Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anant Baburao Kulkarni v. Vyasacharya Madhavacharya Ghalasasi

Bombay High Court
Nov 24, 1943

1. This appeal arises in execution proceedings of a decree for rent. The facts shortly are that the plaintiff, who is the respondent in this appeal, obtained a decree against the present appellant, who was, defendant 1 in the suit, and six other persons for arrears of rent consisting of about Rs. 18 for three years with costs and future interest. The suit was contested by defendant 7, who was a minor, through his guardian. The other defendants remained absent and did not contest the suit. The decree was a joint and several decree against all the defendants. Defendant 7 alone filed a revisional application to the District Court against that decree as it was only open to revision by the District Judge under the provisions of the Dekkhan Agriculturists' Relief Act, 1879. Pending the hearing of that application the plaintiff, who was the opponent in that application, filed an application for the withdrawal of the suit as against defendant 7. The District Judge granted the plaintiff's application with liberty to bring another suit against defendant 7 on the same cause of action. In the meanwhile, the plaintiff had taken out execution of the decree against defendant 1 and recovered the decretal amount with costs consisting of about Rs. 55. After the suit was allowed to be withdrawn by the District Judge in revision against defendant 7, defendant 1 filed an application for restitution under section 144 of the cpc, alleging that the suit in which the decree was obtained by the plaintiff was withdrawn by him and that therefore he was entitled to refund of the amount recovered from him in execution through Court. The trial Court granted the application for restitution under the belief that the revisional application was filed by defendant 1. The plaintiff appealed to the District Court against the order and the learned Judge set aside the trial Court's order on the ground that the trial Judge was under a misapprehension that the revision application was filed by defendant 1. As a matter of fact, it was filed by defendant 7 only. He further held that the withdrawal of the suit, which was permitted in revision, was of the suit against defendant 7 only and not against all the defendants, with the result that the decree in so far as it was passed against the remaining defendants remained a valid decree even after the suit was allowed to be withdrawn against defendant 7. The order of the trial Court was therefore set aside and the application for restitution dismissed.

2. Defendant 1 has now filed this appeal and Mr. Dharap on his behalf has contended that the suit was allowed to be withdrawn not simply against defendant 7 but against all the defendants, because the reason for withdrawal proceeded on a ground which was common to all the defendants, viz., that the defendants were not the plaintiff's tenants but were pot inamdars and not liable to pay rent. It is however clear that the plaintiff in his application asked for leave to withdraw from the suit as against defendant 7 only and the learned Judge granted the application. He did not say that the suit was allowed to be withdrawn against all the defendants on the ground that the reason for withdrawal was common to all of them. It could not, therefore, in my opinion, be contended that the effect of the order passed by the District Judge was to permit the withdrawal of the suit against all the defendants. In fact the learned Judge could not have passed an order of withdrawal of the suit against all the defendants when the remaining defendants were not parties to the revision application. It is no doubt true that a decree can be reversed or varied in appeal at the instance of some of the defendants only and the effect of such reversal or variation would be for the benefit of all the persons who are parties to the litigation though not to the appeal, if the reversal or variation proceeds on a ground common to all of them. But it is difficult to say that an order of permission to withdraw from the suit an against all defendants can be passed in a proceeding to which some of them were not parties. Anyhow, there is no doubt that the order of the learned Judge amounted to permission to the plaintiff to withdraw from the suit against defendant 7 alone, and it must therefore be taken that the decree, which was already passed against the remaining defendants, was not affected by that order. That being so, the amount recovered by the plaintiff in execution of that decree cannot be refunded to defendant 1.

3. It is, however, contended that even though the suit might be deemed to have been withdrawn as against defendant 7 only, the plaintiff was not entitled to retain the amount which he recovered in execution from the appellant when he conceded in his application for withdrawal that defendant 7 had a one-fourth share in the suit property. It appears that contention was raised on behalf of defendant 7 in the suit itself, but it was over, ruled. Defendant 1 ought to have preferred a revision application against that decree just as defendant 7 did on the ground that he was not liable to pay the rent because he was not a tenant but a pot inamdar and also because defendant 7 had a one-fourth share in the property and that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover the whole. But having not taken any steps to set aside the decree against him, defendant 1 cannot, in my opinion, take advantage of the circumstance that after the execution was levied against him, the suit against defendant 7 was allowed to be withdrawn. If the revisional Court had reversed or varied the decree in favour of all the defendants even though they were not parties to the revision on the ground that such reversal or variation proceeded on a ground common to all, then, on the authority of the decision in 38 Bom. L.R 13261, defendant 1 could have applied for restitution. But the District Judge has not reversed or varied the decree against all the defendants. He has only permitted the suit to be withdrawn as against defendant 7 only, and that order, in my opinion, would not have the effect of a reversal or variation of the decree against all of them. It has been held by the Madras High Court in 25 Mad. 4262 that where a decree has been reversed in favour of the appellant only and not against the other persons having a similar interest in the suit, the original decree must be regarded as still in force against the other persons.

4. In my opinion, therefore, in spite of the withdrawal of the suit against defendant 7, the original decree passed against defendant 1 was not affected in any way by the permission to withdraw the suit as against defendant 7. No doubt the power of the Court to allow restitution is not limited to the terms of S. 144 and the Court would have inherent power to direct restitution even though the decree was not reversed or varied in appeal. But I am not disposed to exercise the inherent power of restitution, because the very ground on which defendant 1 wants to take benefit now, viz., that defendant 7 had a share in the property, had been taken in the original suit itself and seems to have been rejected defendant 1 remained absent in the suit. He could have taken steps to have the decree against him set aside in revision just as defendant 7 did, but he did nothing of the kind, and he must therefore be taken to have acquiesced in the decree. As a result, therefore, the order of the lower appellate Court is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

5. Appeal dismissed.