- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shripati Pandurang K... v. Maharashtra Stats Co...
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Government of Maharashtra, under the Maharashtra Cotton (Procurement, Processing and Marketing) Act, 1971, had appointed the Maharashtra State Co-operative Marketing Federation (the Marketing Federation) as its agent. The Marketing Federation's jurisdiction covered various agricultural produce including cotton. In February 1984 the Government decided to separate the cotton levy operations from the Marketing Federation and to create a new society, the Maharashtra State Co-operative Cotton Growers Federation (the Cotton Growers Federation), to which cotton-related activities would be assigned.
To implement this division the Government issued directions by letters dated 8 September 1984 (taking effect 30 September 1984), 10 August 1984 and 9 November 1984, dealing variously with transfer of assets and liabilities, stock, loans and the positioning of staff. The directives included absorption, deputation or termination provisions for different categories of staff and an instruction that certain regular staff be placed at the disposal of the Cotton Growers Federation on an "As Is Where Is" basis as on 1 July 1984.
Letters were issued to many employees indicating placement in a specified pay scale (200-505) and fixing seniority after accounting for previous service. Approximately 2,077 employees were absorbed by the Cotton Growers Federation, but the present petitioners were not absorbed.
The petitioners filed complaints (U.L.P. Nos. 255 of 1984, 14 of 1985, 19 of 1985, 37 of 1985) before the Industrial Court at Kolhapur alleging unfair labour practice and claiming permanent status and absorption in the Cotton Growers Federation, relying on Award No. 213 of 1973 (which directed the Marketing Federation to make permanent workers with continuous service of 240 days). The Industrial Court Member held that the Cotton Growers Federation was a separate juristic person and the award binding on the Marketing Federation did not bind the Cotton Growers Federation; complaints were dismissed. Another batch of related petitions and revisions (including U.L.P. Nos. 141–146 of 1985 and U.L.P. Nos. 3–8 of 1986) were similarly decided on 30 January 1985 by the same Member. Those adverse decisions led to the present writ petitions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether employees who had rendered continuous service (allegedly exceeding 240 days and in many cases years of service) were entitled to be made permanent and absorbed into the Maharashtra State Co-operative Cotton Growers Federation in terms of Award No. 213 of 1973 and government directions.
- Whether the award that bound the Marketing Federation could be held to bind the newly created Cotton Growers Federation, given its separate juristic personality.
- Whether the Government circular (dated 18 January 1985) communicated to many erstwhile employees but not the petitioners created a legitimate expectation (or an equivalent enforceable right) that the petitioners should be processed for absorption with protection of seniority, pay and other benefits, and if so whether the petitioners were entitled to relief on that basis.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners alleged unfair labour practice: that respondents attempted to terminate their services despite long service (described in the opinion as up to about 12 years for some).
- They relied on Award No. 213 of 1973, which directed the Marketing Federation to make permanent workers with continuous service of 240 days; they asserted they had such continuous service and therefore should be made permanent and absorbed into the Cotton Growers Federation per government directives.
- The petitioners produced an ad hoc seniority list showing dates of birth, joining, designations and qualifications; many joined in 1972–1975, i.e., before the Cotton Growers Federation was established, and the list was signed by the deputy zonal manager and union officers.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Cotton Growers Federation contended (generally) that it was not in a position to know or did not possess records of the petitioners' antecedent service with the Marketing Federation and made general denials.
- In at least one instance (S.P. Khade), the Marketing Federation denied that the complainants had put in continuous service in permanent posts as ginning clerks for more than 240 days.
- The Industrial Court Member had held that the Cotton Growers Federation was a separate juristic person and, therefore, an award binding the Marketing Federation did not automatically bind the Cotton Growers Federation — an argument reflected in the previous adverse orders.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Regina v. Secretary of State for the Home Department Ex parte Asif Mahmood Khan [1984 — I W.L.R. 1337] | The effect of a government circular: a circular may create a reasonable expectation that decisions will be made on the basis of the criteria set out in the circular, and if a new policy is to be adopted those affected should be given a full opportunity to make representations. | The court invoked the Khan principle, stating "Likewise here," to support the view that the government circular dated 18 January 1985 created an expectation which required the petitioners to be processed and considered for absorption and benefits as per that circular, particularly given the absence of reasons for excluding them and the documentary evidence of prior service. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the sequence of government directions creating the Cotton Growers Federation and the subsequent staffing decisions: transfers of assets and liabilities were directed in September 1984, while staffing instructions were issued in August and November 1984. Many employees were absorbed (about 2,077), but the petitioners were excluded.
The petitioners relied on Award No. 213 of 1973 (which required permanence after continuous service of 240 days) and on the government's circular dated 18 January 1985, which assured seniority, pay, allowances and other benefits and stated that the addressee would be absorbed in the scale 200-505 from 1 February 1985 after proper fitment.
The court noted the factual record: the petitioners had submitted a seniority list showing joining dates (many in 1972–1975) and other particulars; most petitioners had joined before the Cotton Growers Federation was established. Respondents either made general denials or, in one instance, denied continuous service for the statutory threshold.
The court relied on the principle in Regina v. Khan to analyse the effect of the circular: a general circular may create a reasonable expectation that it will be followed or, if a departure is contemplated, that affected persons will be given an opportunity to make representations. Applying that approach and having regard to the documentary evidence produced by the petitioners and the lack of reasons for excluding them from the benefits of the circular, the court concluded that the petitioners should be processed on the basis that they had put in more than 240 days of service and entitled to the benefits indicated by the circular.
The court contrasted this reasoning with the earlier Industrial Court Member's conclusion that the two federations were separate juristic persons and that the award binding the Marketing Federation did not bind the Cotton Growers Federation. The present court did not accept that reasoning as a barrier to relief where the circular and the underlying facts supported the petitioners' claim to processing and benefits.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petitions were allowed and the rule was made absolute. Both respondents (the Marketing Federation and the Cotton Growers Federation) were directed to process the cases of the petitioners on the basis that they had put in more than 240 days of service and to grant them all benefits under the government circular dated 18 January 1985 (EST/P (DD) of 1984) addressed to the Cotton Growers Federation.
Implications and immediate effects:
- The respondents must process the petitioners' cases and grant the protections and benefits set out in the 18 January 1985 circular (including protection of seniority, pay, allowances and consideration of provident fund, gratuity, family pension and absorption in the specified pay scale after fitment), on the basis that the petitioners have rendered the requisite service (more than 240 days).
- The respondents were ordered to bear their own costs and to pay the petitioners' costs.
- Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court (sought by Sri Bhandari) was refused on the ground that no point of law requiring resolution by the Supreme Court arose in the matter.
- The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying the established principle (cited from Regina v. Khan) to the facts before the court; the decision's direct effect is to require the respondents to process and extend the benefits to the petitioners as directed.
This summary is restricted to the facts, arguments, authorities and conclusions expressly set out in the provided opinion text.
Pursuant to the provisions of the Maharashtra Cotton (Procurement, Processing and Marketing) Act, 1971, the Government of Maharashtra appointed the Maharashtra State Co-operative Marketing Federation, Ltd., (federation), a society, registered under the Co-operative Societies Act, as its agent. The jurisdiction of this federation extended to various agricultural produce including food-grains such as jawar, etc., and it was felt that the working of this federation is becoming unwieldy. In Maharashtra, only certain areas are mainly cotton growing like the Vidarbha area and some portions of Maharashtra, and hence Government decided to carve out the operation of the levy of cotton from the other activities of the federation and assign them to another society, viz., the Maharashtra State Co-operative Cotton Growers Federation, Ltd. This was done sometime in February 1984.
2. Delineating the area of operation from the activities of the main federation did involve certain questions of succession and division of labour. By its letter, dated 8 September 1984, Government of Maharashtra in its Agriculture and Co-operative Department, gave certain directions to take effect from 30 September 1984, to the federation which included transfer of assets and liabilities under the Cotton Growers Scheme, cash and bank balance at Bombay and mofussil areas in the scheme account as well as under the non-scheme account, balance under cash-credit accounts with the Maharashtra State Co-operative Bank and other banks as well as the other legal claims and insurance claims to be transferred to the Cotton Grovers Federation. It was also provided that the stock of cotton bales, cotton seed, lint, tarpauline and other movables as on 30 September 1984, should be transferred to the Cotton Growers Federation after preparing a detailed list. The Cotton Grawers Federation was also to take up the liability of loans from the Maharashtra State Co-operative Bank. This letter did not make any reference to the action to be taken as respects the employees whose services have been transferred to the federation. That was done at a later date. By letter, dated 9 November 1984, the State Government gave directions regarding the positioning of the staff. Such of the members of the staff that were recruited after 1 July 1972, for the cotton scheme were to be placed on deputation without payment of deputation allowance with the federation. The federation was expected to absorb the above categories as staff. On 10 August 1984, further directions were given and the staff was divided into two categories. The first category was in respect of the staff working under the Cotton Monopoly Scheme whose services were to be terminated with immediate effect and in any case, not later than 15 August 1984. As far as the “regular staff.” is concerned, it was decided that the staff working in the cotton department of the federation at Bombay and in the mofussil area should be placed at the disposal of the new organisation, i.e, the Cotton Growers Federation on “As Is Where Is” basis as on 1 July 1984. (As is where is rather an old way of describing men; it is used for machinery).
3. Pursuant to the orders of the Government, letters were issued to various employees in which the employee was told that he is being fixed in the scale of 200-505 and his seniority is to be fixed after taking into consideration his previous service. This scheme of absorption of the employees of the federation by the newly formed Cotton Growers Federation worked well and even according to the federation, some 2077 employees were absorbed in the new federation.
4. The present petitioners along with others were not so absorbed. They moved the Industrial Court at Kolhapur by filing complaints being U.L.P Nos. 255 of 1984, 14 of 1985, 19 of 1985 and 37 of 1985 in which they alleged that the Co-operative Marketing Federation as well as the Cotton Growers Federation being respondents 1 and 2 engaged in unfair labour practice inasmuch as they tried to terminate the complainants' services in spite of the fact that the complainants have put in a long 12 years' service. The complainants then referred to Award No. 213 of 1973 which had directed the Co-operative Marketing Federation to make permanent such of the workers who have put the continuous service of 240 days. All the complainants averred that they have put in such service, but in flagrant breach of the provisions of the award, the respondents treated them as temporary. The complainants prayed that they may be directed to be made permanent and absorbed in the service of the Cotton Growers Marketing Federation as per the directives of the State Government issued from time to time. The learned Member of the Industrial Court held that the Cotton Growers Federation is a separate creation of the Government of Maharashtra and being a new and separate establishment created for the purpose of implementation of the Cotton Monopoly Scheme, the two federations are separate juristic persons. The learned Member then proceeded to say that supply because the office premises, furniture, etc., are the same, it cannot be said that the Cotton Growers Federation is a part and parcel of Marketing Federation. In view of this finding, the learned Member held that the award between the employees and the management of the Marketing Federation does not become binding on the Cotton Growers Federation. In view of this finding, the learned Member dismissed the complaints as no act of unfair labour practice was made out. Another set of complaints being U.L.P Nos. 141, 142, 143, 144, 145 and 146 of 1985, was filed before the Labour Court, Sangli, for claiming interim relief on the basis that the complainants are premanent employees of the Cotton Growers Federation., Interim relief having been refused, revision applications being U.L.P Nos. 3 to 8 of 1986 were filed before the Member, Industrial Court, Kolhapur. Orders on this batch of revision applications as well as the complaints being U.L.P Nos. 255 of 1984, 14 of 1985, 19 of 1985 and 37 of 1985, were passed on one and the same day, viz., 30 January 1985, by the same Member Sri Kotnis. Obviously, the reasoning in both the orders is the same, viz., that the petitioners cannot claim as of right that they should be absorbed in the Cotton Growers Federation because these two federations are different. Similar orders have been passed in both these sets of petitions refusing relief to the petitioners giving rise to the present set of writ petitions.
5. The effect of the general circulars issued by the Government as a matter of policy came to be considered in the English case of Regina v. Secretary of State for the Home Department Ex parte Asif Mahmood Khan, [1984 — I W.L.R 1337]. Khan was a Pakistani by birth settled in England with his wife who did not have a child of their own. They wanted to adopt his brother's child living in Pakistan. Before applying for entry clearance for the child, Khan obtained a circular letter of the Home Office which stated that, although there was no provision in the Immigration Rules for bringing a child to the United Kingdom for adoption, the Home Secretary, in the exercise of his discretion, might exceptionally allow the child to be brought into the United Kingdom if the intention to adopt under the law of United Kingdom was genuine. Khan's application was rejected. But allowing his appeal, it was held that the circular letter creates, though not an estoppel, a reasonble, expectation in the minds of the recipients of the letter that decision should be made solely on the basis of the criteria therein or if a new policy was to be adopted, it was only after the applicant has been offered a
“full opportunity to make representation why, in his case, it should not be followed.”
Likewise here.
6. The circular, dated 18 January 1985, has been sent to all the erstwhile employees of the federation except the petitioners. The circular refers to the earlier services rendered by the addressee with the federation and assures him that his seniority, pay, allowances and other benefits would be protected, his provident fund, gratuity, family pension, etc., will also be considered and he will be absorbed in the scale of 200-505 with effect from 1 February 1985, after proper fitment in the scale in view of the services rendered. The petitioners have produced an ad hoc seniority list showing their respective dates of birth, dates of joining, designation, educational qualifications, etc. Most of the petitioners have joined in 1973, some in 1972 and others in 1975. That is to say, they have joined much before the Cotton Growers Federation was established. The seniority list has been signed by the Up-Vyavasthapak (Vibhagiya) (Deputy Zonal Manager), Faltan as well as officers of the union. In most of these petitions, the Cotton Growers Federation had made a general denial because they were not in the know of the things nor did they have any record with them of the services rendered by the petitioners with the parent body, Marketing Federation. In one matter of S.P Khade, U.L.P No. 14 of 1985, Marketing Federation has denied the contention of the complainants that
“they have put in continuous service in permanent post as ginning clerks for more than 240 days.”
It was nowhere the case of the complainants that they have put in services as permanent clerks and that is why they have approached the Labour Court and Industrial Court for implementation of the award on the basis of the circular. No reasons have been given as to why the petitioners have not been made permanent on the basis of the general circular, dated 18 January 1985, and the documentary evidence about seniority list produced by them shows that they have put in at least more than 10 years of service which obviously exceeds 240 days.
7. Hence, the petitions succeed. Rule made absolute. Both respondents 1 and 2 are directed to process the cases of the petitioners on the basis that they have put in more than 240 days of service and grant them all the benefits under the circular letter, dated 18 January 1985, bearing No. EST/P (DD) of 1984 addressed to the Maharashtra State Co-operative Cotton Growers Marketing Federation, Ltd., Gautam Building, Zakeria Bunder Road, Shiwri, Bombay 400015, by the Saha-Sanchalak (Shasan). Respondents to bear their own costs and to pay those of the petitioners. Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was prayed for by Sri Bhandari. The same is refused as there is no point of law requiring resolution by the Supreme Court is involved in the matter.
Alert