- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suresh Ambadasrao Warpurkar v. State Of Maharashtra
Factual and Procedural Background
These writ petitions challenge the appointment of an Administrator over the Parbhani District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. (a specified co-operative society governed by the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960). The Board of Directors had its term from 1 August 1989 until 31 July 1994. The District Deputy Registrar called for the voters list on 23 June 1994. The Bank's manager replied (after a Government stay on elections) that sending the voters list was unnecessary. The Deputy Registrar took no further action for about six months and again requested the voters list on 20 February 1995. The Bank published a notification on 23 March 1995; the Registrar reminded the Bank on 29 March 1995 to submit the voters list by 4 April 1995. On 4 April 1995 the District Deputy Registrar, without waiting for the whole day, appointed himself Administrator under section 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and assumed charge at about 15:30 hours. Petitioners allege the voters list was delivered later that day at 18:00 and challenged the appointment in several writ petitions (Writ Petition Nos. 4011/1995, 1780/1995, 2194/1995 and 1734/1995). The petitioners seek setting aside of the Administrator's appointment and a direction for early elections.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appointment of an Administrator under section 77A read with section 73G(2B) was valid in the factual circumstances of this case.
- Whether, under section 73G(2B), the outgoing committee continued in office because the Collector failed to hold elections, and if so, whether that precluded appointment of an Administrator.
- Whether the District Deputy Registrar complied with the procedural requirement (first proviso to sub‑section (f)(ii) of section 77A(1)) to publish a notice inviting objections/suggestions before appointing an Administrator, or whether the exemption (second proviso) applied—and if so, whether reasons for applying the exemption were recorded.
- Whether the appointment was the product of non-application of mind or mala fide conduct by the District Deputy Registrar and whether restoration of the committee should be ordered despite the Administrator having run the society for several months.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- An order under section 77A(1)(o) cannot be passed unless it is established that the committee has failed or has not co-operated in taking new elections and completing election procedures before the expiry of its term.
- Under section 73G(2B) (proviso), if the Collector fails to hold elections, the committee has a right to continue in office until the first meeting of the newly constituted committee; therefore the committee should not have been superseded.
- The appointment of the Administrator followed a change in the State Government after assembly elections in March 1995 and the petitioners — members of a rival political party — were superseded by a mala fide exercise of power.
- The Registrar failed to comply with the publication requirement in section 77A(1)(f)(ii) (first proviso) and did not record reasons for bypassing that procedure; the petitioners relied on the Court's prior decision in Ghatageppa Parreppa Mugeri v. M.R. Naik (1983 Mh.L.J. 984) to insist that the publication requirement is substantive and not an empty formality.
Respondent / State's Arguments
- The Government Pleader argued that the Administrator had taken charge on 4 April 1995 and had run the society for about nine months; therefore it would be undesirable to restore the old committee and at best the Court could direct early elections.
- It was contended there is no universal rule that, where appointment of an Administrator is set aside, the old committee must be restored before fresh elections; restoration depends on the circumstances of each case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ghatageppa Parreppa Mugeri v. M.R. Naik, 1983 Mh.L.J. 984 | Support for the proposition that the notice provision in the proviso to sub‑section (f)(ii) of section 77A(1) is substantive and serves two purposes: allowing objections to proposed committee members and allowing the outgoing committee to show cause regarding its efforts to ensure timely induction of the new committee. | The court accepted petitioners' reliance on this authority to criticise the District Deputy Registrar's failure to publish the required notice; it noted no affidavit or explanation was provided for omission of the notice. |
| Civil Application No.556 of 1995 (Supreme Court) — Terana Shetkari Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. | Illustrates that where the appointment of an Administrator replacing a Board of Directors was set aside, the Supreme Court directed restoration of the Board. | The court relied on this outcome to hold that mere lapse of about nine months since the Administrator took charge did not preclude restoring the old committee in the present case. |
| Writ Petition No.3367 of 1995 (this Court) — Nanded Sahakari Kapus Jinning and Pressing Factory Ltd. | Demonstrates that this Court has previously directed an Administrator to hand back charge to the Chairman and Board of Directors in similar circumstances. | The court cited this earlier order to support its conclusion that restoration was appropriate despite the Administrator having administered the society for several months. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeds from a textual and factual reading of section 73G(2B) and the powers under section 77A. It first quotes and explicates section 73G(2B): the provision is composite and twofold — the first part declares that members cease to hold office on expiry of their term; the proviso preserves the members' term where the Collector fails to hold elections, effectively extending the committee's term until the first meeting of the newly constituted committee.
The court emphasises that the reason for the failure to hold elections is decisive. If the Collector's failure stems from non-cooperation by the committee (for example, by withholding the voters list or not depositing election costs), the committee cannot claim continuation and appointment of an Administrator may be justified. Conversely, where failure arises from the Government's directions not to hold elections or because of deficiencies in the Collector's own machinery, the committee continues in office under the proviso.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court notes:
- The Bank's management wrote (on 9 August 1994) that it was unnecessary to send the voters list because of a Government stay. The court declined to justify the Bank's refusal to comply with the Registrar's direction — it was the Bank's duty to supply the list because a Government stay could be withdrawn at any time.
- Nevertheless, the District Deputy Registrar then remained inactive for over six months (until 20 February 1995), which suggests the Registrar himself treated the matter as not urgent; thus any initial default by the Bank was, in effect, condoned by the Registrar's inaction.
- On 29 March 1995 the Registrar directed the voters list to be submitted on 4 April 1995. That direction, the court reasons, implicitly kept the existing committee in office until the elections if the list was submitted on that date, thereby indicating acceptance of the committee's continuance pending compliance. Despite that, on 4 April 1995 the Registrar appointed himself Administrator at 15:30 without waiting until close of business or recording any material satisfaction that the committee had failed to make necessary arrangements.
- There was a failure to comply with the procedural requirement of publishing a notice inviting objections and suggestions under the first proviso to sub‑section (f)(ii) of section 77A(1). The second proviso (which exempts publication where the Registrar is satisfied that immediate action is required and publication is not reasonably practicable) was not invoked with any recorded reasons in the order. The affidavits filed by subordinate officers were silent about the subjective satisfaction of the District Deputy Registrar; the court explains such satisfaction should have been evidenced by an affidavit from the officer who passed the order.
- The court concluded that the Registrar's action demonstrated a total non‑application of mind; there was no material before him to justify the satisfaction required to appoint an Administrator under section 77A read with section 73G(2B).
The court declined to adjudicate allegations of political mala fides in detail because the persons alleged to be responsible were not before the court. The State's argument that restoration should not be ordered because the Administrator had run the society for about nine months was considered but rejected: the court found that unreasonable haste had been employed in removal of the committee and relied on higher and coordinate court decisions directing restoration in comparable circumstances.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The court set aside the appointment of the Administrator and directed restoration of the committee that was in office prior to 4 April 1995, subject to specified restrictions.
Direct effects and specific directions imposed by the court:
- The Administrator shall hand back charge to the committee which was in office before 4 April 1995.
- The reinstated committee is restricted from taking policy decisions, making appointments, dismissing any servant of the society, dealing with any property, entering into agreements relating to society property, and from disbursing any loans other than regularly disbursed crop loans.
- The Collector, Parbhani, is directed to hold elections of the Board of Directors within six months from the date of the order. The process of preparing the final voters list is to commence within two weeks. The State Government has liberty to seek extension of time if Parliamentary elections are announced in the meanwhile. The Collector has liberty to call for amendments to the list already supplied if he decides to change the qualifying date under the rules.
- The writ petitions were disposed of and the rule made absolute; no order as to costs.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel precedent; the court relied on established principles in section 73G(2B) and section 77A and on precedents directing restoration in comparable situations. The decision's broader consequence is the reaffirmation that appointment of an Administrator requires objective material and recorded satisfaction, and that procedural safeguards (such as publication of notice) cannot be ignored without explanation.
Cases referred :
1983 Mh.L.J. 984 [ 15 ]
Chapalgaonker, J.- Rule. Taken up for hearing forthwith by consent of the parties.
2. All these writ petitions raise common question of facts and law and, therefore, they are taken together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
3. The Parbhani District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Parbhani is a specified co-operative society governed by the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. The elections of the said society took place some time in the year 1989 and the first meeting of the Board of Directors was held on 1st August 1989. the terms of the Board of Directors expired on 31st July 1994. The District Deputy Registrar, Parbhani called for the voters list from the Bank on 23rd June 1994 but since in the meantime, the Government had stayed the elections of the Co-operative societies on 9th August 1994, the Manager of the Bank wrote to the District Deputy Registrar that in view of the stay to the elections, the sending of voters list is not necessary. It appears that the District Deputy Registrar did not take any action despite this letter for a period of about six months and on 20th February 1995, the District Deputy Registrar again sent a letter to the Bank calling for the voters list.
4. On 23rd March 1995, the Parbhani District Central Co-operative Bank published a Notification in the newspapers calling names of the delegates representing the valid societies for the ensuing elections of the Board of Directors. On 29th March 1995, the District Deputy Registrar again reminded for sending the voters list forthwith and gave a time limit upto 4th April 1995, directing the Bank that the voters list should be submitted on 4th April 1995.
5. On 4th April 1995, the District Deputy Registrar, without waiting for the whole day for receipt of the list of members, passed an order appointing an Administrator under section 77A of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and appointed himself as an Administrator and assumed charge at 15.30 hours on the same day.
6. It is the case of the petitioners that the voters list was submitted on that day at 6 p.m. The order of appointment of the Administrator has been challenged in Writ Petition Nos.4011/1995, 1780/1995 and 2194/1995 whereas in Writ Petition No.1734/1995, which was filed prior to the appointment of Administrator, it was sought that the appointment of Administrator, if any, should not take effect for a certain period to enable the petitioners to challenge that order. The petitioner prays for a further direction that the elections of the District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. Parbhani be directed to be held as early as possible.
7. Shri R.N.Dhorde, Shri S.C.Bora and Shri V.D.Salunke, counsels for the petitioners, urged following grounds in support of their submission that the order of appointment of the Administrator superseding the managing committee is illegal.
(i) That an order under section 77a(1-o) cannot be passed unless it is established that the committee has failed or has not co-operated for taking new elections and complete the procedure of election before expiry of its term;
(ii) If the Collector has failed to take new elections in time, the committee has a right to continue in office till the new elections take place, by virtue of the provisions of section 73g(2b) proviso;
(iii) Since new elections took place for Maharashtra Legislative Assembly in the month of March 95 and the new Government assumed the office, the petitioners, who are members of a rival political party, were superseded by malafide use of power.
8. Section 73G (2B) is quoted below for ready reference :-
Section 73G (2B) P -
Where for any reason whatsoever, the election of the members of the committee was held or could not be held before the expiry of the term or the extended term, as the case may be, of the existing committee, the members, including the officers of the committee shall cease to hold office on the expiry of its terms extended term as the case may be and they shall be deemed to have vacated their offices;
Provided that where the Collector fails to hold election to the committee of any such society, the term of office of the members of the committee of that society shall be deemed to have been extended till the date immediately preceding the date of the first meeting of the newly constituted committee.
The provision is to meet the exigencies of the new committee not coming in office before expiry of the term of old committee. This is a composite and two fold provision. By the first part, it provides that the members will vacate the office as soon as their term expires and the second part provides that if the Collector fails to hold the election, then the first part will not come in operation and the members will continue in office.
9. It is needless to say that cause of failure to hold the elections is the crux of the matter. If the Collector has failed to hold elections for the reason of non-cooperation or non-supply of required material like the list of members to be included in the voters list or the requisite costs for election to be deposited by the said society, then the members cannot get a right to continue in office till the new elections take place and an alternate arrangement like appointment of Administrator will have to follow. But when the failure of the Collector is because of the Governments directions not to hold the elections or because of the failure of the Collectors own machinery to hold the elections, then the committee will continue in office till the elections take place. The appointment of an Administrator under section 77a read with section 73g (2b) has nothing to do with the performance of the existing committee.
10. We are told that time and again, the State Government postponed the elections of the specified co-operative societies in Maharashtra for one reason or the other. It is not necessary to go into those reasons. But if the elections are postponed because of exercise of Governments powers under section 73G (2B), then the continuance of the committee for that reason will be a consequence not to be attributed to the members desire to continue in office. We have to examine whether the committee has failed to co-operate with the Collector by complying with its obligation under the Statute and the Rules made thereunder.
11. The term of the committee expired on 31st July 1994. Normally, at least before 5 to 6 months before expiry of this term, the District Deputy Registrar should have asked for the voters list. We are told that since the elections were stayed, the District Deputy Registrar did not ask for voters list and the first letter addressed to the Bank for this purpose was sent barely a month before expiry of the term. On 9th August 1994, the management of the Bank informed that now there is no necessity to send the voters list. We do not justify this action on the part of the management of the bank. It was their duty to comply with the directions of the District Deputy Registrar because the Government was competent to withdraw the stay to the elections of co-operative societies at any time and it was not within the powers of the Bank to withhold sending the voters list under the pretext that the State Government has stayed the elections. But it appears that even the District Deputy Registrar felt that there is no necessity of sending the voters list because he was keeping quiet till 20th February 1995 i.e. for a period of more than 6 1/2 months after receipt of the above referred letter of the management of the Bank.
12. On 20th February 1995, the District Deputy Registrar again directed the Bank to give the voters list. It appears that during this time, there was no stay to the elections of the co-operative societies by the State Government. On 29th March 1995, i.e. after one month and nine days, the District Deputy Registrar gave another reminder directing that the voters list should be submitted on 4th April 95. Barely seven days time was given to the Bank by this reminder. if the District Deputy Registrar had given a direction that the voters list should be submitted on 4th April 1995, it pre-supposes that the District Deputy Registrar was willing to allow the committee in office till the elections under the supervision of the Collector, if the voters list it submitted on 4-4-1995 meaning thereby that the previous defaults, if any, in this respect by the Bank were condoned by him. Strangely enough, without waiting till close of office hours on this day of 4th April 1995, the District Deputy Registrar, Parbhani passed an order appointing himself as an Administrator of the District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Parbhani and assumed charge at 15-30 hours, as per the affidavit filed by respondent before us.
13. These facts show that there was total non-application of mind. Even if we kept aside the allegations about malafides, the jurisdiction to appoint an Administrator under section 77a read with section 73g (2b) will commence only after the satisfaction of the registrar that the committee has failed to make necessary arrangement. We do not see that there was any material before the District Deputy Registrar to get this satisfaction in the instant case, since he himself had given the time till 4th April 1995 for the society to send voters list and did not wait for close of the day.
14. The another point was raised before us by the learned counsel Shri Dhorde that the provision for publishing notice on notice board at the head office of the society inviting objections and suggestions in respect of proposed order of appointment of Administrator, as contained in first Proviso below sub-section (f)(ii) of sec.77A(1) was given a go bye. It is not an empty formality and should have complied with by the District Deputy Registrar. Shri Dhorde contended that the second proviso exempting the publication of such notice is applicable only when the Registrar is satisfied that the immediate action is required and it is not reasonably practical to publish such notice. Shri Dhorde submits that the order does not show and record any reason for giving a go-bye to the provision of previous publication of notice inviting objections and suggestions and there was no emergency like misconduct of members of the committee or any other similar thing.
15. Shri Dhorde relied on the judgment of this Court in the case of Ghatageppa Parreppa Mugeri Vs. M.R.Naik reported in 1983 Mh.L.J. 984 . The provision for giving notice made by the above referred proviso has two purposes. If the committee of some members is to be appointed, then other members would be entitled to file their objections in respect of the proposed members of the committee and in all cases, the members of the present committee would be entitled to show cause against the proposed order by pointing out that they have done everything within their powers to see that the new committee enter into the office in time. The affidavits filed on behalf of the District Deputy Registrar in these matters are totally silent on this point. Nothing has been placed before us as to why the notice, as provided under section 77a(1)(f)(ii) proviso, was not published.
16. There are allegations about the political malafides, which we do not propose to consider in view of the absence of the persons concerned before us but the action of the District Deputy Registrar appears to be in total haste and not based on a proper satisfaction founded on sufficient material. There is one more aspect of which we want to take notice. Whenever the statutory powers are exercised by any statutory authority and are challenged before the Court for non-application of mind or for malafide, it is always necessary that the authority himself should file an affidavit to satisfy the Court about existence of the circumstances which are sine-qua-non for his subjective satisfaction. Here, in one of these cases, the affidavit is filed by the Office Superintendent in the office of the District Deputy Registrar and in another case, the affidavit is filed by the Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies, whereas the order came to be passed by the District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies. We fail to understand how these officers can testify about the subjective satisfaction which the District Deputy Registrar had before passing the impugned order.
17. Shri A.M.Kanade, learned Government Pleader, contended that the charge was taken by the Administrator on 4th April 1995 itself and for about nine months, the society is run by the Administrator. Therefore, it is not desirable to restore the committee in office and at best, early elections can be directed by this Court. There cannot be any rule of universal application to hold that in every case, wherein the appointment of Administrator is to be set aside, the old committee needs to be restored before the fresh elections take place. it would depend on circumstances of each case. In the case at hand, we find an unreasonable haste in removing the members of the committee and the Administrator was appointed without waiting for expiry of time, which was given for compliance of the order by the District Deputy Registrar. Therefore, we feel that this is a case in which the committee will have to be restored.
18. In Civil Application No.556 of 1995, while setting aside the appointment of Administrator replacing the Board of Directors of Terana Shetkari Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd., the Supreme Court was pleased to direct the restoration of the Board. Similar orders were passed by this Court in respect of Nanded Sahakari Kapus Jinning and Pressing Factory Ltd., in Writ Petition No.3367 of 1995 and the Administrator was directed to hand over the charge back to the Chairman and the Board of Directors. Therefore, merely because a time of nine months has elapsed f rom the Administrator taking the charge, we do not feel that the petitioners can be refused the relief for restoration of their membership of the committee.
19. Since we are directing the State Government to hold the elections at an early date, we feel that certain restrictions will have to be imposed on the present Board of Directors, which will continue in office because of our order.
20. The charge shall be handed over back by the Administrator to the committee which was there in office before 4th April 1995 but the committee will not take any policy decision, will not make any appointments, will not dismiss any servant serving with the society, will not deal with any property, will not enter into the agreements in respect of any property owned by the society and will not disburse any loan except the crop loans, which are regularly disbursed to members.
21. We direct the Collector, Parbhani to hold the elections of the Board of Directors of Parbhani District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Parbhani within a period of six months from today. The process of preparation of final list of voters should commence within a period of two weeks from today. Liberty to the State Government for extension of time in case the Parliamentary elections are announced in the meanwhile. Liberty to the Collector to call for amendment to the list already supplied in case he decides to change the qualifying date under the rules.
22. With these directions, writ petition disposed of. Rule made absolute. No order as to costs.
Rule made absolute.
Alert