- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Abdul Hussein Essufalli v. D.J. Mistri & Co.
Factual and Procedural Background
The defendants in Suit No. 1312 of 1918, as decree-holders on their counter-claim, sought an order to estrear the surety bond given by Hussein-bhai Heptulla for the plaintiff's appearance before the Chamber Judge on 31st March 1921 and to realize the sum of Rs. 2,000 deposited as security. The plaintiff was arrested and produced before the Chamber Judge on 15th March, requesting time to file a petition under the Insolvency Act. The Chamber Judge ordered the plaintiff to appear on 31st March and accepted the surety bond as security for his appearance and insolvency application. The plaintiff failed to appear on the specified date, prompting the defendants to apply for realization of the security. The Chamber Judge ordered the plaintiff's re-arrest and commitment to jail. The defendants relied on sections 55(4) and 145 of the Civil Procedure Code for execution against the surety. The plaintiff claimed he was unaware of the Chamber Judge's location and thus could not appear, but had filed the insolvency petition and partially complied with the condition for release.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the surety bond given for the plaintiff's appearance before the Chamber Judge should be estreated and the security amount realized due to the plaintiff's failure to appear.
- Whether the judgment-creditor can execute the decree against the surety under section 145 of the Civil Procedure Code without filing a separate suit.
- The extent of the surety’s liability in the context of insolvency proceedings and the plaintiff’s compliance with conditions for release.
- The Court’s discretion in refusing or granting an order for realization of security deposited in Court.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendants' Arguments
- They contended that the surety bond should be estreated and the Rs. 2,000 security realized because the plaintiff failed to appear before the Chamber Judge on 31st March 1921.
- They relied on section 55(4) and section 145 of the Civil Procedure Code to justify execution against the surety without a separate suit.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaintiff swore that he had attempted to appear but did not know the Chamber Judge’s location and was informed the work was over when he arrived.
- He argued that he had partly fulfilled the condition of release by filing his insolvency petition and could have proceeded with the insolvency application if given time.
Surety's Arguments
- The surety was argued to have been careless in not ensuring the plaintiff was properly guided to the Chamber Judge.
- The surety contended that his liability did not extend beyond the pendency of insolvency proceedings, although this point was not appealed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Basanti Lal v. Chhedo Singh | Surety's liability for production of a person in insolvency proceedings and forfeiture of security under section 145 of the Civil Procedure Code. | The Court cited this case to illustrate that the surety’s security could be forfeited and executed against under section 145, and that forfeiture in favour of Government was not permissible. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the provisions of sections 55(4) and 145 of the Civil Procedure Code regarding security for appearance and execution against sureties. It noted that the plaintiff was required to appear before the Chamber Judge and that failure to do so empowered the Court to realize the security or commit the plaintiff to civil prison. The Court observed that realizing the security was unnecessary since the decree-holder could directly proceed against the surety under section 145. The Court considered the plaintiff’s sworn statement about his inability to find the Chamber Judge and his partial compliance by filing the insolvency petition. The surety’s alleged negligence was acknowledged but deemed sufficiently addressed by imposing costs on the surety. The Court exercised discretion in refusing to order realization of the security and instead ordered each party to bear their own costs, allowing repayment of the security to the surety.
Holding and Implications
DISCHARGED the summons.
The Court refused to order the realization of the surety bond amount and directed that each party pay their own costs, effectively discharging the summons filed by the defendants. The security deposit was to be repaid by the Prothonotary. This decision directly affected the parties by denying the defendants' application to forfeit the surety bond but did not establish any new legal precedent.
Macleod, C.J:— The defendants in Suit No. 1312 of 1918 have taken out this summons as decree-holders on the counter-claim filed by them in the above suit, for an order that the surety bond given by one Hussein-bhai Heptulla for the appearance of the plaintiff before the Chamber Judge on the 31st March 1921 should be estreated and that the sum of Rs. 2,000 should be realized by the Prothonotary and paid to the defendants, as the said Husseinbhai Heptulla had failed to produce the plaintiff in Court on such day. The plaintiff was arrested at the instance of the defendants and produced before the Judge in Chambers on the 15th March when he asked for time that he might file his petition under the Insolvency Act. Accordingly the order was made that he should appear before the learned Judge on the 31st March, and, as security for his applying to be declared an insolvent and for such appearance, the aforementioned Husseinbhai Heptulla deposited with the Prothonotary Rs. 2,000, which was to remain with the Prothonotary as security. It may be noted that under section 55(4) of the Civil Procedure Code the judgment-debtor should give security not only that he will apply to be declared insolvent but also that he will appear when called upon in any proceeding upon the application, so that the security should continue until a final order is made upon the petition. The plaintiff failed to appear on the 31st March before the Chamber Judge. When that happens, under section 55, sub-section (4), of the Civil procedure Code, the Court may either direct the security to be realized or commit the judgment-debtor to the civil prison in execution of the decree. A direction that the security should be realized seems unnecessary, as the judgment-creditor can proceed in execution against the surety under section 145 of the Civil Procedure Code, thus dispensing with the necessity of filing a separate suit. The actual order made by the Chamber Judge on the 31st March was to direct the plaintiff to be re-arrested and committed to jail. section 145 of the code directs that where any person has become liable as surety, inter alia, for the fulfilment of any condition imposed on any person under an order of the Court in any suit or in any proceeding consequent thereon, the decree or order may be executed against him to the extent to which he has rendered himself personally liable in the manner therein provided for the execution of decrees. In Basanti Lal v. Chhedo Singh(1), one Chhedo Singh stood surety for the production of one Chhedi Halwai, who, on filing an application for insolvency, was ordered to be released from the civil jail. As the surety failed to produce Chhedi on the date on which he was directed to produce him, the security was forfeited. The decree-holder prayed that the amount should be forfeited to him basing his claim on section 145 of the Civil Procedure Code. The District Judge refused that application and declared that the money should be forfeited to Government. On appeal it was held that there was no power in the Court to declare a forfeiture in favour of the Government. The surety contended that his suretyship did not extend beyond the pendency of the insolvency proceedings, but as he had not appealed from the order adjudicating upon this point adversely to him, the Court directed that the sum of Rs. 500 should be paid to the decree-holder, to this extent executing the decree against the surety. If the security has been realized under an order of the Court under section 55(4) or in the first instance consists of a cash deposit, as in this case, the judgment-creditor may ask the Court to execute the decree under section 145 against the money lying in Court. But the Court may in exercise of its discretion refuse to make an order in favour of the judgment-creditor.
Now, the debtor has sworn that he came to the Court, but did not know where to find the Chamber Judge, and when after moving from Court to Court he found himself at last in the right place, he was told that the Chamber work was over and an order had been made for his arrest. Whether that story is true or not, there is no doubt that he had so far fulfilled the condition on which he was allowed to be released on the 15th March by filing his petition in the Insolvency Court, and if he had issued notices to the creditors he would be able to apply to the Insolvency Court for a protection order on the 5th April. And taking it at the most that the surety was guilty of great carelessness in not seeing that the plaintiff was guided to the proper place where he would find the Chamber Judge, I think he will be sufficiently punished by having to pay his costs of this summons, which will otherwise be discharged. The moneys can be repaid by the Prothonotary.
I think the proper order is that each party do pay his own costs.
Solicitors for the surety: Messrs. Little & Co.
Solicitors for the defendant: Messrs. Amin & Desai.
Summons discharged.
G.G.N
Alert