- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
N.B Chakraborty v. The Union Of India And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Pathak, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner challenged, by a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, an order dated 20 September 1968 terminating his services with one month's notice under sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965 ("Temporary Service Rules").
The petitioner had been appointed on a purely temporary basis as Field Exhibition Officer by an order dated 21 December 1965, effective from 29 November 1965. Subsequent reorganization changed the status and pay scale of the post and by order dated 6 October 1967 the petitioner (with others) was appointed to the Gazetted post on a purely temporary/ad hoc basis pending regular recruitment.
Following certain complaints alleging irregularities by the petitioner (as part of the Gauhati Field Exhibition Unit), a departmental preliminary enquiry was undertaken and the petitioner was suspended by order dated 25 January/4 February 1968 under Rule 10(1) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 ("Civil Service Rules"). The matter was later submitted to the Central Bureau of Investigation for further inquiry and the petitioner was informed by letter dated 24 June 1968 that investigation was pending.
Meanwhile, a UPSC recruitment exercise (notification dated 7 August 1967) invited applications for 20 Field Exhibition Officer posts; the petitioner was interviewed but not selected. By order dated 20 September 1968 the Director of Advertising and Visual Publicity issued a notice terminating the petitioner's services under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules. The petitioner challenged this termination as being punitive and in breach of Article 311(2) of the Constitution because the termination occurred while disciplinary proceedings/enquiry were pending.
The writ court considered the matter and ultimately quashed the impugned order, made the Rule absolute, allowed the petition with costs and directed payment of hearing fee Rs. 200/-. S.K. Dutta, C.J., agreed with the judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned order terminating the petitioner's services was an ordinary termination under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules or whether it was, in effect, a punitive dismissal/reduction amounting to punishment; and consequently whether Article 311(2) of the Constitution applied.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner was placed under suspension under Rule 10(1)(a) of the Civil Service Rules and disciplinary proceedings were pending against him when his services were terminated.
- The termination, though styled under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules, was in reality by way of punishment, thereby attracting the protections of Article 311(2) of the Constitution which the authorities failed to comply with.
Respondents' Arguments
- A preliminary departmental enquiry had been conducted and the matter was referred to the Central Bureau of Investigation for investigation; no departmental disciplinary proceeding had been conducted by the department.
- The termination under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules was unrelated to the pending investigation; the petitioner was replaced by a regularly selected person through UPSC and, having not been selected by UPSC, his services had to be terminated under the Rules with one month's notice.
- Termination was not by way of punishment and therefore Article 311(2) did not apply; the petitioner was not entitled to relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P.L. Dhingra v. Union of India, AIR 1958 SC 36 | The Supreme Court's articulation of two tests to determine when a termination is punitive and attracts Article 311 protections: (1) whether the servant had a right to the post or rank; and (2) whether the order visited the servant with "evil consequences" (loss of pay/allowances, stigma affecting future career, loss of seniority, etc.). | The court applied these tests: it found the petitioner did not satisfy the first test (he was a temporary officer with no right to continue), but the second test was satisfied because the termination order expressly described the petitioner as "at present under suspension," thereby leaving an indelible stigma likely to affect future employment. On that basis the court held Article 311(2) was attracted and the termination order was quashed for non-compliance. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise legal analysis grounded on the test set out by the Supreme Court in P.L. Dhingra:
- Characterisation of the post and applicable rule: The petitioner was a temporary officer and, as such, prima facie his services could be terminated with one month's notice under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules.
-
Invocation of the Dhingra two-test framework:
- First test — entitlement to the post or rank: Because the petitioner held a purely temporary post and had no right to continue, the first test was not satisfied.
- Second test — whether the termination inflicted "evil consequences" (punitive effects): The court examined whether the termination order, though made under Rule 5(1), on its face carried penal consequences or an indelible stigma.
- Application to facts: The impugned order expressly described the petitioner as "at present under suspension." The court found that this phrase, appearing in the termination order, carried an indelible stigma that could reasonably impair the petitioner's prospects of future employment and therefore amounted to an evil consequence analogous to punishment.
- Conclusion from the test: Because the second Dhingra test was met (stigma/evil consequences), the termination was, in substance, punitive and consequently required compliance with the protections of Article 311(2). The authorities had not complied with Article 311(2).
- Remedy: For non-compliance with Article 311(2), the court struck down the termination order, quashed it and allowed the petition with costs and specified hearing fee.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The impugned order dated 20th September 1968 terminating the petitioner's services under Rule 5(1) of the Temporary Service Rules is quashed for violation of Article 311(2) of the Constitution; the Rule is made absolute. The petition is allowed with costs (hearing fee Rs. 200/-).
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The termination order was set aside; the petitioner obtained relief by way of quashing of the termination and award of costs as recorded by the court.
- Scope and precedent: The judgment applies the established two-test framework from P.L. Dhingra to determine when a purportedly non-punitive termination of a temporary employee may nonetheless be treated as punitive because it carries an indelible stigma. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond applying that precedent to the facts; no broader new precedent is stated in the judgment beyond applying the cited authority.
Additional notation from the record: S.K. Dutta, C.J., agreed with the judgment.
Pathak, J.:— By this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 20th September, 1968, by which his services had been terminated in pursuance of sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965 with one month's notice.
2. The petitioner was appointed as Field Exhibition Officer by order dated 21st December, 1965 of the Director of Advertising & Visual Publicity in the same Directorate on a purely temporary capacity with effect from the forenoon of the 29th November, 1965 until further orders and he joined and continued to serve in that post. As a result of reorganization of the said Directorate, the post of Field Exhibition Officer, which was previously included in Grade IV of the Central Information Service and carried a scale of Rs. 270-10-290-15-410-EB-15-485, was excluded from the Central Information Service and was made a Gazetted post in the same Directorate in the scale of Ra 350-20-450-25-575. By order dated 6-10-67, the petitioner, along with other Field Exhibition Officers who had been similarly appointed to the non-Gazetted post on ad hoc basis previously was appointed by the Director of Advertising and Visual Publicity, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, to the Gazetted post on a purely temporary capacity pending regular recruitment to the post according to the recruitment rules (Vide Notification No. 17/34/64-Est dated 6-10-67). These posts of Field Exhibition Officers were not permanent even at that stage.
3. On receipt of certain complaints regarding the alleged irregularities committed by the petitioner, who was functioning as Field Exhibition Officer in the said Directorate at Gauhati as well as by certain other members of the Gauhati Field Exhibition Unit, a preliminary enquiry was conducted on the departmental basis and pending disciplinary proceedings the petitioner was suspended by order dated 25th January, 1968/4th February, 1968 by the Director of Advertising and Visual Publicity under Rule 10(1) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter called the ‘Civil Service Rules’). On enquiry the petitioner was informed by letter No. 1-9/67-V dated 24-6-68 that the investigation was pending in the case. By a notification dated 7-8-67 the Union Public Service Commission invited applications for recruitment to 20 posts of Field Exhibition officers in the said Directorate under the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. The petitioner who submitted an application in response to the advertisement was called for interview along with 171 other candidates, but the Union Public Service Commission did not select him. Thereafter by order dated 20-9-68 the Director of Advertising and Visual Publicity terminated the services of the petitioner with one month's notice in pursuance of Rule 5(1) of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services Rules, 1965 (hereinafter called the “Temporary Service Rules”). The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that while the petitioned was serving as Field Exhibition Officer, though temporarily, disciplinary proceeding Page: 100against him was started under the provisions of the ‘Civil Service Rules’ and he was placed under suspension under Rule 10(1)(a) of the said Rules and while the disciplinary proceeding was pending his services were terminated by way of punishment though it was purported to be under Rule 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’, and thus Article 311(2) of the Constitution was attracted to the case and the impugned order of termination was bad in law for non-compliance with the provisions of Article 311(2) of the Constitution.
4. The learned counsel of the respondents, on the other hand, submitted that a preliminary enquiry was conducted on the departmental basis against the petitioner and some others and after the preliminary enquiry, the matter was referred to the Central Bureau of Investigation for necessary investigation and no disciplinary proceeding was conducted by the department. The petitioner was informed by letter dated 24-6-68 that the investigation was pending in the case. The termination of the petitioner's services under Rule 15(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’ had nothing to do with the pending enquiry concerning the petitioner. His services were replaced by those of a regularly selected person through Union Public Service Commission. As the petitioner was not selected by the Union Public Service Commission, his senders had to be terminated as required under the provisions of the Rules with one month's notice. The termination of services of the petitioner was not by way of punishment and as such it did not attract Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India and the petitioner was not entitled to any remedy in this case.
5. The point that falls for determination in the case is whether the impugned order of termination of services of the petitioner was by way of punishment or it was an order of termination of services simpliciter under Rule 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’.
6. The impugned order is in the following terms:
“In pursuance of sub-rule (1) of R. 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965, I hereby give notice to Shri N.B Chakrabarty, Field Exhibition Officer, ad hoc at present under suspension that his services shall stand terminated with effect from the date of expiry of a period of one month from the date on which this notice is served on him.
Sd/- R. Streenivasan.
Director of Advertising and Visual Publicity.”
7. The cases in and the circumstances under which the provisions of Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India are attracted have been summarised by the Supreme Court in the case of P.L Dhingra v. Union of India, AIR 1958 SC 36, as follows:
In short, if the termination of service is founded on the right flowing from contract or the service rules then prima facie, the termination is not a punishment and carries with it no evil consequences and so Article 311 is not attracted. But even if the Government has, by contract or under the rules, the right to terminate the employment without going through the procedure prescribed for inflicting the punishment of dismissal or removal or reduction in rank, the Government may, nevertheless, choose to punish the servant and if the termination of service is sought to be founded on misconduct, negligence, inefficiency or other disqualification, then it is a punishment and the requirements of Article 311 must be complied with. As already stated if the servant has got a right to continue in the post, then, unless the contract of employment or the rules provide to the contrary, his services cannot be terminated other wise than for misconduct, negligence, inefficiency or other good and sufficient cause A termination of the service of such a servant on such grounds must be punishment and, therefore, a dismissal or removal within Article 311, for it operates as a forfeiture of his right and he is visited with the evil consequences of loss of pay and allowances. It puts an indelible stigma on the officer affecting his future career. A reduction in rank likewise may be by way of punishment or it may be an innocuous thing. If the government servant has right to particular rank, then the very reduction from that rank will operate as a penalty, for he will then lose the emoluments and privileges of that rank. If, however, he has no aright to the particular rank, his reduction from an officiating higher rank to his substantive lower rank will not ordinarily be a punishment. But the mere fact that the servant has no title to the post or the rank and the Government has, by contract, express or Implied, or under the rules, the right to reduce him to a lower post does not mean that an order of reduction of a servant to a lower post or rank cannot in any circumstances be a punishment. The real test for determining whether the reduction in such cases is or is not by way of punishment is to find out if the order for the reduction also visits the servant with any penal consequences. Thus if the order entails or provides for the forfeiture of his pay or allowances or the loss of his seniority in his substantive rank or the stoppage or postponement of his future chances of promotion, then that circumstance may Page: 101indicate that although in form the Government had purported to exercise its right to terminate the employment or to reduce the servant to a lower rank under the terms of the contract of employment or under the rules, in truth and reality the Government has terminated the employment as and by way of penalty. The use of the expression “terminate” or “discharge” is not conclusive. In spite of the use of such innocuous expressions, the Court has to apply the two tests mentioned above, namely, (1) whether the servant had a right to the post or the rank or (2) whether he has been visited with evil consequences of the kind hereinbefore referred to? If the case satisfies either of the two tests then it must be held that the servant has been punished and the termination of his service must be taken as a dismissal or removal from service or the reversion to his substantive rank must be regarded as a reduction in rank and if the requirements of the rules and Article 311, which give protection to Government servant have not been complied with, the termination of the service or the reduction in rank must be held to be wrongful and in violation of the constitutional right of the servant”
8. In the instant case, the admitted position is that the petitioner was holding the post temporarily, and he was not in quasi-permanent service and as such his service could be terminated with one month's notice under Rule 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’. That bang the position, the present case does not satisfy the first test mentioned by the Supreme Court Let us consider whether the petitioner's case falls within the second test as laid down by the Supreme Court in the above decision. The petitioner was suspended because there were allegations of defalcation against him and disciplinary proceeding was either, contemplated or was pending against him. After his suspension admittedly there was a preliminary enquiry and the petitioner's case was submitted to the Central Investigation Bureau for necessary investigation. The Government may dispense with the services of a temporary government servant if his services are either not required or the Government finds that he is for any reason not suitable to be retained in service and in such cases his services may be terminated under R. 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’. When the services of such a temporary government servant are terminated under Rule 5(1) of the “Temporary Service Rules” it does not ordinary visit with evil consequences or loss of pay and allowances as contemplated under the second test laid down by the Supreme Court. The Government may also after contemplating to draw up proceedings against a temporary officer for allegations against him, choose not to draw up proceedings but dispense with his services under Rule 5(1) of the “Temporary Service Rules”. But if the Government decides to draw up proceedings against a temporary officer and accordingly a charge of serious allegations is framed against him and proceeds with the disciplinary proceedings against him and thereafter without completing or withdrawing the disciplinary proceedings, terminates the services of the temporary officer, ordinarily such an order of termination of services of temporary officer under Rule 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’ may not be hit by non-compliance of Article 311(2) of the Constitution; but there may be cases in which the termination order itself on the face of it may carry indelible stigma on the officer endangering his future appointment and entailing evil consequences, which may amount to punishment and the case may attract Article 311(2) of the Constitution, according to the second test as laid down by the Supreme Court.
9. In the Instant case, the impugned order while terminating the services of the petitioner, has described him as “at present under suspension”. On the face of it, the impugned order leaves the stigma on the petitioner that he is a suspended officer, and any future employer may reasonably think that the petitioner must have been suspended in service on some serious allegations and may refuse employment to the petitioner on that ground alone. In our opinion, the inclusion of the words “at present under suspension” in the order itself carries an Indelible stigma on the petitioner which may stand in his way in any future employment in government service or elsewhere. That being the position, we hold that the impugned order though passed under Rule 5(1) of the ‘Temporary Service Rules’ carries an Indelible stigma on the petitioner entailing evil consequences and may seriously affect his future employment and, therefore, the case comes under the second test laid down in such matters by the Supreme Court. In the circumstances, we hold that since admittedly the provisions of Article 311(2); of the Constitution were not complied with in terminating the services of the petitioner the impugned order must be struck down as violative of Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India. In the result, the impugned order dated 20th September, 1968, is quashed and the Rule is made absolute. The petition is allowed with costs. Hearing Fee Rs. 200/-.
10. S.K Dutta, C.J:— I agree.
11. Rule made absolute.
Alert