Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Charan Singh v. Ajit Singh And Another

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Sep 30, 1969

Bal Raj Tuli, J. - The petitioner is the proprietor of Bahktawar Engineering Works, Goraya, and is carrying on the business of manufacturing chaff-cutting machines and accessories and other agricultural implements. It is alleged in the petition that the petitioner-firm has been using mark of two pigeons on a twig facing each other as a distinctive mark of its products. The mark is known as `Do Kabuttar'. It is then alleged that the birds in various postures are commonly used as trade marks in the trade of agricultural machinery and implements and some of those birds have been registered as trade marks while others have not been got registered. The customers of these goods are illiterate agriculturists of rural areas. They are hardly able to distinguish one trade mark from another from its pictorial devices inscribed on the steel and cast iron parts. The products of various manufacturers thus come to be known by the bird or the animal which is used as the trade mark, such as `Horseman' is known as `Ghora Marka' `Lion Brand', is known as `Shermarka' and goods of other trade marks are known as `Tota Marka', `Do-Chiri Marka', `Baaz Marka' `Mayna Marka' etc. 2. The petitioner goes on to allege that when respondent 1 applied for the registration of his trade mark `Do Chiri', a dispute was raised by Sadhu Singh, the owner of the Parrot Brand, and in those proceedings the said respondent admitted that birds were commonly used as trade marks in the trade and gave a list of 20 trade marks with pictorial devices of birds, registered and unregistered but in current use. The petitioner has also made an application for registration of his trade mark `Do Kabuttar' which is pending with the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks who called for evidence of concurrent user by his letter dated April 24, 1969. The petitioner claims that the register of the trade marks is liable to be rectified in respect of the trade mark `Do-Chiri' of respondent 1 because the Registrar, while registering it, did not safeguard the interests of other persons making use of birds in different postures as trade marks on the basis of honest concurrent user for a long time. Respondent 1 filed a complaint under Sections 78 and 79 of the Trade and Mechandise Marks Act, 1958, (hereinafter called the Act), against the petitioner in the Court of the Judicial Magistrate, Phillaur, on March 17, 1969 which has necessitated the filing of this petition for the rectification of the entry in the register of trade marks. The relief claimed by the petitioner is that respondent 2 may be directed to cancel the registration of respondent No. 1's trade mark `Do Chiri' under No. 141359 as entered in the register of trade marks and only allow the registration of respondent No. 1's trade and `Do Chiri' strictly amended in colour and other particulars to protect the honest concurrent user of the petitioner's trade mark `Do Kabuttar' and the petitioner may be allowed costs of the petition. 3. Respondent 1 has filed a written statement in which it has been pointed out that the petition is not competent under Section 56 of the Act and that the petition has been filed about twenty years after the registration of the trade mark of the answering respondent which was done in 1949. On merits it has been stated that the petitioner has not been using the trade mark `Do Kabuttar' since 1952 and that the respondent came to know that the petitioner was using the trade mark in October, 1967, and filed the complaint against the petitioner on December 27, 1967, because the petitioner had imitated the trade mark of respondent 1 and was using it dishonestly in order to cause injury to respondent 1 and illegal again or profit to himself. It has further been alleged that respondent 1's firm is the owner of the trade mark `Do Chiri' under No. 141359 dated November 28, 1949, in Class 7, and has been using the said trade mark regularly and continuously in the course of trade in respect of `Agricultural Machinery, Chaff-cutter Blades and their components, all included in Class 7' since the year 1922 to indicate that such goods are of his manufacture. Finally, it submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to any relief in the present petition. 4. Along with the petition, a miscellaneous application was made for an order staying further prosecution of criminal complaint filed by respondent 1 against the petitioner. After hearing the learned counsel for both the parties, I had stayed further proceeding in the complaint by my order dated September 3, 1969, when the following preliminary issue was framed. "Whether, on the allegations made in the petitioner, a case for rectification of the register of trade marks under Section 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, is made out ?" The counsel for the parties have led no evidence on this issue and have only addressed arguments. The learned counsel for the petitioner has stated that the petitioner would be satisfied if it is noted against the trade mark of respondent 1 in the register of trade marks that his trade mark `Do Chiri' shall not interfere with the concurrent user of any other birds in different postures as a trade mark by any manufacturer. The learned counsel for respondent 1, however, opposes the grant of even this relief to the petitioner. Section 56 of the Act, under which the present petition has been made, reads as under :- "56. (1) On application made in the prescribed manner to High Court or to the Registrar by any person aggrieved, the tribunal may make such order as it may think fit for cancelling or varying the registration of a trade mark on the ground of any contravention, or failure to observe a condition entered on the register in relating thereto. (2) Any person aggrieved by the absence or omission from the register of any entry, or by any entry made in the register without sufficient cause, or by any entry wrongly remaining on the register, or by any error or defect in any entry in the register, may apply in the prescribed manner to a High Court or to the Registrar, and the tribunal may make order for making, expunging or varying the entry as it may think fit. (3) The tribunal may, in any proceeding under this section, decide any question that may be necessary or expedient to decide in connection with the rectification of the register. (4) The tribunal, of its own motion, may, after giving notice in the prescribed manner to the parties concerned and after giving them an opportunity of being heard, make any order referred to in sub-section (1) or sub-section (2). (5) Any order of the High Court rectifying the register shall direct that notice of the rectification shall be served upon the Registrar in the prescribed manner who shall upon receipt of such notice rectify the register accordingly. (6) The power to rectify the register conferred by this section shall include the power to remove a trade mark registered in Part A of the register to Part B of the register." Sub-section (1) of Section 56 does not apply in the present case as three is no allegation that respondent 1 has made any contravention of the trade mark or has failed to observe a condition entered on the register in relation thereto. The learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the present case is covered by sub-section (2), as the petitioner is aggrieved by the entry of the trade mark of respondent 1 in the register without sufficient cause and is, therefore, entitled to the expunction or variation of the entry in order to protect his interests. I regret I cannot agree to this submission. It cannot be said that the entry with regard to the trade mark of respondent 1 was made in the register of trade marks without sufficient case. When the said respondent made the application for the registration of his trade mark, the procedure prescribed under the relevant Act was followed and objections were invited. It is stated by the petitioner himself that one Sadhu Singh opposed the registration of the trade mark, but, in spite of his opposition, the registration was granted. It cannot also be said that the petitioner is aggrieved by the entry wrongly remaining on the register and, therefore, a case for the expunction of the entry or its variation is established. This submission is made on the ground that the petitioner has been using the trade mark `Do Kabuttar' since 1952 which fact has been denied by respondent 1 and the Assistant Registrar of Trade marks has called for evidence on this aspect in the application filed by the petitioner for the registration of his trade mark. The matter can appropriately be decided by that officer. The petitioner has himself applied for the registration of his trade mark `Do Kabuttar' which clearly implies that event, according to the petitioner, the use of birds makes the trade mark distinctive which is entitled to be registered. It cannot, therefore, be said that the trade mark of respondent 1 was not distinctive in nature when it was got registered or has ceased to be so since its registration because some other birds as a Trade mark on their products. The distinctiveness of the trade mark is not lost in this manner. When the petitioner has applied for the registration of his own trade mark, in my opinion, he is not entitled to the relief of expunging or varying the entry with regard to the trade mark of respondent 1. This petition is, therefore, not competent under Section 56 of the Act, and no other provision of the Act has been brought to my notice under which the petitioner is entitled to any relief. 5. For the reasons given above, this petition is dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 100/-. Petition dismissed.