- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri Ashwani Kumar Sehgal v. Smt. Swatantar Sehgal
6. The evidence produced by the appellant in this case about cruelty consists of the oral evidence of himself and his father. Both of them have alleged that the conduct of the respondent was unbecoming of a family member living in a joint family. The appellant states that soon after the marriage the respondent started persuading him to live separately from the family suggesting that they can manage to live comfortably with the pay, which he was drawing, When he did not accede to this proposal, then the respondent started picking up quarrels on trifles to the inconvenience of the family. But these trifles have not been described by him. He only mentioned that there used to be pin-pricking with his mother or sister. The appellant has failed to describe the conduct of the respondent during this period to satisfy the two elements of cruelty referred above and justify the appellant's taking a drastic step for asking for a divorce decree so soon after their marriage. After going through the evidence of the witnesses examined in the Court and hearing the learned counsel, I am not impressed by the evidence and also do not find cogent of sufficient ground to hold that there was any cruelty on the part of the respondent so as to justify the acceptance of this prayer. 7. The statement of the appellant that the respondent left his house suddenly on November 23, 1975, on the pretext of her mother's illness failed to impress the learned trial Judge. It has failed to create any impression in my mind also. The illness of a mother-in-law to the newely weds in usually a matter of some concern. If the respondent had left so suddenly on that pretext the appellant was expected subsequently to call on his mother-in-law on the same evening or on the following day to enquire about her health. When enquired about this, he admitted that he did not do so, but went there on the third day. His conduct exposes the weakness of the ground, which has been projected by him. It seems to me that it has been contrived only as a ground to justify the petition. 8. On the other hand, the case of the respondent is that soon after the marriage she was continuously nagged by herein laws and the husband for the meagreness dowry. When she could not satisfy their demands, she was maltreated by the appellant. Apparently from the circumstances this seems to be made out. It is difficult to imagine that a newly married girl within such a short time of marriage would acquire such a quarrelsome stance towards her husband or his parents without any serious reason. The cause for the difference between the parties appears to be on the question of dowry, which as it is common becomes a matter of controversy soon after the marriage. The possibility, therefore, cannot be ruled out that it was the appellant and his family members, who tried to be quarrelsome on the ground of insufficiency of the dowry. The appellant orally stated that the plot was allotted to him after the respondent had left the house on November 23, 1975. His oral assertion on that point is not sufficient. which could best be proved from better evidence that is by the production of the record regarding the allotment of the plot. 9. From the circumstances of the case, the appellant has failed to prove that because of the temperamental behaviour of the respondent and his inability to meet her demand for a separate residence, the atmosphere was so created by her that he could not live comfortably with her as his spouse and that it would be injurious or harmful for him to live with the respondent. 10. As the appellant has failed to make out a case or to prove the circumstances alleged by him, the appeal is without any merit and the same is dismissed with costs. Counsel fee Rs. 100/-. Appeal dismissed.
Alert