Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Philip Morris Belgium S.A v. Golden Tobacco Co. Ltd. .

Delhi High Court
Jun 3, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, Philip Morris Belgium S.A., brought a suit for permanent injunction and rendition of account of profits against the defendant, Golden Tobacco Company Limited. The plaintiff moved an application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking a temporary injunction until disposal of the suit to restrain the defendant from using the plaintiff's registered trade mark "VISA" or any deceptively similar mark in relation to the defendant's goods (cigarettes).

The plaintiff is the registered proprietor of trade mark No. 243469 "VISA" in Class 34 for "Tobacco manufactured and un-manufactured." The plaintiff alleges that although it uses the mark on cigarettes in many countries, it has not sold cigarettes in India for some years because of Government of India import restrictions.

The plaintiff learned, via an advertisement in the Times of India dated 27-10-1980, that a new brand of cigarettes called "VISA" had been introduced in India; enquiries thereafter indicated the defendant was the manufacturer/seller. The plaintiff's trade mark attorneys wrote to the defendant on 27-11-1980 and again on 17-3-1981 calling for cessation of the use. The defendant's solicitors replied on 25-3-1981 stating that the defendant had initiated rectification proceedings against the plaintiff's registration. The plaintiff filed an earlier suit (S. No. 158 of 1982) on 3-2-1982 which was withdrawn because it was filed in the plaintiff's former name (Weltab S.A.), with liberty to file afresh; permission was granted on 6-10-1983 and a fresh suit was filed subsequently in late October 1983 (the opinion records both 26-10-1983 and 27-10-1983 as filing dates in different paragraphs of the judgment).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant's use of the mark "VISA" on its cigarettes constitutes infringement of the plaintiff's registered trade mark.
  2. Whether the plaintiff's registration is vulnerable to removal or limitation under Section 46 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 for non-use, or whether non-use is excused by "special circumstances" (import restrictions).
  3. Whether the suit is barred by limitation having regard to the dates of alleged user and public notice.
  4. Whether, on the balance of convenience, a temporary injunction should be granted in favour of the plaintiff pending trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff is the registered proprietor of trade mark No. 243469 "VISA" in Class 34 (tobacco manufactured and un-manufactured).
  • The plaintiff's cigarettes bearing the mark "VISA" are used internationally; non-use in India is due to Government import restrictions and not abandonment.
  • The defendant has adopted the plaintiff's registered mark in toto for cigarettes sold in India, creating a clear case of infringement and deception of the public.
  • Prompt steps were taken once the plaintiff became aware: cease-and-desist letters of 27-11-1980 and 17-3-1981, legal advice from attorneys (including counsel in New York), and the filing of a suit in February 1982 (subsequently re-filed in October 1983 after procedural correction).

Defendant's Arguments

  • The registered mark covers "tobacco manufactured and un-manufactured" but not specifically "cigarettes," so using "VISA" on cigarettes does not infringe the registration.
  • The plaintiff's mark is liable to removal or limitation for non-use under Section 46 of the Trade Marks Act.
  • The suit is barred by limitation, because the defendant claimed user since 22-5-1980 and had made registration applications and journal publication which, it was contended, should have put the plaintiff to action within three years from the alleged date of user.
  • On the balance of convenience, the defendant argued that it had built a substantial business (crores of rupees) under the mark in India over the previous 3½ years, whereas the plaintiff had no present business in India (no factory and no cigarette sales since 3-8-1967), so injunction would cause disproportionate harm to the defendant.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Plaza Chemical Industries v. Kohinoor Chemical Co. Ltd., AIR 1973 Bom 191 Import restriction by the Government of India constitutes "special circumstances" under Section 46(3) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, excusing non-use of a registered trade mark. The court applied this principle to hold that the plaintiff's non-use of "VISA" in India was attributable to import restrictions and not to abandonment, so the defendant's contentions under Section 46 lacked substance.
Kedar Nath v. Monga Perfumery & Flour Mills, AIR 1974 Delhi 12 Temporary injunction must be granted when there is clear infringement of plaintiff's registered trade mark and the plaintiff's right to exclusive use is clear. The court relied on this authority to support granting an interim injunction where identity/infringement of the registered mark was established.
M/S Atlas Cycle Industries Ltd. v. Hind Cycles Limited, ILR (1973) 1 Delhi 393 (at p.405) In infringement actions, if the defendant's mark is identical with the plaintiff's registered mark, infringement is made out without further questions. The court applied this dictum to the facts: since the defendant's mark was identical to the plaintiff's registered "VISA," infringement followed.
Wearwell Cycle Co. (India) Ltd. v. Wearwell Industries & Another, Ludhiana (1969) 5 DLT 469 The balance of convenience is relevant only when parties are on comparable footing and rights are at least prima facie equal. The court held that this principle was inapplicable where the defendant had adopted the plaintiff's registered trade mark in toto; thus balance of convenience did not outweigh the case for injunction.
Synthetic Moulders Ltd. v. Semperit Aktiengesellschaft, 1980 Rajdhani LR 263 The nature/value of the article and the public's buying criteria (look/feel versus brand identity) affect whether deception is likely and influence balance of convenience analysis. The court distinguished that case (which concerned combs) on facts: cigarettes are not items where look/feel alone drives purchase; brand identity matters and deception was therefore more likely, so the synthetic moulders reasoning did not prevent injunction here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through discrete legal points, applying statutory law, dictionary meaning and relevant authorities to the facts before it:

  1. Identity and Infringement: The defendant admitted using the mark "VISA" on its cigarettes. The court noted the identity of the marks and—relying on Atlas Cycle—held that where the impugned mark is identical to the registered mark, infringement is established. The court rejected the defendant's technical distinction between "tobacco" (registration) and "cigarettes" (use) by reference to Webster's dictionary definition of "cigarette" as a tube of finely cut tobacco enclosed in paper; since tobacco is the constituent of a cigarette, the registration in Class 34 for tobacco covered cigarettes for the purpose of the infringement analysis.
  2. Non-use and Section 46: The defendant's contention that the plaintiff's registration should be removed or limited for non-use under Section 46 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act was considered. The court applied Section 46(3)'s exception for non-use caused by "special circumstances" and relied on Plaza Chemical (1973 Bom) to hold that Government import restrictions on cigarettes constitute such special circumstances. The court therefore found the plaintiff's non-use excused and the defendant's challenge under Section 46 to lack substance.
  3. Limitation: The court examined limitation contentions. The defendant claimed user since 22-5-1980 and journal publication dated 1-4-1982; however, the plaintiff's first knowledge of the infringing cigarettes was via the 27-10-1980 Times of India advertisement which did not name the manufacturer, and only later did enquiries reveal the defendant's role. Computing limitation from 27-10-1980, the suit filed in late October 1983 was within the three-year statutory period. The court also noted the plaintiff's prompt correspondence and earlier suit proceedings, which explained any perceived delay.
  4. Balance of Convenience: The defendant argued heavy commercial reliance on the mark in India versus the plaintiff's lack of present business there. The court considered authorities on balance of convenience. Relying on Wearwell and Kedar Nath, the court held that where there is clear infringement by adoption of the registered mark in toto, the question of balance of convenience loses significance because the plaintiff's exclusive right is clear. The court distinguished Synthetic Moulders (comb case) on the ground that combs are common articles where look/feel can drive purchases and the plaintiff was virtually unknown in India; by contrast, cigarettes involve consumption and brand identity matters to purchasers, making deception likely when the registered mark is appropriated.
  5. Cumulative Assessment: Taking the established identity of the marks, the excusing of non-use by import restrictions, the sufficiency of the plaintiff's prompt steps, and the inapplicability of balance of convenience to defeat a clear infringement of a registered mark, the court concluded there was a clear prima facie case and that interim relief was warranted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the plaintiff's application and granted a temporary injunction until disposal of the suit, restraining the defendant from using the plaintiff's registered trade mark "VISA" or any other trade mark deceptively similar thereto in relation to its cigarettes.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is an interim restraint on the defendant's use of "VISA" (or deceptively similar marks) on cigarettes pending the final trial.
  • The court treated the plaintiff's non-use in India as excused by Government import restrictions under Section 46(3) (as affirmed by Plaza Chemical), so the defendant's challenge to the registration on non-use grounds was rejected at this stage.
  • The court emphasised that the observations in the order are provisional and "shall not affect in any manner the trial and decision of the suit on merits." Thus the interim order does not decide the ultimate rights beyond granting interlocutory relief.
Application allowed.
Show all summary ...

In this suit for the grant of permanent injunction and rendition of account of profits the plaintiff Philip Morris Belgium S.A, 187-189 Chaussee de la Hulpe, 1170 Bruxelles-Boitsfort, Belgium has moved an application against the defendant Golden Tobacco Company Limited, Tobacco House, Swami Vevekananda Road, Ville Parle West, Bombay under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the grant of temporary injunction till the disposal of the suit whereby the defendant is sought to be restrained from using the plaintiffs registered trade mark “VISA” or any other trade mark deceptively similar thereto in relation to its goods. The plaintiff alleges itself to be the registered proprietor of the following trade mark :

Number Trade Mark Class Goods 243469 VISA 34 Tobacco manufactured and un-manufactured

The said trade mark is further alleged to be valid and subsisting. This trade mark is being used by the plaintiff in relation to cigarettes manufactured by it and sold in a large number of countries of the world but has not been able to sell in India any of its products under this trade mark since recent years because of import restrictions.

2. It is further alleged that it was in or about the month of November 1980 that the plaintiff learned from an advertisement appearing in the Times of India Delhi issue of 27th October, 1980 introducing a new brand of cigarettes under the trade mark “VISA” but this advertisement did not indicate the name of the manufacturer and on enquiries made by the plaintiff it was learnt that it was the defendant who had introduced VISA cigarettes which were being sold not only in Delhi but in many parts of the country by the defendant taking advantage of the ban on the import of cigarettes which prevented the plaintiff from selling its cigarettes in India. Thereupon, the plaintiff's trademark attorneys, Remfry and Son, New Delhi called upon the defendant vide letter dated 27-11-1980 to cease and desist from using the plaintiff's registered trade mark VISA in relation to goods not of the plaintiff's manufacture or any other mark which could be deceptively similar to the plaintiff's aforesaid trade mark. No reply having been received from the defendant the plaintiff's attorneys again wrote to the defendant on 17-3-81 drawing its attention to the earlier letter dated 27-11-1980 and warning of a resort to the law court if no reply was received. A letter dated 25-3-1981 was received by the plaintiff's attorneys from R.K Dewan and Co. on behalf of the defendant in which the plaintiff was informed that the defendant had already initiated rectification proceedings in respect of the plaintiff's aforesaid trade mark. The rectification proceedings are alleged to be only as a counter-blast to the plaintiff's aforesaid letter and in anticipation of the proceedings which had been threatened by the plaintiff. The plaintiff after taking legal advice through their aforesaid attorneys from reputed attorneys in New York (USA) filed a suit being S. No. 158 of 1982 on 3-2-1982 against the defendant in this Court. That suit having been inadvertently filed in the plaintiffs former name Weltab S.A, the same was withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh suit against the defendant in respect of the same subject matter and the necessary permission was granted by the Court on 6-10-1983 whereafter this suit was filed on 26th October, 1983.

3. The application was resisted by the defendant.

4. Admittedly the defendant-company is using the plaintiff's trade mark VISA on its cigarettes sold in India. There is, thus the identity of the trade-marks and the plaintiff being the registered proprietor of the trade mark VISA, there is a clear infringement of the same oft the part of the defendant.

5. It is contended by the learned counsel for the defendant that the registered trade mark ‘VISA’ of the plaintiff is only in respect of tobacco manufactured and unmanufactured and is not in respect of cigarettes and so the display of the same on the cigarettes of the defendant could not constitute infringement, but this contention does not appear to have any appreciable force in view of the dictionary meaning of the word “cigarette” given in Webster's Third New International Dictionary Volume I according to which cigarette is “a tube of finely cut tobacco enclosed in paper, designed for smoking.” So, the actual constituent of a cigarette is tobacco though enclosed in a paper and for that reason the contention of the learned counsel for the defendant does not appear to have any substance and the infringement of plaintiff's trade mark on the part of the defendant remains quite obvious.

6. Plaintiff-company is located in Belgium and its cigarettes under its aforesaid trade mark are sold in various countries throughout the world except in India wherein their import has been restricted for some years by the Govt. of India. The defendant has admittedly made an application for rectification of the plaintiff's trade mark ‘VISA’, which can be taken as an admission on the part of the defendant in regard to the existence of a prima facie case in favour of the plaintiff and the infringement thereof on the part of the defendant. But it is, however, contended that the plaintiff's trade mark is liable to be removed from the register of the Registrar of Trade Marks as also for imposition of limitations on ground of non-use thereof under Sec. 46 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958. But sub-sec.(3) of Sec. 46 provides an exception to the aforesaid general rule when the non-use is occasioned due to special circumstances in the trade and not to any intention to abandon or not to use the trade mark in relation to the goods to which the application relates. The non-use of the trade mark ‘VISA’, registered in India, on the part of the plaintiff, is not due to any intention on its part to abandon or not to use the trade mark in relation to the goods but it is due to the special circumstance which is the import restriction imposed by the Government of India on cigarettes for which the plaintiff cannot be blamed. Plaza Chemical Industries v. Kohinoor Chemical Co. Ltd., AIR 1973 Bom 191 has held that the import restriction by the Govt. constitutes ‘special circumstances’ within the meaning of Sec. 46(3), justifying non-use of the trade mark. So, the defendant's contention for the removal of the trade mark ‘VISA’ of the plaintiff from the register of the Registrar of Trade Marks or imposition or restriction thereon on ground of non-use does not appear to have any substance. Import and Export Policy for the year 1984-85, in its list of banned items, at item No. 104 pertaining to ‘miscellaneous items’ shows ban on “all consumer goods” howsoever described. Similar is the position for the import and export policy and in its list of banned items for the year 1983-84. All consumer goods necessarily include cigarettes.

7. The contention of the learned counsel for the defendant that the suit is barred by limitation, also does not appear to be borne out from the facts, as at present, on the records of this case.

8. Applications Nos. 358097 and 362162 both dated 24-5-1980 were made by the defendant for registration of the trade mark VISA claiming user thereof since 22nd May, 1980. 1-4-1982 is the date of journal in which these applications appeared when the plaintiff could acquire knowledge of the defendant's applications. The contention of the defendant's counsel that the date 22-5-1980 since when the defendant claimed user of this trade mark ought to have put the plaintiff to file the suit within the statutory period of limitation of three years from that date, cannot be accepted. The suit was filed on 27-10-1983. The plaintiff learned for the first time of the infringement of its trade mark, as stated in para 4 of the plaint, through an advertisement in the Delhi issue dated 27-10-1980 of the English daily ‘The Times of India’ but that advertisement did not indicate the name of the manufacturer and it was only after enquiries that it was found that VISA cigarettes had been introduced and were being sold by the defendant. The making of enquiries also must have taken some time and even otherwise computing the period of three years from 27-10-1980 the suit filed on 27-10-1983 is within limitation.

9. Even delay on the part of the plaintiff starting action against the defendant does not appear to be there inasmuch as it was on 27-11-1980 that the plaintiff's trade mark's attorneys Remfry and Son, New Delhi were instructed by the plaintiff to call upon the defendant to cease and desist from using the trade mark ‘VISA’ and accordingly the said attorneys wrote a letter dated 27-11-1980 drawing its attention to the plaintiff's registration and calling upon the defendant to cease and desist immediately from using plaintiff's registered trade mark or any other word deceptively similar to the same. When no reply was received by the plaintiff's attorneys they again wrote to the defendant another letter on 17-3-1981 drawing its attention to their earlier letter dated 27-11-1980 stating that if no reply thereto was received the plaintiff would be left with no alternative but to take the matter to the court of law. The plaintiffs attorneys then received a letter dated 25-3-1981 from R.K Dewan and Co. purporting to have been written on behalf of the defendant in which the plaintiff was informed that the defendant had already initiated rectification proceedings in respect of the plaintiff's aforesaid registered trade mark. The rectification proceedings on the part of the defendant appear to be a counter-blast to the plaintiff's aforesaid letters and in anticipation of the proceedings threatened by the plaintiff. The plaintiff then filed a suit on 3-2-1982 against the defendant being Suit No. 158/82 after taking legal opinion from a firm of attorneys located in New York (USA). But that suit, inadvertently mentioned the plaintiff's former name Weltab S.A and on plaintiff's counsel seeking, leave of the court to withdraw the said suit with liberty to file a fresh one in respect of that very subject-matter, was granted vide order dated 6-10-1983 whereafter the instant suit was filed on 27-10-1983. The aforesaid correspondence and legal actions taken by the plaintiff located in Belgium, through its attorneys in Delhi, and the consultations which the plaintiff had to have from trade mark attorneys in New York (USA), reasonably explain away the delay, if any, and rather are suggestive of promptitude on the part of the plaintiff.

10. Then the learned counsel for the defendant laid much emphasis on the question of balance of convenience urging that the business of cigarettes of the defendant in India had run into crores of rupees during the period of last3½ years under the trade mark ‘VISA’ whereas the plaintiff was not having any business of cigarettes in India since 3-8-1967, nor had established any factory for manufacture of cigarettes in India in spite of import restrictions and consequently balance of convenience was in favour of the defendant and not in favour of the plaintiff. In Kedar Nath…Plaintiff; v. Monga Perfumery & Flour Mills. Delhi-6…Defendant., AIR 1974 Delhi 12, it was held that temporary injunction must be granted when there is clear infringement of plaintiff's registered trade mark and its right to its exclusive use. As already pointed out above the plaintiff is the proprietor of the registered trade mark ‘VISA’ on account of its registration in India in its favour, and the defendant has been using that very trade mark without any justification whatsoever and has rather taken advantage of the import restrictions on cigarettes and has thus been deceiving the public in India by inducing belief in them that they are (sic) being sold the cigarettes of the manufacture of the plaintiff which is a company reputed for the same.

11. In M/S Atlas Cycle Industries Ltd.… v. Hind Cycles Limited…, ILR (1973) 1 Delhi 393 (at page 405) this Court has said :—

“In an action for an alleged infringement of a registered trade mark, it has first to be seen whether the impugned mark of the defendant is identical with the registered trade mark of the plaintiff. If the mark is found to be identical no further question arises and it has to be held that there was infringement.”

12. In Wearwell Cycle Co. (India) Limited…Petitioner v. Wearwell Industries & Another…S, Ludhiana(1969) 5 DLT 469 in a case of passing off dealing with the scope of grant of temporary injunction under Order 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure with reference to the balance of convenience, this Court had held that this question was relevant only when at least prima facie the two parties were on the same level and their rights were about equal. This obviously is not so in the case in hand when the defendant has adopted in toto the registered trade mark of the plaintiff which makes it a case of clear infringement casting away the consideration of any balance of convenience.

13. The learned counsel for the defendant relied upon Synthetic Moulders Ltd.… v. Semperit Aktiengesellschaft…, 1980 Rajdhani LR 263. The perusal of that authority shows that the import of the plaintiff-respondent's combs had been banned in India and the defendant-appellant had adopted the plaintiffs word ‘Matador’ for the combs manufactured by it. In the matter of temporary injunction this authority held that the nature of the article ‘combs’ was such that it was of common use by almost every person in this country and for such a common article of small value what one saw was the article itself and the feel of the article in combing the hair and it was only the look and the feel and not the name of the plaintiff's article ‘Matador’ which made the purchasers wished to buy it and the plaintiff was almost totally unknown in India and one would be surprised that a substantial number of persons in the country could be shown to go to the market to buy the combs made by the plaintiff. It was further held that if an article of special nature and of higher value made by a renowned manufacturer were concerned, then it could be possible to hold that the purchasers in buying the article made by the defendant would be misled into thinking that they were purchasing the article made by such a renowned maker. In view of the nature of that particular article ‘combs’ it was held that no such deception could be envisaged. On the balance of convenience it was observed in that very authority that the same was to be determined by relative amount of damage it was likely to result after the injunction was granted and the plaintiff ultimately failed. It was then observed that the damage which would be caused to the defendant could be total and on the contrary no damage would be caused to the plaintiff for the simple reason that from 1954 onwards the import of plaintiff's combs had been banned in India. The question of balance of convenience could arise in view of ‘the particular facts of that case’ in view of the particular nature of the article ‘combs’ involved therein about which the look and the feel and not the name of the plaintiff's article ‘Matador’ which made the purchasers wish to buy a comb. The cigarettes do not belong to such category of items and the look and the physical feel thereof alone were not the guiding factors for the purchasers to which to buy the cigarettes. The purchasers want first to consume the cigarettes and then to know the quality thereof and in this view of the matter and further for the reason that the defendant had adopted the plaintiff's trade mark in its entirety on its own cigarettes in India, there was a clear case of infringement in which, as already pointed out above on the authorities cited above already, the question of balance of convenience did not matter and the analogy of balance of convenience in the aforesaid authority cannot be attracted for deciding the matter in hand.

14. For the aforesaid reasons and there being a clear case of infringement of plaintiff's registered trade mark ‘VISA’ in India, on the part of the defendant, the plaintiff is allowed the grant of temporary injunction till the disposal of the suit restraining the defendant from using the plaintiff s registered trade mark ‘VISA’ or any other trade mark deceptively similar thereto in relation to its cigarettes. It is hardly necessary to emphasise that the observations made in this order shall not affect in any manner the trial and decision of the suit on merits.

Application allowed.