- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
L.V.Jadhav v. State Of Maharashtra & Anr.
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition arises from the dismissal in default of Criminal Appeal No.700 of 1988 by the learned Sessions Judge, Pune, dated 19-9-1990. The appellant had filed this appeal against his conviction under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code by the Judicial Magistrate, F.C. Court No.4, Pune, wherein he was sentenced to two months' simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs.100, with an alternative imprisonment of two months in default of payment of the fine.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the learned Sessions Judge was justified in dismissing the criminal appeal in default of prosecution by the appellant or his counsel.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The dismissal of the appeal in default was improper as the appeal ought to have been disposed of on merits after perusal of the record.
Respondent's Arguments
- This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1978 SC 1500 | Permissibility of dismissal of criminal appeal for non-prosecution but not on merits without hearing the accused or counsel. | The court noted this precedent but observed it had been overruled by a later Supreme Court judgment. |
| 1996 SCC (CRI) 848 | Overruled the earlier view permitting dismissal for non-prosecution; held that appeals must be disposed of on merits after perusal of the record and hearing the accused or counsel. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that dismissal in default was erroneous and the appeal must be decided on merits. |
| 1971 - 1 SCC 855 (equal to AIR 1970 - 1977 Cri. 253 equal AIR 1606) | Confirmed the principle that appeals must be disposed on merits and not dismissed merely for non-prosecution. | Supported the 1996 judgment and was cited to reinforce the obligation to dispose appeals on merits. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the legal position based on the Supreme Court's recent authoritative judgment reported in 1996 SCC (CRI) 848, which overruled the earlier view in AIR 1978 SC 1500. The court emphasized that Sections 385 and 386 of the Code of Criminal Procedure mandate that an appellate court must dispose of appeals on merits after examining the record and hearing the accused or his counsel. The law does not allow dismissal of appeals merely for non-prosecution or default. The court found that the learned Sessions Judge erred in dismissing the appeal in default without disposing it on merits. Consequently, the order of dismissal was set aside and the appeal was remanded for decision according to law.
Holding and Implications
The petition is allowed and the order dismissing the appeal in default is set aside.
The appeal is remanded to the Sessions Court, Pune, for hearing and disposal on merits in accordance with the law. The Sessions Judge is directed to hear the appeal expeditiously given its age. No order as to costs was made. The decision directly affects the parties by restoring the appellant's right to have the appeal decided on merits, but does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming existing Supreme Court authority.
Cases referred :
AIR 1978 SC 1500 [ 3 ]
1996 SCC (CRI) 848 [ 3 ]
Advocates appeared :
Shri ANIL V. ANTURKAR for Petitioner.
Shri A. P. MUNDARGI for Respondent no.2.
:- This is a petition against the order dismissing Criminal Appeal No.700 of 1988 in default by the learned Sessions Judge, Pune by order dated 19-9-1990 . The Petitioner has filed the said appeal against the order of conviction passed against him in C.C.No.1604 of 1986 by the Judicial Magistrate, F.C. Court No.4, Pune thereby convicting him of offence punishable under Section 500 of IPC and sentencing him to simple imprisonment of two months, and to pay a fine of Rs.100/-, in default to undergo simple imprisonment for two months.
2. As the appeal was dismissed in default the only question that is required to be decided is whether the learned Sessions Judge could have dismissed the criminal appeal in default. I have heard the arguments of the learned Counsel for the Appellant Shri A. V. Anturkar and learned Counsel for the Respondent Shri A. P. Mundargi.
3. Previously the Supreme Court had taken a view in the judgment reported in AIR 1978 SC PAGE 1500 in Criminal Appeal dismissal for non prosecution is permissible but it cannot be disposed of on merits against the accused unless the accused and/or his Counsel are heard. However, in the recent judgment the Supreme Court has overruled the said judgment. The judgment of the Supreme Court is reported in 1996 SC Cases (CRI) 848 wherein after overruling the aforementioned judgment of the Supreme Court and confirming the judgment reported in 1971 - 1 SCC 855 equal to AIR 1970 - 1977 Cri. 253 equal AIR 1606 (Sic -ed) the Supreme Court has observed in para 14 at page 854 as under :-
14. We have carefully considered the view expressed in the said two decisions of this Court and, we may state that the view taken in Shyam Deos case appears to be sound except for a minor clarification which we consider necessary to mention. The plain language of Section 385 makes it clear that if the appellate court does not consider the appeal fit for summary dismissal, it must call for the record and Section 386 mandates that after the record is received, the appellate court may dispose of the appeal after hearing the accused or his counsel. Therefore, the plain language of Sections 385-386 does not contemplate dismissal of the appeal for non prosecution simliciter. On the contrary, the Code envisages disposal of the appeal on merits after perusal and scrutiny of the record. The law clearly expects the appellate court to dispose of the appeal on merits, not merely by perusing the reasoning of the trial court in the judgment, but by cross checking the reasoning with the evidence on record with a view to satisfying itself that the reasoning and findings recorded by the trial Court are consistent with the material on record. The law, therefore, does not envisage the dismissal of the appeal for default or non prosecution but only contemplates disposal on merits after perusal of the record. Therefore, with respect, we find it difficult to agree with the suggestion in Ram Naresh Yadavs case that if the appellant or his pleader is not present, the proper course would be to dismiss in appeal for non prosecution.
In view of this legal position, the learned Sessions Judge was clearly in error in dismissing the appeal in default and should have disposed it of on merits.
The Petition therefore succeeds and is allowed.
The order of dismissal in default passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge in Criminal Appeal No.700 of 1988 on 19-9-1990 is hereby set aside and the appeal is remanded to the Sessions Court, Pune for decision in accordance with law. Since the appeal is of 1988 the learned Additional Sessions Judge shall hear it as expeditiously as possible and dispose of in accordance with law. No order as to costs.
Order accordingly.
Alert