- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Makhan Lal v. Anand Parkash
Judgment Summary — Mehar Singh, J. (Revision Application)
Factual and Procedural Background
The present revision challenges an appellate order dated October 8, 1960, which accepted a landlord's appeal under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 and ordered eviction of the tenant for arrears of rent and for not having paid or tendered the rent due on the first hearing of the landlord's application.
The landlord's original application claimed arrears computed at a rate of Rs. 600 per annum for the period 1 April 1954 to 7 July 1959. The first hearing occurred on 5 August 1959. On that date the tenant tendered rent calculated at Rs. 300 per annum (totaling Rs. 925 plus interest and costs as recorded), and disputed the landlord's assertion that the rent was Rs. 600 per annum.
The Rent Controller conducted an enquiry and, relying on the tenant's admission in reply Exhibit P.F., found that the rent had been increased from Rs. 300 to Rs. 600 per annum from 3 December 1956. The Controller allowed the tenant to make up the difference by the next day; the tenant did so and the Controller concluded there had been compliance with the proviso to Section 13(2)(i) and dismissed the eviction application.
On appeal, the Appellate Authority accepted the landlord's appeal, concluded (as recorded) that the increase took effect from 3 December 1966, held that the tenant had not tendered the whole arrears due at the first hearing and therefore was not entitled to the proviso's protection, and ordered eviction. The tenant filed the present revision against that appellate order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an agreement between landlord and tenant increasing the rent is void under Section 6(1)(b) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, and, if so, whether such an increase must be ignored for the purposes of the proviso to Section 13(2)(i).
- Whether Section 6(1)(b) applies only when the Controller has fixed the fair rent (i.e., whether the prohibition in Section 6 applies only after fixation of fair rent under Section 4).
- Whether the phrase "any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent" in Section 6(1)(b) refers to lump-sum demands (such as a fine or premium) or also covers contractual increases in periodic rent agreed between parties.
- Whether an argument on pure question of law (regarding effect of Section 6) can be raised for the first time in a revision petition when it was not argued before the authorities below.
Arguments of the Parties
Tenant's Arguments
- Section 6(1)(b) makes any agreement between landlord and tenant that increases rent null and void; therefore, for the purposes of the proviso to Section 13(2)(i) any contractual increase must be ignored and the tender made by the tenant at Rs. 300 per annum on the first hearing was adequate.
- Because the contractual increase is void, the tenant was entitled to the statutory protection and eviction should not have been ordered by the appellate authority.
Landlord's Arguments
- Section 6 should be read as applying only when the Controller has fixed the fair rent; because no fair rent had been fixed in this case, Section 6 does not operate to void a contractual increase.
- Even if Section 6 is applicable, the phrase "any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent" in Section 6(1)(b) refers to lump-sum demands (fines or premiums) and not to an agreed increase in periodic rent.
- The tenant's present argument (relying on Section 6) was not advanced before the authorities below and should not be permitted at the revision stage.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jamuna Bai v. Narayanamurthy, AIR 1909 A.P. 108 | The opinion collected several reported cases; cited as a collection of authorities mentioned by the parties. | The court reviewed this collection and the other referred cases and concluded that none of them decided the particular question before the court. |
| Venkatesvera v. Mohammad Mohihulla, AIR 1985 Mad. 705 | Raised in argument in that case on a similar point (as noted by the court). | The court observed that in that reported decision the matter was raised in argument but the learned judge did not give a clear answer; the present court therefore did not treat it as decisively resolving the issue. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a statutory interpretation of Sections 4, 5, 6 and 7 (and the penal provision in Section 19(2)) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949.
- Context and statutory framework:
- Section 4 gives parties the right to have fair rent fixed by the Controller.
- Section 5 prescribes the circumstances in which an increase in fair rent is permissible; no increase is permissible except in accordance with Section 5.
- Section 6(1) contains two clauses: (a) restricting claims of premiums and rents in excess of fair rent, and (b) declaring "any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent or of rent in excess of such fair rent shall be null and void."
- Section 7 contains a general prohibition on requiring payment of fine, premium or other sums in consideration of tenancy, and Section 19(2) makes contravention of certain provisions punishable.
- Textual interpretation of Section 6(1)(b):
- The court parsed clause (b) into two components: (i) agreements for payment of any sum in addition to rent, and (ii) agreements for payment of rent in excess of fair rent.
- The judge reasoned that the first component (agreements for payment of any sum in addition to rent) must be read as applying to rent "simpliciter" — i.e., rent agreed between parties before any fixation of fair rent — and therefore it operates to prohibit parties from increasing rent by private contract after the Act came into force.
- Although sub-section (1) begins with the phrase "when the Controller has fixed the fair rent," the court held that clause (b) is an independent provision that must be read as standing by itself; it operates to prevent contractual increases in rent and leaves the parties with the statutory remedy of applying to the Controller for fixation or increase under the Act.
- On the parties' procedural/contentions:
- The court rejected the landlord's submission that the point could not be raised for the first time in revision, treating the issue as a pure question of law arising on undisputed facts and therefore properly raised.
- The court acknowledged that the Rent Controller erred in reasoning that a subsequent payment (made after the Controller's enquiry but allowed by his order) satisfied the proviso to Section 13(2)(i). The court, however, did not rely on the Controller's precise path of reasoning because it arrived at the same result on a different and independent legal ground (the voidness of the contractual increase).
- Use of authorities:
- The court considered the reported cases cited by the parties (collected in Jamuna Bai v. Narayanamurthy) and specifically noted that none decisively answered the statutory question; in Venkatesvera v. Mohammad Mohihulla the matter was raised but not clearly decided.
- Conclusion of analysis:
- Because contractual increases in rent are prohibited by Section 6(1)(b) and therefore void, the purported increase from Rs. 300 to Rs. 600 per annum (admitted by the tenant in Exhibit P.F.) must be disregarded for the purpose of the proviso to Section 13(2)(i).
- Consequently, the tender made by the tenant on the first hearing at the Rs. 300 rate was a proper and valid tender within the proviso to Section 13(2)(i), and the tenant was entitled to the protection of that proviso.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition was accepted; the appellate authority's order of eviction was set aside and the Rent Controller's order was restored.
Direct consequences for the parties:
- The Appellate Authority's eviction order is set aside.
- The Rent Controller's dismissal of the landlord's eviction application is restored (though the court noted it was restored on a different legal ground than that used by the Rent Controller).
- The court recorded that there is no order as to costs in the revision application.
Implications beyond the parties: The opinion reasons that contractual increases in rent are void under Section 6(1)(b) and that parties must resort to the statutory mechanism to obtain any increase; the judgment does not state any broader policy pronouncement or declare that a new precedent is being set beyond the decision in this case. The direct effect described above is the operative outcome on the parties.
Revision petition: accepted. Order: Appellate order set aside; Rent Controller's order restored; no costs.
Mehar Singh, J. - This is a revision application from the appellate order, dated October 8, 1960 of the Appellate authority ordering eviction of the tenant, who is the applicant here, in an application by the landlord, the respondent, under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (East Punjab Act No. III of 1949), on the ground of arrears of rent and the tenant not having paid or tendered the rent due on the first hearing of the landlord's application. 2. The landlord in his application claimed arrears of Rent at Rs. 600/- per annum for the period April 1, 1954 to July 7, 1959. The first date of hearing was August 5, 1959. On that date the tenant tendered rent at the rate of Rs. 300/- per annum for the period amounting to Rs. 925/- plus Rs. 99/2/- as interest and Rs. 22/- as costs of the application, in all Rs. 1,046/2/-. He contested the averment of the landlord that the rent was Rs. 600/- per annum. The Rent Controller made an enquiry in this respect and came to the conclusion on the admission of the tenant in his reply Exhibit P.F. to the notice given by the landlord that the rent had been increased from Rs. 300/- to Rs. 600/- per annum from December 3, 1956, that the rent from the date stated had been increased to Rs. 600/-. This was on May 24, 1960. He then allowed the tenant to make up the difference by the next day, and the tenant in fact did make up the difference within the time allowed. So the Rent controller was of the opinion that in these circumstances there had been compliance with proviso to Section 13(2)(i) of the Act. He disallowed this ground urged by the landlord and dismissed his eviction application. On appeal the learned appellate Authority comes to the conclusion as the Rent Controller that the increase of the rent from Rs. 300/- to Rs. 600/- per annum took place from December 3, 1966, and the tenant not having paid or tendered the whole of the arrears of rent due to the date of first hearing, he comes to the conclusion that the tenant was not entitled to the protection of provision to Section 13(2)(1) of the Act. The appeal of the landlord was accepted and eviction of the tenant was ordered. It is against this appellate order of the Appellate Authority that this revision application by the tenant is directed. 3. At this stage it is common ground between the parties that initially the contractual rate of rent agreed upon between the parties for the premises was Rs. 300/- per annum. The concurrent finding of the authorities below is that this figure was increased to Rs. 600/- from December, 1956, and this is not open to question because there is the tenant's own admission of this in his reply Exhibit P.F. to the landlords notice. It is true that taking this increase into consideration from December 3, 1956, the tenant did not tender on the first date of hearing the arrears calculating the same at the rate of Rs. 300/- per annum. 4. The contention on behalf of the tenant is that in view of Section 6(1)(b) of the Act. any agreement between the landlord and the tenant increasing rent is null and void, and this being so for the purposes of proviso to Section 13(2)(i) of the act any such increase must be ignored. If this approach is correct, the order of the Appellate Authority cannot be correct, and the order of the Rent Controller will have to be restored, for in that case the tender actually made by the tenant on the first date of hearing was in accordance with proviso to Section 13(2)(i) of the Act. No doubt the Rent controller was not right, when on enquiry he found that the rent had been increased, to come to the conclusion that subsequent payment by the tenant, even though under his orders, met the requirement of proviso to Section 13(2)(i) of the Act. The reply on behalf of the landlord is two-fold : one aspect urged is that Section 6 of the Act as a whole, only applies when the Controller had fixed the fair rent, and in this case no fair rent had been fixed, and the second aspect of the argument is that,even if the approach of the learned counsel for the tenant to Section 6 of the Act is conceded, Section 6(1)(b) when it refers to any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent', it refers not to increase in the rent but to a lump sum demand in the nature of something like fine or premium. 5. The learned counsel for the landlord also objects to this argument being advanced for the first time at this stage in this revision application, when it was not advanced before the authorities below. 6. The last argument on behalf of the landlord is entirely without substance because the facts are not in dispute and on the proved facts all that has to seen is what is the effect of Section 6 of the Act on those facts. This is a pure question of law and I have no doubt in my mind that even though it was not so urged before that authorities below it can be urged in an application like this. 7. After coming in force of the Act, both the tenant and the landlord have been given right under Section 4 of the Act to have fair rent fixed. Section 5 then provides the circumstances in which increase in the fair rent fixed is permissible it means that no increase is permissible except in accordance with the provision of this section. sections 6 and 7 are in these words - 6(1) Save as provided in Section 5, when the Controller has fixed the fair rent in a building or rented land under Section 4 - (a) The landlord shall not claim or receive any premium or other like sum in addition to fair rent or any rent in excess of such fair rent, but the landlord may stipulate for and receive in advance any amount not exceeding one month's rent; (b) Any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent or of rent in excess of such fair rent shall be null and void. (2) Nothing in this Section shall apply to the recovery of any rent which became due before the first day of January, 1939. 7. (1) No landlord shall in consideration of the grant, renewal or continuance of a tenancy of any building or rented land require the payment of any fine, premium or any other like sum in addition to the rent. (2) Nothing in this Section shall apply to any payment under any subsisting agreement entered into before the first day of January, 1939". Section 19(2) makes contravention of Section 6(1)(a) and Section 7(1) a punishable offence, and Section 6(1)(b) provides that any agreement referred to therein shall be null and void. How it is obvious from the consideration of these provisions that the prohibitions provided in section 6 and 7 clearly show the intention of the legislature that the provisions of the act were not intended to be waived by the parties by a contract to the contrary. So that the parties cannot contract out of these provisions of this Statute. 8. Apparently sub-section (1) of Section 6 starts with the words `when the Controller has fixed the fair rent', and then enacts clauses (a) and (b) Clause (a) only deal with the matter of fair rent, but clause (b) deals with the matter of rent or of fair rent. It provides that "any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent or of rent in excess of such fair rent shall be null and void. "The two matter dealt with in this clause when split will read........... (i) Any agreement for the payment of any sum in addition to rent or. (ii) Any agreement for the payment of rent in excess of fair rent...... shall be null and void. When so read, to my mind this clause can only be read in this manner, it becomes clear that the first part of this clause deals with rent simpliciter & not with fair rent fixed under the provisions of the statue. When it deals with rent as such, it obviously deals with rent settled by the parties between themselves, and obviously that is a stage before fair rent is fixed. So that while sub Section (1)of Section 6 starts with the case of fixation of fair rent, but in clause (b) there is then independent provision relating to rent only which provides that any agreement for payment of any sum in addition to rent shall be null and void. This provision cannot possibly be practically applied to any situation in which fair rent has already been fixed. The meaning of this provision, when it is read in conjunction with section 4 and 5 is that after the coming into force of the Act the parties are prohibited from increasing rent by contract between themselves. The only courseing left open to them from that date is an approach to the authorities under the statute to have fair rent fixed, and when that has been done then there are provisions in section 5 which deal with in what circumstances there can be an increase and there are provisions in Section 6 and 7 which deal with penalty, when read with Section 19(2) for claims, in excess fair rent, which are prohibited. As I read clause (b) of Section 6(1) my conclusion is that it is an independent provision although shown as clause (b) to sub-section (1) of Section 6. It must be read as if it stand by itself and when so read it prohibits parties from increasing rent by contact, leaving them only to have resource to the provisions of the Act for fixation of fair rent and for any increase in the fair rent according to the provisions of the Act. 9. On behalf of both sides reference has been made to some reported cases all of which are collected in Jamuna Bai v. Narayanamurthy, AIR 1909 A.P. 108. I have had the advantage of pursuing not only this particular case in which 11 the other cases are referred to but also those other cases. Not one of these cases decides this question, although in one, Venkatesvera v. Mohammad Mohihulla, AIR 1985 Mad. 705,the matter was raised in argument but the learned Judge has not given a clear answer to the argument. 10. In the view that I have taken the parties not having right to increase rent by contract but the it right only being to have fair rent fixed and to have any increase permitted by the statute, the tender made by tenant of the first hearing of the eviction application was proper and valid tender according to proviso to Section 13(2)(i) of the Act, and so the Appellate Authority was wrong in ordering eviction of the tenant for non-compliance of that proviso. This revision application is accepted the order of the Appellate Authority is set aside, and the order of the Rent Controller is restored, though on a ground different than upon which the Rent Controller proceeded. There is no order in regard to costs in this application. Revision petition accepted.
Alert