Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Palani Roman Catholic Mission v. S. Bagirathi Ammal .

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 2, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The High Court disposed of AAO No. 767 of 1989 and CRP No. 1445 of 1988, holding that the petitioner, being a registered society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, was not a public, religious and charitable institution exempted under the Madras City Tenants Protection Act, 1921. A special leave petition under Article 136 of the Constitution was then filed before the Supreme Court and was dismissed in limine on 3-12-1996 by a non-speaking order. Thereafter, the appellant filed a review application in the High Court on 2-1-1997. The High Court dismissed the review petition as not maintainable on the ground that its earlier judgment had merged into the Supreme Court’s order dismissing the special leave petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court’s judgment merges into a non-speaking Supreme Court order dismissing a special leave petition in limine, thereby rendering a High Court review petition not maintainable.
  2. Whether a review petition before the High Court can be entertained after dismissal of a special leave petition in limine where no leave to appeal was granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant raised the question whether the High Court’s judgment merges into a non-speaking order of the Supreme Court dismissing the special leave petition in limine without reasons.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000) 6 SCC 359, JT (2000) 9 SC 110 A non-speaking Supreme Court order dismissing a special leave petition in limine does not attract the doctrine of merger; it only indicates that the Court was not inclined to exercise discretion to permit an appeal. Consequently, a review before the High Court is maintainable because no leave to appeal was granted and there is no appeal “in the eye of law” in the superior court. The Supreme Court applied this rule to hold that the High Court erred in treating the review as non-maintainable on merger grounds, and therefore set aside the High Court’s order and remitted the review for fresh consideration.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the High Court’s basis for dismissing the review petition—namely, that the High Court’s earlier judgment had merged into the Supreme Court’s order dismissing the special leave petition. The Court noted that the appellant’s contention concerned whether a non-speaking dismissal in limine of an SLP triggers the doctrine of merger, and held that the question was settled.

Relying on Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala, the Court reiterated that a non-speaking order dismissing an SLP does not attract merger and does not substitute the impugned High Court order; it merely reflects the Supreme Court’s refusal to exercise discretionary jurisdiction to grant leave. The Court further applied the principle from the same decision that, because leave was not granted and no appeal comes into existence in law in the superior court, a review petition before the High Court can be filed and maintained even after dismissal of the SLP.

On this footing, the Court concluded that the High Court’s order dismissing the review as not maintainable could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED; HIGH COURT ORDER SET ASIDE; REMITTED.

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order dismissing the review petition and remitted the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration of the review petition in accordance with law. The Court also indicated that, as the matters were old, the High Court should dispose of them expeditiously. The decision’s direct effect is to revive and restore the review proceedings before the High Court; the opinion applies the principle from Kunhayammed and does not indicate that any new precedent was laid down.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted. After disposal of AAO No. 767 of 1989 and CRP No. 1445 of 1988 by the High Court holding that the petitioner being a registered society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 is not a public, religious and charitable institution exempted under the Madras City Tenants Protection Act, 1921, a special leave petition had been filed before this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution, and this Court by an order made on 3-12-1996 dismissed the same in limine without setting out any reasons. Thereafter, an application for review was filed in the High Court on 2-1-1997.

2. The review petition has been dismissed on the ground that it is not maintainable as the judgment dated 26-7-1996 of the High Court has merged in the order of this Court dated 3-12-1996 dismissing the special leave petition. The learned Judge in reaching this conclusion relied upon various other decisions of this Court.

3. On behalf of the appellant the learned counsel raised a question whether the judgment of the High Court merges in a non-speaking order of this Court, dismissing the special leave petition in limine without stating any reasons. This question is no longer res integra.

4. This Court in Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000) 6 SCC 359, JT (2000) 9 SC 110 has taken the view that an order of the nature made in the special leave petition arising out of the order of the High Court, which is a non-speaking order, does not attract the doctrine of merger and it would not substitute the order impugned in the special leave petition proceedings with the result that the Court was not inclined to exercise its discretion so as to allow the appeal to be filed.

5. This Court has in the said decision proceeded to state that a review can be filed in such a case even after special leave petition is dismissed inasmuch as no leave had been granted to file an appeal and until there is no appeal in the eye of the law in the superior court, review can be preferred in the High Court.

6. In view of the decision in Kunhayammed case (2000) 6 SCC 359, JT (2000) 9 SC 110 the order made by the High Court cannot be sustained. The judgment of the High Court is set aside and the matters are remitted to the High Court for fresh consideration of the review petition filed by the appellant in accordance with law. Inasmuch as the matters are old one, it would be appropriate for the High Court to dispose of them as expeditiously as possible. The appeals are allowed accordingly.