, this can be said to be on a better footing than the land covered by the award Exhibit P. 20. If compensation at the rate of Rs. 270/- per marla was found by the Collector Acquisition to be reasonable in 1968 relating to the land covered by. award Exhibit P. 20, the compensation for the land presently in question should be at a higher level. The petitioners have not been able to produce any reliable evidence to show how far the price of land in question should be higher than the compensation awarded by the award Exhibit P. 20 and therefore, the petitioners can be granted minimum possible compensation at the same rate. In this manner they would be given the rates prevailing in 1968 in another locality which was much inferior to the locality in question.”

4. The contention of Mr. Agarwal, as noticed above obviously has merit. It is w??? indicated by the site plan Exhibit P. 1 that the area covered by Exhibit 20 lay at a considerable distance from the suit land on the main Kapurthala Sultanpur Lodhi road. Further the suit land had acquired a very great potential for being utilised as residential and commercial area by the time it was notified for acquisition. It, therefore, appears wholly unjust and unfair to treat this land at par with the land covered by Exhibit P. 20. Keeping in view the totality of facts and circumstances, it appears fair to me to allow a raise of about 25 per cent on the rate at which the land covered by Exhibit P. 20 was evaluated. I, therefore, determine the market value of the presently acquired land at Rs. 340/- per marla. It hardly need be highlighted at this stage that in these matters some sort of guoss work has essentially to be resorted to in the light of the objective data available on record in order to compensate the owners of land which has been acquired.

5. The other claim of the landowners is under clause 3 of sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the Act i.e, they have hot been justly compensated for the severance of their land which has been totally rendered inaccesssible on account of the present acquisition. In order to sustain this plea, it is pointed out by their learned counsel that out of Khasra No. 2352, an area measuring 19 kanals 9 marals has been left out of acquisition and the said area is not accessible from any side. The factual position is not in dispute in the light of the evidence of Bachan Singh Patwari (P.W 1) and Gurbachan Singh objector himself. There is no rebuttal to this evidence whatsoever. It is, therefore, patent that the landowner-objectors cannot utilize the land left with them out of Khasra No. 2352. The observation made in the last paragraph of the impugned judgment to the effect that “there is a passage 13 karams away on the western side of the remaining land” i.e, the severed land appears to be wholly ill-founded. The site plan Exhibit P. 1 does not indicate any such passage nor has any other witness spoken about it. In somewhat similar situation, in an earlier judgment in Smt. Norinder Kaur v. State of Punjab and other, 1980 PLR 473, I had opined that where the acquired land had rendered the unacquired area completely Page: 549inaccessible and ??? total loss, the measure of damage by severance would undoubtedly be the diminution in the value of the unacquired land and the owner is entitled to at least 50 per cent of the market value of the unacquired land by way of damages for its severance from the acquired land in addition to the market value of the acquired land.

6. For the detailed reasons recorded in that judgment, I direct that for their unacquired land of Khasra No. 2352 i.e, 19 kanals 9 marlas, the obje???s would be paid compensation at the rate of Rs. 170/- per marla, i.e, one half of the market val???e determined for the acquired land.

7. Lastly, it is maintained by Mr. Aggarwal that the payments to be made to the claimants in terms of Sections 23(1-A), 23(2) and 28 of the Act are to be worked out on the basis of the entire amount of compensation payable to them, i.e, the market value of their acquired land and the damages assessed under clause ‘thirdly’ of Section 23 of the Act. This, however, appears untenable. So far as the claims under Section 23 (1-A) and sub-section (2) of this section are concerned, the learned counsel appears to ignore the distinction between the market value as permissible under clause first of sub-section (1) and the amount of damages payable under clause thirdly of this sub-section. The amount of damages cannot possibly be treated as part of the market value. The distinction in the two phrases has clearly been noticed by the two Division Benches in the State of Madras represented by Collector of Madras v. Mohamed Mustafa, AIR 1971 Madras 213 and State Of Bihar… v. Rameshwar Singh…., AIR 1973 Patna 123.

8. I, therefore, hold that the additional amount and solatium as envisaged by Section 23 (1-A) and sub-section (2) respectively are payable only on the market value, as determined under clause first of sub-section (1) of Section 23 and not on the amount as determined under clause thirdly of this sub-section. The interest as envisaged by Sec. 23 of the Act it, of course, payable on the entire amount of compensation, i.e, the market value and the damages assessed under clause thirdly of sub-section (1) of Section 23, at compensation essentially includes market value and the damages payable to a landowner on account of the acquisition of his land.

9. For the reasons recorded above, the State Appeal is dismissed but with no order as to costs and the Cross-Objections filed by the landowner-claimants are allowed, as already indicated, with proportionate costs.

Appeal dismissed.