Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Narayan Amhaji Chavan v. Hari Ganesh Navare .

Bombay High Court
Apr 16, 1930
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

1. One Ganesh Anant Desai filed suit No. 29 of 1918, against the present plaintiff for possession of the property in suit and obtain a decree in execution of which he was put in possession. On appeal the plaintiff got the decree reversed and then applied under section 144 of the cpc, for restoration of possession. The application was granted but defendant 1 resisted the delivery of possession. Thereupon the plaintiff made an application under O. 21, R. 97, for removal of the obstruction which was dismissed on 15th April 1924, under O. 21, R. 99. It was incumbent on the plaintiff to bring a suit under O. 21, R. 103, within one year but the present suit was brought by the plaintiff on 24th June 1925. The suit is governed by Article 11-A, Lim. Act and R. 103, O. 21, and is clearly beyond time. The plaintiff tried to save limitation on the ground that he had made an application to the High Court in revision on 11th July 1924, which was dismissed on 3rd April 1925. It is urged on behalf of the appellant that if that time is excluded under section 14 of the lim. act, the suit would be within time.

2. The first question arising in the case is whether an application for revision to the High Court is a “civil proceeding in a Court of appeal” within the meaning of S. 14. The lower appellate Court relying on the decision in the case of Subramania Pillai v. Seethai Ammal (1) held that a revision application in the High Court could not be covered by the words “a civil proceeding in a Court of appeal.” It appears that the decision relates to the words “order on appeal,” in Article 182, Lim. Act, and has no application to section 14 of the lim. act. The appellant's counsel relied on the decision in the case of Baijnath Sahai v. Bamgut Singh (2). But it appears from the judgment that the point under section 14 of the lim. act was not decided. The High Court is not a Court of appeal but a Court of revision in respect of an order of a Second Class Subordinate Judge under O. 21, R. 99. Assuming, however, that an application for revision to the High Court is covered by the words “civil proceeding in a Court of appeal” within the meaning of section 14 of the lim. act, the further question for decision is whether the High Court was not able to entertain the application from defect of jurisdiction or other cause of like nature. It appears that the High Court refused to interfere on the ground that there was another remedy by way of a suit. I think, therefore, that the conditions necessary under section 14 of the lim. act, are not satisfied.

3. In Baiznath Lala v. Ramadoss (3), it was held that in computing the period of limitation for the filing of a suit the plaintiff was not entitled to deduct under section 14 of the lim. act, the period of time taken by him to file a revision petition in the High Court or the time during which he was prosecuting the revision petition against the order of distribution under section 73 of the cpc. At p. 66 it is observed:

“We think, further that the respondent is entitled to rely upon the contention that in any event plaintiff cannot be said to have prosecuted the revision petition in good faith-with-in the meaning of section 14 of the lim. act inasmuch as it has been frequently held by this and other High Courts that the High Court will not exercise its revisional power when there is any other remedy open. Here the plaintiff had his remedy by suit.”

4. Similarly, in S.R.M.M.A Firm v. Maung Po Saung (4), it was held that where a person does not file a suit within one year after the adverse order under O. 21, R. 63, and chooses to apply for revision of such order, he cannot get the benefit of section 14 of the lim. act, and ask for the exclusion of time taken up in the revision proceedings, and that the proceedings contrary to the clearly expressed provision of law cannot be regarded as prosecuting another civil proceeding in good faith. Under O. 21, R. 103, it has been specifically laid down that subject to the result of a suit which is therein expressly provided for, the order shall be conclusive.

5. Even on the facts of the present case, it cannot be said that the plaintiff was diligent in filing the present suit.

6. The revisional application was dismissed on 3rd April 1925, and the present suit was not brought till 24th June 1925. If the plaintiff had filed the suit soon after the dismissal of the revisional application on 3rd April, his suit would have been within time.

7. I think, on the whole, that the view taken by the lower Court was right, and this appeal must be dismissed with costs.

R.M/R.K

8. Appeal dismissed.