Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Amratlal And Others v. Land Acquisition Officer, Ahmedabad .

Bombay High Court
Feb 16, 1944
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The reference arises under the Land Acquisition Act in relation to lands in Ahmedabad acquired for the Kalupur Relief Road Scheme. The scheme was initiated in 1928; a notification under Section 4 was first issued on 23 August 1925. The municipality abandoned the project in 1930 but revived it in 1933, issuing a declaration under Section 6 in May 1934. A notice under Section 9 was published in 1936 and actual possession of the properties was taken in 1939.

The claimants are an institutional body described as the Khoda Dhor Panjara Pole at Ahmedabad (acting through its vahivatdars and trustees). The acquired parcels included Survey Nos. 523–526, part of 527, 528–533 and two small surveys (2420 and 2421), totaling 3,254 square yards.

The Land Acquisition Officer awarded Rs. 1,99,715 to the claimants; they had claimed Rs. 12,79,578 and, on reference to the District Court, requested Rs. 7,53,420. The Joint Judge hearing the reference divided the acquired land into ten blocks, valuing eight at market value and two on a rental basis, and awarded a total of Rs. 2,24,629 to the claimants. Some blocks were valued substantially higher than others based on location (for example Block No. 4 at Rs. 150 per sq. yd. and Block No. 2 at Rs. 35 per sq. yd.).

Two members of this Court (Stone, C.J. and Divatia, J.) delivered opinions. Both judges discussed (a) the local inspection carried out by the learned Judge below after evidence and after final speeches, during which the Judge made extensive notes; and (b) the nature and scope of the municipal scheme under Section 114 of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925, including acquisitions and re-sales of abutting properties. The appellate Court confirmed the valuation findings of the lower Court but remitted a specific issue to the lower Court for determination under the Land Acquisition Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the proper evidentiary role and weight of a Judge's local inspection under Order 18, Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 — in particular, whether a Judge may treat his inspection as displacing sworn evidence or whether his inspection is limited to assisting in understanding and appreciating evidence?
  2. Whether the factual findings based on a local inspection carried out after the close of evidence (and after final speeches) are open to challenge on appeal where the parties accompanied the Judge or when such inspection was effectively consented to (expressly or impliedly) by the parties.
  3. What are the limits and proper exercise of the compulsory acquisition powers under Section 114 of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925 (particularly sub-section (2)) when a scheme acquires some abutting properties but leaves others, and when the municipality re-sells land acquired?
  4. Whether the claimants have established damage under clauses 3 and 4 of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, and if so, the quantum of such damages (this question was framed as a specific issue to be remitted to the lower Court).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.I.R. 1937 Pat. 3331 (Wort J.) The function of a Judge's local inspection under the CPC is to understand the evidence, not to contradict a witness or declare a witness untrue solely on the basis of what the Judge observes. The inspection assists comprehension of complex facts but is not a substitute for sworn testimony. The Court invoked this authority (Stone, C.J.) to emphasize that local inspection must be used only to understand evidence. Stone C.J. relied on the principle to limit the Judge's reliance on inspection and to ground his view that the inspection in this case could only proceed with the parties' consent and did not permit upsetting the Judge's findings of fact on appeal when the parties had effectively consented to the inspection.
35 Bom. 3173 A Judge's notes of inspection under O.18, R.18 are relevant and important evidence; a Judge may believe or disbelieve evidence in light of what he has seen on inspection. Findings based on such inspection are entitled to great weight on appeal. Divatia, J. cited this authority to support the proposition that the learned Judge's inspection notes were an important piece of evidence and that the appellate Court should attach great weight to those findings unless the Judge had adopted a wrong principle or flagrantly disregarded material evidence. Applying that principle, Divatia confirmed the lower Court's valuation findings.
39 Bom. L.R. 12572 Authority on the municipal scheme: that Court, having considered all facts, held the scheme not to be ultra vires. Stone, C.J. observed that the earlier representative action and its holding that the scheme was not ultra vires is binding in the present appeal because the present appellants were represented in that action. Stone also stated his personal doubt whether he would have reached the same conclusion, but acknowledged the earlier decision's binding effect.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis can be divided into two principal strands addressed by the two judges.

1. Stone, C.J. — Inspection and Section 114 observations

  • Stone, C.J. agreed with Divatia J.'s judgment but added focused remarks on two points: (a) the nature and consequences of the learned Judge's local inspection, and (b) the character of the municipal scheme under s.114 of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925.
  • He described the facts of the inspection: the learned Judge inspected the property and neighbourhood on 13–14 March 1940 after evidence had closed and apparently after final speeches; the Judge made extensive notes (over ten typed pages, 33 paragraphs) that recorded impressions and conclusions about particular survey numbers.
  • Relying on the principle in A.I.R. 1937 Pat. 3331, Stone emphasized that the statutory inspection power exists so the Judge may understand evidence and not to contradict witnesses or declare them untrue based solely on what he sees.
  • Stone stated that an inspection like the one conducted can only properly proceed on the basis that it was made with the consent of the parties so that the Judge might determine and decide points of conflict in the evidence already given. He found it significant that evidence was closed and that there was no further argument after the inspection.
  • Because there was no material before the appellate Court to show the learned Judge was wrong in his findings of fact, and because the parties had consented (expressly or impliedly) to the inspection, Stone concluded that it was not competent for either party in the appeal to controvert or appeal against the learned Judge's findings of fact arising from that inspection.
  • Stone then turned to the nature of the municipal scheme under Section 114 (Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925). He described how the alignment plan sometimes compulsorily acquired abutting properties while leaving others, resulting in some former owners being almost compelled to purchase back property to retain access. He observed that earlier authority (39 Bom. L.R. 12572) had held the scheme not ultra vires and that decision was binding, though he personally doubted he would have reached the same conclusion. He warned that the construction of s.114 places broad powers in municipal hands and that compulsory powers should be very carefully exercised.

2. Divatia, J. — Background, valuation and the evidentiary role of inspection

  • Divatia set out the procedural history of the scheme and the details of the properties and valuations made by the learned Joint Judge below, including the division into ten blocks and the per-square-yard values assigned to each block. He summarized how the lower court arrived at the total award of Rs. 2,24,629.
  • On the inspection, Divatia observed that the learned Judge had conducted a local inspection in the company of the claimants' manager, pleaders in companion references, and the Government Pleader, visiting the acquired site, neighbouring localities and properties relied upon in evidence. Notes of inspection were shown to the Government Pleader and the pleaders in the companion reference and initialled by them.
  • Divatia reiterated the applicable principle under O.18, R.18: the Judge has power to conduct such inspection; his notes are relevant and important evidence; although conclusions from inspection cannot substitute for sworn evidence, the Judge may accept or reject witness evidence based on what he observes. Findings grounded on inspection are entitled to great weight on appeal, particularly where parties accompanied the Judge and had opportunity to explain their case.
  • He stated the standard for appellate interference: the appellate Court will interfere only if the judge below adopted a wrong principle in valuation or flagrantly disregarded material evidence. Divatia concluded the learned Judge had done neither, and therefore the findings on valuation should be confirmed.
  • Divatia criticized the procedure whereby inspection occurred after arguments were over and the Judge recorded impressions in notes shown to pleaders who simply initialled them. He described this as an equivocal and improper practice because pleaders had no opportunity to address the Judge's recorded impressions in subsequent argument. He advised best practice: inspections should usually be done before arguments; if the Judge records impressions in notes, parties must be given an opportunity to meet those impressions during argument; ideally notes should focus on observed facts rather than impressions.
  • Finally, after addressing valuation, the Court framed and sent a specific issue to the lower Court to determine whether the claimants proved damage under clauses 3 and 4 of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act and, if so, the quantum. Directions were given about returning the finding within three months, costs were reserved, and procedural directions were issued for the lower Court to obtain a formulated monetary demand from the claimants, allow a written statement from the opponent and permit further evidence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appellate Court confirmed the learned Judge's valuation findings for the various blocks of acquired land and remitted a single, specific issue to the lower Court:

Issue sent to the lower Court: "Whether the claimants prove damage, if any, under clauses 3 and 4 of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act; and if so, how much?"

The lower Court was directed to return its finding on that issue within three months of receipt of the record. Costs were reserved. The Court further ordered that after the record is received, the lower Court should ask the claimants to formulate their demand in money terms, permit the opponent to file a written statement in response, and allow the parties to lead evidence on that point.

Implications

  • Direct effect: The valuation determinations made by the learned Judge below were confirmed and will operate as the valuations for the acquired blocks, subject to the further inquiry (remitted issue) on damages under Section 23 clauses 3 and 4.
  • Remittal and procedure: The case proceeds on a remand limited to the Section 23 damage question; the lower Court must receive a formulated monetary claim from the claimants, the opponent may file a written statement, and further evidence may be led on the remitted issue.
  • Guidance on inspection practice: The Court provided guidance on the proper use of local inspections — that inspections are to assist understanding of the evidence and should not be used to displace sworn testimony, that inspections conducted after arguments with impressions recorded without giving parties an opportunity to meet those impressions are improper, and that parties accompanying a Judge may be taken to have consented such that factual findings based on the inspection are difficult to challenge on appeal.
  • Scope of municipal acquisition powers: Stone, C.J. warned about the broad and potentially confiscatory powers conferred by s.114 of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act (1925) and expressed the view that compulsory powers under that provision should be very carefully exercised. The Court, however, did not overturn the earlier authority (39 Bom. L.R. 12572) which had held the scheme not ultra vires and treated that earlier decision as binding in this appeal.
  • Precedential effect: The Court confirmed factual findings and clarified procedural expectations regarding local inspections, but it did not announce a novel legal doctrine altering existing authorities; it applied and reiterated established principles concerning the evidentiary role of inspections and the high weight accorded to findings based on such inspections where parties have participated.
Show all summary ...

Stone, C.J:— I agree with the judgment about to be delivered by my learned brother Divatia. But in deference to the very full arguments that have been advanced by counsel, I desire to refer to two features of this appeal about which there has been much discussion. In the first place, the learned Judge in the Court below proceeded on 13th and 14th March, 1940, to view the property and the locality in question. This was done after the parties had closed their evidence, and apparently after the final speeches of the pleaders had been delivered. Some of the pleaders accompanied the learned Judge on this expedition. In the case of the appellants they were represented by their manager who also accompanied the Judge. The Judge made extensive notes of what he saw. In that state of affairs the learned Judge on 29th April, 1940, delivered his judgment. The notes he had made, which extend over ten typewritten foolscap pages, are divided into 33 paras. Two instances will suffice to show their character. Paragraph 6 is as follows:

“We then saw Survey Nos. 532 and 533. The condition of the superstructures on these survey numbers is shabby. The estimate of the future life as made by the Land Acquisition Officer is quite correct.”

2. And para. 27 is as follows:

“The statement made by the expert that the situation of Survey No. 522 is superior to that of Survey No. 460 was also examined during this inspection. I have already observed that the busiest centre of shopping activity of the Ratanpole road ends at the police chowky situated to the south of the entrance to Nagorishala. On an inspection of the whole locality, I am not at all prepared to accept this statement of the expert. In my opinion Survey No. 522 is certainly not superior to Survey No. 460, but that it ought to be inferior to Survey No. 460.”

3. It is O. 18, R. 18 of the CPC, 1908, which provides for inspection by a Judge, and the object and effect of such inspection by a Judge has been considered in a number of cases, and in A.I.R 1937 Pat. 3331 appears this passage in the judgment of Wort J. (p. 334):

“Now, the function of the learned Judge in exercising his rights of local inspection granted by the statute, i.e, under the Code of Civil Procedure, is for the purpose of understanding the evidence and for no other purpose. By ‘understanding the evidence’ is not meant ‘contradicting a witness.’ A witness may make a statement which from the local inspection may appear to be untrue, but the learned Judge is not entitled to say that it is untrue from what he himself observes. The reason for granting this power of local inspection is perfectly obvious. In certain cases facts are complicated and without having the opportunity to see the subject-matter of the witness's evidence it is almost impossible to understand what the witness means and it is for that purpose that the Judge is entitled to inspect the locality.”

4. But, in my judgment, an inspection such as took place in this case can only proceed on the basis that it was made with the consent of the parties, in order that the Judge might determine and decide finally points of conflict on questions of fact appearing in the evidence already given before him. It is most significant that the evidence was closed and that there was no further argument upon it by the pleaders. There is no material before us to show that the learned Judge was wrong in any of his findings of fact, and, in view of the course which these proceedings have taken and the consent of the parties to it, which even if it was not express must certainly be implied: it is not competent, in my judgment, for either party in this appeal to controvert or to appeal against any of the learned Judge's findings of fact.

5. The other feature of this case to which I desire to refer concerns the nature of the scheme itself. In this scheme besides the land actually required for the formation of the carriage-way, foot-ways and drains, the municipality sought to acquire areas of lands and buildings adjacent thereto, some of which were eventually re-sold at a large profit resulting in the whole scheme being put through at comparatively small cost. The releivant section is Section 114 of the Bombay Municipal Boroughs Act, 1925, which provides by sub-s. (1) that it shall be lawful for a municipality to lay out and make new public streets; and the sub-section goes on to provide for power: “to lease or sell any such land, theretofore used or acquired by the municipality for the purposes of such streets.” Sub-section (2) is as follows:

“In laying out, making, turning, diverting, widening, opening, enlarging or otherwise improving any public street, in addition to the land required for the carriage-way and foot-ways and drains thereof, the municipality may purchase the land required for the construction of houses and buildings to form the said street; and, subject to the provisions contained in sub-s. (2) of S. 48, may sell and dispose of such additional land in perpetuity or on lease for a term of years, with such stipulations as to the class and description of houses or buildings to be erected thereon as it may think fit.”

6. The alignment plan produced by Government is a plan signed by the Consulting Surveyor to Government and bearing date 17th March, 1923. When it is examined, it will be seen that in some cases lands and buildings abutting on the site of the proposed new street are to be compulsorily acquired and in some cases they are left, to the great advantage of the owners who will have a frontage on the new street. But in the case of some of the properties abutting on the new street which are taken, the former owners are almost bound to purchase them back, if they retain their back lands and desire to make any use of them; severed as they will be from any egress or access to the new street. There is no more striking example of this than the one which is to be found in the case of the appellants, who retained a large area of land cut off from its former frontage; so that access and egress to the public highway is barred on its principal side. Although some private arrangement appears to have been made for a passage way, the appellants did in fact also buy back at the rate of Rs. 340 per square yard land which had been compulsorily taken from them at the rates of Rs. 40, 50 and 60 per square yard and which was not used by the municipality for the purposes of the new street, foot-ways and drains. The scheme came before this Court in 39 Bom. L.R 12572 in which this Court having taken all facts into consideration held that the scheme was not ultra vires. That action was a representative action and the present appellants were represented, so that it is binding in this appeal: but with great respect to the learned Judges who decided it, I desire to state that I doubt if I should have come to the same conclusion had it been open to us to consider the question in this appeal. But as a result of the construction which has thus been put upon S. 114, there has been placed in the hands of those who have the control of the inception and alteration of these schemes wide powers of a confiscatory nature. While they are apparently at the same time endowed with powers of dispensation which will greatly enhance the value of any land or building abutting upon the new street which they do not choose to take. Looking at the lay out of the scheme it is difficult to follow, and the learned Advocate-General has been unable to give any explanation, why some of the properties abutting upon the new street have been taken and some have been left. Especially is this so when the key to the plan is consulted and it is found that there appears to be no uniform system, so that excluding altogether lands used for religious purposes it will be found that cheap properties are acquired and expensive ones are left and that sometimes the opposite occurs. No explanation of this has been given, and the matter is left in a somewhat unsatisfactory state. At the same time it is only fair to add that there is no evidence at all of any impropriety in this case: but in view of the construction which has up to the present been put upon sub-s. (2) of S. 114 enabling acquisitions to be made which have no continuity of plan or scheme for the construction of houses and buildings to form the new street: it is my opinion that these compulsory powers should be very carefully exercised.

7. Divatia, J.:— This is an appeal arising on a reference under the Land Acquisition Act. The properties, which are situated in the city of Ahmedabad, have been acquired for the purpose of what is known as the Kalupur Relief Road Scheme. This scheme was started in 1928 and the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act was for the first time issued on 23rd August, 1925. In 1930, however, the Ahmedabad Municipality gave up the idea of the acquisition of lands for the purpose of the new road and cancelled their resolution for that purpose. However, in 1933 the scheme was revived and in May 1934 a notification was issued under S. 6 about the declaration of the public purpose for which the lands were to be acquired. A notice under Section 9 of the Act was published in 1936 and actual possession of the properties was taken in 1939. The properties of the present claimant, which is fin institution known as the Khoda Dhor Panjara Pole at Ahmedabad through its vahivatdars and trustees, were Survey Nos. 523 to 526, a part of a large Survey No. 527, Survey Nos. 528 to 533 and two small Survey Nos. 2420 and 2421. The total area of these survey numbers is 3254 square yards. The land acquisition officer in his award gave Rs. 1,99,715 to the present claimants as against their claim for Rs. 12,79,578. Being dissatisfied with the award, the claimants applied for a reference to the District Court, and there the claimants made a demand for Rs. 7,53,420. Both sides led evidence before the learned Joint Judge who heard the case. The claimants as well as the opponent relied upon several transactions of sales and other transfers in the neighbouring locality and the learned Joint Judge divided the acquired properties into ten blocks, eight of which he valued ad their market value and two at their rental value. The total amount which he awarded to the claimants was rupees 2,24,629. The lands are situated on a junction of the main Ratan Pole Swaminarayan Temple Koad and the cross road which joins that road with the Gheekanta Road towards the Civil Hospital. A part of the acquired lands which abutted on the corner of the junction of the roads and which was demarcated as Block No. 4 was assessed by the learned Judge at Rs. 150, having regard to its prominent position in a shopping locality. The other plots towards the north were valued less at a lesser amount because on the evidence the learned Judge was of the opinion that the value of the lands became less and less as one proceeded from the south, i.e from the Ratan Pole, towards the north, i.e the Swaminarayan Temple. He thus assessed Block No. 5 at Rs. 125, Block No. 6 at Rs. 120 and Block No. 7 at Rs. 115 per square yard. Then on the western side, i.e on the cross road, Block No. 3, which adjoins Block No. 4, was valued at Rs. 100 and Block No. 1 which lay further to the east was valued at Rs. 65, having regard to the fact that the road on which this block was situated was not a shopping locality. Block No. 2 was just behind Block No. 1 and that was valued at Rs. 35 per square yard. The remaining blocks, viz. Blocks Nos. 8, 9 and 10, were valued by the learned Judge at Rs. 60, Rs. 40 and Rs. 50 respectively. Blocks Nos. 7 and 10 were assessed on a rental basis and the claimants have accepted the valuation put upon them. We may take it, therefore, that their value was Rs. 115 and Rs. 50 per square yard respectively.

8. Before dealing with the evidence, it is necessary to make a few observations about the arguments urged before us as to the evidentiary value of the notes of inspection made by the learned Judge. He went in company of the claimants' manager, the pleaders in two companion references and the Government Pleader for local inspection. He visited not only the site of the acquired properties but the neighbouring localities and also several other properties which were the subject-matter of the sales, etc., relied upon by the parties. Thereafter he made notes of inspection which were shown to the Government Pleader and the two pleaders who appeared in the other reference. Under O. 18, R. 18 of the CPC, the learned Judge had the power to conduct such local inspection and his notes are not only a relevant but an important piece of evidence in the case. It is true that the con-elusion to which the Judge may come on such inspection cannot take the place of sworn evidence, but it is open to him to believe or disbelieve the evidence of witnesses on what he sees on inspection: 35 Bom. 3173. As a general rule, his findings based on such inspection are entitled to great weight by the Court of appeal in the same manner in which findings based on appreciation of oral evidence would be. This would be particularly so when, as in the present case, the party accompanied the Judge for inspection and had an opportunity to explain his case to him. Most of the conclusions arrived at by the learned Judge on his local inspection are, in my opinion, supported by evidence. This Court will, therefore, interfere only if the learned Judge has adopted a wrong principle in arriving at the valuation of the lands or has flagrantly disregarded evidence having a material bearing on the points in dispute. In my opinion, he has done neither of the two and his findings about the valuation of the different blocks must therefore be confirmed. But even apart from his opinion based on local inspection, the learned Judge is, in my opinion, right on the merits.

9. There is one point about the local inspection made by the Judge on which I desire to make a few observations. This inspection seems to have been carried out not only after the whole of the evidence was led but after the arguments of both sides were over. It appears that the notes were shown to the pleaders of the parties and they have simply initialled them. This has an equivocal effect. It may give rise to an inference that they impliedly accepted their truth or it may mean that they initialled them merely to show that they had read them, even though they may not accept their accuracy or truth. As the arguments were over, the pleaders would have no opportunity to challenge them before the judgment was pronounced. This procedure is quite improper. It is always desirable in all cases where local inspection is necessary that the Judge should carry out the inspection at any stage before the arguments are heard, and if he conducts the inspection at the request of the parties, it should be made clear whether the parties have left the matter to be decided as he thinks proper from his inspection or that he is merely inspecting under O. 18, R. 18 of the CPC. If the Judge records his impressions or opinions in his notes of inspection, the parties must have an opportunity to urge their arguments on those notes at the time when the case is generally argued before the Court. In most cases it would be desirable for the Judge to confine his notes to the facts which he observes without recording his impressions or opinions. He is entitled to form his impressions, but if he records them in the notes, the parties should have the opportunity to meet them in their arguments and he should not decide the case merely from his impressions without giving due weight to the evidence. No doubt the Court of appeal would attach due weight to what the Judge observes in his inspection, but the purpose of local inspection is not to make it a substitute for the evidence but to assist in its appreciation. [The judgment next dealt with the question of valuation of plots compulsorily acquired and concluded:] We, therefore, send an issue to the lower Court on this point. The issue will be:

“Whether the claimants prove damage, if any, under clauses 3 and 4 of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act; and if so, how much?”

10. The finding of the lower Court should be returned to this Court within three months of the receipt of the record by the lower Court.

11. Costs reserved. After the record is received by the lower Court it should ask the claimants to formulate this demand in terms of money claim and thereafter the opponent would be entitled to put in a written statement against that claim. The parties will be entitled to lead evidence on this point.

12. Order accordingly.