Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sayeeda Iqbal Vakil v. Javed Abdul Latif Shaikh

Bombay High Court
Apr 17, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant filed an application seeking leave to file an appeal against the acquittal of respondent No. 1, who was charged under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The respondent was acquitted by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 12th Court, Bandra, Mumbai, by judgment dated 21.12.2006 in C.C No. 3189.SS/2005. The case involved a cheque for Rs. 65,000/-, which the complainant alleged was given as a repayment of a loan advanced to the accused for house repairs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the acquittal of respondent No. 1 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was justified based on the evidence presented.
  2. Whether leave to appeal should be granted against the acquittal order of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The complainant (PW2) alleged that she had advanced a loan to the accused for house repairs.
  • The cheque for Rs. 65,000/- was given as repayment of this loan.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The cheque was delivered to the complainant not directly by the accused but through PW1 Abdul Rauf Shaikh.
  • The accused did not sign the cheque in the presence of the complainant.
  • The account on which the cheque was drawn was a special account meant for monthly instalments to Sadguru Finance Company for a vehicle loan.
  • The cheque was allegedly in the custody of PW1 Abdul as part payment for a motorcycle, not as repayment of a loan.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vasudev Ramchand Ahuja v. Vilas Shripati Kamble, 2006 (2) Bom C.R (Cri) 1 Importance of documentary evidence and reflection of loan amounts in income tax returns for substantiating loan claims in cheque bounce cases. The court relied on this precedent to note that absence of loan reflection in income tax returns and lack of documentary evidence weakened the complainant's case, supporting the acquittal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the evidence produced by the complainant and the impugned judgment. It noted significant deficiencies in the complainant’s case, including inability to specify the date or month when the loan was advanced, absence of any receipt for the loan, and the fact that the loan amount was not reflected in the complainant’s income tax returns despite her status as an income-tax assessee. These factors indicated a lack of documentary evidence to prove the loan's existence.

Furthermore, the court highlighted that the cheque was not handed over directly by the accused but through another person (PW1 Abdul Rauf Shaikh), and the accused did not sign the cheque in the presence of the complainant. The accused’s account was a special account dedicated to vehicle loan repayments, with no other transactions, further casting doubt on the complainant’s claim.

The court referenced the precedent of Vasudev Ramchand Ahuja to emphasize the necessity of corroborative documentary evidence in such cases. Considering these facts and the overall evidence, the court found the learned Metropolitan Magistrate’s acquittal to be a reasonable and possible view, thus not warranting interference.

Holding and Implications

The application for leave to appeal against the acquittal was rejected and dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the acquittal of respondent No. 1. No new precedent was established, and the ruling reinforces the principle that absence of adequate documentary evidence and inconsistencies in the complainant's case can justify acquittal under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Show all summary ...

V.K Tahilramani, J.:— The applicant has preferred this application for leave to file appeal against the acquittal of the respondent No. 1 accused.

2. By judgment and order dated 21.12.2006 passed in C.C No. 3189.SS/2005, the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 12th Court, Bandra, Mumbai has acquitted the respondent No. 1 accused of the offence under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

3. I have heard the learned Advocate for the applicant-complainant. I have perused the evidence which has been produced by him as well as the impugned judgment and order.

4. The cheque in question is for an amount of Rs. 65,000/-. The case of the complainant PW2 Ms. Sayyada is that she had advanced loan to the accused No. 1 for repairs of his house. However, in the cross-examination of this witness, it has been brought on record that she could not state the date or month on which she claims to have advanced the loan to the accused. She has also stated that while advancing loan amount, she has not obtained any receipt from the accused. Though the complaint is an income-tax assessee, she has admitted that the amounts which she had advanced by way of loan to the accused is not reflected in the income tax returns. Thus, it is seen that there is absence of documentary evidence to substantiate the factum of advance of loan. Useful reference may be made to the decision of this Court in the case of Vasudev Ramchand Ahuja v. Vilas Shripati Kamble, 2006 (2) Bom C.R (Cri.) 1, wherein it is observed as under:

“The observation seen by the Trial Court that amount allegedly paid by complainant during period has not been reflected in income tax returns as well as in books of account. Reasons recorded by the Court below on appreciation of evidence on record, impugned judgment cannot be said to be unreasonable and perverse.”

5. Moreover, it is seen that the complainant has stated that the cheque was delivered to her not by accused but by PW1 Abdul Rauf Shaikh. She has categorically admitted that accused had not put signature on the cheque in her presence. The extract of the account clearly indicates that there was no other transaction in the said account except payments to Sadguru Finance Company. There is no evidence on record to indicate that as to in what circumstances, the accused had delivered the cheque to PW1 Abdul who in turn handed over to the complainant. This aspect has not been brought out in the evidence of either PW1 Abdul nor in the evidence of complainant. On the other hand, the case of the accused is that the cheque was in the custody of PW1 Abdul by way of part payment for motorcycle. The account of the accused on which the cheque came to be drawn, shows that the account was for a special purpose i.e for payment of monthly instalments to Sadguru Finance Company in respect of loan for vehicle. It was special account and cheque book was issued in respect of the said special account. The learned Magistrate has acquitted the respondent No. 1 accused on the basis of above facts and the other facts which have been brought out in the evidence. Looking to the evidence on record, I am of the opinion that the view taken by the learned Magistrate is a reasonable and possible view, hence, no interference is called for.

6. In this view of the matter, application for leave to appeal is rejected.

7. Application dismissed.