- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Onkar Bhika v. Vithal Onkar
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff purchased survey no. 1, plot no. 2 of the village Valwadi at an auction held in execution of his own mortgage decree against the minor defendant. The defendant's father had mortgaged the land to the plaintiff in 1921 and died in April 1929, leaving Zumkabai (the minor's grandmother), the minor's young mother Sonabai, and the minor son (the defendant).
The Record of Rights showed the minor as proprietor with Zumkabai as guardian. The minor's mother's brother, Badhu, applied to the District Court and was appointed the minor's guardian in December 1929 with Bhivasan as surety, but Zumkabai continued in possession of the property. In 1932 Zumkabai applied to cancel Badhu's appointment but was rejected, and she continued possession.
In 1935 the plaintiff filed Suit No. 259 of 1935 to recover the mortgage amount. Zumkabai was appointed guardian ad litem for the minor defendant and defended the suit; a decree was entered for the plaintiff. In execution (darkhast No. 759 of 1938), the plaintiff purchased the mortgaged land with the Court's permission on 23-6-1939; Zumkabai again acted as guardian ad litem in the execution proceedings.
On 17-7-1939 Badhu applied to have the Deputy Nazir appointed guardian in his place; the Deputy Nazir was appointed on 8-8-1939 and obstructed the plaintiff taking possession. The plaintiff filed the present suit to recover possession; the Deputy Nazir (representing the minor) contended that Zumkabai's appointment as guardian ad litem in contravention of O.32, R.4(2) CPC was illegal and vitiated the proceedings, so the auction-purchase conferred no title on the plaintiff.
The trial Court held the appointment of Zumkabai was an irregularity not causing prejudice and thus the auction sale was valid; the plaintiff was given a decree for possession and mesne profits. On appeal the Assistant Judge held the appointment was an illegality vitiating the proceedings and set aside the auction sale, dismissing the suit. The present matter is a second appeal by the plaintiff challenging that appellate decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the auction-sale (the plaintiff's acquisition of the mortgaged land in execution) is void by reason of the appointment of Zumkabai as the minor defendant's guardian ad litem in alleged contravention of Order 32, Rule 4(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent's (Deputy Nazir / minor's representative) Arguments
- The appointment of Zumkabai as the minor's guardian ad litem in Suit No. 259 of 1935 and darkhast No. 759 of 1938 contravened the mandatory provisions of O.32, R.4(2) CPC because a guardian had already been appointed by a competent authority (Badhu).
- Because of that contravention the appointment was illegal and all proceedings, including the decree and execution sale, were vitiated and therefore the plaintiff acquired no title by the auction-purchase.
Appellant's (Plaintiff) Position as Reflected in the Record
- The trial Court's view — reflected in the plaintiff's successful result there — was that the appointment of Zumkabai, though irregular in the factual circumstances, did not cause any prejudice to the minor, and hence the decree and subsequent auction-sale were valid and binding on the minor.
- The plaintiff relied on the absence of allegation or proof of any prejudice, Zumkabai's conduct in preserving the property and defending the suit for the minor's benefit, and authorities treating such contraventions as irregularities rather than fundamental illegality.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 36 I.A. 1682 (Privy Council) | Held that where a person (in that case a married woman) was absolutely disqualified by statute from acting as guardian, her appointment was an illegality vitiating proceedings. | The court distinguished this authority as dealing with an absolute disqualification (married woman under the 1882 Code), and therefore not analogous to the present case where Zumkabai was not absolutely disqualified from acting as guardian ad litem. |
| 43 Mad. 808 | Followed the Privy Council and held that appointment of a guardian ad litem in breach of O.32, R.4(2) was illegal and vitiated the decree and subsequent proceedings. | The court considered and rejected the analogy drawn in 43 Mad. 808, observing that the Privy Council's reasoning turned on absolute disqualification unlike the present facts; thus 43 Mad. 808 was not followed here. |
| 61 Cal. 10233 (Costello, J.) | Pointed out that O.32, R.4(1) lists the qualifications for a next friend/guardian for suit and that there is no inherent disqualification of persons other than the certificated guardian, provided they meet those qualifications. | The court relied on this view to show that Zumkabai was not inherently disqualified from acting and that the presence of a certificated guardian does not render every other appointment void ab initio. |
| 29 All. 2904 | Held that an appointment of a guardian ad litem in ignorance of an already appointed guardian by competent authority was a mere irregularity and did not vitiate proceedings. | The court invoked this ruling as authority for treating the appointment of Zumkabai (made in ignorance of Badhu's appointment in the Records) as an irregularity that did not invalidate the decree or sale in the absence of prejudice. |
| I.L.R. (1942) All. 5095 (Allsop, J.) | Observed that proceedings should not be declared void where the plaintiff had no knowledge of the certificated guardian and the person before the Court was able and willing to represent the minor adequately. | The court quoted Allsop, J. to support the view that it would be unfair to void proceedings where the minor was effectively represented and no prejudice was shown. |
| A.I.R. 1918 Pat. 5206 | Expressed the view that appointment of a guardian of a minor for purposes of suits is essentially a procedural matter. | The court used this principle to justify treating the contested appointment as a procedural irregularity rather than an illegality automatically vitiating the proceedings. |
| 7 C.L.J. 2707 (Woodroffe, J.) | Noted that passing over a certificated guardian was not more than an irregularity and would not of itself vitiate either the decree or a sale consequent upon it. | The court relied on this reasoning to reinforce its conclusion that, absent prejudice, the proceedings and the auction sale should stand. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the narrow question as whether the auction-sale was void because Zumkabai had been appointed guardian ad litem in alleged breach of O.32, R.4(2) CPC. It then examined the competing lines of authority and the language of the Code.
First, the court distinguished the Privy Council authority (36 I.A. 1682) and the Madras decision in 43 Mad. 808 on the ground that those cases involved an absolute statutory disqualification (a married woman under the 1882 Code) from acting as guardian, whereas Order 32, Rule 4(1) and (2) CPC do not create an absolute disqualification of persons other than a certificated guardian. Instead, Order 32, Rule 4(1) sets out qualifications (sound mind, majority, no adverse interest, and not being a party) and does not, by itself, render other qualified persons incapable of acting as next friend or guardian for the suit.
The court noted that Zumkabai met the relevant qualifications in O.32, R.4(1), that she was the grandmother and had no adverse interest, that she took steps to preserve the property for the minor's benefit and defended the suit and execution for the minor's benefit. Crucially, the court observed that there was no allegation or proof of prejudice to the minor arising from her appointment.
The court relied on decisions (including 29 All. 2904, I.L.R. (1942) All. 5095, A.I.R. 1918 Pat. 5206 and 7 C.L.J. 2707) treating the passing over of a certificated guardian or appointment in ignorance of such a guardian as a procedural irregularity which, in the absence of fraud or prejudice, does not vitiate the decree or a subsequent sale in execution. The court emphasized that the distinction between absolute disqualification (which makes representation non-existent) and discretionary appointment (where the Court could have appointed someone else but did not) must guide the result.
Concluding its legal analysis, the court held that, on the facts of this case (no fraud or prejudice shown, Zumkabai qualified and acting for the minor's benefit), the appointment was at most an irregularity that did not render the decree or sale void. Therefore the auction-sale was valid and the lower appellate court's finding of voidness could not stand.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The appeal is allowed. The court set aside the decree of the lower appellate Court and restored the decree of the trial Court. The respondent shall pay the costs of the appellant in this Court and in the lower appellate Court.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the trial Court's decree (which had upheld the auction-sale and granted possession and mesne profits to the plaintiff) is restored.
- The court treated the appointment of Zumkabai as a procedural irregularity rather than an illegality automatically vitiating proceedings, on the basis that Zumkabai was not absolutely disqualified and there was no shown prejudice to the minor.
- The opinion resolves the case before it in favour of upholding the auction-sale; the opinion applies prior authorities favouring the irregularity view rather than the line of decisions (e.g., 43 Mad. 808) that deem such appointments void where they breach O.32, R.4(2). The judgment does not purport to set aside or fully reconcile all conflicting High Court decisions beyond the present case facts; its consequence is the reinstatement of the trial Court's order and the award of costs to the appellant.
This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those expressly stated therein.
1. This appeal arises out of a suit to recover possession of survey no. 1, plot No. 2, of the village Valwadi, purchased by the plaintiff at an auction held in execution of his own mortgage decree against the minor defendant. The defendant's father mortgaged the land to the plaintiff in 1921 and died in April 1929, leaving Behind his old mother Zumkabai, his young wife Sonabai, aged about 17 or 18, and a minor eon, the defendant. The land Vas then transferred in the Record of Eights to the name of the minor defendant, represented by his grand mother Zumkabai as his guardian. His mother's brother Badhu made an application to the District Court that Zumkabai was too old to manage the property, and he was appointed as the defendant's guardian in December 1929. One Bhivasan stood surety for him and the guardian certificate was duly granted to him, but Zumkabai continued in possession of the defendant's property, as Badhu lived at Pasthe, 45 miles away from Valwadi. In 1932 Zumkabai applied to the District Court to cancel the appointment of Badhu as the defendant's guardian as he was a man of vices, and lived far away from Valwadi where the minor's property was situated, but her application was rejected. Yet she continued in possession as before. In 1935 the plaintiff filed Suit No. 259 of 1935 against the minor defendant to recover his mortgage amount. In that suit Zumkabai was appointed the defendant's guardian ad litem and she defended the suit on behalf of the minor defendant. The suit ended in a decree for the plaintiff, and in execution of that decree in darkhast No. 759 of 1938, the plaintiff himself purchased the mortgaged land with the permission of the Court on 23-6-1939. In the execution proceedings also Zumkabai acted as the defendant's guardian ad litem. About a month later, on 17-7-1939, Badhu applied to the District Judge that as he had not been able to get possession of the minor's property, the Deputy Nazir of the District Court should be appointed as the minor's guardian in his place. Accordingly the Deputy Nazir's appointment was made on 8-8-1939. He obstructed the plaintiff when he proceeded to take possession of the land which he had purchased at the auction. Hence the plaintiff filed the present suit and the Deputy Nazir contended on behalf of the minor defendant that the appointment of Zumkabai as the defendant's guardian ad litem in the plaintiff's suit No. 259 of 1935 and darkhast No. 759 of 1938 in contravention of the mandatory provisions of O. 32, R. 4(2) of the CPC, was illegal, and all those proceedings being thus vitiated, the plaintiff acquired no title to the land in suit by his auction-purchase. The trial Court held that the appointment of Zumkabai as the defendant's guardian ad litem, when Badhu was his appointed guardian, was only an irregularity, and as it had caused no prejudice to the defendant, the auction sale was valid and binding on the defendant. The plaintiff was, therefore, given a decree for possession and mesne profits. But in appeal the learned Assistant Judge took a different view. He held that it was not a mere irregularity, but an illegality which vitiated the proceedings and that the auction sale was void. He, therefore, allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit with costs.
2. In this second appeal by the plaintiff, the short question for decision is whether the auction-sale is void by reason of the appointment of Zumkabai as the defendant's guardian ad litem in violation of the provisions of O. 32, R. 4(2) of the CPC That sub-rule says:
“Where a minor has a guardian appointed or declared by competent authority, no person other than such’ guardian shall act as the next friend of the minor or be appointed his guardian for the suit unless the Court considers for reasons to be recorded, that it is for the minor's welfare that another person be permitted to act or be appointed, as the case may be.”
3. There is a sharp conflict of judicial opinion regarding the effect of disregarding the provisions of this sub-rule. According to the High Courts of Allahabad, Calcutta and Patna, the violation of this provision is only an irregularity, and does not, by itself, vitiate the decree, in the absence of any proof of prejudice to the minor. The High Court of Madras has, on the other hand, held that in such a case the appointment is illegal and the decree obtained against the minor and all subsequent proceedings in execution of that decree are void. The trial Court adopted the former view while the learned Assistant Judge preferred the latter.
4. In 43 Mad. 8081, on which the learned Assistant Judge relied, both Sadasiva Ayyar and Spencer, JJ. purported to follow the decision of the Privy Council in 36 I.A 1682. In the latter case the guardian ad litem was a married woman, and at that time there was a definite provision in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1882, that no married woman could act as the guardian of a minor in the course of proceedings in a Court of law. A married woman, being absolutely disqualified, her appointment was held to be an illegality vitiating the whole proceedings. Referring to this case, and the provisions of O. 32, R. 4(2) of the CPC, 1908, Sadasiva Ayyar, J. observed in 43 Mad. 808 (p. 809):
“The Legislature clearly made this provision, because. It was strongly of opinion that it was not for the minor's welfare that anybody else except such certificated guardian, where one exists should act for a minor defendant. Where there is such a clear prohibition by the Legislature, the Court's - ignorance of the existence of a certificated guardian cannot be taken into consideration in deciding the question whether there has been a proper representation of a minor in the suit, any more than the ignorance of a Court under the old provision that a woman appointed by it as a guardian was a married woman could affect the decision of the question whether the minor was properly represented by such a woman.”
5. With all respect, I think that there is no analogy between the two cases. Order 32, R. 4(1), sets forth the qualifications of a person who can act as next friend of a minor or his guardian for the suit. It says:
“Any person who is of sound mind and has attained majority may act as next friend of a minor or as his guardian for the suit:
Provided that the interest of such person is not adverse to that of the minor and that he is not, in the case of a next friend, a defendant, or, in the case of a guardian for the suit, a plaintiff.”
6. Even when there is a certificated guardian, as pointed by Costello, J. in 61 Cal. 10233, there is no inherent disqualification in all persons other than the certificated guardian to be a guardian ad litem, the only qualifications laid 1 down being that the person must be of sound mind, must have attained majority, must have no interest adverse to that of the minor and must not be arrayed as an opposite party in the same litigation. In the plaintiff's suit and darkhast against the minor, Zumkabai was not absolutely disqualified from representing the minor defendant who was her grandson and who is found to have had no interest adverse to his. Although she had not handed over possession of the minor's property to his certificated guardian Badhu, she did take care to preserve it for the minor's benefit, and it has been found that she defended the suit and the darkhast for the benefit of the minor defendant. It is neither alleged nor proved that any prejudice was caused to the minor, or that Badhu or some one else might have contested the plaintiff's claim better than Zumkabai. It may be conceded that if the Court had known that Badhu had been appointed the minor defendant's guardian by the District Court, it might not have appointed Zumkabai as his guardian ad litem, or would have given reasons why she was appointed in preference to Badhu. It may even be conceded that the Court did not apply its mind to this question since it was evidently not aware of Badhu's appointment and in the Record of Eights Zumkabai was still shown as the minor's guardian. But according to the ruling in 29 ALL. 2904 the appointment of Zumkabai as the minor defendant's guardian ad litem, in ignorance of Badhu's appointment by the District Court as his guardian under the Guardians and Wards Act, was mere irregularity and did not vitiate the proceedings. Accepting this as the correct view, Allsop, J. observed in I.L.R (1942) All. 5095 (p. 513):
“The person proceeding against the minor might, as is alleged in this case, have no knowledge at all about the appointment of guardian by competent authority, and, if that was so, it would be most unfair to hold that the proceedings were void if the minor was represented by a person who was able and was thoroughly willing to represent him and who did not bring to the notice of the Court the fact that there was another person appointed by competent authority to be the guardian of the minor.”
7. As remarked in A.I.R 1918 Pat. 5206 the appointment of a guardian of a minor for purposes of suits is really a question of procedure. Hence in 7 C.L.J 2707 Woodroffe, J. observed (page 273):
“….the passing over of the certificated guardian was not… more than an irregularity and would not of itself vitiate either the decree or a sale consequent upon such decree…
8. I respectfully agree with this view which is in no way in conflict with the decision of the Privy Council relied upon in 43 Mad. 808. It is one thing to say that a minor is not represented at all if represented by a person who is wholly disqualified to represent him as in the Privy Council case, and quite another to say that he is not represented at all if represented by a person whom the Court in its discretion could appoint to represent him but might not have appointed him if it had come to its knowledge that there was a certificated guardian appointed by competent authority.
9. In the absence of any allegation of fraud or prejudice to the minor caused by such an irregularity, the proceedings must be regarded as valid and the auction sale upheld.
10. I allow the appeal, set aside the decree of the lower appellate Court and restore the decree of the trial Court. The respondent shall pay the costs of the appellant in this Court and in the lower appellate Court.
11. Appeal allowed.
Alert