Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Fateh Chand And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Sep 17, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (M.M. Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a claimants' appeal filed under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1890 challenging the judgment dated 18.3.1983 of the Additional District Judge, Jind, which had awarded Rs. 100 per square yard as the market value of land acquired for extension of a Children Park. A Section 4 notification under the Act was issued on 9.6.1976 for acquisition of a total of 3 kanals located on the Gohana-Jind road at Jind. The Arbitrator originally announced an award on 16.11.1978 at Rs. 40 per square yard. The claimants filed an application under Section 18 alleging that the land fell within municipal limits, was near the abadi and developing towards the land, abutted the Jind-Gohana Road and had commercial potential. The District Judge accepted the Collector's recommendation (Ex. P.7) and awarded Rs. 100 per square yard, while declining to rely upon certain sale deeds (Exs. P.2 and P.3) of small pieces of land. The claimants appealed against that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Additional District Judge erred in awarding Rs. 100 per square yard as the market value of the land and in discarding certain sale instances (notably Exs. P.2 and P.3) on the ground that they related to small pieces of land.
  2. Whether sale instances of small pieces of land and sale instances occurring after the Section 4 notification may be considered in fixing the market value (i.e., whether such instances can be used to show the land's potential and comparable value).
  3. What is the correct market value per square yard to be adopted for the acquired land, given the evidence of contemporaneous and subsequent sale instances and the Collector's assessment.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimant-Appellants' Arguments

  • The site plan (Ex. P.8) shows that the land acquired was commercial in nature and that shops had been built adjacent to the relevant khasra numbers, indicating a likelihood that the land would be sold in small pieces (e.g., shops of about 200 sq. yds.).
  • The sale instances of small portions (Exs. P.2 and P.3 dated 15.3.1976) showing a rate of approximately Rs. 187 per sq. yard ought not to have been discarded merely because they dealt with small areas.
  • Subsequent sale instances (Exs. P.4 to P.6 dated 1979–1980) should not be entirely discarded as they indicate the potentials of the land and show an increase in prices that should be taken into account in assessing market value.
  • Reliance was placed on a judgment of this Court: The State of Punjab v. Smt. Lila Wati (1981 Current L.J. 95), in support of the contention that the smaller sale instances should be considered.

Respondents' Arguments

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mehta Ravindrarai Ajitrai v. State of Gujarat, 1989 (2) RRR 243 (SC) : 1989 4 SCC 250 The market value for Section 23 purposes is the price at which property changes hands between a willing seller and a willing, but not too anxious, buyer dealing at arm's length. Prices fetched for similar lands with similar advantages and potentialities under bona fide transactions at or about the time of preliminary notification are the best evidence of market value. The court relied on this guideline to treat sale instances at or about the time of the notification as persuasive evidence of market value and to justify considering adjacent sales that are close in time to the Section 4 notification.
Administrator General of West Bengal v. Collector, Varanasi, 1988 (1) RRR 480 (SC) : 1988 2 SCC 150 Referenced in the Mehta judgment as supporting the proposition that prices of similar lands under bona fide transactions near the time of notification are the usual and best evidence of market value. Invoked (through Mehta) to support the proposition that contemporaneous comparable sales are the best evidence of market value; the court used this to justify reliance on nearby sale instances around the date of notification.
Gulzara Singh v. State of Punjab, 1993 (3) RRR 247 (SC) : (1993) 4 SCC 245 The Supreme Court observed that sale instances of small pieces of land cannot be completely discarded and may be considered for assessing potentialities of land given its location and position. The court used this principle to justify considering Exs. P.2 and P.3 (small-area sales) as relevant evidence of market value because the location and site plan indicated commercial potential and likely subdivision into small plots.
The State of Punjab v. Smt. Lila Wati, 1981 Current L.J. 95 Cited by the claimant-appellants' counsel in support of the contention that small sale instances should be relied upon. The opinion records that counsel relied on this judgment; the court's reasoning does not extract a distinct principle from it beyond noting counsel's reliance and instead applies the principles set out in the other cited Supreme Court decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a step-by-step analysis limited to the materials and principles set out in the opinion:

  1. The court examined the sale instances relied upon by the claimants (Exs. P.2–P.6) and tabulated their dates, areas and per-square-yard rates:
    • Exs. P.2 and P.3 — dated 15.3.1976, each for 16 sq. yards at Rs. 3,000 (≈ Rs. 187.30 per sq. yd.).
    • Ex. P.4 — dated 27.3.1979, 16 sq. yd for Rs.5,000 (≈ Rs. 312.50 per sq. yd.).
    • Ex. P.5 — dated 8.2.1980, 22 sq. yd for Rs.8,000 (≈ Rs. 363.63 per sq. yd.).
    • Ex. P.6 — dated 7/8.2.1980, 22 sq. yd for Rs.7,000 (≈ Rs. 318.18 per sq. yd.).
  2. The court found Exs. P.2 and P.3 to be sufficiently proximate and comparable: they concerned land in Khasra No. 174/30, while the acquired land was in Khasra No. 174/29 — adjacent parcels according to the Aks Shejra (Ex. P.9) and site plan (Ex. P.8). The expositions in the record showed the parcels to be near one another and only the Jind-Gohana Road intervened in part.
  3. Given that Exs. P.2 and P.3 were dated about three months prior to the Section 4 notification of 9.6.1976, were bona fide transactions and that the acquired land lay within municipal limits and near the abadi, the court concluded it was improper for the Additional District Judge to ignore those sale instances merely because they involved small areas.
  4. The court applied the Supreme Court's guidance (Mehta and Administrator General cases) that contemporary sales of similar lands are the best evidence of market value, and the Gulzara Singh observation that sales of small pieces cannot be wholly discarded and may show potentialities depending on location.
  5. The court also acknowledged that post-notification sales (Exs. P.4–P.6) showed a marked increase in price (over Rs. 300 per sq. yd.), which indicated the potential of the land; while post-notification sales are not conclusive, they may furnish an indication of potential and assist assessment.
  6. Balancing these considerations — the contemporaneous sales (187.30 per sq. yd.), the post-notification higher rates (≈ Rs. 312–363 per sq. yd.), the Collector's assessment of Rs. 100 per sq. yd., and the land's location within municipal limits and near abadi — the court concluded that Rs. 100 was inadequate.
  7. To account for the small-area nature of the closest contemporaneous sales (Exs. P.2 and P.3), the court applied a 20% reduction to those sales' per-yard figure and fixed the market value at Rs. 150 per square yard for the acquired land.
  8. The court ordered that the claimant-appellants would be entitled to the enhanced amount (as determined) along with all statutory benefits.

Holding and Implications

Appeal allowed.

Holding (core ruling):

  • The Additional District Judge's decision to ignore the contemporaneous sale instances Exs. P.2 and P.3 was incorrect in the circumstances shown by the record.
  • The Court fixed the market value of the acquired land at Rs. 150 per square yard (after applying a 20% cut to the contemporaneous small-area sale instances Exs. P.2 and P.3).
  • Claimant-appellants are entitled to the enhanced amount on that basis together with all statutory benefits.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The award at Rs. 100 per sq. yard was set aside to the extent necessary and replaced by a market value of Rs. 150 per sq. yard, with claimants to receive the enhanced compensation and statutory benefits.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applies and follows guiding principles from Supreme Court authorities regarding reliance on contemporaneous comparable sales and the limited but permissible role of small-area and post-notification sales in assessing market value. The opinion does not assert the creation of any new legal precedent beyond applying those existing authorities to the facts before the court.


Note: This summary is based exclusively on information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

M.M Kumar, J.:— This is claimants' appeal filed under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1890 (for brevity ‘the Act’) challenging judgment dated 18.3.1983 passed by the Addl. District Judge, Jind, awarding Rs. 100/- per sq. yard to the claimant-appellants as the market value of the acquired land.

2. Brief facts of the case are that a notification under Section 4 of the Act was issued on 9.6.1976 for the purposes of extension of Children Park. Total land acquired was 3 kanals situated at Gohana-Jind road at Jind. Award was announced by the Arbitrator on 16.11.1978 @ Rs. 40/- per square yard. The claimants-appellants filed application under Section 18 of the Act alleging that the land was within the municipal limits and as the abadi of the town was developing towards the said of this land, the land had potentials to be developed into commercial area because it abutted the Jind-Gohana Road and as such it was very valuable. The afore-mentioned claim was contested by the respondents. On Issue No. 1, concerning the market value of the land in dispute at the time of notification under Section 4 of the Act i.e 9.6.1976, the ld. District Judge found that the rate recommended by the Collector has been discarded because no reason has been given by the Tribunal constituted under the Punjab Town Improvement Act 1922 in his award dated 26.2.1981 Accordingly, it accepted the recommendation of the Collector made in Ex. P. 7 and awarded Rs. 100/- per sq. yard. Moreover, no evidence was led to show that the afore-mentioned rate was erroneous. However, ld. Addl. District Judge refused to take into Consideration the sale instances Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 dated 15.3.1976 on the ground that the afore-mentioned instances were in respect of land concerning small pieces of 16 sq. yards., Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 are the sale deed dated 15.3.1976 and 16 sq. yd. of land has been sold for Rs. 3,000/-. The views of the ld, Addl. District Judge in this regard read as under:

“The other instance produced by claimants are copies of two sale deeds Ex. P. 2 and P. 3. Both the sale deeds are dated 15.3.1976 and vide the same an area of 16 Sq. Yards was sold for Rs. 3,000/-. In the sale deed Rs. 2,500/- are shown to have been paid before the Sub Registrar. The land sold is part of Khasra No. 174/30, while the land acquired is in khasra No. 174/29. The copy of Aks Shejra has also been placed on the file as Ex. P. 9. Perusal of Ex. P. 9 shows that only Jind-Gohana Road intervenes in between the land acquired and the land of Khasra No. 174/30. The counsel for the claimants contended before me that these instances be relied upon to hold the market value of the acquired land at Rs. 187/- per square yard. I do not agree with his contention because the above instances are also about sale of small plot of only 16 square yards, while the land acquired is about 3 kanals.”

3. The other sale instances Exs. P. 4, P. 5 and P. 6 which were dated 27.3.1979, 8.2.1980 and 8.2.1980 respectively Page: 124were discarded on the simple ground that they were subsequent to the date of notification under Section 4 which was issued on 9.6.1976

4. Shri Amarjit Markan, learned counsel for the claimant-appellants has argued that a perusal of Ex. P. 8 i.e site plan would show that the land acquired is commercial in nature and the sale instances of small portions cannot be discarded. According to the learned counsel shops have been built on the site beside the afore-mentioned khasra numbers and it shows that the land is bound to be sold in small pieces as a shop of about 200 sq. yds. would be sufficient in a commercial market. In support of his submission, the learned counsel has placed reliance on a judgment of this Court in the case of The State Of Punjab… v. Smt. Lila Wati…., 1981 Current L.J 95. Learned counsel has further contended that the land acquired is situated within the municipal limits and near the abadi. In such a situation, the sale instances available would be only of small pieces of land and highest rate which has been mentioned in the sale instances Exs. P. 2 and P. 3 should be awarded. Learned counsel has also pointed out that there was no justification for the Addl. District Judge to ignore the sale instances showing the rate of land at Rs. 187/- per sq. yard. Learned counsel has also submitted that the sale instances Exs. P. 4 to P. 6 cannot be discarded merely because they are subsequent to the notification under Section 4 of the Act and the same can be kept in view for the purpose of assessing the potentials of the land.

5. After hearing the learned counsel, I am of the considered view that this appeal must succeed. The sale instances relied upon by the claimant-appellants with their dates, area sold and the rate are as under:

Ex. date area amount Per Sq.Yd Ex. P. 2 153.1976 16 Sq.yd 3000/- 187.30 Ex. P. 3 15.3.1976 16 Sq.yd 3000/- 187.30 (Part of Khas. No. 174/29. Acquired from land comprised in Khasra No. 174/30) Ex. P. 4 27.3.1979 16 Sq.Yd 5000/- 312.50P Ex. P. 5 8.2.1980 22 Sq.Yd 8000/- 363.63 Ex. P. 6 7.2.1980 22 Sq.Yd 7000/- 318.18

6. A perusal of the above table shows that sale instances Exs. P. 2 and P. 3 are in respect of Khasra No. 174/30 and the land acquired is from Khasra No. 174/29 which are almost adjacent to each other as is apparent from the perusal of Aks Shejra Ex. P. 9. The land acquired and the sale instances Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 are although away from each other yet are very near. Moreover, the sale instances Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 are about three months prior to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act. It is also undisputed that the land was not away from the abadi and fell within the municipal limits. Therefore, it was not proper for the ld. Addl. District Judge to ignore those sale instances. If the sale instances of the land adjacent are available then it would help to conclude that the market value of the land acquired would be similar especially when the sale is around the same time when the notification under Section 4 of the Act has been issued. It is true that evidence with regard to smaller pieces of sale instances should be discarded but at the same time such sale instances can furnish good proof of the market value of the land. Even the subsequent sale instances may furnish some indication about the potentials of the land acquired. The market value of the land, according to sale instances Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 is Rs. 187.50 and according to sale instances of 1997-1998 Exs. P. 4, P. 5 and P. 6 is over Rs. 300/-. However, the assessment made by the Collector is Rs. 100/- only. In these circumstances, the guide-lines provided by the Supreme Court even with regard to post acquisition sale instances is that price at which the adjacent land with similar advantages and potentials have been bona-fide sold after about 5 months of the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act in respect of the land acquired can furnish the best evidence for fixing the market value. These observation have been made by their Lordships in Mehta Ravindrarai Ajitrai v. State of Gujarat, 1989 (2) RRR 243 (SC) : (1989) 4 SCC 250 and the same reads as under:

“The market value of a piece of property for purposes of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act is stated to be the price at which the property changes hands from a willing seller to a willing, but not too anxious a buyer, dealing at arm's length. Prices fetched for similar lands with similar advantages and potentialities under bona fide transactions of sale at or about the time of preliminary notification are the usual and, indeed the best, evidence of market value. (See Administrator General of West Bengal v. Collector, Varanasi 1988 (1) RRR 480 (SC) : (1988) 2 SCC 150.”

With regard to small pieces of land, it has been observed by the Supreme Court that the same cannot be completely discarded. Such sale instances can be considered for assessing the potentialities of the land keeping in view its location and position. The afore-mentioned observations have been made in the case of Gulzara Singh v. State of Punjab, 1993 (3) RRR 247 (SC) : (1993) 4 SCC 245.

7. Keeping in view the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in the afore-mentioned judgments, it would be appropriate to assess the market value of the land at the time of acquisition by referring to sale instances Exs. P. 2 to P. 6. There is a valid objection concerning Exs. P. 2 and P. 3 on the ground that these are in respect of small pieces of land measuring 16 sq. yards whereas the land acquired was 3 kanals. Objection raised regarding small pieces of land have to be considered by keeping in view the location of the building and its potentialities. A perusal of Aks Shejra and the site plan Ex. P. 9 and P. 8 clearly shows that adjacent to the area around the land acquired is a portion of the Page: 125area where shops have been constructed. Had the land acquired remained with the claimant-appellants, it would also have been converted into shops. On the one hand sale instances which comprised of small areas may be considered by showing the higher price but at the same time, a comparison between the sale instances in respect of the period before acquisition and post acquisition would show the marked increase in the price which is almost twice. Before acquisition even in respect of small area the market value was Rs. 187.50 per.sq yard and after acquisition in 1980 it was Rs. 363/- per sq. yard or Rs. 312/- per sq. yard. Therefore, the question for determination is would it be fair to grant Rs. 100/- per sq. yard as compensation by taking the market value on 9.6.1976 The answer to this question, to my mind, is in the negative. There has to be enhancement after taking into consideration all the factors that the land is situated near to the abadi. within the municipal limits, and the potentials of the land as reflected by sale instances Exs.P 4 to P. 6. I, however, impose a cut of 20 percent on the sale instances Ex. P. 2 and P. 3 which are dated 15.3.1976 and determine the market value of the land at Rs. 150/- per sq. yard. Claimant-appellants shall be entitled to the enhanced amount along with all the statutory benefits.

Appeal allowed.