- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mrs. Preeti Petitioner v. Manmohan Singh And Another S
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Rajive Bhalla, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is a tenant who was inducted into the demised premises in 1994 by one Sh. Satvir. Satvir filed an ejectment petition dated 4.10.1996 alleging non-payment of rent. During the pendency of that petition, Satvir died on 15.12.1998. The respondents, Manmohan Singh and Madan Mohan (sons of Mehnga Singh), applied to be impleaded as legal representatives and were impleaded by order dated 2.12.1999. The Rent Controller, by order dated 21.12.1999, determined the monthly rent to be Rs. 450 and water and sewerage charges; because the petitioner had tendered rent up to April 1997 at the determined rate, that petition was dismissed.
Subsequently, the respondents filed another ejectment petition on 5.2.1999 alleging non-payment of rent from 1.5.1997. The petitioner appeared before the trial court but did not tender any rent and objected that the respondents had no locus standi as they were not owners/landlords; she also denied any landlord–tenant relationship with Satvir. The Rent Controller framed issues on arrears, locus standi and relief, and ultimately held the respondents to be owners/landlords and ordered the petitioner's ejectment for failure to tender rent.
The petitioner appealed to the Appellate Authority, which, by judgment dated 5.5.2003, set aside the Rent Controller's order and remitted the matter for fresh decision directing a provisional assessment of rent, interest and costs and an opportunity for the petitioner to tender rent. The respondents filed revisional proceedings (C.R. No. 5497 of 2003); on 10.2.2005 the revision was accepted, the remittal was set aside and the Appellate Authority was directed to decide the appeal in accordance with law. Thereafter, after hearing, the Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal by order dated 1.5.2006.
The petitioner filed the present petition under Section 15(5)A of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act impugning the Rent Controller's ejectment order and the order dismissing her appeal. The present opinion records the hearing and disposition of that petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondents (Manmohan Singh and Madan Mohan) had locus standi as landlords/owners to maintain the ejectment petition against the petitioner.
- Whether, once the Rent Controller held that the respondents were owners/landlords, he was obliged under Section 13 of the Act (as interpreted in Rakesh Wadhawan) to assess rent, interest and costs and afford the petitioner an opportunity to tender the assessed rent.
- Whether the ratio of Rakesh Wadhawan applies where a tenant denies the landlord–tenant relationship and whether a tenant who so denies can claim protection of an assessment-and-tender mechanism.
- Whether the Rent Controller and the Appellate Authority committed jurisdictional or legal errors warranting interference by the Court.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The ejectment was ordered solely because the petitioner failed to tender rent; she had a bona fide dispute about respondents' ownership and locus standi and thus could await the outcome of the civil proceedings.
- The respondents had filed Civil Suit No. 320 of 1999 seeking declaration of their ownership, which supported the petitioner's bona fide belief and justified not tendering rent pending that suit.
- Once the Rent Controller held that respondents were owners/landlords, he was obliged under Section 13 of the Act, as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation, to assess the rent, interest and costs and afford the petitioner an opportunity to tender rent.
- The Appellate Authority failed to exercise jurisdiction properly: despite a bona fide dispute on ownership, it held Rakesh Wadhawan inapplicable and accepted that the petitioner had denied the landlord–tenant relationship and thereby lost the right to call for assessment; the petitioner relied also on Sham Lal (Dead) v. Atma Nand Jain regarding the meaning of "the first hearing of the application".
- On an interim order the petitioner had deposited the entire arrears and as of the date of the hearing no rent was due to the landlords (contention put forward by counsel).
Respondents' Arguments
- The impugned orders do not suffer from any jurisdictional or legal error; the petitioner's challenge to locus standi was mala fide and a sham intended to harass and evade rent obligations.
- The respondents had been impleaded as legal representatives in the 1996 petition and the petitioner knew of their status but did not object then; the locus standi objection was therefore an afterthought.
- Rakesh Wadhawan does not apply where a tenant positively denies the landlord–tenant relationship; a tenant who repudiates the relationship asserts a right not to tender rent and cannot claim protection of that ratio. Reliance was placed on a series of precedents (Ramanand Shastri, Yash Pal Singh, Hukama Devi, Narinder Singh, Jagdish Singh).
- In revisional proceedings a party should not be permitted to raise fresh pleas that were not asserted before the lower forums; the petitioner's new contentions based on the civil suit and the interpretation of "first date of hearing" were not taken below and should be disregarded.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation, 2002 (1) RCR (Rent) 514 : 2002 (2) PLR 370 | Interpreted Section 13 of the Act to require assessment of rent, interest and costs and to afford a tenant an opportunity to tender assessed rent. | The petitioner invoked this case to contend that once the Rent Controller found respondents to be landlords he should have assessed rent and allowed tender. The Court held that Rakesh Wadhawan's ratio does not apply where the tenant denies the landlord–tenant relationship and thus rejected the petitioner's reliance on it. |
| Sham Lal (Dead) by Legal Representatives v. Atma Nand Jain Sabhya (Regd), 1987 (1) RCR (Rent) 181 : 1987 (1) PLR 1 | Interprets the expression "the first hearing of the application" to mean the day the court applies its mind/decides issues or takes evidence (relevance to tendering on first appearance). | The petitioner relied on this interpretation to argue it was incorrect to eject for not tendering on the first date. The Court noted the argument but found it without merit because the petitioner never offered to tender rent at any stage and continued to deny the landlord–tenant relationship. |
| Ramanand Shastri v. Gian Singh, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 735 : 2003 HRR 771 | Holds that where a tenant disputes the landlord–tenant relationship, the Rent Controller is not expected to pass an assessment order in terms of Rakesh Wadhawan; such an assessment would be futile and contrary to the parties' stands. | The Court relied on this precedent to support the proposition that a tenant's denial of relationship is a positive refusal to tender rent and thus Rakesh Wadhawan protection is inapplicable. The Court applied this view to conclude that the petitioner's denial excluded entitlement to assessment/tender protection. |
| Yash Pal Singh v. Vijay Kumar, 2004 (1) RCR (Rent) 718 : 2004 (3) PLR 504 | States that once a tenant denies the landlord–tenant relationship, there is little justification for a Rent Controller to make an assessment under the proviso to Section 13(2)(1) as interpreted in Rakesh Wadhawan. | The Court cited this authority to reinforce the principle that permitting deposit of arrears after an interim assessment would create an imbalance of equities where the tenant denies the relationship; applied to reject the petitioner's claim for assessment-and-tender relief. |
| Hukama Devi and others v. Bhagwan Dass, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 533 : 2003 (2) PLR 371 | Adopts similar view that the ratio in Rakesh Wadhawan is inapplicable where the tenant denies the relationship or the landlord's locus standi, particularly when such denial is mala fide or intended to evade rent. | The Court included this case among a series of authorities establishing that a denial of landlord status, if mala fide or evasive, precludes reliance on Rakesh Wadhawan; applied this line of authority to find the petitioner's denial mala fide and to refuse relief. |
| Narinder Singh…Petitioner v. Sarabjit Singh…, 2006 (2) RCR (Rent) 226 : 2006 (2) HRR 467 | Affirms the principle that a tenant denying the relationship cannot thereafter be allowed to benefit from an assessment-and-tender mechanism under the Rakesh Wadhawan ratio. | The Court relied on this precedent as part of a consistent line of decisions supporting the view that denial of relationship negates applicability of Rakesh Wadhawan; applied to support dismissal of the petition. |
| Jagdish Singh v. Mohan Lal, 2004 (2) RCR (Rent) 114 (P&H) | Part of a body of authorities holding that where denial of relationship/locus standi is mala fide or intended to prolong proceedings/evade rent, the Rakesh Wadhawan ratio will not apply. | The Court cited this case among others to conclude that the petitioner's denial was mala fide and that the Rent Controller and Appellate Authority did not err in refusing the petitioner the benefit of assessment-and-tender protections. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a focused analysis of the petitioner's primary contention and the interplay between a tenant's denial of landlordship and the protective assessment-and-tender mechanism derived from Rakesh Wadhawan.
Stepwise analysis recorded in the opinion:
- The petitioner asserted a bona fide dispute regarding the respondents' ownership and locus standi and submitted that, once the Rent Controller held the respondents to be landlords, Section 13 (as interpreted in Rakesh Wadhawan) obliged the Rent Controller to assess rent, interest and costs and permit the petitioner to tender the determined sum.
- The Court analysed the legal effect of a tenant disputing the landlord–tenant relationship and concluded that such a dispute effectively constitutes a positive refusal to tender rent. The Court relied on a consistent line of earlier decisions (notably Ramanand Shastri and Yash Pal Singh, among others) holding that where a tenant denies the relationship of landlord and tenant, an assessment order under Rakesh Wadhawan is ordinarily inappropriate and would be futile or unjust.
- The Court examined the factual matrix to determine whether the petitioner's objection to locus standi was bona fide or mala fide. It noted that:
- the respondents were impleaded as legal representatives in the earlier 1996 ejectment petition in the petitioner's presence and that the petitioner did not challenge that impleadment by appeal or revision;
- the petitioner had denied connection with Satvir (the original landlord) and alternatively alleged the property belonged to the Wakf Board;
- the timing of pleadings indicated an afterthought: the written statement to the ejectment petition (dated 20.5.1999) was filed on 20.7.1999 whereas the civil suit relied upon by the petitioner was filed on 23.7.1999; the Court treated this timing as undermining the claim of a bona fide pending civil dispute that justified non-payment of rent.
- The Court found that the petitioner never offered to tender rent at any stage before the Rent Controller, and that she continued before the Appellate Authority to deny that the respondents were her landlords. On these material facts, the Court concluded that the petitioner's challenge was mala fide and aimed at avoiding payment of rent.
- Given the above, the Court held that the precedents relied upon by respondents (and followed by the Court) established that the Rakesh Wadhawan ratio does not apply where the tenant denies the landlord–tenant relationship or challenges locus standi in a manner that is mala fide. Accordingly, the impugned orders did not suffer from jurisdictional or legal error.
- On the basis of these findings of law and fact, the Court dismissed the petition but exercised equitable discretion to grant the petitioner six months' time to vacate, subject to conditions (continued payment/deposit of rent by the 7th of each month and filing an undertaking to deliver possession within six months).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is dismissed. The Court found no jurisdictional or legal error in the impugned orders and rejected the petitioner's plea that she was entitled to an assessment-and-tender opportunity under Rakesh Wadhawan.
Implications and direct consequences:
- The dismissal leaves the Rent Controller's ejectment decision and the Appellate Authority's order intact as they stood in the record of these proceedings.
- The petitioner was granted six months' time to vacate the premises as a matter of equitable concession, subject to the conditions that she pay/deposit the rent by the 7th of each month and file an undertaking before the Rent Controller to deliver possession within six months. The Court made no order as to costs.
- The Court applied established precedents to hold that the Rakesh Wadhawan assessment-and-tender mechanism is not applicable where a tenant positively denies the landlord–tenant relationship, particularly where such denial is mala fide or intended to evade rent. The opinion treats this as an application of existing authority rather than as the announcement of a new principle.
Note: This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided opinion and does not introduce information not found in that text.
Rajive Bhalla, J. (Oral) — The petitioner-tenant, has filed this petition, under Section 15(5)A of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’), impugning the order of ejectment passed by the Rent Controller, Hoshiarpur, as also the order of dismissal of her appeal, passed by the Appellate Authority, Hoshiarpur.
2. The petitioner, admittedly, was inducted as a tenant in the demised premises in 1994 by Sh. Satvir, who filed an ejectment petition dated 4.10.1996, praying for the petitioner's ejectment for non payment of rent. During the pendency of this petition, Satvir passed away on 15.12.1998 The respondents Manmohan Singh and Madan Mohan sons of Mehnga Singh, alleging that they had inherited ownership of the demised premises, filed an application for their being impleaded as legal representatives. The said application was allowed vide order dated 2.12.1999 and the respondents were impleaded as petitioners. The Rent Controller, vide order dated 21.12.1999, held the rate of rent to be Rs. 450/- per month and in addition, held that the tenant was required to pay water charges @ Rs. 15/- per month and sewerage charges @ Rs. 5/- per month. As the tenant had tendered rent upto April 1997 at the determined rate, the petition was dismissed.
Page: 3083. During the pendency of the above, the respondents, namely; Manmohan Singh and Madan Mohan, filed another petition for ejectment, on 5.2.1999, on the plea of non payment of rent from 1.5.1997 The petitioner, appeared before the trial Court but did not tender any rent. She raised a preliminary objection that the respondents were neither owners nor landlords and, therefore, had no locus standi to institute the petition. The petitioner also denied relationship of landlord and tenant with Sat Vir, the deceased landlord. On the basis of the respective pleadings, the learned Rent Controller framed the following issues :—
“1. Whether respondent is in arrears of rent? OPA
2. Whether the applicant has no locus standi to file the present application? OPR.
3. Relief.”
4. On issue no. 2, the learned Rent Controller, held that the respondents were owners/landlords of the premises in dispute and, therefore, negatived the petitioner's contention that the respondents had no locus standi to maintain the petition for ejectment. On issue no. 1, it was held that as the petitioner failed to tender rent at any stage of the proceedings, she was liable to be ejected.
5. Aggrieved by the aforementioned order, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority, Hoshiarpurl Vide judgment dated 5.5.2003, the Appel late Authority, set aside the order, passed by the Rent Controller and remitted the matter for a decision afresh, by directing the Rent Controller, to make a provisional assessment, of rent, the interest due thereon and the costs to be paid by the tenant and thereafter, call upon the petitioner to tender rent. The respondents, however, filed C.R No. 5497 of 2003, impugning the correctness of the order. Vide order dated 10.2.2005, the revision was accepted and the order passed by the Appellate Authority, remitting the matter to the Rent Controller was set aside. The Appellate Authority was directed to decide the appeal in accordance with law.
After hearing counsel for the parties and perusing the record, the Appellate Authority, Hoshiarpur, dismissed the appeal vide order dated 1.5.2006
6. Counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner's ejectment had been ordered on the sole ground that she failed to tender rent, at any stage of the proceedings. It is submitted that the petitioner raised a bona fide dispute, as to the status of the respondents i.e their ownership and their locus standi to maintain the petition for ejectment. The bona fides of this plea are established by the fact that the respondents filed Civil Suit No. 320 of 1999, against their mother, praying for a declaration, that they were owners of the demised premises. The petitioner, therefore, was of the bona fide belief that she could validly await the outcome of the suit and tender rent thereafter. Thus, after the Rent Controller held that the respondents were owners/landlords he was obliged, as per the provisions of Section 13 of the Act, as interpreted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation, 2002 (1) RCR (Rent) 514 : 2002 (2) PLR 370, to assess the rent, the interest and the costs and thereafter afford an opportunity to the petitioner-tenant, to tender the rent as assessed. The Rent Controller, however, failed to provide an opportunity, to tender rent and instead ordered the petitioner's ejectment.
7. Another contention pressed into service, by counsel for the petitioner is that the order passed by the Appellate Authority reveals an abject failure on the part of the Appellate Authority, to exercise jurisdiction, as per law. The Appellate Authority, after recording that the tenant had led sufficient evidence to prove that the property in dispute did not belong to Satvir, proceeded to hold that the petitioner was inducted as a tenant by Satvir and as the respondents had inherited the property from Satvir, the relationship of landlord and tenant stood established. The Appellate Authority Page: 309despite the existence of a bona fide dispute between the parties, as to the ownership of the property in dispute, proceeded to hold that Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra) was not applicable, as the petitioner had denied the relationship of landlord and tenant and had foregone her right to call upon the Rent Controller, to assess the rent and grant an opportunity to her to pay the arrears of rent. It is further submitted that as held in Sham Lal (Dead) by Legal Representatives v. Atma Nand Jain Sabhya (Regd), 1987 (1) RCR (Rent) 181 : 1987 (1) PLR 1, the words ‘the first hearing of the application’ would mean the day on which the Court applies its mind to the facts of the case or decides the issues or evidence is taken and, therefore, the petitioner's ejectment on the ground that she did not tender the rent on the first date of appearance is incorrect. It is further pointed out that on the basis of an interim order, the petitioner had deposited entire arrears of rent and as on date, no rent is due to the landlords.
8. Counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, submits that the impugned orders do not suffer from any error of jurisdiction or of law, as would warrant interference by this Court. It is submitted that the plea, raised by the petitioner, challenging the locus standi of the respondents, was mala fide and a sham. In the rent petition filed by Satvir, on 4.10.1996, the respondents were impleaded as his legal representatives. The petitioner did not raise any objection and was thus, aware of the respondents having inherited the demised premises and their status as landlords. The objections as to the locus standi of the respondents to file the ejectment proceedings was, therefore, a mala fide attempt to harass the landlords, evade the duty to pay rent and to deprive them of the rent.
It is further submitted that the petitioner's mala fides are further established by the fact that the petitioner filed her written statement dated 20.5.1999 on 20.7.1999 The civil suit, which the petitioner alleges is the basis of her plea, challenging the locus standi of the respondents was filed on 23.7.1999 The petitioner's plea is, therefore, hollow and lacks bona fide.
9. It is further submitted that the judgment in Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra) does not apply to the facts of the present case. A tenant denying the relationship of landlord and tenant asserts a positive right not to tender rent and, therefore, cannot fall back upon the ratio in Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra). Reliance for the above assertion is placed upon Ramanand Shastri v. Gian Singh, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 735 : 2003 HRR 771, Yash Pal Singh v. Vijay Kumar, 2004 (1) RCR (Rent) 718 : 2004 (3) PLR 504, Hukama Devi and others v. Bhagwan Dass, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 533 : 2003 (2) PLR 371, Narinder Singh…Petitioner v. Sarabjit Singh…, 2006 (2) RCR (Rent) 226 : 2006 (2) HRR 467 and Jagdish Singh v. Mohan Lal, 2004 (2) RCR (Rent) 114 (P&H).
10. Counsel for the respondents further asserts that in revision, a party cannot be allowed to raise fresh pleas. The petitioner's pleas, based upon the civil suit and the interpretation assigned to the expression first date of hearing were never asserted before the Rent Controller or before the Appellate Authority and should, therefore, not be taken into consideration.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length, perused the impugned judgements, as also the precedents pressed into service.
11. The primary assertion put forth by counsel for the petitioner is that the petitioner raised a bona fide dispute, with respect to the locus standi of the respondents, their ownership of the demised premises and the relationship of landlord and tenant. Thus, after the learned Rent Controller arrived at a conclusion that the respondents were owners/landlords of the premises in dispute, he was required to make an assessment of the rate of rent, tabulate the arrears of rent, assess the interest thereon Page: 310and after calculating the costs to be paid by the petitioner, call upon the petitioner, to tender rent, in accordance with the provisions of Sectional 3 of the Act, as interpreted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra).
12. The aforementioned contention, in my considered opinion is without merit. Where a tenant, proceeds to dispute the locus standi or the ownership of the landlord and thereupon denies the relationship of landlord and tenant, such a tenant in essence, asserts a positive plea of refusal to tender rent. Whether such a tenant would be entitled/to the protection of Section 13 of the Act, as interpreted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra) has been answered in a host of judgements by this Court, namely; Ramanand Shastri v. Gian Singh (supra). A relevant extract from the aforementioned judgment would be appropriate :
“I have thoughtfully considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the tenant-petitioner and am of the view that the same are devoid of merit. The first submission that the tenant-petitioner was entitled to an order of assessment by the Rent Controller in terms of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Rakesh Wadhawan (supra) would not require any detailed consideration because in cases where the tenant disputes the relationship of landlord and tenant it is not expected of the Rent Controller to pass an assessment order of rent directing the tenant to pay that rent. In such cases, exercise to be taken by the Rent Controller would be futile and would rather go contrary to the stand of the parties. After all framing of assessment order is not a mere ritual by the Rent Controller that in every case the Rent Controller must pass such an order. Moreover, even if the Rent Controller passes such an order and the tenant maintains his stand of denying the relationship then he cannot be asked to pay the rent. It would also be unjust that the tenant would first get the finding of subsisting relationship and then deposit the rent. Such a course would also be unfair and unjust to the landlord-respondent. Therefore, I have no hesitation in rejecting the first argument raised by the learned counsel.”
13. Another judgment, taking a similar view is Yash Pal Singh v. Vijay Kumar (supra), para 7 whereof reads as follows :
“Once the tenant has denied the relationship of landlord and tenant, then there would be hardly any justification for the Rent Controller to frame an assessment order in pursuance of the provisions of proviso of Section 13(2)(1) of the Act as interpreted by the Supreme Court in the case of Rakesh Wadhawan (supra). After the evidence has been led by the landlord showing the relationship of landlord-tenant, then there would be no justification to permit the tenant to deposit the arrears of rent in accordance with the interim assessment order of rent. Such an approach would create imbalance of equities and would hardly be justified. Therefore, I have no hesitation in rejecting the argument raised by the learned counsel and reiterate my view taken in the cases of Ramanand Shastri (supra) and Hukama Devi (supra).”
14. A similar view was taken in Hukama Devi and others, Narinder Singh…Petitioner v. Sarabjit Singh… and Jagdish Singh v. Mohan Lal's cases (supra). The aforementioned precedents, make it abundantly clear that where the plea denying the relationship of landlord and tenant, or laying challenge to the locus standi of the landlord, to file a petition for ejectment is mala fide and asserted with a motive to prolong proceedings, evade responsibility for payment of rent or to harass the landlord, the ratio in Rakesh Wadhawan's case (supra) would not apply. I find no reasons to differ with the aforementioned judgements, as they apply to the facts of present case with all their vigor. As held by the first appellate Court, the petitioner's assertion, challenging the locus standi of the landlord and denying relationship of landlord and tenant Page: 311was mala fide. The petitioner not only denied relationship of landlord and tenant with the respondents, but also denied any connection with Satvir, the original landlord, who admittedly, had inducted her into the premises as a tenant. She also went on to assert that the property was owned by the Wakf Board. Another aspect of the matter that has a significant bearing, on the conclusion recorded herein before, is that Satvir filed an ejectment petition in the year 1996 but during its pendency, Satvir passed away on 15.12.1998 The respondents claiming to have inherited the demised premises from Satvir, filed an application for their being impleaded as legal representations/landlords in place of Satvir. This application was allowed and the respondents were impleaded as owners/landlords, in place of Satvir, in her presence. The petitioner did not impugn the correctness of this order, whether by way of an appeal or a revision. It is, thus, apparent that the plea raised by the petitioner, impugning the locus standi of the respondents and denying any relationship of landlord and tenant, was a mala fide attempt on her part, to avoid payment of rent and a positive asserting of a right not to tender rent.
15. Another significant fact that would merit mention is reliance by the petitioner, upon the civil suit filed by the respondents for declaration of their ownership, with respect to the demised premises. The civil suit was filed on 23.7.1999, whereas the written statement in the ejectment petition dated 20.5.1999 was filed on 20.7.1999 The written statement, therefore, does not refer to or rely upon the civil suit. Therefore, the argument that the petitioner raised a bona fide dispute based on the pendency of the civil suit was clearly an after thought.
As regards the assertions, with respect to the first date of hearing, suffice it to say that the petitioner never offered to tender rent at any stage of the proceedings before the Rent Controller. In fact, she continued to maintain even before the Appellate Authority that the respondents were not her landlords. Thus, the above assertion is without merit.
16. In view of what has been stated herein above, as the impugned orders do not suffer from any error of jurisdiction or of law, the present petition is dismissed, with no order as to costs.
17. However, with the consent of counsel for the respondents, the petitioner is granted six months' time to vacate the premises, subject, however, to the condition that she would continue to pay/deposit the rent by the 7th of each month and files an undertaking before the Rent Controller, to deliver possession within six months' from today.
Petition dismissed.
Alert