- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vicky @ Victor Julias Manthera v. State Of Maharashtra
Structured Summary of the Court Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion.
Three separate applications under section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 were presented to the Court. Although they arise from different criminal matters and involve different applicants, the Court disposed of them by a common order because they raised an identical legal issue and identical submissions were advanced.
The only procedural fact of relevance recorded in the opinion is that earlier bail applications in each of these matters had been allowed to be withdrawn unconditionally under different orders passed by different learned Single Judges of the High Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a successive bail application, in the absence of any material change in the factual situation, is maintainable.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The applicant's counsel contended that successive bail applications are tenable even where earlier bail applications had been withdrawn, and even if there was no change in the fact situation.
- The applicant relied notably on the judgment of the Apex Court in Kalyan Ranjan Chandra Sarakar Vs. Rajesh Ranjan and on several decisions of Single Judges of the High Court to support that proposition.
State's Arguments
- The learned Additional Public Prosecutor opposed the applicant's contention, submitting that successive bail applications should be permitted only when there is a change in the fact situation warranting fresh consideration.
- The State argued that permitting successive applications without change would promote abuse of the court process, encourage forum-shopping, lead to inconsistent orders by different Judges, and undermine the majesty of the courts.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kalyan Ranjan Chandra Sarakar Vs. Rajesh Ranjan, 2005(2) S.C.C. 42 (A.I.R. 2005 S.C. 921) | The Apex Court held that it is not open for the aggrieved person to make a bail application even on a ground previously rejected by the Court (including the Apex Court); the opinion quotes the Apex Court to that effect. | The Court referred to this Apex Court judgment as a principal authority and observed the holding quoted; it treated the case as limiting the scope for successive applications absent change in circumstances and found that the applicant's reliance on other decisions did not support the broader view urged. |
| Kailash Dhirajlal Gandhi Vs. State of Maharashtra, 2007 (Supp.) Bom.C.R. 75 (A.B.) : 2007(2) Mh.L.J. 850 | A Single Judge (Shri Gavai, J.) held that successive bail applications can be entertained after rejection of an earlier application, subject to change in fact situation and the law; he relied on the limited area carved out by the Apex Court in Kalyan Chandra Sarakar. | The Court noted this decision as taking the view that successive applications may be entertained if there is change in facts or law, and observed that the Single Judge relied on the limited scope indicated by the Apex Court. |
| Laxman Irappa Hatti Vs. State of Maharashtra, 2004(2) Bom.C.R.(Cri.) 525 | A Single Judge (Shri Bhosle, J.) expressed the view that successive bail applications may be entertained subject to change in fact situation and law (aligned with the limited area drawn from Kalyan Chandra Sarakar). | The Court recorded this decision as another instance of a Single Judge adopting the conditional approach that successive applications are permissible only where there is a material change. |
| Ganesh Sukhanda Mhastke Vs. State of Maharashtra, 2005 B.C.I. 55 (N.B.) : 2006 All.M.R.(Cri.) 450 | A Single Judge (Shri Joshi, J.) refused to permit the applicant to withdraw a bail application when the advocate sought withdrawal after the Court indicated it was not convinced; the permission to withdraw was refused and it was observed the applicant could apply on new grounds. | The Court cited this decision to illustrate that withdrawal should not be used to avoid an adverse view and that an applicant remains entitled to apply again on new grounds (i.e., change of facts or law). |
| Munna Singh Tomar Vs. State of M.P., 1990 Cri.L.J. 49 (M.P.) | The Madhya Pradesh High Court, explaining Shahzad Hasan Khan (Supreme Court), ruled that subsequent bail applications should be placed before the same Judge who rejected the earlier bail application, so long as that Judge is available, to prevent forum-shopping and conflicting decisions. | The Court relied on this decision for the proposition that successive applications should be handled so as to avoid forum-shopping and inconsistent orders; it treated the decision as supporting the restriction on successive applications absent change. |
| Shahzad Hasan Khan Vs. Ishtiaq Ishtiaq, A.I.R. 1987 S.C. 1613 : 1987(2) S.C.C. 684 | An Apex Court decision that was explained by the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Munna Singh Tomar; used as part of the foundational authorities addressing successive bail applications and related practice. | The Court referred to Shahzad Hasan Khan indirectly (through Munna Singh Tomar) as part of the jurisprudential background on how successive applications should be handled to avoid forum-shopping. |
| State of Maharashtra Vs. Captain Buddhikant Subba Rao, A.I.R. 1989 S.C. 2292 : 1989 (Supp. 2) S.C.C. 605 | The Apex Court unequivocally ruled that successive bail applications, in the absence of change of circumstances after rejection of an earlier bail application, are not maintainable; a subsequently granted bail order in that case was held to be bad and illegal. | The Court treated this Apex Court ruling as authoritative and relied upon its unequivocal pronouncement to support the conclusion that successive applications without change should not be encouraged and are not maintainable. |
| Baikunthanath Dalia Vs. Digambar Jena, 1991 Cri.L.J. 203 (Ori.) | The decision held that where a Court entertained and allowed successive applications for bail without indicating any material change in circumstances, and passed apparently contradictory orders within a short time, bail so granted could be cancelled under section 439(2); it supports the proposition that fresh bail applications are not open absent change in facts. | The Court cited this case to show that granting bail on successive applications without changed circumstances can lead to cancellation and that such practice is impermissible. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by acknowledging the rival submissions and then proceeded to review the authorities cited by both sides. The Court's analytical steps, as recorded in the opinion, are:
- The Court first referred to the Apex Court's decision in Kalyan Ranjan Chandra Sarakar and quoted the passage which disapproved the argument that Article 21 permits an aggrieved person to repeatedly make bail applications on grounds previously rejected by the Court (including the Apex Court).
- The Court reviewed decisions of Single Judges of the Bombay High Court (Kailash Dhirajlal Gandhi and Laxman Irappa Hatti) which accepted that successive bail applications can be entertained, but only subject to a change in fact situation and law — and observed that those decisions had relied on the limited area carved out by the Apex Court in Kalyan Chandra Sarakar.
- The Court considered the decision in Ganesh Sukhanda Mhastke where withdrawal of an application was not permitted after an advocate perceived the Court was not convinced; the judgment observed that an applicant would be entitled to apply afresh on new grounds.
- The Court discussed the reasoning in Munna Singh Tomar (explaining Shahzad Hasan Khan) that, where a bail application has been dismissed or withdrawn, a subsequent bail application should, if possible, be placed before the same Judge who dealt with the earlier application so as to prevent forum-shopping and inconsistent orders.
- The Court relied heavily on the Apex Court's clear ruling in State of Maharashtra Vs. Captain Buddhikant Subba Rao that successive bail applications without any change of circumstances after an earlier rejection are not maintainable; it noted that in that case a later bail order was held to be bad and illegal.
- The Court cited Baikunthanath Dalia to illustrate the practical consequence where successive bail applications without changed circumstances led to contradictory orders and consequent cancellation of bail under section 439(2).
- On the basis of these authorities, the Court concluded that the decisions relied upon by the applicant did not support the broad contention that successive bail applications are permissible without any material change in fact or law.
- The Court added a procedural prescription: every successive bail application must expressly refer to all earlier bail applications by the applicant and must attach copies of the orders refusing or allowing withdrawal of those applications; suppression of earlier applications or their outcomes may result in cancellation of bail and imposition of heavy costs.
Holding and Implications
Holding: All three applications are rejected.
Implications and consequences as recorded in the opinion:
- The Court reaffirmed the principle (as laid down by the Apex Court in Captain Buddhikant Subba Rao and supported by other authorities) that successive bail applications, in the absence of any material change in the facts or law, are not maintainable and should not be encouraged.
- The opinion prescribes a procedural requirement for successive applications: applicants must disclose prior bail applications and attach copies of the orders refusing bail or allowing withdrawal. Failure to disclose such material facts may attract cancellation of bail and heavy costs.
- The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the three bail applications before the Court. The decision applies the existing authorities to the facts before the Court rather than purporting to create a new legal principle beyond those authorities.
Cases referred :
1. Kalyan Ranjan Chandra Sarakar Vs. Rajesh Ranjan, 2005(1) Bom.C.R.(Cri.) 683 : 2005 DGLS (soft) 1005 : 2005 Cri.L.J. 944 : 2005(2) S.C.C. 42 : A.I.R. 2005 S.C. 921.
2. Kailash Dhirajlal Gandhi Vs. State of Maharashtra, 2007 (Supp.) Bom.C.R. 75 (A.B.) : 2007(2) Mh.L.J. 850.
3. Laxman Irappa Hatti Vs. State of Maharashtra , 2004(2) Bom.C.R.(Cri.) 525 : 2004 All.M.R.(Cri.) 3073.
4. Ganesh Sukhanda Mhastke Vs. State of Maharashtra, 2005 B.C.I. 55 (N.B.) : 2006 All.M.R.(Cri.) 450.
5. Munna Singh Tomar Vs. State of M.P., 1990 Cri.L.J. 49 (M.P.).
6. Shahzad Hasan Khan Vs. Ishtiaq Ishtiaq, 1987 DGLS (soft) 456 : A.I.R. 1987 S.C. 1613 : 1987(2) S.C.C. 684.
7. State of Maharashtra Vs. Rao Captain Buddhikant Subba Rao, 1989 DGLS (soft) 471 : A.I.R. 1989 S.C. 2292 : 1989 (Supp. 2) S.C.C. 605.
8. Baikunthanath Dalia Vs. Digambar Jena, 1991 Cri.L.J. 203 (Ori.).
Advocates appeared :
S.C. Halli i/b. S.P. Hulyalkar, for applicant.
J.P. Yagnik, A.P.P., for State.
DAGA V.C., J.: - All these three applications, filed under section 439 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, though arise out of different crimes registered against different applicants, can be disposed of by this common order since issue involved is identical and submissions advanced were common.
2. It is not necessary to sketch factual matrix arising from each case except to mention that earlier bail applications moved in these three matters were allowed to be withdrawn unconditionally under different orders passed by different learned Single Judges of this Court.
The Issue :
3. The common question involved in all these applications is:-
Whether the successive bail application, without there being any material change in fact situation is maintainable?
The Submissions :
4. The learned Counsel appearing for the applicant strongly canvassed that in spite of withdrawals of earlier bail applications, successive bail applications are tenable even in absence of change in fact situation. He placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of (Kalyan Ranjan Chandra Sarakar Vs. Rajesh Ranjan)1, 2005(1) Bom.C.R.(Cri.) 683 : 2005 DGLS (soft) 1005 : 2005 Cri.L.J. 944 : 2005(2) S.C.C. 42 : A.I.R. 2005 S.C. 921. He also pressed into service some of the judgments of the learned Single Judges of this Court in support of his submission.
5. The above submission is strongly countered by the learned A.P.P., appearing for the State contending that it is open to the aggrieved party to make bail applications, subject to change in the fact situation, which may warrant fresh consideration. In his submission, it prevents abuse of process of Court in as much as impression is not created that the litigants are shunning or selecting a Court depending on whether the Court is to his liking or not. If successive bail applications on the same subject are permitted to be disposed of by different Judges, there would be conflicting orders and litigants would be pestering every Judge till he gets a favourable order. He submits that forum shopping has to be avoided in larger interest of justice and to maintain majesty of the courts.
Consideration :
6. Having heard rival views, having taken stock of the various judgments cited at the bar, first I propose to refer to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Kalyan Chandra Sarakar (supra) which, in ultimate analysis, holds as under :
Therefore we are not in agreement with the argument of the learned Counsel for the accused that in view of guaranty conferred on a person under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, it is open for the aggrieved person to make bail application even on the ground rejected by the Court earlier including the Apex Court of the country.
(Emphasis supplied)
The very same view has been taken by learned Single Judge of this Court (Shri Gavai, J.) in (Kailash s/o. Dhirajlal Gandhi Vs. State of Maharashtra)2, 2007 (Supp.) Bom.C.R. 75 (A.B.) : 2007(2) Mh.L.J. 850, while holding that the successive bail application can be entertained even after rejection of earlier application, subject to change in fact situation and the law. In support of his view learned Judge relied upon the limited area carved out by the Apex Court in the case of Kalyan Chandra Sarakar (supra) quoted above. The same view was taken by another Single Judge of this Court (Shri Bhosle, J.) in the case of (Laxman Irappa Hatti Vs. State of Maharashtra)3, 2004(2) Bom.C.R.(Cri.) 525 : 2004 All.M.R. (Cri.) 3073.
7. In case of (Ganesh Sukhanda Mhastke Vs. State of Maharashtra)4, 2005 B.C.I. 55 (N.B.) : 2006 All.M.R.(Cri.) 450, learned Single Judge (Shri Joshi, J.) has refused to permit the applicant to withdraw application for bail when the prayer for withdrawal was made by the Advocate noticing that the Court was not convinced in favour of granting application. The permission was refused observing that the applicant would be entitled in law to apply for bail on new grounds.
8. All the above judgments, referred to hereinabove, on which strong reliance is placed by the leaned Counsel for the applicant do not support the view canvassed by him.
9. In the case of (Munna Singh Tomar Vs. State of M.P)5, 1990 Cri.L.J. 49 (M.P.), explaining the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of (Shahzad Hasan Khan Vs. Ishtiaq)6, 1987 DGLS (soft) 456 : A.I.R. 1987 S.C. 1613 : 1987(2) S.C.C. 684, the Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled that even if the earlier bail application had been dismissed as withdrawn or not pressed, by any Single Judge of the High Court as a vacation Judge sitting during High Court vacation or otherwise to hear or dispose of the bail applications, either at the stage of motion hearing or otherwise, the subsequent bail application of the same applicant should be placed before the same Judge who had rejected the earlier bail application, so long he is available. The foundation of this view appears to be to prevent forum shopping, abuse of process of Court in as much as impression is not created that the litigant is shunning or selecting a Court depending on whether the Court is to his liking or not. If the successive bail applications on the same subject and prayer are permitted to be disposed of by different Judges, then there would be conflicting orders and the litigant would be pestering every Judge till he gets a favourable order. The same observation holds good even if the applications are allowed to be withdrawn on the prayer made by the applicant finding that the Court is not convinced in favour of granting application.
10. The Apex Court in (State of Maharashtra Vs. Captain Buddhikant Subba Rao)7, 1989 DGLS (soft) 471 : A.I.R. 1989 S.C. 2292 : 1989 (Supp. 2) S.C.C. 605, unequivocally, ruled that successive bail applications in absence of change of circumstances, after rejection of earlier bail application are not maintainable. In that particular case, the bail order on last application was held to be bad and illegal. Although, technically, there is no bar of res judicata, the successive bail applications should not be encouraged unless some change in fact situation is successfully made out.
11. In the case of (Baikunthanath Dalia Vs. Digambar Jena)8, 1991 Cri.L.J. 203 (Ori.), it is held that where the Court had entertained and allowed successive applications for bail without indicating any material change in circumstances, and had passed apparently contradictory orders within a fairly short span of time and had also tried to sift the material with a view to ascertain the merits of the prosecution case against the accused, bail granted to the accused could be cancelled under section 439(2). Thus, in the ultimate analysis, where the earlier application was rejected or withdrawn, it is not open for the applicant to apply for bail afresh unless there is change in fact situation or law warranting fresh consideration.
12. In order to implement above rule, if successive bail applications are made, the applicant should mention therein all earlier bail applications made by him and should attach copies of order or orders refusing to grant bail or allowing to withdraw the applications. In other words, in every successive bail application moved by the applicant, the applicant must refer to the earlier bail application and its fate. If, in subsequent bail application, the earlier bail application and its refusal or withdrawal is suppressed, it may entail the cancellation of bail on the suppression of material facts with heavy costs.
13. In the result, all these three applications are rejected.
Applications rejected.
-----
Alert