- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shashikant S/O Gulabchand Bora v. State Of Maharashtra
Judgment Summary — Criminal Appeals arising from Special Case No.1/2002 (Nasik)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeals arise from a conviction and sentence dated 30.7.2008 by the Additional Special Judge, Nasik, in Special Case No.1/2002. The appellants (original accused Nos.1, 2 and 4) were convicted for offences punishable under Sections 489-B, 489-C, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and sentenced to varying terms of rigorous imprisonment and fines.
The prosecution case, briefly stated in the opinion, is that on 25.6.2001 employees of State Bank of India (SBI), Ahmednagar main branch suspected that several 500-rupee currency notes (received from Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank branch) were counterfeit. Notes were checked under an ultra-violet machine and later seized. A Security Press report ultimately found 1,950 out of 2,000 notes to be fake.
A complaint was filed by the Assistant General Manager of SBI and investigation was carried out by local police and later by the State CID. The charge-sheet included offences under Sections 3(1)(ii), 3(2), 3(4) of the MCOC Act, Sections 489-B, 489-C, 420 and 120-B IPC, and, as to accused Nos.2 and 4, Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
At trial the Additional Special Judge acquitted the accused of charges under the MCOC Act and some other counts, but convicted accused Nos.1, 2 and 4 under the IPC offences noted above. All appellants challenged that conviction before this Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt the mens rea ("knowing or having reason to believe") required under Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC in respect of the accused who received, possessed or trafficked in the alleged counterfeit currency notes.
- Whether, in the absence of proof for Sections 489-B and 489-C, offences under Section 420 and Section 120-B IPC can be sustained against the accused.
- Whether the convictions of accused Nos.2 (branch manager) and 4 (cashier) could be sustained on the evidence and material available, including any inference of commission, receipt or knowledge.
- Whether precedents relied upon by the parties (including cases concerning presumptions under the Customs Act) are applicable to offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant — Accused No.1 (submission by Smt. S. Jadhav)
- The prosecution bore the burden to prove beyond reasonable doubt that accused No.1 knew or had reason to believe the notes were counterfeit; that burden was not discharged.
- Essential ingredients of Sections 489-B and 489-C require knowledge or reason to believe the notes are forged or counterfeit; the evidence fails to establish such knowledge/reason to believe.
- Bank personnel who handled the notes were themselves doubtful after UV examination; the Security Press report showed imitation only in watermark and security thread while length, width and print size were perfect — a layman could not have discovered the counterfeit by naked eye.
- Large sums from multiple branches were mixed in the bank strong room; testimony indicates mixing and lack of clarity about which depositor supplied the forged notes, so it cannot be proved the accused alone deposited the fake notes.
- Accused No.1 explained the source of funds came from one "Karwa", who was exonerated by police and not charged; the non-prosecution of Karwa creates doubt in the prosecution case.
- No specific question was put to accused No.1 in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination about knowledge or reason to believe the notes were fake.
- Reliance placed on the Apex Court decision in Umashanker v. State of Chhattisgarh to support the requirement of mens rea and the consequences of its non-proving.
Appellant — Accused No.2 (submission by Mr. A. H. Kapadia)
- Conviction of accused No.2 rests on assumptions and presumptions without evidence; there is no material to support conviction.
- As Branch Manager, accused No.2 had no occasion to receive cash or directly examine the notes and thus no occasion to know they were counterfeit.
- No question was put to accused No.2 under Section 313 Cr.P.C. about reason to believe the notes were counterfeit, nor about alleged commission or his accounts; reliance placed on Sharad v. State of Maharashtra to submit that prosecution is vitiated on that count.
Appellant — Accused No.4 (submission by Mr. C. R. Deshpande)
- The SBI officials themselves were doubtful after UV examination and awaited the Security Press report; Burudgaon Branch had no UV machine, so accused No.4 (cashier) could not be expected to discover the notes were counterfeit.
Respondent — State (submission by Mr. K. G. Patil, Assistant Government Pleader)
- Intention of the accused must be inferred from the pattern and volume of deposits occurring over a short period, and accused No.1 opened and operated multiple accounts with unexplained large deposits.
- Accused No.1 did not produce bank account details to prove the alleged receipt from "Karwa"; in absence of that explanation, the accused's intention should be inferred against him.
- Accused No.2 could not have deposited such amounts in his account without receiving commission from accused No.1; accused No.4 as cashier should have detected counterfeit notes and his failure to report suggests involvement.
- Relied on Shah Guman Mal v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Labhchand Dhanpat Singh Jain v. State of Maharashtra to support inferences of involvement or knowledge.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Umashanker v. State of Chhattisgarh (2001 AIR SCW 4051 / 2001 ALL MR (Cri) 2398) | Establishes that Sections 489-B and 489-C require mens rea — "knowing or having reason to believe" that notes are forged/counterfeit; absence of mens rea negates conviction under these sections. | The Court relied on and applied this precedent directly: finding no mens rea proved here (and noting no specific Section 313 questioning on this point), the Court held Umashanker squarely applicable and concluded the charges under 489-B and 489-C were not proved. |
| Sharad v. State of Maharashtra (AIR 1984 SC 1622) | Addresses evidentiary standards, presumptions and the consequences of failing to put relevant questions in Section 313 Cr.P.C. (relied upon by defence to challenge inferences/presumptions). | The Court accepted the applicability of the dictum in the context advanced by accused No.2: one cannot presume accused No.2 must have received commission; absence of evidence and failure to put relevant questions under Section 313 vitiates such an inference. |
| Shah Guman Mal v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1980 Cri.L.J. 557) | Invoked by the prosecution to support inferences of knowledge/intent (prosecutor's reliance); the cases relied on customs/smuggling jurisprudence where statutory presumptions applied. | The Court found this reliance misplaced: those cases involved the Customs Act where Section 123 provides a presumption and shifts burden. The Court held such presumptions are not part of Sections 489-B/489-C IPC, so the precedent could not be applied to relieve the prosecution of its burden here. |
| Labhchand Dhanpat Singh Jain v. State of Maharashtra (A.I.R. 1975 SC 182) | Relied upon by the prosecution similarly as authority where statutory presumptions under customs law affected burden of proof. | The Court rejected its applicability for the same reason as Shah Guman Mal: the case law involved Customs Act presumptions (Section 123), which are inapplicable to offences under Sections 489-B/489-C IPC; thus the prosecution could not derive support from these authorities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded by focusing on the essential mens rea requirement for offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC: the accused must have knowledge or reason to believe that the currency notes are forged or counterfeit.
The Court examined the evidence and emphasized the following factual points from the record:
- Bank officials who handled the notes examined them under an ultra-violet machine and were themselves doubtful about the genuineness of the notes; they deferred lodging a complaint until receipt of the Security Press report.
- Witness depositions expressly stated that without UV checking it was not possible to determine genuineness, and that the Burudgaon branch (where accused Nos.2 and 4 were based) did not possess a UV machine.
- The Security Press report indicated that length, width and printed-design size were correct and paper thickness only slightly different; the notable defects were in watermark and security thread — defects not readily apparent to a layman or even on quick UV check by bank staff.
- There was evidence of mixing of large cash consignments from different branches in the bank strong room over several days, making it unclear from the record that the forged notes were deposited exclusively by accused No.1.
- Accused No.1 had given an explanation that funds were received from a person named Karwa; Karwa was not prosecuted (his name was deleted from the list of accused and not charge-sheeted), and the Court regarded this as creating doubt in prosecution's case when the prosecution had the opportunity to examine him.
- No specific question was put to accused No.1 under Section 313 Cr.P.C. about knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit.
Applying legal principles and precedents:
- The Court applied Umashanker to reiterate that without mens rea the offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C are not made out.
- The Court rejected the prosecutor's reliance on precedents arising under the Customs Act (Shah Guman Mal, Labhchand) because those cases involved statutory presumptions (Section 123, Customs Act) shifting burdens; no analogous statutory presumption exists for Sections 489-B/489-C IPC, and the burden here remains on the prosecution.
- The Court applied Sharad's principle regarding presumptions and the need to put relevant questions in Section 313 Cr.P.C. to counter speculative inferences against accused No.2 where no evidence supported a commission inference and no 313 questioning was made on that point.
On these factual and legal bases the Court concluded the prosecution did not discharge its burden to prove mens rea for Sections 489-B and 489-C as to accused No.1, and consequently those offences could not be sustained. Because the primary offences were not proved, ancillary charges under Section 420 and Section 120-B IPC also failed. The Court further found no case against accused Nos.2 and 4 on the evidence: accused No.2 had explanations and no 313 questioning about alleged commission; accused No.4 could not be faulted where the branch lacked UV facilities and even SBI officials were unsure.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Criminal Appeals were allowed. The Court set aside the convictions and sentences imposed by the trial court and ordered the accused to be released.
Core Ruling: The convictions and sentences imposed on the appellants (original accused Nos.1, 2 and 4) under Sections 489-B, 489-C, 420 and 120-B IPC are set aside and the accused are acquitted of those charges.
Direct Implications for the Parties:
- The accused are directed to be set at liberty forthwith unless they are required in connection with any other crime.
- The prosecution failed to prove the essential mens rea for Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC; consequently, related conspiracy and cheating charges were not sustained.
Broader Implications:
The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying and following existing precedents (notably Umashanker and Sharad) and distinguishing authorities that rely on statutory presumptions in other Acts (Customs Act). The decision reaffirms that for Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC the prosecution must prove knowledge or reason to believe the notes are counterfeit; statutory presumptions from other enactments are not transferable to these IPC offences.
Disposition: Appeals allowed; order of conviction and sentence set aside; accused to be released if not wanted in other matters.
Cases referred :
Umashanker Vs. State of Chhattisgarh, 2001 ALL MR (Cri) 2398 (S.C.) : 2001 AIR SCW 4051 [ 6 , 15 ]
Sharad Vs. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1984 Supreme Court 1622 [ 7, 1 7 ]
Shah Guman Mal Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, 1980 Cri.L.J. 557 [ 10 , 14 ]
Labhchand Dhanpat Singh Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra, A.I.R. 1975 SC 182 [ 10 , 14 ]
Advocates appeared :
Mr. A. H. KAPADIA, Advocate holding for Mr. H. F. PAWAR, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. K. G. PATIL, Asstt. Govt. Pleader for the State.
S. V. GANGAPURWALA, J.:- All these three appeals are directed against same judgment as such are being decided together.
2. The appellants being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 30.7.2008, passed by the Additional Special Judge, Nasik, in Special Case No.1/2002, thereby convicting the appellants (original accused Nos.1, 2 and 4) for the offence punishable U/s.489-B read with Section 120-B(1) of the I.P.C. and sentencing them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life each and to pay fine of 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lac) each, in default to suffer R.I. for three (3) years, so also convicting the appellants (original accused Nos.1, 2 and 4) for offence U/s.489-C read with Section 120-B(1) of the I.P.C., thereby sentencing to undergo R.I. for five (5) years each and to pay fine of 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand), in default to suffer R.I. for one year and U/s.420 read with Section 120-B(1) of the I.P.C. to undergo R.I. for five years and fine of 25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) each, in default to suffer R.I. for one year.
3. The case of the prosecution is that on 25.6.2001, the employees of State Bank of India, Ahmednagar main branch suspected that 200 currency notes of 500/- denomination each received from Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank branch are counterfeit/fake notes. The notes were verified under ultra-violet machine. The Assistant General Manager was also doubtful about those currency notes. This fact was reported to the Police. Thereafter, on 26.6.2001, the currency notes in question were seized and sealed. They were kept in the safe custody of State Bank of India, under panchanama. On 27.6.2001, the Police had taken away the packets of the said currency notes. Thereafter, on 4.7.2001, Bhingar Camp Police Station asked the State Bank of India, as to whether they wanted to lodge the complaint. On 5.7.2001, the then Assistant General Manager of State Bank of India, vide his letter dated 5.7.2001 replied that only after receipt of the report of the security press the complaint would be lodged, as it was not possible to do so without receiving the report of the security press as to whether the said notes are fake. The report of the security press was received. As per the said report 1950 currency notes out of 2000 currency notes of 500/- denomination were fake. Thereafter, the complaint was filed by the Assistant General Manager of the State Bank of India, Main Branch against unknown persons with the Bhingar Camp Police Station, Ahmednagar. The investigation was undertaken by one Mr. Ashok Shankar Shete (P.W.31) who investigated the complaint, recorded the statements of witnesses and Bank employees. The house of accused No.l was searched and one diary was seized. Accused No.1 was arrested on 14.7.2001. Accused No.2 was arrested on 16.7.2001. Accused Nos.3 and 4 were arrested on 21.7.2001. Thereafter it was directed to handover the investigation to the State CID. Mr. Sk. Akkani (P.W.32) Superintendent of Police, CID Branch, conducted further investigation. During the course of the investigation the CID collected ATNT mobile set record. The Investigation Officer of the CID recorded the statements. During the course of the investigation the prosecution was of the opinion that the provisions of M.C.O.C. Act are also attracted. Permission was sought from the competent authority to prosecute the accused persons under M.C.O.C. Act. The competent authority gave the said permission and the provisions of M.C.O.C. Act were also applied. The matter was referred to the Special Court at Nasik, empowered to try offence under M.C.O.C. Act. The prosecution filed the charge-sheet, thereby charging the accused persons for the offences punishable U/ss.3(1)(ii), 3(2) and 3(4) of the M.C.O.C. Act and U/ss 489-B, 489-C, 420 and 120-B of the I.P.C. The accused Nos.2 and 4 were also charged U/s.13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
4. The prosecution during the course of the trial examined 32 witnesses. The Additional Special Judge, Nasik acquitted all the accused persons of charges under M.C.O.C. Act, 1999, acquitted accused Nos.2 and 4 for charges under Prevention of Corruption Act, acquitted accused Nos.3 and 5 to 8 of all the charges against them and convicted accused Nos.1, 2 and 4 for the offences U/ss.489-B, 489-C, 120-B and 420 of the I.P.C..
5. Being aggrieved by the judgment and order of conviction and sentence, as aforesaid, the appellants are before this Court.
6. Smt. S. Jadhav, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No.519/2008 - original accused No.l put forth following submissions :
(i) The burden to prove beyond all reasonable doubt that the accused No.1 had the knowledge or reason to believe that the currency notes were used/possessed by him were counterfeit or fake currency notes is on the prosecution. The prosecution has miserably failed to prove the same. To buttress her submissions she relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of "Umashanker Vs. State of Chhattisgarh" reported in 2001 AIR SCW 4051 : [2001 ALL MR (Cri) 2398 (S.C.)].
(ii) That the essential ingredient for an offence U/s.489-B of the I.P.C. is that the person who receives the notes knows or has reason to believe the said notes to be forged or counterfeit. So also the essence of Section 489-C is that the person in possession of any counterfeit currency notes has knowledge or reason to believe the said notes to be counterfeit or forged one. In the present case, the totality of the evidence on record does not establish that the petitioner had the knowledge or had reason to believe the said notes to be counterfeit. The following circumstances would negate the theory of the prosecution that the appellant/accused No.l had the knowledge or reason to believe that the said notes were counterfeit notes.
(a) The notes were deposited with the Burudgaon Branch of the Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank. The person accepting the notes also did not find the notes to be doubtful. Even P.W.1 who lodged the complaint had seen the said notes under ultra-violet rays. He also has specifically admitted that even under ultra-violet rays, he was doubtful as to whether those currency notes were fake or not.
(b) Even as per the report of the security press, the length and width of the note was perfect. Even the size of the printed design was perfect and paper thickness was slightly thicker than the genuine note paper. The imitation was observed in the water marks and security thread. This could not be noticed by P.W.1 under the ultra-violet rays also. The Bank personnels are experts and handle the notes day in and out. Still, they could not say with certainty that the notes were counterfeit. Then for a layman like the appellant/accused No.1, it would not be possible by naked eyes to know the said fact. Even it is not clear from the statements of P.W.3 and P.W.4 as to who suspected the said notes to be fake. Both are saying that they had first suspected, raising contradictory stand.
(iii) An amount of 4,00,000/- (Rupees four lacs) was received from Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank on 21.6.2001 and the same was lying in the strong room for four days. The accused No.1 had not deposited amount with the Burudgaon Branch on 21.6.2001. Admittedly, he had deposited only an amount of 6,70,000/- (Rupees six lacs seventy thousand) on 25.6.2001. Out of the same an amount of 5,00,000/- (Rupees five lacs) was in denomination of 500/-. P.W.3 has stated that on 25.6.2001 an amount of 16,00,000/- (Rupees sixteen lacs) was received as deposit from Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank, out of them the currency notes of 500/- denomination were 1200 amounting to 6,00,000/- (Rupees six lacs) and 4,00,000/- (Rupees four lacs) received from Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank was lying in strong room from 21.6.2001 to 25.6.2001. From the evidence, it can not be said that the notes which were allegedly fake were deposited by accused No.1 only. Even P.Ws.3 and 4 say that the notes were mixed. P.W.9 who is Branch Manager of the Head Office of Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank only gives details of 6,00,000/- (Rupees six lacs) and does not give details of remaining 10,00,000/- ( ten lacs). According to P.W.9 on 25.6.2001 cash of 16,00,000/- ( sixteen lacs) was sent to SBI. Cash of 6,00,000/- (Rupees six lacs) was having currency notes of 500/- denomination. Out of that 6,00,000/- ( six lacs), 5,00,000/- (Rupees five lacs) was received from Burudgaon Branch and 1,00,000/- ( one lac) was received from Zendigate Branch. This witness does not give the details of remaining 10,00,000/- ( ten lacs).
(iv) Accused No.1 has given explanation that the amount which he had received from one Karwa was being deposited in his various accounts with different Banks. The said Karwa, has been exonerated by the Police. No charge-sheet is filed against him while in fact, he ought to have been the accused person. The accused No.1 has given the details about the receipt of the amount from said Mr. Karwa due to business transaction.
(v) It cannot be proved that the said alleged notes were deposited by accused No.1 only.
(vi) In his statement U/s.313, the accused No.1 has not been put any question about the knowledge of the accused No.l or that accused No.l, had reason to believe that notes were fake.
7. Mr. Kapadia, learned counsel for the accused No.2 i.e. the Branch Manager of the Burudgaon Branch of the Ahmednagar Shaher Sahakari Bank contended :
(i) That the accused No.2 has been convicted only on assumptions and presumptions without any basis. There is absolutely no evidence to convict the accused No.2.
(ii) The accused No.2 was the Branch Manager who had no occasion to receive cash nor had any occasion to see the notes, as such it can not be said that the accused No.2 had any knowledge of the said notes being counterfeit or fake.
(iii) Accused No.2 in his statement had stated the receipt of amount from Dr. Kulkarni and the deposit thereby. No question was put to the accused No.2 regarding reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit U/s.313 of the Cr.P.C. So also there is no reference about the account of the accused No.2 and about the alleged commission in his statement U/s.313 of the Cr.P.C., no question was put to the accused No.2 in that regard. As such the prosecution would stand vitiate on that count. For the said purpose he relies on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of " Sharad Vs. State of Maharashtra " reported in AIR 1984 Supreme Court 1622. As such the said theory of alleged commission can not be used against the accused.
8. Mr. C. R. Deshpande, learned counsel for accused No.4 contended :
(i) That even the officials of the State Bank of India were doubtful and were not certain about the notes being fake or counterfeit even after viewing them under ultra-violet rays as they had to wait till report was received from the Security Press. In such circumstances, when admittedly, there is no facility of ultra-violet machine at Burudgaon Branch, the accused No.4 could not have been made liable.
9. Mr. K. G. Patil, learned Assistant Government Pleader submitted that the intention of the accused will have to be gathered from the deposits being made. It was only during that short period of about a month or two, the accused No.1 had deposited the huge amount. The accused No.1 had opened four accounts and was operating the same. As such the intention is writ large. According to him, no explanation is given for such deposit. He further contended that the accused No.1 had not produced his accounts to prove that he received the amount from Mr. Karwa. In absence of the same, it will have to be presumed or the intentions will have to be gathered.
10. He further submitted that without the amount of commission received from accused No.1 for allowing him to do the illegal acts, the accused No.2 could not have deposited such amounts in his account.
Even accused No.4 was a Cashier and who had accepted the said notes could have easily found that the said notes are counterfeit and the fact that he did not report about this is sufficient to establish that he is involved in the said criminal act. Mr. Patil, relies on the judgment of the Apex Court in a case of "Shah Guman Mal Vs. The State of Andhra Pradesh" reported in 1980 Criminal Law Journal 557 and "Labhchand Dhanpat Singh Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra" A.I.R. 1975 Supreme Court 182.
11. With the assistance of the learned advocates, we have gone through the evidence on record.
12. Before adverting to the arguments canvassed by the respective counsels and the evidence on record, it will be appropriate for appreciating the arguments and the evidence to reproduce the relevant provisions under which the appellants are convicted :
" 489-B. Using as genuine, forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes - Whoever sells to, or buys or receives from, any other person, or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency note or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit, shall be punished with [imprisonment for life] or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.
489-C. Possession of forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes - Whoever has in his possession any forged or counterfeit currency note or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.
420. Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property.- Whoever cheats and thereby dishonestly induces the person deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any part of a valuable security, or anything which is signed or sealed,and which is capable of being converted into a valuable security, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine.
120-B. Punishment of criminal conspiracy.- (1) Whoever is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit an offence punishable with death, imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment for a term of two years or upwards, shall, where no express provision is made in this Code for the punishment of such a conspiracy, be punished in the same manner as if he had abetted such offence.
(2) Whoever is a party to a criminal conspiracy other than a criminal conspiracy to commit an offence punishable as aforesaid shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term not exceeding six months, or with fine or with both."
13. The Additional Special Judge, Nasik, has acquitted the accused persons of the charges under M.C.O.C. Act. The other accused persons have also been acquitted of the charges U/ss.489-B, 489-C, 420 and 120-B of the I.P.C. To bring home the guilt of the accused U/s.489-B or 489-C of the I.P.C. the prima donna requirement is that the said accused should have knowledge or reason to believe that the said notes are fake or counterfeit. The same is the sine-qua non for attracting the offence U/ss.489-B and 489-C of the I.P.C. The entire evidence on record shows that the said notes which are said to be counterfeit or fake were such that by naked eyes they can not be viewed as counterfeit. Even the Bank officials who are expert and who possess the necessary knowledge of the said notes could not even by examining it under ultra-violet rays say with certainty that the said notes were fake or counterfeit and that is why they did not file the complaint till receiving the report from the Security Press. PW 1 in his deposition has stated "In order to ascertain, currency notes were verified under the ultra-violet machine and I was also doubtful about those currency notes." Further in para 11 he states : "It is true since I was doubtful no complaint could be lodged on 25.6.2001." Further in para 12, he states "I have not specifically mentioned in Exh.359 that currency notes were not having genuineness and also silver strips". As such, when the person of the rank of Assistant General Manager of State Bank of India, could not notice the alleged discrepancy in the notes, it could not have been expected of a layman to have knowledge or reason to believe that the said notes are fake. PW 3 in para 5 of his statement says thus "It is true in order to ascertain genuineness of currency notes it is necessary to have checking under the ultra-violet machine". P.W.8 in para 16 of his deposition says thus "It is true that without checking currency notes under ultra-violet not possible to say its genuineness. It is true at the time of incident Burudgaon branch was not having ultra-violet machine".
14. The report of the Security Press also shows that the length, width of the said notes were perfect, so also size of the printed design i.e. its length and width were correct and the paper thickness was slightly thicker. Considering the said report and the evidence of the witnesses, it is clear that when the experts like Bank officials also could not say with certainty that the currency notes were fake or counterfeit then it can not be expected that a layman would have reason to believe the said notes to be counterfeit nor there is any evidence on record to even suggest that the accused No.1 had knowledge that the notes which he had received or possessed were fake or counterfeit. The prosecution has failed to establish beyond all reasonable doubt that the accused No.1 had knowledge or reason to believe that the said notes were counterfeit notes. The reliance placed by Mr. K. G. Patil, Asstt. Govt. Pleader on the judgments of the Apex Court in case of "Labhchand Dhanpat Singh Jain Vs. State of Maharashtra" and "Shah Guman Mal Vs. The State of Andhra Pradesh" cited supra is misplaced, for the reason the offences involved in the said case were under the Customs Act, wherein as per Section 123 of the Customs Act, presumption is given and the said Section 123 cast burden of proof, that the goods are not smuggled goods on the accused persons. It is in the said premise, the Apex Court held that the accused had not discharged the burden that he had no reason to believe that the goods were smuggled. There is no such burden cast upon the accused under offences U/s.489-B and 489-C of the I.P.C.. On the contrary, the burden is on the prosecution to prove that the currency notes which are possessed or received by the accused are counterfeit and the prosecution has to prove the same beyond all reasonable doubts. In the present case the totality of the evidence does not go to show that the prosecution has discharged the said burden. Moreover, when the accused No.1 had specifically stated that the amount which he had deposited and which the prosecution alleges those currency notes to be counterfeit were received from one Karwa, the prosecution ought to have examined him. He was even slated to be accused but then charge-sheet was not filed against him. On the contrary, permission was sought by the prosecution to delete the name of Karwa from the list of accused persons for the reasons best known to the prosecution. This creates a serious doubt on the genuineness of prosecution case.
15. The Apex Court in "Umashanker Vs. State of Chattisgarh" [2001 ALL MR (Cri) 2398 (S.C.)] cited supra has very succinctly laid down in para 8 as under :
"8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mens rea of offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C is, "knowing or having reason to believe the currency notes or bank notes are forged or counterfeit". Without the aforementioned mens rea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489-B of I.P.C. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489-C in the absence of the mens rea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite mens rea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect. The learned trial Judge on the basis of the evidence of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 7 that they were able to make out that currency note alleged to have been given to PW 4, was fake "presumed" such a mens rea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be 18 years old student. On the facts of this case the presumption drawn by the trial Court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency notes being fake or counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 3l3 of Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under Sections 489-B and 489-C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections 489-B and 489-C of I.P.C. and acquit him of the said charges."
In the present case also no mens rea can be made out. Moreover, in the present case in the statement U/s.313 of the Cr.P.C. no question is put to the accused No.1 that he had reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit. The aforesaid judgment squarely applies in the present matter.
16. For the above reasons, we are of the considered view that the prosecution having failed to prove the guilt of the accused U/ss.489-B and 489-C of the I.P.C. beyond all reasonable doubt the accused are entitled for acquittal.
17. If offence U/ss.489-B and 489-C itself is not proved against accused No.1 then no question arises of invoking Section 420 and Section 120-B of the I.P.C. So also no offence can be made out against accused Nos.2 and 4. Even otherwise no case can be made against accused Nos.2 and 4. Accused No.2 has given the details about the amount having been received from Dr. Kulkarni. No explanation was sought from accused No.2 U/s.313 of the Cr.P.C. in this respect. The dictum of the Apex Court in a case of "Sharad Vs. State of Maharashtra" (supra) squarely applies in the present case. One can not presume that the accused No.2 must have received commission from accused No.1. No evidence is on record in that regard. As far as accused No.4 is concerned, there is absolutely no case made out though he was a Cashier. It has come on record that there was no facility of ultra-violet machine in the said Burudgaon Branch. Even after examining the said currency notes under ultra-violet machine, the officials of State Bank of India, were doubtful. In such circumstances, no imputations can be levelled against accused No.4.
18. In light of the above discussion, the Criminal Appeals are allowed. The order of conviction and sentence is set aside. The accused are directed to be set at liberty forthwith, if not required in connection with any other crime.
Appeals allowed.
Alert